Ronald Dworkins Liberal Morality Essay

889 words - 4 pages

Dworkin begins by roughly defining liberalism according to the New Deal: “It combined an emphasis on less inequality and greater economic stability with more abundant political and civil liberty for the groups campaigning for these goals.” Dworkin states that such a definition is inadequate and goes on to elaborate on liberalism in more depth. The liberal, in economic policies, demands that the inequalities of wealth be reduced through social programs such as “welfare and other redistribution financed by a progressive tax.” Liberals also take a Keynesian policy toward the governments stabilizing intervention in the economy, such as controlling inflation and unemployment. And liberals support freedom of speech, racial equality and are “suspicious of criminal law.”
     Dworkin states that in a society, liberty and equality, the most important political ideals, often come into conflict with one another. “In these cases, good government consists in the best compromise between the competing ideals, but different politicians and citizens will make that compromise differently.” Liberals tend to favor equality more than liberty than conservatives do. But the former statement is a tricky one according to Dworkin because liberty, unlike equality, cannot be shown because we lack a concept of liberty that “is quantifiable in the way that a demonstration would require.” Because of this, it would be mistaken of us to state that conservatives favor liberty more than liberals, because conservatives will recede some liberties for some benefits, as our fundamental liberties are valued because of something else that they protect. The conservative “protects the commodity of liberty, valued for its own sake, more effectively” than the liberal. But unlike liberty, equality is a concept that can be shown, and because of this, it can be stated that conservatives do in fact favor equality less and liberals more.
     Two concepts of equality must be distinguished according to Dworkin: the first is that the government should treat all its citizens, or all those that are in its charge as equals, and the second principle of equality requires that the government treat all of those in its charge equally in “the distribution of some resource of opportunity.” Liberals sense of equality will fall more into the latter idea of equality. The conservative feels that, treating citizens as equals, as the liberals see equality, would amount to treating the citizens in fact as unequal. The most efficient means of helping the least well off in fact is the free market, and not the government’s redistribution of wealth.
     But then what does it mean for the government to treat its citizens as equals? The first “supposes that government must be...

Find Another Essay On Ronald Dworkins Liberal Morality

Gauthier Summary from SEP Essay

1512 words - 6 pages called the "no agreement position," the situation to which the individuals return in case of failure to make an agreement or contract. This situation may be more or less hostile, and more or less social, depending on how the theorist characterizes human life in the absence of rules of morality or justice. But crucial to all contractarian theories, there is some scarcity or motivation for competition in the initial situation and there is some

Gauthier Essay

1512 words - 6 pages called the "no agreement position," the situation to which the individuals return in case of failure to make an agreement or contract. This situation may be more or less hostile, and more or less social, depending on how the theorist characterizes human life in the absence of rules of morality or justice. But crucial to all contractarian theories, there is some scarcity or motivation for competition in the initial situation and there is some


1912 words - 8 pages of 1776. By 1800 Calvinist church had roughly split into an orthodox wing and a liberal wing. The liberals had been strongly influenced by enlightenment ideas. The background for political and religious reforms was built. New era of American history had started. The Jacksonian era was a precursor to the greater extension of such philosophies and tactics in the post-Civil War era, as evidenced by the actions and policies of Presidents Theodore

The Death Penalty Debate

1881 words - 8 pages States specifically, the issue has great significance to the bill of rights and the 8th amendment, which prevents cruel and unusual punishment. The death sentence, due to the intense debate on its morality and constitutionality, as well as the many conflicting decisions made about it until this day, still is and will likely remain a very controversial issue in the United States. The death penalty has existed almost as long as civilization itself

Religion in American Politics

1982 words - 8 pages Majority. The following year brought about the 1980 election in which Ronald Reagan, a Republican and evangelical sympathizer, won the presidency. “Reagan acknowledged white evangelical voters in the 1980’s and embraced (at least rhetorically) their concerns” (Fowler 1995:36). The concerns of the Moral Majority and evangelical Protestants in general include, but are definitely not limited to the following: the return of prayer to public school (via

Comparing Symbols and Symbolism in Blue Hotel, Black Cat, Night, Alfred Prufrock, Red Wheelbarrow

