This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Robert Elliot's Faking Nature Essay

3136 words - 13 pages

Robert Elliot's "Faking Nature"

ABSTRACT: Robert Elliot's "Faking Nature," (1) represents one of the strongest philosophical rejections of the ground of restoration ecology ever offered. Here, and in a succession of papers defending the original essay, Elliot argued that ecological restoration was akin to art forgery. Just as a copied art work could not reproduce the value of the original, restored nature could not reproduce the value of nature. I reject Elliot's art forgery analogy, and argue that his paper provides grounds for distinguishing between two forms of restoration that must be given separate normative consideration: (1) malicious restorations, those undertaken as a means of justifying harm to nature, and (2) benevolent restorations, or, those which are akin to art restorations and which cannot serve as justifications for the conditions which would warrant their engagement. This argument will require an investigation of Mark Sagoff's arguments concerning the normative status of art restorations.

"Faking Nature" begins with an identification of a particular kind of pernicious restoration—restoration that is used as a rationalization for the destruction of nature. On this claim, any harm done to nature by humans is ultimately repairable through restoration and therefore should be discounted. Elliot calls this view, the "restoration thesis." Elliot rejects the restoration thesis through an analogy between the relationship between original and replicated works of art and nature. Just as we would not value a replication of a work of art as much as we would value the original, we wouldn't value a replicated bit of nature as much as we would the original thing.

The force of the analogy is provided by an argument that with art, as with nature, we rely on an understanding of its origins in order to ascribe its value. For example, Elliot asks us to imagine a case where developers, needing to run underground pipes through our backyard, ask to remove a valuable piece of sculpture from the yard. But because the sculpture is so fragile it cannot be moved. The developer tells us not to worry, because he will replace the sculpture with an exact replica after he finishes. We will reject the fake for the original because we "value the original as an aesthetic object, as an object with a specific genesis and history." (80) In the same way, Elliot suggests we value nature as an object with a "special kind of continuity with the past." Restoration as an attempt to reproduce nature, particularly as motivated by the restoration thesis, fakes original nature as reproduction of a work of art fakes the original piece.

But after clarifying this initial claim, Elliot suggest that perhaps all restorations, not just those embodied in the restoration thesis, are problematic through a series of examples designed to push the argument that nature has a distinct, originary value. In the first two examples, a lover of wilderness named John is deliberately...

Find Another Essay On Robert Elliot's Faking Nature

Happiness as it Relates to Morality

1247 words - 5 pages -depth exploration of this theory of a rational and orderly world. Socrates was perhaps the most noble and wisest Athenian to have ever lived. He was a moral citizen on the constant quest for happiness, an conceived the term “eudaimonia”, which means happiness by nature that arises from fulfillment of our function as humans, in other words living “the god life”. Happiness and morality go hand in hand, as a good life consists of moral virtue

Happiness as it Relates to Morality

1381 words - 6 pages of this theory of a rational and orderly world. Socrates was perhaps the most noble and wisest Athenian to have ever lived. He was a moral citizen on a constant quest for happiness, and conceived the term "eudaimonia", which means happiness by nature that arises from the fulfillment of our function as humans; in other words, living "the good life". Happiness and morality go hand in hand, as the good life consists of moral virtue, which is

Dexter "The Dark Passenger"

2361 words - 9 pages is intelligent and likeable. He is handsome and unassuming while possibly coming off as a bit of a “blood-spatter geek” to his colleagues. However, Dexter differs from other serial killers in one key element; he has a family to whom he feels a great sense of attachment. “The Code of Harry,” as Dexter calls it, includes rules such as never killing innocents and faking emotions and normality to fit in and avoid detection. Dexter’s double conscious

Cause of Napoleon Bonaparte's Death

2170 words - 9 pages . Print. Genta, Robert M., Inti Zlobec, Gad Singer, Alessandro Lugli, Andrea Kopp Lugli, and Luigi M. Terracciano. "Napoleon Bonaparte's gastric cancer: a clinicopathologic approach to staging, pathogenesis, and etiology." Nature Clinical Practice Gastroenterology & Hepatology 4.1 Jan. (2007): 52-57. Print. Johnson, Paul. Napoleon. New York: Viking, 2002. Print. Kauffmann, Jean. The black room at Longwood: Napoleon's exile on Saint Helena

Representation of Mental Illness in Hamlet by Shakespeare

2689 words - 11 pages scholar Robert Burton describes these differences in his work, the Anatomy of Melancholy. Burton defines melancholy as “a perpetual anguish of the soul fastened on one thing”. Madness, although similar in nature, differs in that this “anguish of the soul” has no reason behind it (Burton 108). For Ophelia who struggles not only with the loss of her father, but also with losing Hamlet (Lidz 18), melancholy appears more fitting as it is easy to see the

