Rottman V Commissioners Of Police For The Metropolis

1404 words - 6 pages

Rottman v commissioners of police for the Metropolis
“Extradition search is lawful, lords say common law power is still available”
The name of the parties are (appellant) commissioner of the police of the metropolis,(respondent) Mr. Michael Rottman . The judgment has been held in the house of lords. The judges on this were- Lord Nicholls of Birkenhead, Lord Hoffmann, Lord Hope of Craighead, Lord Hutton and Lord Roger of Earlsferry. The barristers and solicitors in this case were, Mr. Perry, on behalf of the appellant and Miss Montgomery, for the respondent. The date of the judgment was 16th may 2002.
MATERIAL FACTS- the respondent, Mr. Micheal Rottman , is a German businessman and was suspected of fraud in Germany. A court in Germany issued a warrant for his arrest on the 27th December 1996. The respondent left Germany at the end of 1995. On 13TH September 2000 the metropolitan police received a request from the German authorities via Interpol, for the respondent’s extradition to Germany. On 22nd September 2000 a provisional warrant for the respondents arrest was issued by the Bow street magistrate’s court under section 8(1) of the extradition Act 1989. The respondent was arrested a few yards from his front door. Though in section 17 of the police and criminal evidence act 1984,the police had to enter the grounds of the house to arrest according to the warrant . After a short period of time two German police officers arrived and asked Detective Sergeant Loudon, the senior Metropolitan police officer to search the house and seized a number of properties in it. The respondent brought an application for judicial review against the appellant and the home secretary in respect of the decision by the police to enter his home in Hazlemere to search and seize items.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY-This case was previous in the queen’s bench divisional court where the court ruled in favor of the respondent Mr.Micheal Rottman. 1) declared that the entry and search carried out by the police on 23rd September 2000 were unlawful,2) declared that the respondent’s rights under article 8 of the European conventions for the protections of Human Rights and fundamental freedoms had been violated,3)ordered that there be a mandatory order requiring the police to deliver up to the claimant all the items seized on 23sep 200, 4)ordered that the respondent claim for damages be adjourned for directions and a hearing before a single judge in the administrative courts.
In the Divisional Court Lord Justice Brooke said that in R v Governor of Pentonville Prison, Ex p. Osman Lord Justice Lloyd had said:
Is there any difference between a warrant of arrest in domestic proceedings and a provisional warrant under section 6 of the Fugitive Offenders Act 1967? We can see none.
His Lordship found it impossible to interpret Part II of the 1984 Act as providing any saving for the common-law power identified in Osman
Parliament intended s. 18 to provide in codified form for the full extent of a...

Find Another Essay On Rottman v commissioners of police for the Metropolis

The Power of Police Essay

1909 words - 8 pages officer "must be able to point to specific and articulable facts" that warrant the governmental intrusion; reliance on "inchoate and unparticularized suspicion or [a] 'hunch' " is not permissible. Furthermore, the scope of any resulting police search must be narrowly tailored to match the original reason for the stop. The Court emphasized that a search must always be "strictly circumscribed by the exigencies which justif[ied] its initiation." In

Political Analysis of the Novel 'V for Vendetta'

1112 words - 4 pages starts a riot among the people present. Another woman whose husband was taken and killed by the secret police or 'Fingermen' took it one step further and assassinated the leader of the regime as they were all instructed to smile and wave to him. This was the tipping point for the revolution; the head had essentially been cut from the body. At this same time, V is mortally shot and gets back to the Shadow Gallery so that Evey knows what has to be

The Treat Of V

1434 words - 6 pages wounds or illnesses that struck during this time. Germany, also, suffered tremendous losses during this war. Out of the 11, 000, 000 mobilized soldiers that they had, 1,773,700 were killed. Their total casualties amounted to 7,142,558 in all, which, when calculated, was 64.9% of their men (WW1 Casualties and Death Tables). Germany, although suffered from massive casualties and was not exempt from any of the tragedies that took place for all the

The Discretion of the Police

829 words - 3 pages decision that will make both parties involved be content with the resolution. This discretion that a police officer uses at the time of a domestic disturbance is the most difficult because his decisions ends up affecting either parties to a situation for the better or for the worse. In such situation, the officer can either mediate a peaceful agreement, can suggest counseling or if this doesn’t work he can also make an arrest of the person that is

