Romeo And Juliet" A True Aristotelian Tragedy

2375 words - 10 pages

A true Aristotelian tragedy is considered to contain characters with one single flaw. Characters such as these display actions that wholly influence the outcome of the tragedy. William Shakespeare does just that in the writing of Romeo and Juliet. The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet shall be considered an Aristotelian Tragedy as opposed to a tragic poem. This is true because every aspect of this poem adheres to the definition of Aristotelian. This poem should be considered an Aristotelian Tragedy because Romeo and Juliet committed their own flaw, which causes a chain reaction leading to their deaths. The two lovers are incontestably able to control their actions, yet they simply and eagerly choose not to. This is a decision completely controlled by one’s own self, and it can easily be prevented. In addition, Romeo and Juliet is not considered plainly tragic because in a tragic poem, the outcome is controlled by fate. However, in this suspenseful poem, that is not the case. William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet is an Aristotelian Tragedy because an unexpected couple is unable to control their love, the realization that their coming between a disdainful feud, and their immaturity causes them to take extreme actions.
In this tragedy, Romeo and Juliet display their weaknesses when it comes to love. Romeo and Juliet tend to make poor decisions in general, but especially when it comes to their love. It all started when Romeo saw Juliet for the first time: “What lady is that which doth / enrich the hand / of yonder knight?” (I, v, 40-42). This is when Romeo immediately falls in love, displaying how Romeo tends to fall in love rather quickly, rather than actually getting to know a person first. In essence, Romeo falls head over heels for Juliet because, in a matter of days he falls in love, marries, and soon enough kills himself for her. As Thrasher has previously stated: “It is too perfect and too passionate for their world” (Page). He is saying how Romeo and Juliet think they are living in their own prefect world where nothing bad can happen to them. Soon reality will strike, and there will be no turning back. Furthermore, since they are teenagers who think they are in love, they do not understand what mistakes they are truly making by continuing with their romantic relationship. Romeo soon takes his love to the extreme when he continues to show his undying love for Juliet. In their reality, he believes “For fear of that, I still will stay with thee, / And never from this palace of dim night/Depart again” (V, iii, 115-117). Here, he is bestowing the ultimate sacrifice for Juliet. He does this to be with his one and only love for the rest of his life. This shows weakness on Romeo’s part because for Juliet, Romeo is willingly paying the ultimate price, which is death. Rite then and there, Romeo commits a behemothic mistake, his suicide. Juliet, on the other hand, shows her weakness in her romance by indubitably wanting to marry Romeo the night she meets...

Find Another Essay On Romeo and Juliet" A True Aristotelian Tragedy

Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet as a Tragedy

1955 words - 8 pages Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet as a Tragedy "Romeo and Juliet" is the most famous love story in the English literary tradition. The play focuses on romantic love, specifically the intense passion that arises at first sight between Romeo and Juliet. The play covers a very short time span of three days, in which Romeo and Juliet meet, fall in love, marry and die. The "story of…woe" is inevitable from the moment the

Romeo and Juliet as a Tragedy

791 words - 3 pages ROMEO AND JULIET AS A TRAGEDYShakespeare's Romeo and Juliet is his eleventh play. It is with no doubt a tragedy.Shakespeare has included all the necessary elements for a tragedy. The play has a tragic heroof high standing who dies. The hero opposes some conflicting force. The hero has a tragicflaw and this flaw will lead to his downfall and the downfall of others. Good is alwayswasted driving out evil. Indeed, Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet is a

Romeo and Juliet: A Tragedy or Simply Tragic?

1147 words - 5 pages and out of despair takes her own life. Juliet could have accepted Romeo’s death and live without him; but because she attaches herself so closely to him, she must suffer the consequences. Juliet’s loyalty is her major flaw and makes Romeo and Juliet a true Aristotelian tragedy. Finally, what qualifies Romeo and Juliet as an Aristotelian tragedy is the major reversal of fortune that the star-crossed lovers undergo. According to Aristotle, in order

THE ELEMENTS THAT ESTABLISH ROMEO AND JULIET AS A TRAGEDY

1249 words - 5 pages Shakespeare is a well known author who wrote in the 1500's. Many of his plays are classified as tragedies. According to the Oxford dictionary of current English, a tragedy is described as a serious disaster or a sad event. In Shakespeare plays, tragedy is identified as a story that ends unhappily due to the fall of the protagonist, which is the tragic hero. For a play to be a tragedy, there must be a tragic hero. In the play Romeo and Juliet

Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare as a Tragedy

1437 words - 6 pages Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare as a Tragedy "Romeo and Juliet" is considered by most people to be Shakespeare's most tragic work. Two young people die for their love for each other - what can be more purer, romantic and tragic than that. But is it as simple as that? What does actually make the play so tragic? Before we can discuss the tragic aspects of Romeo and Juliet, we must first understand the meaning of

The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet

1481 words - 6 pages Tragedies show events that make the audience feel pity and fear for the tragic heroes because of the things that the characters had to go through. Many people feel that a tragedy is something that is sad and nothing more. However, that is not the case with Aristotle. According to Aristotle, a tragedy has several key components that have to be fulfilled before it can be considered a true tragedy. Romeo and Juliet, a classical play by William

Impulsiveness in Shakespeare’s Tragedy "Romeo and Juliet"

865 words - 3 pages Reckless actions lead to untimely deaths. In Shakespeare’s tragedy “Romeo and Juliet”, both protagonists fight for their hopeless love. Bloodshed and chaos appear inevitable in fair Verona; Romeo and Juliet come from enemy households, the Montegues and the Capulets, who have sworn to defeat one another. The young and handsome Romeo weeps over his unrequited love for Rosaline, until he lays his eyes on Juliet. Strong and independent, Juliet

The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet

1233 words - 5 pages combination of a personal failing and circumstances with which he cannot deal". This is directly proportional to Romeo and Juliet due to the fact that both of the major characters commit suicide in the end in order to finally be together. A tragic hero is "a literary character who makes an error of judgement or has a fatal flaw that, combined with fate and external forces, brings on a tragedy". This definition explains the characters Romeo and Juliet, and

The tragedy of romeo and juliet

729 words - 3 pages true tragedy. The elements are the play must have an extraordinary hero or heroine, and the hero must be destroyed, and the death must serve a purpose. A tragedy must have an extraordinary hero or heroine. Romeo and Juliet have those qualities. For example, Romeo was prepared to take risky steps to preserve their love. One risky step he did was when he was in the Capulet's Vaults with Juliet. "For fear of that I will stay with thee, / And

The tragedy of "Romeo and Juliet"

792 words - 3 pages William Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet" is a story filled with misery and the lack of obedience. It takes part in Verona where two families pour hatred over each other passed on from generations. The hatred between the two families leaves two desperate "star-crossed lovers" in despair and tragedy. In this play many characters may be blamed for the tragedy because they do not do their duty. These certain characters include the motherly nurse

The tragedy of Romeo and Juliet

804 words - 3 pages Romeo and Juliet, is a story of two young lovers, whose love was destined for destruction. They did not imagine that their love would lead to the tragedies that it did. These two young people did nothing wrong except fall in love. Three aspects of their destruction included the feud between the two families, the nurse and her betrayal of Juliet and the most important aspect of all is fate.The feud between the two families was one factor that

Similar Essays

Romeo And Juliet: A True Aristotelian Tragedy

1122 words - 4 pages Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare is often referred to as a classic love story. It is a story of love at first sight and fighting between families. The classic is a true tragedy because of the way it is created. Romeo and Juliet is an Aristotelian tragedy because it clearly follows the model shown by Aristotle. All aspects of the plot and characters perfectly follow way Aristotle defined. The plot follows the events that need to occur and

Romeo And Juliet: A True Tragedy

1658 words - 7 pages Romeo and Juliet: A True Tragedy An Aristotelian tragedy consists of several different aspects. In William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, the main characters contain a tragic flaw, or hamartia, that contributes to their fall from esteem or regal status. Additionally, the audience experiences pity and fear evoked by Shakespeare for the duration of the play. Furthermore, the two star-crossed lovers undergo a catastrophe at the end of the

Romeo And Juliet: A True Tragedy

2306 words - 9 pages tragic elements, protagonists with tragic flaws, and the unavoidable path of destiny. These ideas from Romeo and Juliet follow Aristotle’s ideas about creating a true tragedy. Due to these components in the play Romeo and Juliet becomes a level higher than an ordinary emotional story. Not only does it contain important Aristotelian ideas, but these ideas are integrated with the plot so that the cause and effect chain can progress throughout the

Elements Of Aristotelian Tragedy Depicted In Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

1811 words - 7 pages An Aristotelian tragedy includes many different characteristics. It is a cause-and-effect chain and it contains the elements of catharsis, which is pity and fear, and hamartia, which is the tragic flaw embedded in the main characters. The famous play Romeo and Juliet, written by William Shakespeare, is about two lovers of two different families who hate each other and the misdemeanors they have to surpass. Many debate on whether it is an