Rousseau And The Battle Between French And Italian Music

930 words - 4 pages

In the mid-eighteenth century, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, one of the most important French philosophers of the time, wrote Lettre sur la musique francaise (Letter on French Music) in response to the musical debate pitting French music against Italian music. In the first part of this paper, an attempt will be made to explain both Rousseau’s argument for so heavily criticizing the music of his people and what elements of Italian music he prefers; in the second half, an endeavor will be made to defend Jean-Phillipe Rameau’s opera against Rousseau’s criticism by examining an excerpt from Rameau’s Hippolyte et Arcie.
In his letter, Rousseau seeks to determine whether France actually possesses its own music by explaining some experiments he conducted concerning “which of the two languages [Italian or French] is by its nature adapted to the best kind of music.” In one experiment, Rousseau gave some Italians “the most beautiful airs of Lully to sing” and he gave some French some Italian airs to sing. He observed that the Italian airs were melodious, agreeable, and well-cadenced, but that the French airs—while sung with the greatest exactness—were merely a series of notes set down almost randomly. In another experiment, Rousseau observed an Armenian man who had never heard any music listen to both a French monologue and an Italian air that were sung. Rousseau noted that “during the French song the Armenian showed more surprise than pleasure, but everybody observed that from the first bars of the Italian air his face and his eyes grew soft; he was enchanted; he surrendered his soul to the impressions of the music; and though he understood little of the language, the mere sounds visibly enraptured him.”
Rousseau identifies three things which seem to him to unite in contributing to the perfection of Italian melody: the softness of the language; the boldness of the modulations; and, most importantly, the extreme exactness of time. The first “makes all the inflections easy” and allows for the singer’s unique characterization of style and variety. Because the second is more perceptible, it is more pleasing and adds a “lively energy to the expression.” The third and final thing—the one which gives to melody its greatest effect—makes the singing animated and interesting and the accompaniments lively and rhythmical. These three things, Rousseau writes, are the sources from which Italian music derives its charms and its energy. Italian composers incorporate these into their works by adhering to this idea of unity in melody in which the harmony, accompaniment, and bass work together to “convey only one melody to the ear and only one idea to the mind.”
As a result of the experiments conducted, the identification of the three unifying things which contribute to the perfection of Italian melody, and the discussion of airs and...


Rousseau and The Republican Party Essay

1441 words - 6 pages . In regards to justice, the Republican Party states the following:   The delicate balance of power between the respective branches of our national government and the governments of the 50 states has been eroded. The notion of judicial review has in some cases come to resemble judicial supremacy, affecting all segments of the public and private endeavor.   Conclusion In closing, Rousseau envisioned several different forms of

Italian Renissance and the Reformation Essay

1422 words - 6 pages The renaissance and the reformation are the beginning of the golden age of Europe. Many economic, religious, and cultural changes occurred during this time period. The economic and cultural rise of Italian city-states, the recentralization of government in northern Europe, and the separation of the Roman Catholic Church into different Catholic and Protestant groups were important achievements for Europe during this time. The renaissance and the

A Battle Between The Traditional and The Modern

1450 words - 6 pages This is an essay about the battle between the traditional and the modern. It has focused on Pound and Yeats’ works in Literature to show the position of each poet’s contribution to modernity. Both poets used different approaches to contribute to modernity. Yeats used classical illusions in his poems to pass the messages and was more focused on culture. This shows his characteristic as a traditionalist more than a modernist (Yeats). Grading his

Italian Renissance and the Reformation

924 words - 4 pages sadness. In the Catholic Church, the Great Schism between the eastern and western halves of the Church created a loss of faith and questions about religious authority. Seemingly endless wars, such as the Hundred Year’s War between France and England, were just now coming to an end, finally giving the population time to stop and reflect on what had gone on in the past. When they began to mull over things, more inquiries about the state of their

Italian Renissance and the Reformation

1416 words - 6 pages . This led to a peak in the interest of Classical literature, art, social, and political ideas of Greece/Rome. Humanism was a literary movement that occurred during the Renaissance. During this movement, authors began to deal with general questions of the soul. Dante wrote about the soul’s journey to salvation. Petrarch, another renowned author from Italy, began to write epics and sonnets; he later became known as the “Father of The Italian

