Rob Parson Management Case Study

1684 words - 7 pages

Rob Parson Management Case Study

1 Case Overview
The internal environment at Morgan Stanley was one of teamwork, employee development, dignity and respect. Morgan Stanley had developed a way of building consensus rather that individualism. Rob Parson was thrust into this environment – not sure of what was expected of him and with only one objective in mind – improving the performance of the Capital Markets division. He went about doing this ruthlessly without much care about the organization and its existing practices. While his performance was stellar, he developed a hostile environment around him. On joining there was a tacit agreement with him and his boss that he would be given the position of Managing Director, something that didn’t happen because of his poor inter – personal skills. After two years, he demands the position of Managing Director in return for his stellar performance. It is now up to Gary Stuart, his boss to decide whether to promote him or not. In the pages that follow we take up the role of Gary Stuart and suggest possible solutions to help put an end to this dilemma.
2 Strategy Or Culture?
The decision, whether to promote Rob Parson to the position of Managing Director or not, ultimately boils down to a single question: What is more important to Morgan Stanley: the firm’s culture or the performance of its divisions?
Morgan Stanley’s mission statement clearly states that they “aim to be the world’s best investment bank” and that “they have a commitment to add maximum value which will be characterized by extraordinary effort and innovation”. They aim to “distinguish themselves by creating an environment that fosters teamwork and innovation”. Our interpretation of this statement is that, the focus/strategy is on growth by innovation and providing exceptional customer satisfaction while developing an atmosphere of teamwork and collaboration. We believe that it is the firm’s strategy that dictates its culture and not the other way round. To quote Charles O’Reilly , “once established, a firms strategy dictates a set of critical tasks …achieved through a congruence among the elements of people, structure and culture”.
3 Hire or Fire?
Rob Parson, from what we gather was a person who excelled at providing exceptional customer satisfaction, put in extraordinary effort and often came up with the most innovative financial products to match the needs of his client. True, he wasn’t much of a team player, but then most people in that division of Morgan Stanley wasn’t the most innovative or hard working people either. If that were the case then they wouldn’t need the services of Rob Parson. Not giving him the promotion would not be fair to him. If we were to evaluate this case on the basis of fairness alone, we strongly believe that Rob Parson should be promoted to the position of Managing Director. If not, there is every reason to believe that he will leave Morgan Stanley for a lack of job satisfaction. To quote Dennis W. Organ,...

Find Another Essay On Rob Parson Management Case Study

Human Resource Management Case Study: Google

2367 words - 9 pages -case-study/De Cieri, H. & Kramar, R. et al. (2008). Human Resource Management in Australia: Strategy, People, Performance. North Ryde: McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd.Deutschman, A. (2005,Sep 15). Google will continue to Google? Financial Digest, pp35-41.Google. (2010). Corporate Information - Google Management. [On-line]. Available: http://www.google.com/corporate/execs.htmlMcShane, S.& Travaglione, T. (2007). Organisational BehaviourL On the Pacific Rim. North Ryde: McGraw-Hill Australia Pty Ltd.Nankervis, A., Compton, R., & Baird, M. (2008). Strategic Human Resource Management. Southbank: South-Western Publishing Co. PAGE PAGE 1

CASE STUDY: INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

7214 words - 29 pages - old ways? A case study for the prospects of implementing human resource management practices in a Chinese owned state enterprise. Employee Relations, 25(1), 42-60MMR, (2004December 13). Retailer agrees to do things the Chinese way. 2/(20), 102.Why is HR outsourcing activity so slow in greater China? (2003b), China Staff, 9(5), 1-6.Williamson, P., and Zeng, M. (2004, Summer). Strategies for competing in China: the success of local companies in

Case Study of Hospital Management Issues

2040 words - 8 pages Case Study Analysis: Faith Community HospitalThe article entitled: Let it Pour - My First Assignment as Executive Assistant, exposes three major problems that Faith Community Hospital is faced with. Chris Smith, a recently promoted Executive Assistant, has been enlisted to assist the troubled Chief Executive Officer diagnose and solve these issues. Chris is a recent UOPHX graduate who is very excited to have been chosen to help the CEO with such

Case Study - Intel This is a strategic management case

3078 words - 12 pages . Intel have the unique ability to meet adapt and overcome practically all obstacles to its growth and development. Through the information we are given in the Intel case study we can see much evidence for this core competency, Intel showed their ability to enter and create new markets at ease and also to respond to new challenges in those markets. Intel's move from semi conductors to microprocessors highlights this. The basis for this flexibility

Case study: Knowledge Management at American Management Systems - Knowledge Centers

