This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Saint Augustine's Deduction That Free Will Is A Good Gift From God

1204 words - 5 pages

Saint Augustine's Deduction that Free Will is a Good Gift from God


Before the central theme of this essay is analytically summarized, it
is important to note a few propositions already established in the
conversations between Saint Augustine and Evodius. Firstly, Saint
Augustine has already ascertained that God gave human beings free
choice of the will – Evodius is also sure of this proposition. He
deduces that since our existence came from God, then it must be God
who gave us free will. Secondly, Augustine then questions Evodius on
how he knows that our existence comes from God. His answer begs the
question as he states that our existence must come from God since he
punishes the unjust and rewards those who are good.

Another proposition that must be established before the crux of the
argument may be presented is that although God gave human beings free
will, we must use it to live rightly. This again is resting on the
assumption that God rewards the just and punishes those who use their
free will to sin. Augustine proposes that God does not punish those
who live rightly. Moreover, if free will was intended for living
rightly and unjustly, then punishment of those who sin and reward for
those who live rightly would not be justified. Therefore, Saint
Augustine concludes that free will must have been given to humans by
God for the purpose of living rightly.

This leads to the crux argument discussed between Saint Augustine and
Evodius that free will is a good gift from God. The argument may be
summarized as follows: 1) All good things come from God, 2) God gave
humans free will, therefore, 3) free will is a good thing from God.
Although the argument is sound, it is not completely valid. Evodius
notes that our free will could also be used wrongly. This jeopardizes
the second proposition that all good things come from God. Augustine
rebuts this argument of Evodius by giving another example. He states
that a great good is missing from the body with no hands and yet
people can use their hands wrongly (i.e., by committing
violent/shameful acts). Augustine is still begging the question. He
states that it is better to have something which be used for just and
unjust acts the not possess it at all. From this statement, however,
one can conclude that free will is not a good thing in itself because
it can lead to wrong or unjust acts.

Saint Augustine was a Christian, and a brief and simple counterexample
from his religious perspective could prove this proposition to be
false. Augustine states that a great good is missing if someone lost
their hands or eyes,...

Find Another Essay On Saint Augustine's Deduction that Free Will is a Good Gift from God

Is Free Healthcare a Good Thing?

1575 words - 7 pages Marisol Maturino Ms. Nguyen Essay May. 27. 14 Word Count: 1270 Health Care Controversy Essay Most people in the United States think that free health care is a good thing. This free health care is known as the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act or Obamacare. Obamacare is a health care system invented by president Barack Obama for people to receive either free or low costing health insurance. It invites people to sign up for it by

Differences Between Individuals Will Always Occur In Work Organisation. Ideally, Good Management Practice Should Use Performance Appraisal Information In Ways That Will Promote Equality Amongst...

734 words - 3 pages is a comparative method of evaluation. It is system of comparing one employee with other. Mostly, there is a ranking from the best to the worst. Comparative standard includes simple ranking, alternate ranking, paired comparison and forced distribution. For absolute standard, employees are evaluated independently of one another. It includes pen picture or essay narrative, critical incident, weighted check-list, forced choice, graphic rating scales

What is Free Will?

806 words - 4 pages notion of free will and ideology of determinism are compatible (hence their name) with one another. Determinism, as explained by authors James and Stuart Rachels of Problems with Philosophy, is "to say that a system is deterministic means that every that happens stems from a prior cause" (pg 97). To put it simply, a determinist believes that an event that will occur in the present time was in itself influenced by a series of events in past, much

This Essay Examines The Idea Of Fate In Shakespeare's Play Macbeth, And Attempts To Show That The Characters Acted Of Their Own Free Will, Not Due To The Wishes Of Some Higher Being

835 words - 4 pages campaign against Macbeth had much larger goals in mind. All of these could have been accomplished without the death of Macbeth. Macduff, instead of focusing on the prophesized removal of Macbeth from the throne, wanted to kill Macbeth, and so he did.Ultimately, in Macbeth, Shakespeare shows Macbeth as a character who fulfills his future as predicted by the instruments of fate, the witched. He does indeed act in the manner that has been prophesized, but he does so of his own free will, not because any outside force wishes him to act as he does.

“A Gift Sent from Heaven”

2627 words - 11 pages slums too. “That reminds me Marcie, I’ve been meaning to ask you something.” Marcellina raised her head to look at her beloved husband. “Yes my dear?” “Did you ever find out who left that box at you mother’s grave?” Marcellina laughed at Celio’s inquiry, her voice like the rippling of wind chimes, “I was wondering when you’d ask that, but no, we really didn’t. Although my father and I like to believe that it was a gift sent from heaven.”

