This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Room For A Cosmopolitan Future: Habermas And The New Order

1270 words - 6 pages

Given the antagonism between rights-based claims to sovereignty and democratic self-determination by groups of people and similarly rights-based claims to human rights by individuals, can Habermas’ theory of cosmopolitan law offer a solution which does not jeopardize the construction of a political community that regulates itself through the control of relationships between the interior and the exterior?

Jürgen Habermas’ notion of a cosmopolitan democracy conceptualizes a legalized regulation of world politics through the formulation of a collected system of mediated institutions, transnational organisations and regional economics in such a way as to promote the individualistic, cosmopolitan rights of the individual as well as the strengthening of the democratic processes within the state itself. This paper will attempt to show, however, that such a framework is largely unsuccessful because it is incapable of legitimating the internal and external democratic structure through the creation of a shared political and social culture. This seems to depend, for the most part, on the nature of the democratic ideals towards which the cosmopolitan order would have to lend itself.
Democracy appears to necessitate the constitution of the person as part of a demos; that is to say, as an individual within a meta-community whose functional capacities are governed by identifiable rules establishing the relational modes that exist between those on the inside and those on the outside, which for Habermas represents the construction of a system for the exclusion of the other (reference). This system of exclusion, which can be understood with reference to the rule of law - that which governs the relationships of all parts of a demos - is authored, addressed and accepted by the democratic people. On this account, the members of a democracy - the citizen body - are not citizens of the world, but rather are members of geographically, politically and legally distinct communities. However, as it becomes increasingly difficult to differentiate between the internal and the external – between the foreign and the domestic – the existing model of states with self-styled sovereignty existing independently from external control has become increasingly questionable. This being said, the outcomes of a process of globalization such as the rapid growth and accelerated dispersal over international borders of the political, economic and cultural influences does not necessarily contradict the democratic practice nor the nation state, and clearly neither look ready to collapse. If, however, globalization is to continue in the face of an ever-narrowing space for a feasible popular input into the political, without deleteriously reducing the ability for states to retain legitimacy in decision-making, then alternative structures for a democratic process needs to be developed.
The cosmopolitan democracy offered by Jürgen Habermas may offer a structural and ethical solution for a world...

Find Another Essay On Room for a Cosmopolitan Future: Habermas and the New Order

A comparison of two types of renewable energies in China: hydro energy and biomass energy, in order to determine the most suitable for China’s future

1860 words - 7 pages energy here comes from the coal power and oil combustion (Feng 2007, 14). However, China needs to look to the future: coal and oil minerals, which are resources for coal burning and oil energy respectively, are exhaustible resources and at one time will come to an end. In addition, China is the greatest emitter of CO2 (carbon dioxide) (Sang and Zhu 2010, 5) where more than 80 per cent of these emissions come from coal firing (Wang and Chen 2010

the future world order Essay

1608 words - 7 pages The future world order There were a talk on ‘the future world order’ which is held on 23 march in Hall A, UUM Convention Centre. This talked was conducted by three panelists. First talk was given by Professor Ken Booth, the second talked was given by Professor Dato. Dr. Zakaria Ahmad and the last talked was given by Professor Arujunan Narayanan. This talked was held for three hours and it was a great opportunity for the students to know more

Control And Order As A Metaphor For Social Order In One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest

700 words - 3 pages patients seems far more terrible and socially unacceptable than their humorous psychotic behavior. The question of what constitutes insanity is a powerful metaphor throughout the film for questioning the social and moral order of American society.In the context of America in 1975, this question has pertinent social implications as well. Disillusionment replaced optimism as North Vietnam finally overran South Vietnam in April of 1975. Democracy had

Defeats at the Workplace, in the Media, and Within the New Corporate Order: The Homestead Strike, a Lost Cause for American Labor

3236 words - 13 pages win, and win easier than you suppose.” However, for the strikers, stakes were extremely high: they were defending the security of their livelihoods in the steel industries, their homes (which depended on the mills’ support), their history of labor organization, and above all, the future of AAIS. In their struggle to regain a sense of agency to maintain control over workplace conditions and wages as well as preserve unionism at Homestead, workers

"For the Fun, Fearless, Female" - analysis of Cosmopolitan magainze (articles and ads)

940 words - 4 pages for her man. While also encouraging her to check out the new fashions that will make her her own person. This kind of 'liberated' woman is fictional and misleading, and makes readers believe that following the tips the articles offer will make them the perfect woman, perhaps like the woman on the cover.Advertising is a very extensive part of Cosmopolitan, seemingly more so than that of the articles. Of the 268 pages in one issue of Cosmo, only