2457 words - 10 pages was given to marketing the company.Alternative SolutionsResolving which Knowledge Strategy is AppropriateKnowledge Management strategy is characterized by its goals and methods used to pursue the goals. The goals, methods and techniques can be managed in a central or de-central way. (Grolik et al, n.d.) The company needs to resolve whether to retain the central strategy or de-central strategy. In the case presented, the company apparently

Case Study - JKL International plc. International Human Resource Management

5016 words - 20 pages Case Study - JKL International plc.International Human Resource ManagementContents4Case Study- JKL International plc. International Human Resource Management 4Introduction 4Organisational Context (Case Study) 5Part One: Expatriates Management and Cross culture management in Multinational Corporations 5Introduction 5Expatriates and Organisation Problems and Proposals for Changes 5Expatriates Organisation 7Conclusion 8Part Two: 9Appraise The

A Fictional Case Study in Systems and Operations Management

3106 words - 12 pages Case Study in Systems and Operations ManagementAnalysis and evaluation of systems and operations managementBy applying the systems-level hierarchy and by the 4v's topology, one can evaluate and analyse systems and operation management system. An illustration is as follows. GOAL Sale of stationery and office supplies Criterion 1 Retail operations Criterion 2 Store management Criterion 3 Issues of operation Business customer Criterion 4

Non-Profit Management Case Study: Greenhill Community Center

1474 words - 6 pages community.Conclusion:After study with this case, we found the problems for the Greenhill were mainly focused on planning process, communication, fundraising, and staff training & recruitment, with our advises and suggestions, we hope these will help with the management level to deal with such issues and making improvement for further development and services for the community in Coastal City.ReferencesRobert D. H. & Associates (2005). THE JOSSEY-BASS HANDBOOK OF NONPROFIT LEADERSHIP & MANAGEMENT (2nd ed.). San Francisco, CA: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Sales Management-Warren Soft Drinks Ltd. Case Study

3216 words - 13 pages INTRODUCTIONWarren Soft Drinks Ltd is a company which operates in the very competitive market of soft drinks with giants like The Coca-Cola Company and PepsiCo as competitors, but with even less significant ones like Tango and Virgin Cola, as far as carbonated drinks are concerned. In the mineral waters and still concentrates markets the competition is less fierce but existent all the like.As the case study shows there are several issues which

Organizational And Hr Management: Best Buy Case Study

1443 words - 6 pages Case Study of Best Buy, Inc. Best Buy’s History & Main Characters: Best Buy is Minneapolis-based and is North America's leading specialty retailer of consumer electronics, personal computers, entertainment software and appliances. Throughout Best Buy's 37-year history, the company has maintained the tradition of making life fun and easy for customers and employees, while providing a significant return to partners and investors. It has

New Balance Athletic Shoes - A case study for operation management

1771 words - 7 pages Operations Management and Management Science Case Study Capacity Planning New Balance Athletic Shoes Summary James Davis is the president and general manager of New Balance Athletic Shoes. The Boston, Massachusetts based company began producing corrective shoes and arch supports in 1906. New Balance garnered a reputation for quality specialty footwear when in the 1950's it began producing running shoes for men. It is the beginning of 1978

Similar Essays

Rob Parson At Morgan Stanley: Exploring Managerial Problems Associated With Performance Appraisal And Performance Management.

1530 words - 6 pages Statements.Rob Parson was a star producer in the Capital Market Services Department who had been recruited from a competitor two years ago and had generated substantial revenues since joining the firm. I would like to address more specific and surface problems for this situation as follows:2.1 Problem 1 -Rob Parson's Performing Issues.Parson's success at generating business was offset by performance reviews from internal co-workers that painted him

Strategy Management/Case Study/Fed Ex

2378 words - 10 pages To assess FedEx case with Strategy Management, the first question should be asked is"What is strategy?" Johnson and Scholes said: "Strategy is the direction and scope of an organization over the long-term: which achieves advantage for the organization through its configuration of resources within a challenging environment, to meet the needs of markets and to fulfil stakeholder expectations".How Strategy is Managed is why we study Strategic

Case Study Management At Southwest Airlines

977 words - 4 pages Assignment: Case study - Management at Southwest AirlinesQuestion: 01 Name at least two things that Southwest is doing efficiently. Name at least two things that Southwest is doing effectively. In what ways do efficiency and effectiveness support each other at Southwest? In what ways do they contradict each other? Southwest Airlines is one of the important Airline of USA. Southwest Airlines may only rank 317 on the Fortune 500 List but the

Decision Making Case Study Health Care Management

1386 words - 6 pages Question Behind the DecisionBefore making an informed decision, the manager must formulate a research question out of the management question. In this case study the management question is "How will the Young and Middle Aged Adult Department operate with a 15% budget cut?" The research question is "What clinical services should be eliminated or added to allow for the 15% budget cut within the Young and Middle Aged Adult Department's and how will it