Robert Merton’s Work And Criminological Theory

799 words - 3 pages

Durkheim was raised in France during the second half of the eighteenth century, a time when individuals were regulated through society’s collective conscience which was heavily reliant on religion, enlightenment, and Darwinism. It was also a time of great turmoil generated by the French revolution in 1789 and the industrialisation of society, which created the division of labour and specialisation between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie (Gold & Bernard, 1986). One of Durkheim’s key themes is centred on social solidarity, where the transition from mechanic solidarity and the collective conscience of the church became punctured leading to the rise of individualisation (organic solidarity). Durkheim theorized that if the desire for goals was boundless, anomie would ensue, followed by the emergence of strain. The strain would manifest into a range of outcomes, one of which could be deviant behavior (Pfohl, 1994). As crime was an inevitable product of the strain produced by the alienation and dissatisfaction concurrent in the deregulation of society, anomie was therefore representative of suicide and the division of labour.

Merton’s upbringing in Philadelphia and the events that occurred during his writing influenced his take on anomie (Evans, 2006-2009). The Great Depression and the influx of immigrants into America during the nineteenth century turned the land of opportunity into desperation. Nonetheless, Merton came to the similar conclusion of Durkheim’s that deviance was a product of societal structures (Sztompka, 1986). However, because Merton was a middle-range functionalist, he questioned and furthered Durkheim’s concept of anomie from a different perspective. He looked at the smaller problems and tied it to greater society, whereas the grand theorist Durkheim focused on society as a whole. Merton therefore wanted to find out what produced anomie in the first place (Hunt, 1961). Even though Merton accepted anomie and its meaning of a normless society, he posited there were two parts. There was a dichotomy between the goal of wealth in society, and the insufficient means and opportunities to achieve these unlimited aspirations (Merton, 1957, in Cuzzort, 1969). As society encourages all citizens to strive for these goals, irrespective of socio-economic position, anomie thus becomes a problem of relative depravation, and it is this unbalanced process that can create deviance (Johnson, 1981).

To complement his theory, Merton established five modes of adaptation of how an individual responds to the schism/chasm between societal goals and means. Where, the constructed ‘American Dream’ ideal may produce strain for certain groups or individuals and lead to the attainment of culturally accepted...

Find Another Essay On Robert Merton’s Work and Criminological Theory

Evaluate to what extent a) expectancy theory and b) goal theory can explain motivation at work.

863 words - 4 pages the immediate connexion the two engage as they both contain decision-making responsibilities. The question being asked is to what extent can the ideas being used justify motivation at work. Victor Harold Vroom developed the first expectancy theory of work motivation. This theory involves three principles, valence, instrumentality, and expectancy (Vroom, 1964). Valence is the value that is put on the anticipated result; a personal aim would be a

The Strange Case of Dr.Jekyll and Mr Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson as a Work of Horror Fiction

4506 words - 18 pages The Strange Case of Dr.Jekyll and Mr Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson as a Work of Horror Fiction Horror fiction in the 21st century has evolved far from its origins, to the extent where classic horror novels of the Victorian Era are considered to be parodies of how people perceive horror today. The novel 'The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde", which stands alongside classics such as Dracula and Frankenstein, is a

Discuss the use of group work theory and skills and apply to your role as a child or youth practitioner.

1373 words - 6 pages stage model. We will be comparing both theories and picking out their weaknesses and strengths and relating them both to working with young people. Firstly we are going to give a brief description on what is the terms of team work is. Thereafter we will be starting with Tuckmans theory then following Belbin’s theory. After discussing both theories. After both views we will be looking at how successful it really is and include communication other

Strain Theories of Criminal Behaviour

1997 words - 8 pages . Durkheim felt that a large discrepancy between needs and available means would lead an individual to become hopeless with their situation and contemplate suicide. Durkheim’s work greatly influenced fellow structural functionalist Robert Merton (Williams and McShane, 2010). Merton elaborated on Durkheim’s concept of anomie and created two distinct theories of deviance and criminality. Merton’s anomie theory stated that deviance is the result of a

What Causes Crime?