The Political Battle between Patty Murray and Linda Smith

1803 words - 7 pages The Political Battle between Patty Murray and Linda Smith In a state known for its apples, and nicknamed the “Evergreen State” looms a bitter battle between Democrat Incumbent Senator Patty Murray and Representative Linda Smith (Republican) for the only U.S. Senate seat open in the state of Washington. Washington has been historically Democratic for years. But changes in the state’s economy and a low amount of challengers have led to

The Battle Between Gun Control and Gun Rights

1215 words - 5 pages The debate over the right to bear arms according to the Second Amendment has been a hotly contested issue for many years in American history. The matter has been one of the most controversial issues in the second half of the twentieth century and into the twenty-first; disputed between politicians on the liberal and conservative side along with issues such as abortion, capital punishment, and gay marriage. The Supreme Court has officially

The Battle Between Materialism and Spirituality in Shakespeare's King Lear

930 words - 4 pages believes that she is one of a long line of people “who with best meaning have incurred the worst”(5.3). She sacrifices everything for King Lear in the end, as is shown when she kisses him to “repair those violent harms that my two sisters have in thy reverence made”(4.7) and eventually dies for him. After viewing the text of King Lear in this perspective, the continual battle between materialistic ideals and spiritualistic ideals throughout the

The Battle between Passion and Responsibility in Great Expectations

975 words - 4 pages How do passions and desires eight in against duties and responsibilities? It is a personal battle that many people fight every day. In Great Expectations, young Pip fights this battle with himself. Charles Dickens portrays Pip as a young lower middle class boy in Victorian Era England. Pip is a blacksmith-to-be and early on is satisfied with his life. As Pip’s life progresses, he is confronted with opportunities and situations that challenge

How does Rousseau argue that the exercise of force cannot provide a legitimate basis for social order? The areas of shared concern between Rousseau and David's Brutus.

1135 words - 5 pages Jean-Jacques Rousseau argues that the exercise of force (physical power) cannot provide a legitimate basis for social order; some may say that the strongest always win, but how do they win and will they always win? The power produced by force doesn't create duty, only obedience. Let's take for example a wealthy land owner; do his employees work hard for him at all times or just when they are being watched? His power over them is their wages

Rousseau and the Artists of th

1429 words - 6 pages Jean-Jacques Rousseau, (1712-1778) was a French social philosopher and writer. His book Du Contrat Social, ou Principes du droit politique (Social Contract) published in 1762, emphasised the rights of the people over the government and was a significant influence on the French Revolution . Rousseau believed that people were not social beings by nature. He stated that ?Society corrupts individuals by bringing out their inclination toward

Similar Essays

Difference Between Italian And French Baroque Architecture

871 words - 3 pages Difference Between Italian And French Baroque Architecture Baroque is the name given to the art of the 17th century. But the baroque style, like all other styles in the history of art, began gradually. It started in the latter part of the 16th century and continued to be used well into the 18th century. Baroque can be defied as the florid, ornate style characterizing fine arts in Europe from the middle 16th to middle 18th centuries

Edmund Burke And Jean Jacques Rousseau Concerning The Justification Of The French Revolution

651 words - 3 pages Edmund Burke, who is often regarded as a spokesman for modern conservatism, believed that human rights were based on tradition and could only be inherited. Burke strongly opposed the French Revolution, which in his view, attempted to break from the traditions of France and destroy their contemporary society. On the other hand, Jean-Jacque Rousseau believed that general will would always be correct and that it would unshackle humans from their

Symbolism Of Italian And French Theatre And Opera

2412 words - 10 pages that ‘six out of the fourteen compositions performed during the Italian Season in Paris contained music by Pergolesi’ (Lazarevich, 1988, pp. 202). La serva padrona was an intermezzo presented between acts of a serious opera. It was superb in its genre and because of this it became both a catalyst and a weapon in the war against the coin du roi. The fact that Geneva born French encyclopédiste and musician Jean-Jacques Rousseau could use it to

The Battle Between Heart And Head

630 words - 3 pages . Brocklehurst would expel you… It is far better to endure patiently a smart which nobody feels but yourself, than to commit a hasty action whose evil consequences will extend to all connected with you; and, besides, the Bible bids us return good for evil. (Bronte, Chapter 6, pg. 78) Taught at Lowood to follow sense and reason, Jane continues to battle between her duty to sense and the passion of her heart. Specifically in her romantic life