Russia's Collectivization Vs. China's Cultural Revolution

836 words - 3 pages

During the rise of Communism one of the most difficult tasks that a leader had to face was to have the citizens of the country to agree with and support the idea of communism. This would, without doubt, not be an easy task because never does an entire country believe the same thing. But all believing the same thing and working together is one of the main characteristics of communism itself. Two countries tried to morph their society to fit the standards of Marxist communism, everyone working together for the same common goal with no personal gain desired. Mao Tse Tung in China and Josef Stalin in Russia were two leaders who tried to change their society very quickly to fit communism but one did better than the other.Josef Stalin's collectivization began in 1929. Although it was a bloody time for peasant with up to 10 million deaths, Stalin found that he could eliminate the more wealthy kulaks and move all other peasants to collectives. Collectives were massive farms that were controlled by the government appointed party members. These farms took the land, livestock and farm tools from the peasants driven out by the Red army. This cost the country many lives and much money but Stalin believe it was a necessary prerequisite to his industrial dream. The peasants on these collective farms were eventually put to work building and working in new industrial factories. In 11 years Russia's industrial production went up by 400%.This rapid switch to industrialization did have some detrimental effects on the people of Russia, prices on common good rose to be much higher than afforded and food was even rationed at one point because of how little was being produced from collectivization. Stalin ended his Five-Year Plan with the closing out of any political opposition to himself within or outside the Soviet party. He did this by striking fear into any who would think of opposing him through secret police forces and strict punishments. Stalin was not the only on with big plans for his big country though.Mao Tse Tung also planned to turn his country into a communist state for the good of the people and the country. In 1966 Mao's Communist Cultural Revolution began. Like Stalin, Mao Tse Tung had a Red army called Red Guards, they stormed the cities taking anyone who was though to possibly oppose communism in the future, burning their possessions and either killing them or moving them out...

Find Another Essay On Russia's Collectivization Vs. China's Cultural Revolution

Identify and discuss two or three major challenges the Chinese reformers faced since 1978.

1767 words - 7 pages Party (CCP) originally was a top-down model, in which policies were centrally planned and being carried out by the cadres, who were appointed by the Party. Policies such as mutual-aid team, collectivization and communization were carried out in the 1940s and 1950s.Thus, the contemporary China was a highly political centralized state. However, after the drawbacks of the "ten bad years" and the Cultural Revolution, reality demanded an economic reform

Deng Xiaoping Essay

1438 words - 6 pages allocated primarily to finance the growth of heavy industry. These policies depressed consumption and popular living standards.The problems in industry were compounded by technological backwardness. The Cultural Revolution had devastating effects on higher education, basic research, and the morale of the technological intelligentsia.Despite all the failings and setbacks, the Maoist era was the time of China's modern industrial revolution. At the

Ekaterina Olitskaia: A Social Revolutionary Against Russian Political Beliefs

2407 words - 10 pages proposed ‘Cultural Revolution,’ a program that aimed to discover and promote new socialist visions of culture, art and literature. This Cultural Revolution led to the creation of films and written works, such as the “Voyage of the Red Star Troop,” which portrayed a worldwide Soviet government that was utopian in character. However, the Cultural Revolution did not produce the complete results it hoped to. While ordinary workers, such as Tonia

Stalin: Did his Rule Benefit Russian Society and the Russian People?

2524 words - 10 pages In this paper I plan to prove that even though Stalin made improvements in the Russian industrial system, his rule did not benefit Russian society and the Russian people. In order to accomplish this, several questions must be asked. How did Stalin affect Russia's industrial power? How did Stalin try to change Russia's agricultural system? What changes did Stalin make in society? What were Stalin's purges, and who did they effect?Joseph

Explain how Russia and the Soviet Union modernized from 1917 to 1945

1080 words - 4 pages Despite the soviets unions initial desires to pursue a global revolution policy soon changed in light of reality and a shift in doctrine modernization in one country and with an unprecedented speed was pursued. The initial policy of War Communism proved hopeless in regards to modernization, the NEP proved more successful however, it too became incapable of achieving the rapid modernization. Stalin's policy launched with the "great turn" back to

Causes and aftermaths of the russo japanese war

1794 words - 7 pages States came to China's assistance in an attempt impede Russia's continual infiltration to no avail however. The revolt also targeted the Japanese for their Economic and Political exploitation of China and humiliating military defeats during the Sino-Japanese war.On January 1, 1905 Russian forces, overpowered by the Japanese on all fronts, offered to negotiate terms of surrender, which related particularly to Lu-Shun . Japan's defeat was a turning

