Sacco And Venzetti Robbery And Homicide

1634 words - 7 pages

Ever since the court system was established in America, many have come to ask the question, “What case still raises controversy because it is unclear whether or not the defendants are guilty?” Though many scholars can list different cases, the Sacco-Vanzetti trial is probably one of the first major cases that remains a mystery to this day. Even though most of America was focused on World War II, the court case in Massachusetts sparked political outbreaks and violent terrorism across America and Europe. The case was about two Italian immigrant anarchists named Ferdinando Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Venzetti who were accused of murdering Frederick Paramenter, a paymaster, and Alesandro Berardelli, a security guard during a robbery in South Braintree, Massachusetts. Though they were charged as guilty and executed on August 23, 1927, many scholars and lawyers believed that they were innocent due to their convincing alibis, lack of evidence against them, and the belief that the judge and jury were prejudiced in their decision because the accused were anarchists. These beliefs brought many people to give motions to prolong or review the case such as the Medeiros Confession.
Montgomery believes that the case was judged fairly, and that Sacco and Venzetti had truly committed the crime. He argues that there was enough evidence to be held against them, analyzes the flaws in their alibis, and gives evidences of testimonies of both the jury and other witnesses that the trial was not judged unfairly because of Vanzetti and Sacco’s beliefs about the government. He also argues the validity of the motions for Vanzetti and Sacco, and affirms his belief that the Medeiros Confession was another false alibi to clear up Vanzetti and Sacco’s name.
In the first opening chapters, he summarizes the arrest that led up to the case. He then proceeds to introduce and expand upon each chapter: the alibis of Sacco and Venzetti at the trial in Plymouth and in Dedham (though Vanzetti did not take the stand at Plymouth), the jury and witnesses, the evidences that many people proved them innocent such as the cap which could not fit on Sacco’s head, the misconception that radicalism was a large factor, and Madeiro’s confession, the Morelli Hypothesis, and the conspiracy between Katzmann and the Department of Justice that was given during and after the case. To argue against the points that were presented, Montgomery relies heavily on his use of facts and logic. For example, when Vanzetti presented his alibi during the trial at Dedham, Montgomery shows he is guilty because after the trial, “…thousands of dollars were spent by the defense to find new witnesses and new evidence…” (120), but there was no new evidence or new witnesses that were brought to the court. Montgomery then speculates that Moore, Vanzetti’s lawyer, was really doing all he could to better the circumstances of the situation because he knew that Vanzetti was guilty of committing the murder.

Find Another Essay On Sacco and Venzetti Robbery and Homicide

The Sacco and Vanzetti Case Essay

551 words - 2 pages them with the crime.The case came up for trial on May 31, 1921. At first, this murder and robbery generated only local interest, but soon the case attracted wider attention due to the politics of the accused murderers. Sacco and Vanzetti were immigrants, but politically they were anarchists who had participated in armed labor strikes. They were also pacifists who had evaded the draft in 1917 by going to Mexico. In presenting his case, the

Poverty and Homicide Essay

2105 words - 8 pages Hypothesis In this study, I will examine the relationship between poverty and homicide. I anticipate that there will be a significant association between the increase of poverty rates and the increase of homicide rates. The null hypothesis states that there is no significance relationship between poverty and homicide. The alternative hypothesis states that there will be a significant relationship between poverty and homicide. The two theories I

Criminal Responsibility and Homicide

1349 words - 5 pages Criminal Responsibility and Homicide A killing can be either lawful or unlawful. Killings that are lawful are those by the police, armed services and doctors in strictly controlled circumstances. An unlawful homicide is considered to be those of: murder, voluntary manslaughter, involuntary manslaughter, infanticide and death caused by dangerous driving or careless driving. Homicide in criminal law is the

Media and Homicide Victims

591 words - 3 pages siginificant effects on their crime index, which included robbery, assault, and burglary. The support for whether newspapers increases fear of crime is mixed. Chiricos et al (1997) found the frequency of reading the newspaper was not significant in increasing fear of crime. Campbell (1995) argued that newspapers have a structure that allows them to be less involved in promoting racial myths than television news media. The author argues that

Italian Immigrants and Sacco and Vanzetti Trial

3005 words - 12 pages radical activities and not on the specifics of the Braintree crime, the two men lied in response. These lies created a "consciousness of guilt" in the minds of the authorities, but the implications of that phrase soon became a central issue in the Sacco-Vanzetti case. Did the lies of the two men signify criminal involvement in the Braintree murder and robbery or did they signify an attempt to conceal their radicalism and protect their friends during

