This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Case Against Gun Control Essay

2482 words - 10 pages

Anti - Gun Control
The issues of gun control are the subject of much controversy. In the article “The Killer Who Supports Gun Control” by Nicholas D. Kristof (2013), he argues that a strong gun control will yield fewer deaths. Kristof summarizes how the gun itself and the person are responsible for deaths, in order to show how dangerous the combination of the two is.
Kristof (2013) argues that more gun control will make it difficult for people to acquire guns, which will lead to fewer deaths by guns in the following way:
We lose many lives to gun violence.
People kill people and so do guns.
When products are “killing machines”, we should tighten measures to keep them away from criminals.
Cars are potentially lethal instruments that could have been made safer through regulation.
We need to approach gun safety in a way similar to how we approach safety in motor vehicles.
Therefore, more gun control will result in a lower casualty rate.

Kristof’s argument for strict gun control fails because his second premise is false, his premise does not provide enough support for his conclusion, and his premise is inductively weak because he commits several fallacies such as weak analogy, ad hominem, false cause, and appealing to unqualified authority.
In Kristof’s argument, he possesses some hidden assumptions that are worth noting. There are two hidden assumptions he makes in his argument. First, Kristof assumes that all products that fall under the category of “killing machines” should be regulated and controlled. This is not an acceptable assumption because anything made by humans could be classified as a “killing machine”. For example, a pencil is a “killing machine” if it were to be used to stab someone in the skull. It is true that the classification of a “killing machine” varies from person to person; however, it still shows the vagueness of what can be classified as a “killing machine”. The definition of a “killing machine” is ambiguous; so, his assumption that all products that are considered “killing machines” should be regulated is not an acceptable assumption. Second, he assumes that anything that is labeled as a “potentially lethal instruments”; it could be made safer through controls and regulations. This is not an acceptable assumption because a “potentially lethal instrument” will always be a potentially lethal instrument no matter how many controls and regulations are installed. Take ladders, for example, which is still a potentially lethal instrument that can cause harm to others or the person despite all the regulations and controls that were put into effect. It is true that ladders and other “potentially lethal instruments” are different; however, they all share similarities because each one of those “potentially lethal instruments “are could possibly be considered lethal despite the different precautions that were installed. Therefore, his assumption of anything that is labeled as a “potentially lethal instrument” could be made safer...

Find Another Essay On A Case Against Gun-Control

An Argument Against Gun Control Essay

899 words - 4 pages occur. Guns do not commit crimes alone. It is the irresponsibility and ignorance of gun owners that cause it. Guns do not have a mind of their own and if there are owners, who fail to act responsibly, do not punish other law- abiding citizens who are responsible when owning guns. If a student makes an error in their writing, do we blame the pencil they use to write? Highly unlikely. Gun control would not prevent criminals from

An Argument Against Gun Control Essay

1763 words - 7 pages that gun control works in theory, but not in real life. Sure, there are many violent crimes where guns are used, but most of these guns are obtained illegally, because the gun control laws enforced are not enough. With the growing gun-related crime rate in the United States today, many bills have been proposed to control guns. The most popular of these bans is The Brady Bill. The bill focuses on semi-automatic handguns. People wishing to buy a

Persuasive Speech: Against Gun Control

1264 words - 5 pages that every nation, which has disarmed its citizenry, has ended up with a dictator, a police state, and with countless horrible atrocities. It is true that we either learn from history or history will repeat itself. Personal Protection Not only is it our right to own guns for protection against a overbearing government, but also against those who intend to infringe on the peoples security. The criminals don't care about gun control

The Cons Against Gun Control in the United States

976 words - 4 pages would like for this right to be abolished altogether. Both sides of this issue have a good argument, but when further researched, there are many more details that come up explain why siding against gun control is a better conclusion for the United States and its people. Some may say gun control should be enforced because it will make the pubic a safer place to be and decrease gun violence. “An average of eight children and teens under the age of

Gun Control: A Deadlier Weapon

1853 words - 8 pages , Edward F. Gun Control: a Decision for Americans. New York: Watts. 1978. Print. “Firearms and Ammunition Industry Economic Impact Report 2013.” National Shooting Sports Foundation. 2014. Web. 14 May. 2014. Goldberg, Jeffrey.” The Case for More Guns (And More Gun Control).” Atlantic Monthly. Nov. 2012. Print. Noyes, Dan. "How Criminals Get Guns." PBS. (n.d). Web. 13 May 2014.

