Rites Of Passage Essay

959 words - 4 pages

During a strenuous trek in the mountains, a teenage boy dies of starvation. A girl wearing an elegant gown completes a dance with her father. Both of these things come from rites of passage. Why are they so different? Rites of passage are almost as diverse and widespread as individual cultures. Depending on cultural values, initiation into adulthood varies immensely. Unquestionably, all rites of passage start with the same purpose. The goal is to bring a child into adulthood. However, the process might be redundant or even harmful. Some rites of passage should continue to be practiced, like the Quinceañera and Bar Mitzvah, because they have strong benefits and cultural value while others, like hazing and cutting should not because they can harm and possibly kill people.
The Quinceañera, which turns a 15-year old Latino girl into a woman on her birthday, is important and should continue being practiced because it contains strong cultural values. These cultural values along with messages about faith and sexuality are some beneficial outcomes of the Quinceañera. In the end, these benefits make the event worth the cost. For example, in On La Quinceañera, Jan Risher says, “The Reyes family said the expense was worth it, even if they will only now begin saving for college” (2). This is an example of a person who was satisfied by these outcomes. While some people argue that the Quinceañera is too extravagant and expensive for a rite of passage, the fact is that the actual benefits last for a lifetime. For example, in On La Quinceañera, Risher says, “Sometimes a defining point, even a choreographed one, helps bring home the fact of one’s place in the world” (2). This is a great example of one of the long-lasting benefits of this rite of passage. As a result, The Quineañera should be continued to be practiced because of its benefits.
Like the Quinceañera, the Bar Mitzvah also has good benefits. The Bar Mitzvah, which is an event that turns a child into a spiritual adult, should continue being practiced because it provides spiritual values and encourages Judaism. For example, in Entering Adulthood, Aron Moss says, “For many, the Bar/Bat Mitzvah experience determines their attitude to Judaism” (1). This shows that the child’s religion will be dependent on this event. While some people argue that this event could also have negative effect if not exercised correctly, the fact is the pros almost always outweigh the cons in the end. For example, in Entering Adulthood, Moss says, “Their Jewish identity will be reinforced and they will be proud of their heritage” (1). This shows that the benefits do outweigh the possible negatives. This is a good rite of passage but hazing is not.

Find Another Essay On Rites of Passage

"Rites of Passage" by Sharon Olds.

615 words - 2 pages Rites of PassageA poem by Sharon OldsMinor Generals - By Henning ThielSharon Olds' "Rites of Passage" is about the hidden adults in the children that come to her son's birthday party. All the children are boys and display male adult personality traits that remind the speaker of small mighty Generals of war. The tone comes across sad, ironic and disillusioned about the future of the children, like they are doomed to follow in the war mongering

The Rites of Passage Within Judaism

4200 words - 17 pages The Rites of Passage Within Judaism (a) Examine the rituals and teachings which are associated with circumcision and Bar Mitzvah (20 marks) Two very important rites of passage within Judaism are circumcision and Bar Mitzvah, both of which are only for boys and happen during childhood. Circumcision, also known as Brit Millah, symbolizes the covenant between God and the Jewish people, which was agreed with

Transition to Adulthood --> Rites of Passage and ritual Cross Culturally

1715 words - 7 pages biologically inferior to males, yet culturally they certainly are. Emergence to adulthood is celebrated by both males and females through trying rites of passage. For boys, the transition begins from about age four, when a village elder uses a knife to extract the lower incisors. Following symbolic rituals such as burning with hot coals and tattooing with sharp utensils are indicators to the Masaai people that a boy is prepared to enter adulthood. The

The South by Ruth Parks Analyzed in respect to Rites Of Passage, physical setting, style and the roles of the Characters

752 words - 3 pages most of there time. Along with what they like, there attitudes and responsibilities. There values and attitudes are explained to the responder without them knowing. All of these main features are interweaved together to produce a text that is exciting, shocking and sad. Ruth Parks has done this extremely well to produce this amazing text.Rites of passage reflects genre because Rites Of Passage refers to growing up and its experiences. Wile a part

The Monomyth: Rites of Passage in a Hero's Life

508 words - 2 pages A rite of passage is a memorable, emotionally charged journey that leads a person from one place in their life to another. Joseph Campbell, an american mythologist, recognized a structure which was often used in the story of a heroes journey. This structure he called a Monomyth, can be simplified and described as a 3 step process of departure, initiation and return. The "hero" (or anyone for that matter) departs their current situation and


796 words - 4 pages In a BBC article, Dr. Janssen, a sociologist, asserts, “People thought rituals were fixed and never hanged but of course they do…they get reinterpreted all the time” (Smith-Spark). Unfortunately, the changes referred to in these quotes are for the worse. Almost all cultures have rites of passage that evolve over time, and these have become harmful to their culture and society. After establishing the difference between helpful and harmful rites

Are the three phases of a rite of passage equally important? Demonstrate your argument through an ethnographic example.

