This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Role Of The Majority In A Society

1142 words - 5 pages

One of the defining principles of democratic society is the idea that “majority rules.” Despite the fundamental nature of this principle, it has been challenged by some of the greatest thinkers in history. Henry David Thoreau, Emmeline Pankhurst and Karl Marx are among these great thinkers who have commented on the role of the majority in different political and social situations. In works such as, “Civil Disobedience,” “Why We Are Militant,” and the “Communist Manifesto,” they point out some of the inherent flaws with the “majority rules” maxim.
In 1849, transcendentalist philosopher and writer, Henry David Thoreau, wrote a treatise originally entitled “Resistance to Civil Government.” This piece is however, now more commonly known as “Civil Disobedience.” Thoreau was staunchly opposed to the two major issues that were prominent in his lifetime: slavery and the Mexican-American War. These issues shaped his political views and led him to write “Civil Disobedience” (SparkNotes Editors).
As an abolitionist, Thoreau was clearly aware of the unfair treatment of African Americans (SparkNotes Editors). African Americans, as now, were a part of the majority that is expected to follow the laws of the country. At this time, African Americans were not being represented, and therefore, the majority was not truly being represented.
However, Thoreau’s stance on majority is two-fold. The second part of Thoreau’s issue with the democratic principle of “majority rules” is more fundamental. He questions the morality of the “majority rules” setup:
But a government in which the majority rule in all cases cannot be based on justice, even as far as men understand it. Can there not be a government in which majorities do not virtually decide right and wrong, but conscience? (Thoreau 2)
Thoreau is concerned that decisions of the majority may not always be just, but rather beneficial to the majority. He feels that it should not be the job of the majority to determine what is right and what is wrong, but the job of the conscience to make such decisions, because “there is little virtue in the action of the masses of men” (Thoreau 4).
He goes on to describe the process of change through the bureaucracy of the governement:
Men generally under such a government as this, think that they ought to wait until they have persuaded the majority to alter them. They think that if they should resist, the remedy would be worse than the evil. But it is the fault of the government itself that the remedy is worse than the evil…Why does it not cherish its wise minority...Why does it not encourage its citizens to be on the alert to point out its faults… (Thoreau 5)
Thoreau argues that under the democratic government, if a small faction recognizes something as evil, they believe they must wait for the majority to believe the same. However he wonders why the government can’t appreciate the wisdom of the few who might have a better grasp of the big picture....

Find Another Essay On Role of the Majority in a Society

The Role of Education in Our Society

1379 words - 6 pages The Role of Education in Our Society Meritocracy is a universalistic viewpoint favoured by many and is widely seen as the ideal way in which society should be founded on. In addition, as the education system is arguably the most important and influential

The Role of Business in Society

1935 words - 8 pages Dr. Novak has strong and well thought out viewpoints of the role of the corporation in society. His belief is that the corporation in the United States is a stronger and better society because of its ability to provide rewards to stakeholders rather than society as a whole. Dr. Novak further adds to his argument that by understanding the differences between corporations and between stakeholders in the United States and Britain he can identify

The Role of Hermaphrodites in Society

659 words - 3 pages The Role of Hermaphrodites in Society In Ruth Gilbert’s At the Border’s of the Human, she discusses society’s interest in hermaphrodites in terms of “people’s desire to examine, scrutinize, and display objects which are alien, strange and other” (6). The anomalous and bizarre spectacle of the hermaphroditic body has drawn the focus of scientists since the early sixteenth century. Hermaphrodites have long evoked a “mixture of disgust and

The Role of Religion in Roman Society

3506 words - 14 pages The Role of Religion in Roman Society Throughout the history of Rome, from the monarchy to the late empire, religion had played a great role in it's society and was involved in almost every aspect of the life of the Roman citizen. It was common for each house to have it's own patron god/gods and ,on special occasions, the head of the house would make a sacrifice to the personal gods of the family. Also, great festivals were usually held in