3063 words - 12 pages within the individual to outside influences contributing to the nature of crime and is why Lilly et al., (2011) termed the title "Rejecting Individualism." New theories involving the structure of society were emerging throughout the nation grounded predominately in the Chicago school that posited the city as the root cause and in Robert Merton’s Social Structure and Anomie theory that encompassed cultural values at the core of conformity. Sutherland

Chasing Ghosts: The Search for a General Theory of Crime

2352 words - 10 pages implausible. Nonetheless, the general theories of crime that have been proposed over the past century have been amongst the most influential in the field and shifted the paradigm of criminal thought forever. Furthermore, the contemporary criminological focus seems to be to generate a more comprehensive explanation of criminality; a generalizable theory which can serve as the panacea to the question of what causes people to commit crime (Adams

Anomie and General Strain Theories of crime

1506 words - 6 pages other deviant acts. Development of Anomie Strain Theory Sociologist Robert K. Merton picked up on Durkheim’s concepts of anomie and strain to develop his own perspective. He is most credited for the development of this theory. Merton based his version of the theory on the fact that American society puts its value in material wealth and that all people should strive to attain material wealth. “In Merton’s view, American society is just such a

Learning Theory versus Strain Theory

1815 words - 7 pages was developed by Walter B. Miller and the strain theory was created by Robert K. Merton. Though both Merton’s article, “Social Structure and Anomie” and Walter B. Miller’s article, “Lower Class Culture as a Generating Milieu of Gang Delinquency” both discuss aspects of cultural deviance, there arguments contain several differences. Merton primarily focuses on the materialistic goals all Americans are exposed to regardless of their position in

Criminological Theories Explaining Behaviors of The Cocaine Kids

1584 words - 6 pages -selling world, kept them submerge deep within it, and allowed for them to leave it. Works Cited Lilly, Robert J., Francis T. Cullen, and Richard A. Ball. 2011. Criminological Theory: Context And Consequences. 5th ed. California: SAGE. Williams, Terry. 1989. The Cocaine Kids: The Inside Story of a Teenage Drug Ring. New York: Da Capo Press.

Crime Analysis of Minneapolis

1444 words - 6 pages means to an end. In closing, because this “group” of people feels access and legitimate ways are blocked, influencing a decision of crime as an easy one. Another theory that can explain crime is the general strain theory. This theory builds off Merton’s anomie theory. Robert Agnew claims that this theory, which he further reworked in 1992, builds off three types of strain: the failure to achieve goals, negative treatment by others, and the loss

Classic Strain Theory

1328 words - 5 pages Classic Strain Theory, as introduced and defined by Robert Merton, is a Social Structure Theory used to help explain the effect one’s community, most notably lower class areas, has on their ability to achieve predetermined goals, usually considered culturally normal. Merton theorized that all people in a various culture and social structure have similar values, goals, and norms. He stated that within this social structure there are individuals

Similar Essays

The Contribution Of Robert Merton’s Work To Criminological Theory

2269 words - 9 pages Merton’s work has contributed greatly to criminological theory as he took a different perspective than Durkheim’s concept of anomie and reworked to the American context. The theories and concepts of anomie and strain that Merton argued have influenced the works of Cohen as well as the New Deviancy Theory and the New Penology. Therefore, Strain theory has evolved across time to encompass different situational circumstances of crime. Furthermore

Sociology : Criminology. Criminological Theory And Research

2623 words - 10 pages that connects, integrates and explains them. A good theory is extremely valuable in that it extends our knowledge beyond the facts in front of us (the raw data), enabling us to predict how others might behave at another time and in another place (Bourne and Russo, 1998 p. 33). Criminological theories based on biology, psychology were both, at one stage dominant in the field, however the vast majority of current criminological text employs

Milton Friedman, His Theory And Work.

1068 words - 4 pages steady and only increase it by 3-5 percent each year to allow growth for the economy. Inflation and unemployment would supposedly adjust themselves to the market demands, thus giving the economy low inflation and high stability. He called this theory Monetarism.Milton preached Monetarism for a long period of time until it was finally tried in Great Britain during the 80's. His theory was a big disaster. Milton's theory did not work. For almost seven

John Holland's Theory Of Vocational Personalities And Work Environments

2584 words - 10 pages John Holland's Theory of Vocational Personalities and Work Environments Holland’s theory of vocational personalities and work environments is the premier structural theory behind modern counseling. His theory structural theory is centered around the basic belief that people will seek out careers that offer environments that are compatible with their interest, likes and dislikes. This basic premise is the foundation for Holland’s globally