Free Will A Major Debate

1484 words - 6 pages this is automatically inclined to steal. This would mean that this person's morals are out of his or her control. Therefore this person cannot be held morally responsible and once again free will is irrelevant.The argument from immediate experience states that people are able to deliberate before making a radically free choice. The argument from immediate experience would say that when a person is presented with a decision such as choosing between

Marijuana as a Gift from Mother Earth

1049 words - 4 pages that it is a donkey, eventually the horse will believe it. The amount of propaganda that has been flooding the country for all these years, misinformation from top government officials, and blatant lies from our country’s health “experts” has instigated a furious “war” that has divided the country in half. This war has no winners – the country is not even coming close to ridding the country of the “problem”, and the drug users are growing in

Assessment of the View that it is Rational to Believe that there is a God

1058 words - 4 pages talking about whether or not it is rational to believe in god. Pascal for instance thinks that you should believe in God as you will gain more from it when you pass away if he does exist, i.e. going to heaven, whereas if you don't believe in God and it turns out he does in fact exists you will lose more. This is often referred to as Pascal's wager and Pascal is a prudentialist, which means believing in something because

"Cloning - A Gift From God ... Or an Injustice Towards Humanity?" A moral and religious debate between the pro's and con's of cloning

1722 words - 7 pages Cloning - a Gift From God, or an Injustice Towards Humanity?In a world that is as fast paced as the one we live in today, it is hard to stop and remember the moral values and religious beliefs we were taught as children. We live in a world where science is put on a pedestal, and religion is a far off thought saved for holidays that we hardly remember the meanings of. Why is it that when we hear about scientific advancements we get excited, and

How free is the will in society

789 words - 4 pages religion prevents most of us from a lot. As I am a person that believes in God, I believe that by serving him interferes with our individual free will. The idea of free will in many religions is centered on ideas of God and does not allow the possibilities that we are completely determined in our own actions. Why can’t we have sex out of wed lock? Can two people be in a relationship and have a family without a having to commit to marriage? In God’s eyes

Patience is a Great Gift--Sara Vee

557 words - 2 pages looked at as unprofessional and inappropriate. Keeping my cool and being nice and funny with the kids is something I like to do. It's not too hard to keep everything moving smoothly, but there are always a few days out of the two weeks that are a little more difficult than the others to keep calm. This is where God has blessed me with a hint of patience. This great gift helps me to become a good teacher, and learn about the things that are really important to the kids. Patience is a tough role, but with a little work everyone can achieve it.

Similar Essays

Augustine's Thoughts On Free Will Essay

1010 words - 5 pages One thing that philosophers are great at is asking big questions, usually without providing answers. However, Saint Augustine has a more direct approach to his speculation, often offering a solution to the questions he poses. One such topic he broached in The City of God against the pagans. In this text, Augustine addresses the problem of free will and extends his own viewpoint. Stating that humankind can have free will with an omniscient God

Elements That Make For Good Horror Fiction: The Great God Pan And The Three Strangers

886 words - 4 pages will enjoy the same horror fiction, because not everyone is scared by the same things. But it is fair to say that horror fiction needs to illicit a response from it’s readers in order to be successful. The Great God Pan encompasses the elements that I believe to be a good horror story: the feeling you are on a roller coaster, bodily reactions, and a confrontation of our fears. Whereas The Three Strangers does not use any of them, and is

From Sinner To Saint: Augustine's Conversion To Christianity

2217 words - 9 pages chronicles this exhaustive trial and gives us insight into Augustine's conversion from a life of sin to a life carried out in accordance with the rules of the Catholic Church.To Augustine, God represents the sole constant in a universe that is continuously undergoing change. He is unwavering in his belief that God is imperishable, inviolable, and unchangeable. Were any of these three conditions proven false, it would imply that there existed a power

Antonio Dvorak Musical Talents Are A Gift From God

693 words - 3 pages "Do not wonder that I am so religious. An artist who is not could not produce anything like this." (-Antonio Dvorak) A person of humble origins and demeanor and of deep faith, Antonio Dvořák often attributed his musical talents as being "a gift from God." His Bohemian nationalist music spurred generations of folk and romantic music to continue on into the 19th Contrary. He followed the path of God and it showed through in his music. To further