Haven The New Order

3309 words - 14 pages see what Cam and Madison looked like, both of them were skinny with brown hair. They could have been brother and sister, but they didn’t act like it. “How old is Haven Tower?” Melanie asked. Cam answered her question, “It has only been open for four months, President Dux has even shown commitment to the New Order by living there.” “We’re pretty lucky that we are even allowed access to Haven. Last night there was a close call, airplanes flew over

Many New Eggs for the Future

712 words - 3 pages limited to regular 9 to 5 constraints like physical stores. These stores are open 24/7/365 and offer a new level of convenience to their shoppers. The added convenience and reduction in price has given a great advantage to many e-commerce sites over their physical store competitors. By the same token, the advantage many business’ have from e-commerce stores has gone to crippling many physical stores. For example, is an online retailer of

iPad: The New ‘Scalpel’ and ‘Eyes’ of the Operating Room

857 words - 4 pages of operating theaters everywhere since the inception of the Da Vinci Robot, laparoscopy, and digital screens for imaging display. As with the aforementioned devices, skepticism and opposition to the introduction of the iPad as a new assistive tool in the operating room has arisen. First and foremost, is the matter of sterility, which advocates have addressed by way of sterile X-ray cassette bags clamped off with hemostats, both a relatively

"Cosmopolitan Race Analysis". The essay explores racial representation in Cosmopolitan Magazine, and how limited it is

900 words - 4 pages Cosmopolitan Magazine's notoriety is mostly based upon displaying the "most beautiful" women in the world. This magazine gives young women a standard of beauty to strive for, although it is realistically unattainable. Therefore, it was chosen as the site of study due to it's popularity and provision of the hegemonic notions of what is beautiful. Looking through the October and November issues of Cosmopolitan magazine, over 150 advertisements

To what extent does modern technology pose new challenges for the police in balancing liberty and order concerns

2835 words - 11 pages forces local intelligence pods or officers who amass a wide range of information. These technologies are seen as vital new tools in crime-fighting and are also seen as a necessary response for the police to adopt in relation to the changing nature of some crime. Criminals are becoming more and more techno literate and in some areas have the police at a distinct disadvantage. One clear example of the gap is in areas such as child abuse and money

International Political Economy Essay – China and The New Economic Order

2989 words - 12 pages Ramo (2004), amassed "asym- metric power" in the global arena. Ifit is the power of this state that has enabled China to become a pole of growth for global capitalism during the era of neolib- eral accumulation, itis thefuture direction ofthis state thathas rendered "therise of China" so uns~tding for the evolving global capitalist order. Thebankruptcy of neoliberalism and the Chinese state's ability to resistwholesale neoliberalization- or, put

Similar Essays

Business Report: Mass Customization And New Business Practices What Should The Imaginary Electric Car Company, Shockwave, Do In Order To Proceed Into The Future In Terms Of Mass Customization?

2460 words - 10 pages Executive SummaryThe term "mass customization", while seemingly an oxymoron to anyone who has lived through the past century, is becoming a reality. Despite the fact that since manufacturing began customization was a luxury reserved for the most wealthy, today's markets are demanding more and more from today's producers. A new found buying power enables customers to ask for the apparently impossible and with such variety in all forms of industry

Advocates For A New Social Order: Dickens, Marx, And The Trade Union In Hard Times

2651 words - 11 pages Advocates for a New Social Order: Dickens, Marx, and the Trade Union in Hard Times For over a century, Charles Dickens has been praised as being the working man's advocate, and the lower classes have played a major role in peopling his vast world of characters. Always, the reader is left with a sense of sympathy and pity for these characters as Dickens' journalistic descriptions of their plight are often dramatic, stirring, and pathetic

Habermas And Bourdieu For World Peace

708 words - 3 pages the opportunity for every sovereign individual to participate within the public realm for rational discourse to take place. Both Bourdieu and Habermas’ theories identify the hurdles of equitable discourse. World peace implies a “neutrality” of speech void of language games and communication anchored in widespread participation. In Bourdieu’s words, “The use of language…depends on the social position of the speaker;” and in effect, the authority

New Energy For The Future Essay

1717 words - 7 pages New Energy for the Future For years man has relied on energy in order to be successful in life. The industrial revolution relied on coal for the new inventions brought into the world. Life as has never been the same since then. However since that time, there has been little done to improve on energy efficiency and humans still primarily rely on fossil fuels for energy. For over a hundred years the Earth has become more polluted and dirtier than