Gun Control : A Middle Ground

800 words - 4 pages people feel emotionally and physically safer. A study shows that over 200,000 women a year use guns to protect themselves against sexual abuse (Snyder). Americans are getting hit with all the facts about why gun control should be enforced in their nation, such as: Columbine High School, Sandy Hook Elementary School, and the navel yard shooting. However, Americans aren’t getting told the entire story. Another study shows that, in 1982, Kennesaw

Gun Control - A Persuasive View

1025 words - 4 pages , in countless different settings, with numerous different children. Situations such as this must be stopped, and the best way to do this is with stricter gun control laws. Guns are instruments of death, and there is no pleasant way to put it.The main reasons that we need to enforce a more strict gun control is because of the number of firearm-related homicides in the US, and the danger that guns propose, as they are easily available to children in

Gun Control: Does Having a Gun Reduce Crime?

940 words - 4 pages Coltin Perras Period: A Citizens of the United States have been fighting over the issue of gun control for many years. The debate of citizens owning guns, especially semi automatic guns with high captivity magazines has become a major debate in America today. As citizens of the United States we know it’s our right to own weapons and it has been that way since 1791when the second

I am a gun owner and I want gun control

835 words - 4 pages According to a recent article written by Mark O’Mara a legal analyst of while stating his personal opinion regarding gun control, he brought up several important points of the current debates between opposition and acceptance of new regulations for gun control. He first brings up the inquiry of how does a teenager gain access to fire arms, secondly references that a friend of his predicts 10 mass shootings during 2014 that will make it

A Modest Proposal for Gun Control today

542 words - 2 pages year use guns in this manner to protect themselves and their property. In most instances, no shots are fired and no reports are filed with police. Without exception, states with more liberal concealed-carry laws have seen dramatic drops in crime because if you were a criminal, obviously you would prefer to prey upon the defenseless. They would be scared to be confronted by an armed citizen. The new gun-control proposals address the wrong issue by

A Survery and Results on Gun Control

802 words - 4 pages I remember when I wrote an essay about gun control and one thing was on my mind, which was a scary story. It was about a young girl who was killed by her brother. Their mother stepped outside of her house for just while, and the children were playing in their mother’s bedroom. The gun was in the closet, and the brother got the gun from the closet room and started shooting at his sister, and she died. It is sad story how the young girl died by

Similar Essays

Against Gun Control Essay

984 words - 4 pages plane never made it to the destination of the Pentagon because the Militia helped brought down the fourth plane into a rural area in Pennsylvania. If it was not for the Militia trying to help fight back the terrorist then they would have made it to their destination, and they would have finished off the Pentagon just like they destroyed the Twin Towers. Another reason against gun control is to keep the people in control of its Government. If the

Argument Against Gun Control Essay

802 words - 3 pages defend against criminals. Therefore, ordinary citizens must take control of the situation and provide for their own self-defense, namely with the carrying of a handgun. If concealed carrying were allowed, criminals would be “less likely to commit a violent crime against any given person,” because of the fear that the individual may in fact have a gun on their person (Thompson 543). Tighter gun control laws and laws against concealed

The Fight Against Gun Control Essay

1685 words - 7 pages the right to bear arms. Guns have been in America for a very long time, and some people would like them gone because they think firearms are not needed anymore. While other people believe that guns may be needed for many reasons. There are arguments for and against gun control laws. Self defense and protection, but also people think that we need gun control laws to prevent violence and shootings. Self defense is a key argument point for those who

An Argument Against Gun Control Essay

858 words - 3 pages Argument Against Gun Control An Argument Against Gun Control As long ago as 1789, the creators of the Constitution realized the importance of guns in American society. The Second Amendment states,"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." No loopholes, or legal caches exist in this statement. The Founding Fathers