Was Stalin a neccessary evil? Assess

1979 words - 8 pages Joseph Stalin is undoubtedly one of the most notorious characters in history. He has been called: The greatest criminal in history and a 20th century Ivan the Terrible. He ruled as a supreme dictator and was responsible for the deaths of millions during collectivization, through slave labour camps and through grave mistakes during WW2. He isolated the Soviet Union from most of the world, keeping his people inside and keeping foreigners out. He

The Impact of China's Economic Reform on the Operations of International Firms

3268 words - 13 pages least three reasons initiating China's economic reform. First, after experiencing several decades of isolation and ten years of the 'Cultural Revolution' between 1966-1976, both the regime and people faced tremendous pressure both politically and economically (Riskin 1988). The second reason is that the increase in population that had occurred during the Culture Revolution, combined with a reduction in the production of consumer goods, resulted

How does China's fascist-style government help/impede economic growth and the well-being of its subjects?

1265 words - 5 pages claimed one simply knows nothing about China or Chinese culture. China won't have a democracy anytime soon for the same reason Iraq won't: culture. You can get rid of the CCP tomorrow, hold elections tomorrow and then call me in 10 years, and we'll discuss how the next emperor is getting along.Many assert that China's main problem is the utter destruction of Chinese civil society (during the Cultural Revolution for starters), which China has not

The Import of China for Recent 10 Years

2413 words - 10 pages −2010',Economic Development and Cultural Change, Vol. 15, Issue 1, pp. 247−56.Cui, Li & Syed, Murtaz 2007, 'The Shifting Structure of China's Trade and Production', IMF Working Paper 07/214.Czinkota, Michael R & Ronkainen, Ilkka A 2001, International Marketing, 6th edition, Harcourt College,United States of America.Guo, Kai & N'Diaye, Papa 2009, 'Is China's Export-Oriented Growth Sustainable?', IMF Working Paper 09/172.IIF

Animal Farm: Stalin and Napoleon

908 words - 4 pages The novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell, was an allegory about the Russian Revolution in which the author used a farm and it's members to symbolize major characters and their actions. In this composition, I will reveal to you many of Joseph Stalin' s important contributions and how they relate to the actions of Napoleon from Animal Farm. I will break this topic down into the following three parts, their rise to power, Stalin's Five Year Plan

Similar Essays

The Orgins Of The Cultural Revolution. Talks About How The Cultural Revolution In China Came About. May Need Some Grammatical Work.

1589 words - 6 pages the Cultural Revolution, some historians do. One Historian felt that the League of Nations criticizing China's education system was one cause of the Cultural Revolution. She also thought that communism in the Soviet Union was a cause of the Cultural Revolution. The Soviet Union was the first socialist nation in the world and was a country that was well liked in China. In those days as the Republic was established, a slogan such as "Today of the

Communist Politics In China And Films Relationship.

849 words - 3 pages taking the capitalist road.Mao launched the Cultural Revolution during his last decade in power to renew the spirit of the Chinese revolution. "We must reform the arts faculties in the universities. The students must go down and engage in industry, agriculture and commerce" (201, Reader), said Mao. Mao shut down China's schools, and during the following months he encouraged Red Guards to attack all traditional values and "bourgeois" things and

Disrtespect Essay

7253 words - 29 pages indus- trialization and collectivization campaigns of the late 1950s, and the Cultural W a n g F e n g / y o n g c a i / B a o c h a n g g u 127 revolution of the late 1960s and early 1970s. while those grave mistakes both cost tens of millions of lives, the harms done were relatively short-lived and were corrected quickly afterward. the one-child policy, in contrast, will surpass them in impact by its role in creating a society with a

Do The Ends Justify The Means? Analysis Of Stalin, Mao Zedong And Gorbachev.

1392 words - 6 pages Russia's Vladimir Putin will not be able to seize as that much power and turn Russia into a dictatorship again.Works Cited:"A Country Study: Soviet Union (Former)." Library of Congress. 2005. 27 Oct. 2007 .Spense, Jonathan D. "Mao Zedong." TIME 13 Apr. 1998. 28 Oct. 2007 .Trueman, Chris. "The Cultural Revolution." History Learning Site. 2007. 28 Oct. 2007 ."Mikhail Sergeevitch Gorbachev." CNN. 28 Oct. 2007 .