The Crimes of Andrei Romanovich Chikatilo

2041 words - 8 pages and lost control (Bio movie). He also claimed to be clinically insane and to try and prove himself, he jumped up and shouted at the judge taking off his clothes exposing himself and other times he would start cursing and screaming (Cullen). Most of the people in the courtroom believed he was faking it to gain sympathy so that he would be sent to a mental facility instead of being executed (Bio movie). In his defense he blamed Stalin, his parents

The Formation of an Inefficient Market: Analysis of China's securities market

6045 words - 24 pages widely believed that China's securities market has enjoyed irrational exuberance before its collapse starting 2001. The term Irrational Exuberance has first been used by Alan Greenspan in a black-tie dinner speech entitled "The Challenge of Central Banking in a Democratic Society". As explained by Robert J. Shiller, the writer of the book Irrational Exuberance, this term "is often used to describe a heightened state of speculative fervor". It is

When the Bubble Burst

1539 words - 6 pages By the time I arrived state side from my second tour in the Middle East the housing bubble had already burst. I noticed a drastic change in the way that many of my friends and family were living. Several of my friends that worked in real estate had sold their boats and seconds houses. My own stock portfolio had lost a third of its value. My sister and her husband had defaulted on their home mortgage leaving them scrambling for a place to live. I

phase diagram

4456 words - 18 pages Introduction: Chemical equilibrium is a crucial topic in Chemistry. To represent and model equilibrium, the thermodynamic concept of Free energy is usually used. For a multi-component system the Gibbs free energy is a function of Pressure, Temperature and quantity (mass, moles) of each component. If one of these parameters is changed, a state change to a more energetically favorable state will occur. This state has the lowest free energy

Revolutionary Work of Art

1890 words - 8 pages different color scheme of each scene in the movie. The most memorable part of film to me was in the hotel scene, where dream-thieves had to fight in zero-gravity as the walls twist and tumble around them. That was exceptionally brilliant; the movie overall had elevated art in modern times and defied gravity within each scenes. Also, the movie had different interpretations as I was viewing. The confusing nature of the movie caused heat-able debates

Enlightenment Thought in New Zealand Schools

1594 words - 6 pages In this essay I will be looking at how the political and intellectual ideas of the enlightenment have shaped New Zealand Education. I will also be discussing the perennial tension of local control versus central control of education, and how this has been affected by the political and intellectual ideas of the enlightenment. The enlightenment was an intellectual movement, which beginnings of were marked by the Glorious Revolution in Britain

Similar Essays

Robert Frost Home Burial A Reflection Of Reality

938 words - 4 pages not ease her grief following Elliot's death, and Frost later reported that she knew then that the world was evil. Amy in "Home Burial" makes the same observati Often it seems that writers have their own personal inspiration that fuels a great work to cause its readers to realize the complexity of the human nature. Robert Frost's "Home Burial" is a masterfully written example of such works, conceived from his and his wife's anguish at the loss of

A Response To Martin Krieger's What's Wrong With Plastic Trees

1033 words - 4 pages might also be termed "wilderness." As Robert Elliot describes, this has "causal continuity with the past," (230:A:1), "a specific genesis and history"(229:A:3) "outside our domain" or "independent of us" (229:B:3) and is "undeveloped, unspoilt, or unsullied" (228:B:2) by human influence or interaction. Clearly Krieger's notion of restoration via social redefinition of that which is replaced cannot ameliorate the loss of this aspect of nature

Author Research Paper

1791 words - 7 pages willingness to sacrifice his own life in the face of the invading Fascists to allow Maria and the rest of his comrades to escape. Hemingway points out this event not to show his personal pessimistic nature, but to recognize that happiness initially found in sexual relationships will almost always be reciprocated with a tragedy. This tragedy is a direct result of Robert and Maria's sex-driven relationship.Throughout Ernest Hemingway's works of

The Earth Centered Theme Of Shakespeare's King Lear

3102 words - 12 pages mundane subjects. Thou, Nature, art my goddess; to thy law My services are bound. Wherefore should I Stand in the plague of custom and permit The curiosity of nations to deprive me, For that I am some twelve or fourteen moonshines Lag of a brother? Why bastard? Wherefore base? When my dimensions are as well compact, My mind as generous, and my shape as true, An honest madam's issue? Why brand they us With base? With baseness