The Role of Community in Society

774 words - 3 pages The Role of Community in Society Communities are an essential part of our society, because we all depend and interact with each other. Communities are groups of people that help an individual to learn and develop new ideas. A society is where people’s relations with each other are direct and personal and where a complex web of ties link people in mutual bonds of emotion and

The Role of Roman Women in Society

1111 words - 5 pages theses affairs were for their own good and to put them in their place. Few agreed with this commentary but most argued that times had changed and the circumstances led to the change. Roman women were essential supporters of the military.The expansion of rome put great demands on women's role in society by supporting the Senate and the people of with their patriotism and wealth. Also by giving up their sons and husbands for a period of war in the

The Role of Genetics in Modern Society

1470 words - 6 pages The Role of Genetics in Modern Society Genes by definition are information we inherit from our parents, they contain chromosomal information which codes for every physical and mental attribute a human, animal or plant has. Modern society has come to realise by finding the gene that causes the illness they can remove it. They then can insert the correct gene to replace it. Genes are arranged like beads on a piece of

The Important Role of Mathematicians in Society

1626 words - 7 pages The Important Role of Mathematicians in Society Thesis Statement This report will focus on the professional field of mathematicians. It will highlight some of the history, responsibilities, opportunities, and requirements of this occupation. Outline I.     Introduction A.     A condensed history of mathematics B.     Famous mathematicians and their accomplishments II

The Role of Television in Today's Society

3011 words - 12 pages The Role of Television in Today's Society Has this technical box indoctrinated our minds with useless facts and images or has it given us a sensation of enjoyment, education and pure entertainment? Television has become ubiquitous across the globe. Nearly every household in Britain owns at least one television if not more. In my house we have three. For the past 80 years, this piece of technology has become more popular

Role of the Disabled in Today's Society

1300 words - 6 pages ), and the IDEA they influence people about what is going on in today’s world and what more can be done. The Guidelines for Assessment of and Intervention with Persons with Disabilities, have some important key points. Psychologists are in the positioned to help individuals with disabilities become a productive addition to society. They can help them navigate the system and show them how it could a benefit them. Psychologists are there to ensure a

Slavery Evolved: A Minority Control A Majority of The Wealth

1993 words - 8 pages . In essence, Americans become slave holders every time they purchase products manufactured in these conditions. Made vulnerable in their desperation, the poor around the world are subjected to economic exploitation, becoming a seemingly endless supply of slaves to the economic power of free trade. The majority of Americans, in their ignorance, effectively endorse and contribute to the prostitution of over 100 million child laborers (Guay). How

Similar Essays

The Nature Of A Business And Its Role In Society

864 words - 3 pages Outline the nature of business and its role in societyThe nature of a business is to produce and sell products, which can be either goods and/or services that fulfil consumers needs and wants in an attempt to earn a profit. Business plays a vital role in society through it providing both economic and social benefits. These benefits include profit, employment, income, choice, innovation, entrepreneurship, wealth creation, and also the quality of

The Role Of Media In The Society

1254 words - 5 pages The Role of Media in the Society Media has always played a huge role in our society. For a long time media was one of the methods of controlling people and leisure. In ancient times when there was no newspapers and television, people used literature as source of information, some books like "the Iliad", and different stories about great kings, shows those people the information about them. Nowadays media is one of the

The Role Of Police In Society

2152 words - 9 pages The Role of Police in Society In today's society the police, play may roles. They are the peacekeepers, law enforcement and many other jobs. However, recently they have become the subject of a very heated and large debate. Many believe that the police should give up their brute type tactics for a more civilized and humanized approach, while others feel that the police should crack down on the most insignificant of offences to type and

The Role Of Sports In Society

718 words - 3 pages , Sport has become a major institution in society, and, indeed, the modern world. Yet, our understanding of the role of this major social phenomenon are really clear. Sport as a cultural phenomenon affecting human's physical and mental aspects is essential for the development of a happiness and vigorous society and for the attainment of the individual's psychosomatic health. It is therefore of the greatest significance that people should engage in