This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Security Council Resolution 1874: An Empirical Assessment Of Theory Predictions

2378 words - 10 pages

On June 12, 2009 the United Nations Security Council unanimously adopted resolution 1874 under chapter VII of the United Nations (UN) charter. The resolution responded to the decision of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) to challenge the Treaty on Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) and previous resolution 1718 by testing a nuclear bomb on May 25, 2009. Resolution 1874 toughened security sanctions and widened the arms embargo already outlined in resolution 1718. This paper will use empirical evidence to analyze neorealism, hegemonic tools theory and constructivism as explanations for the actions of the Security Council in this case. Ultimately, the paper will argue that the Security Council’s actions were best explained by neorealist predictions but underlying constructivist norms and rules were also influential in resolution 1874.
Neorealism
For resolution 1874, Neorealism predicted that the Security Council would have acted as an alliance to balance states against a threat, as a collusion of great powers to control lesser states and as a forum for great powers to battle. The Security Council acted as an alliance that balanced voting members against the threat of the DPRK when they unanimously supported resolution 1874. The DPRK was a threat not only because of its nuclear weapons, but also because they could potentially provide their nuclear knowledge and materials to other states. Each state backed up their vote with the explanation that the DPRK constituted a threat to the international community. For example, Yukio Takasu, Japan’s representative said that the DPRK’s acts “constituted a grave threat to the national security of his country and to international peace and security.” Because, under the charter, the Security Council’s resolution is a decision that “is binding on all [member] states,” the resolution additionally balanced all UN members against the DPRK. Resolution 1874 was an alliance of states against a common threat.
Resolution 1874 demonstrated great power collusion because the five permanent members sought to maintain a nuclear hierarchy. China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States were not only the permanent seats on the Security Council but were also legitimized nuclear states under the NPT. All voting members used the resolution to support the NPT. However, while non-permanent members appealed for the abolishment of nuclear weapons, the permanent members specifically upheld the laws of the NPT. For example, Vitaly Churkin, Russia’s representative said that the DPRK had “undermined international laws on non-proliferation.” The nuclear powers supported NPT laws because the laws established “different rules for nuclear powers and non-nuclear states” and therefore affirmed nuclear inequality. Resolution 1874 was used by great nuclear powers to endorse the NPT double standards and subsequently the nuclear status quo.
The Security Council acted as a forum for the power...

Find Another Essay On Security Council Resolution 1874: An Empirical Assessment of Theory Predictions

UN Security Council and the International Court of Justice

1396 words - 6 pages countries because of their different ideologies. The United Nations was set up at the end of the Second World War. Its founders were anxious to avoid not only another such catastrophe but also the mistakes which had led to the failure of the League of Nations . It is well settled that although the countries have vested their powers for maintenance of Peace and Security in the UN Security Council, yet it is an accepted fact that if not primary, then one

Assessment of Maracana Stadium Security Essay

2786 words - 11 pages professionalism of the Brazilian security forces. This will give an overview of the levels of threats likely to be faced, and the effectiveness of security response in the incidents of threats. The final step in threat analysis entails examining indicators which shows how the threat environment has changed with time. Identifying how the threat environment has changed with time can help predict future threats. This will be done through comparing

Evaluate the effectiveness of the United Nations Security Council in maintaining World Order - Legal Studies - Assignment

1986 words - 8 pages States. The UNSC immediately addressed and responded to the issue condemning the Iraqi invasion and four days later enforced an economic embargo on Iraq. Beginning a week after the Iraqi takeover of Kuwait, a large international force gathered in Saudi Arabia. The continuing noncompliance of Saddam Hussein and rejection of UN resolutions led to the UN Security Council passing a resolution to allow member states to ?use all necessary means? to force

Does the theory of evolution by natural selection make testable predictions and how should evolutionary theories be tested?

