Rosenthal's Higher Order Thought Theory Essay

2514 words - 10 pages

Introduction:
In this essay I will argue that Rosenthal's Higher Order Thought Theory provides a possible account of conscious awareness, in doing so addresses and gets to solve the mind-body problem for that particular mental phenomenon.
I will commence by defining what makes a mental state conscious. This will be done aiming to distinguish what type of state we are addressing when we speak of a mental phenomenon and how is it, that can have a plausible explanation. By taking this first approach, we are able to build a base for our main argument to be clear enough and so that we can remain committed to.
Next, I will proceed to describe what the HOT Theories are, which conditions or requirements contain, as well as mentioning some constraints they may show and that in turn can motivates them.
At this point I will start developing a more explicit account of how Rosenthal’s higher order thought theory, tries to explain consciousness in some mental states like awareness.
First order theories are a challenge to any higher order thought theories; consequently I will briefly look at some of them, for they are the other type of theories contesting the explanation of consciousness. Also, one of this FO theories is strongly supported by Ned Block, who is the main objector to Rosenthal's HOT Theories in this essay.
Some examples will be added that are necessary to assist us, in sustaining the main argument as well as to facilitate defining some requirements, for a HOT to occur in a conscious state.
Thirdly, some of Ned Blocks objections to the Higher Order Thought Theory will be considered and review in order to reaffirm the validity of the main argument. Block's objections will be taken as the main challenge to Rosenthal's HO theory. These will include his position in support of ‘the Explanatory Gap’ that he alludes the HOT theory is trying to solve the mystery.
In this manner we should reach a conclusion, were one can easily recognize, how a higher order thought theory can provide with a good explanation for conscious awareness. By giving this plausible account, in turn also gets to solve the mind-body problem for that mental phenomenon.

I.
What makes a state conscious? When referring to conscious states, I intended to give an account of how mental states that are conscious varied, from the ones that are not. For doing otherwise, may cause to miss pointing towards the reason why, the conscious ones are that way. This turns out to be a constraint on any type of theory while trying to outline what is it for a state to be conscious.
Mental states such as thoughts and perceptiions are conscious if we are aware of them in some intuitevely manner. We also apply the term conscious to the creatures that are in those mental states and we call this creature consciousness. However, some mental states happen in waking and sentient conscious life without those states being conscious, so a state's being conscious cannot depend upon being the state of a...

Find Another Essay On Rosenthal's Higher Order Thought Theory

Quantity Theory of Money Essay

1049 words - 5 pages Quantity theory of money is a basic topic that one should have general ideas about in order to understand the long run relationship between prices and inflation in macroeconomics class. One of the central implication of the theory basically states that countries which have higher money growth tend to have higher inflation rate. The quantity theory of money has been supported by data from many countries and for different periods of time. A common

Douglas McGregor’s Human Side of Enterprise

1579 words - 6 pages . According to a book review by Eileen Kelly (2000), McGregor left an indelible impression of the American business landscape and on management thought with his Theory X and Theory Y. Interestingly enough, the aforementioned book review was done on a book called Douglas McGregor, Revisited: Managing the Human Side of the Enterprise that was published in 2000, which highlights the fact that McGregor’s work is still relevant and worth revisiting and

What best explains people's willingness to work hard?

2536 words - 10 pages responsibility because creativity and ingenuity are common in the population.McGregor used Maslow's hierarchy of needs as a basis for his work. Theory X consists of the "lower order" needs of Maslow's hierarchy, whilst Theory Y uses "higher order" needs. He believed that management could use either lower or higher order needs to motivate employees, but meeting the needs of Theory Y would give better results.According to Theory X, management

Abraham Maslow - Hierarchy of Needs

1187 words - 5 pages they obtain after the task is complete. Maslow has been a very inspirational figure in personality theories.The Hierarchy of Needs theory has four different levels before one comes to full self-actualizing. These levels are, in order, the psychological needs, safety, love and care and esteem needs. The psychological needs are those one needs to survive, such as food, water, oxygen, shelter and more. Then comes the need for safety and protection for