Suicide Victims and Homicide Offenders

2412 words - 10 pages Suicide victims and homicide offenders require special attention from both the government and the society in order to realize a positive change. Such people affect the moral stability of the society. This means that they must be assisted to eliminate immoralities and encourage the realization of a stable society in the future (Gartner & Macmillan, 1995). The rates of Suicide victims and homicide cases are on the increase in various regions

Ritual Pollution and Homicide Cases

2249 words - 9 pages Religion and superstition played a large part in the everyday life of a classical Athenian, and there was a heavy emphasis on ritual and reverence to the gods. Athenians believed that certain crimes – e.g. homicide – disrupted the sanctity of their city, causing an imbalance they referred to as “pollution.” Restoring balance was of the utmost importance. Otherwise, they believed that the gods would punish them with losses in battle, bad crops

High school essay on Robbery and burglary

513 words - 2 pages crimes end up getting ugly. When a person is involved, such as a break in when people are home, the perpetrator is usually armed with a weapon of some kind. Many times the robbery does not go as planned and robbery plus murder or attempted murder is committed.Trends also show that robberies and burglaries are also committed against certain kinds of people. These people are the ones that are the most vulnerable or naïve. Leaving your garage door

Homicide Rates and Prevention in Indianapolis

1254 words - 5 pages If the homicide rates don't continue to decline, the beautiful city of Indianapolis will not just be known for sports and amenities but criminal homicides as well. However, this has changed tremendously over the past four years. The Department of Public Safety Crime Analysis section (DPS CAS) released the criminal homicide statistic rates for the years of 2007-2010. These statistical rates pack a hard punch, for the criminal homicides which took

Homicide Influences: How culture, religion, and the economy affect homicide rates

1081 words - 5 pages Homicide Influences: How culture, religion, and the economy affect homicide rates Throughout American history, many have tried to identify how the human mind operates. Most have come up with a solution different from the last. This paper will focus on what effects homicide rates such as prejudices, law, morals, and, in general, upraising. The three areas focused on are religion, socioeconomic structure, and culture. Each may be widely varied

Research Paper on The Commonwealth of Massachusetts vs. Sacco and Vanzetti

1689 words - 7 pages took the cash boxes and took off in a waiting automobile. "This type of brutal murder and robbery was not uncommon in post World War I America; therefore at this stage in the crime, it only aroused local interest" (D'Attilio). When approached by police, Sacco and Vanzetti were both carrying guns and lied to police during questioning. Although they were not originally under suspicion, they were held and accused for the Braintree Crime. According

Similar Essays

Homicide, Firearms, And Robbery Essay

1202 words - 5 pages Homicide/Firearms/Robbery In Cold Blood/Red Handed The First 48 Hours video that I have chosen is “In Cold Blood” and “Red Handed.” Because I have chosen this video I decided to do my topic on homicide, firearms, and robbery. I will discuss each one of these. I then will tell how it played a role in the video. I then will explain how it all comes together to help solve the crime. So let’s get started. First is homicide. What does homicide

Sacco And Vanzetti Essay

1401 words - 6 pages point on April 15, 1920 two men were shot to death and $15,766 was stolen. The two killers were said to be Italian foreigners ("Sacco and Vanzetti Trial"). In frenzy, the police hunt down two revolutionary Italian foreigners at fault the homicide on. Twenty days after the fact, on May 5, 1920, the unfortunate twosome of Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti were captured while getting an auto associated with the homicide ("Sacco-Vanzetti Case

Sacco And Vanzetti Essay

1468 words - 6 pages wasn’t related the crime Sacco and Vanzetti were initially arrested for, which is alarming. Vanzetti was convicted in the Bridgewater case first, because the evidence against him in the Braintree crime was so weak. Vanzetti’s defense called upon sixteen working-class Italians to testify that during the attempted robbery they bought eels from Vanzetti. Poor translators were brought in to help the Italians communicate with the court, while Vanzetti

Sacco And Vanzetti Essay

2258 words - 9 pages country, Mr. Sacco?" and other draft evading comments (Transcript). This final fact of the prosecution is perhaps the greatest telling point of the unfair nature of Sacco and Vanzetti's trial. Their escape to Mexico and draft dodging actions were extraneous details to the actual murders. The crimes were robbery and murder, not anarchistic rebellion.This line of questioning, however, should never have been allowed in court: the presiding judge