851 words - 4 pages A prevalent issue in the philosophy of science concerns the extent and nature of testability of natural selection in theories of evolution. Karl Popper (1978) famously claimed that evolution (by which he meant natural selection) was a “metaphysical research programme” and therefore not scientific. By Popper’s falsifiability criterion, in order to be demarcated as scientific a theory must make testable predictions. A further criticism lies in the

A Basic Assessment of Hildegard Peplau's Theory

917 words - 4 pages promotion and maintenance. The purpose of this paper is to conduct a basic assessment of her theory. Theory Vs conceptual model It is important to first define theory and conceptual model in order to classified Pepau’s theory. Karlowicz K. A. states : “Theories are composed of concepts, definitions, models, propositions and assumptions that, when organized, offer a systematic view of a phenomenon (an observable fact or event) that is

An Analysis of the Relationship between Theory and Practice in Nursing Assessment in the Delivery of Patient-Centred Care

2317 words - 10 pages In this essay I will be exploring the relationship between nursing theory and practice in patient assessment. I will analyse the activities of daily living section (Appendix 1) of the combined nursing assessment tool and look at how it facilitates patient centred care. I decided to focus my essay on this after working on a ward on placement where it was routine to complete a Combined Nursing Assessment within four hours of any patient arriving

Multitheoretical Assessment of an Alcoholic

2162 words - 9 pages environment I referred to the ecological theory. According to Bronfenbrenner’s Ecological Theory of Human Development, “the theory focuses on the impact that the environment plays on the growth and development of an individual.” The ecological system also has a three root metaphors, one being that the person is like a living organism. Using this metaphor, the client is looked at like a plant in garden. In Johnathan’s case, this metaphor can be used to

Policy statement of the Norweigan point of view of the security council and possible reforms to it

2918 words - 12 pages proposals, and suggests a formulathat, while not fundamentally affecting the distribution of power on the Council, might satisfy manystates' minimal requirements for an acceptable package of changes.Norwegian Security Policy after the Cold WarThe end of the Cold War between East and West has strengthened Norwegian security,which makes Norway no different from most other European countries. There are nowmore dimensions to security policy than there

An Empirical Study On The Characteristics Of Management And Employee-Driven HRD

3366 words - 14 pages strategy, and training as an effective management instrument. This problematic relationship asks for further investigation of management-driven training and development and the exploration of alternatives.Goal: This paper reports on a series of empirical studies in the Netherlands on the inhibiting factors in management-driven HRD and explores the opportunities for employee-driven training and development. It aims at a better understanding of the

Who are These Guys? Working Toward an Empirical Typology of Street-Level Pimps

1754 words - 8 pages Introduction Traditionally prostitution was viewed as a consensual act, one person selling sexual favors to a willing buyer. Used in many classes as an example of “Mala Prohibita” when differentiating between “Mala Prohibita” and “Mala in Se” (conduct that is illegal because it is prohibited vs. conduct that is illegal because it is inherently wrong or evil). This is perhaps true about prostitution in its simplest form (an independent adult

An Analysis on "Driving Consumer Acceptance of Mobile Marketing: A Theoretical Framework and Empirical Study"

683 words - 3 pages those consequences. The social norms are a result of the individual’s normative beliefs i.e., his assumption about what another person wants him to do, and his motivation to comply with the expectations of this person.This study has proved the validity of the Theory of Reasoned Action for research in the area of mobile marketing. The empirical results also imply that social norms only have a slight direct influence on behavioral intention

Similar Essays

The Security Council Of The United Nations

2269 words - 9 pages The world is at a point where people have to question if they feel safe, and if they do, why they feel safe? The answers will vary, but more than likely, the United States, not the United Nations, will be the answer. The Security Council was made to keep peace among the world, and the concept of it was a great idea in theory. The world needs protection from the horrors of genocide, the death from terrorists, and the corruption of governments

An Integrated System Theory Of Information Security Management

678 words - 3 pages theory in variety aspects in order to prevent the risk, threats and vulnerability of the information. 3.0 An Integrated Theory 3.1 The construction of a theory Construction is one of the important paths that should be analyzed by IT security. The authors have been divided this path into two paths. First path is created new security policy different from before. Second is taking from past policy but upgrade into suitable condition. Third is

The Importance Of The United Nations Security Council

2118 words - 8 pages What is the importance of the UN Security Council? “The United Nations Security Council (UNSC) has primary responsibility, under the Charter, for the maintenance of international peace and security” (UNSecurity Council 2010). The end of the 1980s and the 1990s has been marked by major changes in international relations, both as practice and as an academic discipline. The collapse of the multi-polar system in the world politics, fall of the

The United Nations Security Council Is In Need Of Reform

1967 words - 8 pages Realist sees an improved situation, where more countries have a substantive role in world affairs and, perhaps especially for the Idealist, a greater commitment to the peaceful resolution of conflict. A proposal from France and the United Kingdom , the “Intermediate Reform”, attempts to reconcile the various approaches to reform of the Security Council with a ‘tiered’ strategy they hope will have wider appeal and acceptability to the various