Theories of Motivation

1725 words - 7 pages . His theory also talked bout how, when people move up the ladder of success, their lower order needs become less important than their higher order. There is not much research to support this theory and due to the rapidly changing work environments, these days this type of theory must be made more flexible to accommodate the people working today.The second content theory is called the Erg theory and was founded by a man named Clayton Alderfer. His

Workplace Motivation

1135 words - 5 pages necessary satisfy a lower need before moving on to satisfy a higher needs . ERG theory has some advantages and disadvantages, . Firstly, when the people advance to the higher-level need, the desire to lower-level need increases. Secondly there are some countries changes the order of these groups. Finally, when there are more than one need operative at the same time, that makes the managers who want motivate their employees confuse to what

Prespectives on motivation: the thought and content process

1737 words - 7 pages focuses on the thought processes of motivation.In 1964, Victor Vroom devised the expectancy theory; its main argument is that if the individual is motivated, and believes that there is a positive correlation between effort and performance; the individual will;Produce a excellent work in order to attain a desired reward; the reward will satisfy an important need the desire to satisfy the need is strong enough to make the effort worthwhile.Vroom's

Cognitive Development Theory

1716 words - 7 pages A. Cognitive Development Theory In a general sense the theory of cognitive development is not just a single theory but a number of theories offered by a number of cognitive psychologists over the past century. In summary though, cognitive development is the processes by which learning is developed by the construction of thought processes, memory, solving problems, decision-making and covers the life span from childhood to adulthood, but

Financial Issues Article Review – Explaining Increases in Higher Education Costs

1597 words - 6 pages Financial Issues Article Review - Explaining Increases in Higher Education CostsIntroductionSince the late 1970s, annual costs at four-year colleges have risen three times as fast as inflation, and, with savings rates dropping and state aid to higher education being cut, students and their families have been forced to take on ever more debt in order to receive higher education (Surowiecki, 2011). The rapid increases in higher education costs

Case Analysis Of The Human Enterprise

1500 words - 6 pages assumes that the employee can't handle such responsibility otherwise close monitoring would not be necessary. Also these conventional assumptions makes the employee feel insecure, useless, and less willing to participate in future The human - 3 - Projects. In order to make effective use of their human resources managers must understand the proper methods of controlling behavior.The conventional theory based on authority can no longer be the only

Maslows hierarchy of needs

845 words - 4 pages needs dominate one’s thinking” which will decrease the motivation to achieve the higher ranked needs (Zalenski & Raspa, 2006). Maslow’s theory suggests that these needs are what drive a person to achieve and the hierarchy of these needs create the structure in which the core necessities must be obtained to achieve the humanistic idea of human potential. Maslow’s humanistic theory of psychology is a study that continues today in psychology and in

Similar Essays

Rosenthal And Jacobsen, Experimentor Expectancy In A Classroom By: How Much Of An Outcome Teachers' Expectancies Culd Have On A Group Of Children

956 words - 4 pages learnmazes. Rosenthal's results showed that the rats that were believed by the students to be smart,were able to learn the mazes much quicker. What the children did not know, i.e., whatRosenthal had kept hidden, was that the rats were chosen at random. There were no rats thatwere especially bright or dull. Another case of the experimenter expectancy effect was that ofthe horse known as "Clever Hans". It seemed to be able to read, spell, and solve math

Casino & Frank Rosenthal Essay

1596 words - 6 pages Frank Rosenthal's successful career in Las Vegas and most importantly the way that a making business at its higher pick came to the bottom of the line. After viewing this movie, it made me reflect how money and greed can have a huge impact on people's life.

On Social Theory In Social Work

1164 words - 5 pages therefore required that there be a reduction in the numbers of (government subsidised) trade apprenticeship places - a huge cost saving exercise, an economic positive!However, we have since learned that this theory was implemented without a great deal of thought as to the possible negatives - those of higher youth unemployment (increased welfare bill), a much sharper decline in the number of skilled tradesmen to adequately service the community (have

Leadership In Asia Essay

8674 words - 35 pages peppered with references to both leader attributes and leader behaviors. The following passages summarize specific leadership qualities and conduct. Humility, for example, is perhaps best shown in Rosenthal's interpretation of Chapter 59:By acting with no thought of self-advancement, but with self-restraint, it is possible to lead, and genuinely care for others. This happens by acting virtuously, and leaving nothing to be done. A foundation