The Problem of Police Brutality

818 words - 4 pages brutality. For example, a head officer approach a minority citizen in an aggressive manner, then the other officer would think that it is right to adapt to that style of aggressive interaction which will create more potential problems of police brutality. Therefore, social dynamic plays a huge role in police misconduct because not every police officer is a good law enforcer. The police-civilian interaction can negatively influence the other

The Epidemic of Police Brutality

1344 words - 6 pages Police are abusing their power, of their badge, instead of serve and protect; their ignoring and abusing. There's been many killings (almost about 5,000 people),abusing, and people being ignored from police, Why? For nearly 50 years, a deadly and effective attack has been orchestrated against local police departments all throughout the United States and most Americans do not even realize it is happening. News people like CNN, CBS, or Fox 4

The Problem of Police Corruption

1323 words - 6 pages . What are the effects of police corruption? This review of Police Corruption will focus on answering the above three questions. What is Police Corruption? Although there is no concise definition of police corruption, many define it as the misuse of police authority for personal gain. The key element of corrupt behavior is that the conduct (1) is prohibited by law or rule, (2) involves misuse of position and (3) involves a reward or personnel

The Principles of Police Leadership

2922 words - 12 pages -written policies and procedures (Cordner & Scarborough, 2010). When a certain problem or concern isn’t covered by the book the leader refers to the next level for a decision. This style removes the ability of the leader to manage and forces a strict accordance to the “book”. This style can be very effective when dealing with dangerous situations which can be a common occurrence in police work. Historical Development American law enforcement

The Use of Police Technology

1266 words - 5 pages allows the police to know where a perpetrator may live, work or even hang out at. It also will do the same thing for victims involved in crimes. Most of the crime analysis show that criminals do their crimes in comfort zones and the Crime Mapping makes it easier for law enforcement to see where that is. There are three different types of crime analysis. One is Tactical Crime Analysis which identifies a perpetrator with many targets or targets

Review of Film V for Vendetta

1470 words - 6 pages This movie “V for Vendetta” was taken from a book written by Alan Moore and it was written years before all the things that started happening in the world, like the war, and all the problems that the government is going through. He tells us that “the people should not be afraid of the government, that the government should be afraid of their people”. People can realize that there are no coincidences in this world, everything happens for a

The Development of a Semantic Differential Scale for Assessing the Perceived Image of Citizens about Romanian Police Forces

2071 words - 9 pages . Methodological aspects The aim of the study is represented by the development and validation of a semantic differential scale for the assessment of the public image of Romanian police officers, following a two-phase process: the exploratory research to elaborate the scale, namely the evaluation of the psychometric properties of the scale. 2.1. The construction of the SDS The first stage of phase one, the collection of the qualitative descriptors

Similar Essays

The Economic Superstructure Of Metropolis Essay

764 words - 4 pages in contrast the city for the upper classes, a bright city with intricate architecture and illuminating scenery, demonstrating the working classes near enslavement towards the thinkers. The film illuminates this servitude greatest when the main character compares the main machine running Metropolis to a Semitic deity, Moloch, a deity commonly associated with sacrificially all of those who serve him. Seeing workers being killed in the workforce

Commissioners, City Council Members And The Value Of Forensic Evidence

841 words - 4 pages essentially all claim similarities (Browne, Clayton, 2013). The most extensive city council duties are to decide and appoint the top executive for the city, such as the chief of police or city manager. Smaller cities will have a city council staff of at least one or two individuals to help the city council members in determining and combining candidates, construct meetings and drawing up bills and management. City councils in larger cities might have

Book Essay: Havana Two Faces Of The Antillean Metropolis

1436 words - 6 pages For those who have not studied Cuba, it is simply ‘that socialist island in the Caribbean’, reducing a fascinating history to one label. The book ‘Havana: Two faces of the Antillean Metropolis’ by Scarpaci, Segre and Coyula helps to debunk this myth through the story of its capital city and its citizens proving that Havana, and by extension Cuba, is a complex, contradictory country where “history has left its handprint on every street corner

The Need For Better Supervision Of Police Discretion

1876 words - 8 pages different jurisdictions. It is left in the hands of the individual police officers at the scene, hoping that they use good judgment when making discretionary decisions. Without national guidelines for the use of discretion to outline its range and limit, injustices do occur (Engel). No two police officers are the same, so the big question is how police discretion can be exercised so that it is fair to society when officers have different values and