1644 words - 7 pages color being a moral statement is particularly conventional among the pious where a color such as bright blue would be considered a sign of vanity and therefore sinful." (1) Those in the duller colors of the East see the blue as shameful. If Crane is relating color to morality, then the blue represents the liberal and free spirited nature, while the brown-red and gray represent conservative tradition. (1) Color, therefore, not only is related to

Politics as Media Spectacle - Arnold Schwarzenegger as Governor

1964 words - 8 pages public that Arnold was a “great guy” and “great husband.” On the Oprah Winfrey show, Schwarzenegger was able to tell viewers how he brought his wife coffee in bed in the morning as Maria sat by his side beaming. And on the campaign/media trail, one-time liberal actor Rob Lowe tirelessly appeared in the media touting the virtues of his fellow actor. Schwarzenegger carried the aura of the Kennedy family as his wife Maria Shriver’s

Shaping American Cultures

2532 words - 11 pages were already set apart from any other decade that had come before with the liberal government, the hippies and the threat of nuclear annihilation, while conservatism was not dead, liberalism enjoyed a wide spread revival which aided in evolvement of the sexual revolution. Lyndon Johnson was the first American president to endorse birth control, which played and eminent role in the change of the Americans’ attitude towards sex in the 1960s. “The


5239 words - 21 pages (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1992); see also, e.g., Ronald Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1978); Stephen Macedo, Liberal Virtues: Citizenship, Virtue, and Community in Liberal Constitutionalism (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990). [3] Weber, Economy and Society, op. cit., p. 922. [4] Berger, op. cit. [5] Taylor, "Cross-Purposes," op. cit., p. 165. [6] Ibid., p. 165. [7] Tocqueville

American Political Parties

1368 words - 5 pages challenges the ideology of American conservatism. Conservatism champions smaller governments, lower taxes, limited regulation and open enterprise. Socially, conservatives want a robust government that can enforce the Christian religion as well morality. President Ronald Reagan is known to have strengthened Republicanism by cutting taxes, increasing government spending as well as deregulation in the 1980s. In fact, his model became the basis for

Amartya Sen's What is Equality?

3920 words - 16 pages actually exist) are in the area of empirical assumptions and theories rather than in the area of moral assumptions and theories. With respect to this controversy the fact is that there is as much difference within the liberal egalitarian camp (John Rawls, Ronald Dworkin, Amartya Sen, Martha Nussbaum, Thomas Scanlon, Norman Daniels, Will Kymlicka, et al.) as there is within the socialist egalitarian camp (G.A. Cohen, John Roemer, Jon Elster, Kai

Similar Essays

Tolerance, Liberalism, And Community Essay

3297 words - 13 pages commitments. The defense of tolerance found in Locke, Mill, Hart, and the Rawls of A Theory of Justice is clearly mounted within critical morality. Other communitarian criticisms of the liberal principle of tolerance take many forms and depend upon a variety of appeals to differing conceptions of community. I will deal only with what might be called the appeal to the sources of reflection, as found in Michael J. Sandel(3) and (with qualifications

Liberalism Vs Conservatism And The Blurring Of Lines

1443 words - 6 pages and traditions; want order even at cost to those at the bottom [of society]. In regards to Liberalism, from a political standpoint, modern Liberals are by definition, contemporary freedom fighters, who have taken the ideas of Enlightenment to the extreme, and ultimately aiming to spread a public morality bereft and divergent of religion; and stress the importance of a fully integrated freedom of choice and speech (presumably within the letter of

The Transformation Of Liberalism Essay

2879 words - 12 pages separation between morality and the law. According to Holmes, we fall into 'fallacy' when we take terms such as malice, intent, and negligence and apply them in a moral context to legal issues (Holmes, 1896). This separation of the law and morality signaled the centering of the society as the root of law. The thought that law should reflect the emotions and needs of the citizens is important when reflecting upon the evolution of liberal law

Government And Politics Chapter 2 Modern Ideologies And Political Philosophy

1628 words - 7 pages - On Representative Government: in favor of democratic government on liberal premises. The chief end of politics is to allow people to become responsible and mature.The liberal ideology: Democracy is the proper form of government, people should have full intellectual freedom, govern. Should remain minimal and should regulate people's lives very little (people should learn to make decisions by themselves), people should be free to regulate their own