1587 words - 6 pages Rites of passage are something that almost all societies recognise and celebrate. Theses are times of change for an individual or group, when they pass from on state of being into another. Van Gennep split rites of passage into three distinct phases (separation, transition, and aggregation) all of which having to be completed before an individual can move on into their new role/stage.Separation is the ending of the persons' previous stage/role

The Pressures of todays youth

606 words - 2 pages Many young people in this day and age are tying to look act, and overall seem older. Youths face many dilemmas in their trek to adulthood yet, they still try to obtain adulthood earlier by going through the "proper" rites of passage. These rites create dilemmas which can help or hinder lifetime goals. Two of the dilemmas that young people face today are peer pressure, and adult pressure. Two essayists have given their thoughts on these subjects

Rite of Passage

972 words - 4 pages Rites of passage have existed throughout human history and may be a significant factor in the development of a stable adult personality. Broken down into its most basic elements, a rite of passage involves a separation from society, preparation or instruction from an elder, a transition (in the case of adolescence, from child to adult), and a welcoming back into society with acknowledgment of the adolescent's changed status. (Delaney, 1995)Today

By Close Analysis of Funeral Rites, Explore Seamus Heaney’s Attitude to Death in North.

1203 words - 5 pages with maturity and manhood. This is reminiscent of Mid Term Break, when Heaney ‘felt embarrassed by old men standing up to shake [his] hand’2, insinuating his mature role at the funeral. However, although Heaney portrays himself to be uncomfortable with this role in Mid Term Break, he welcomes manhood more openly in Funeral Rites, as implied by the determined nature of the comma. Funerals are an important final rite of passage in a person’s life (as

In 1879 the South Australian journalist J D Woods (1879, p.xxxviii) in predicting the future of Aboriginal societies argued that:

657 words - 3 pages to document and record their history as they constantly relive their creation through songs, dances, stories, ceremonies and rituals, initiations and rites of passage this is known in English as The Dreaming. The ceremonies recreate the Dreaming to explain and teach the laws passed down from the ancestor spirits or beings. Following Woods comment “without a religion they have no hope” the European settlers claimed the religion of the

Similar Essays

Modern Rites Of Passage Essay

1315 words - 5 pages According to many scholars, such as Mircae Eliade, human beings can be described as creatures of religion and ritual. The appearance of ritual across the globe is one of the prevalent aspects of humanity that transcends all political, social, cultural and geographical differences. While ritual itself has many forms, one of the most regnant aspect is that of the Rite of Passage. This paper will examine rites of passage as defined by the

Rites Of Passage Essay

771 words - 3 pages Rites of passage are defined as ?a ritual or ceremony signifying an event in a person's life indicative of a transition from one stage to another, as from adolescence to adulthood,? but basically, rites of passage are about growing up. ?The Hero?s Journey,? the poem ?Young? by Anne Sexton, and ?The Seven Ages of Man,? by William Shakespeare all tie into the same idea of rites of passage. However, the three different readings are not exactly the

Rites Of Passage Essay

1610 words - 6 pages Rites of PassageWhen an individual experiences movement, or a change from an affixed position in society to another position, that individual can easily describe their change as a passage into a new realm of living. A new realm of living is the way in which the individual and society views, acknowledges, and proceeds with their life. Their changes are monumental not only for the individual, but for his/her society as well. Many changes take

"Rites Of Passage" Essay

1547 words - 6 pages as an adolescent and will expect for you to conduct yourself as an adult. There is maturity expected when you become an adult but you are still maturing as an adult, and will hopefully learn from errors and mistakes. There will be transitions you experience as an adult, someday getting married, having a family, and being able to take care of your new responsibilities.The "rites of passage" purpose is to let adolescence know their transition middle