Same Opportunities, Different Parenting Views Essay

1855 words - 8 pages

Ever think where all those Chinese mathematicians, science geniuses, and music wizards come from? When we think of the Chinese population, we are likely to think of all these sorts of geniuses. That’s what everyone wonders about when it comes to the Chinese parenting. But in order for these prodigies to happen, it must be taught and strongly pushed on when younger. There are two different styles of parenting, which Amy Chua from The Wall Street Journal would call Western and Chinese parents.
In “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” Amy Chua, professor at Yale Law School, and publisher of The Wall Street Journal, describes the differences between Chinese and Western mothers. She elaborates on the main differences by telling us the main rules that her own daughters must follow at home. Chua explains how Western parents worry more about how their kids are going to feel if the parent says the wrong thing, and on the contrary Chinese parents think that their kid should be strong enough to take any shameful thing their parent might say. Second she says, “Chinese parents believe that their kids owe them everything”(para 15), and that the child should always obey and try to make their parents proud because that is their only responsibility. Third, she states that Chinese parents think that they know what is best for their kids and that is why they must decide on everything for their kids. Amy concludes that Chinese parents believe they shouldn’t consider what the child’s desire and preference might be because parents know what is best for them.
Chua’s article comes across effectively using ethos because she talks about her own life at home in which she has gained a lot of knowledge from; she also uses logos effectively because she gives good evidence and reasoning on why Chinese mothers are superior by using statistics. Although Chua uses ethos and logos effectively, she has a narrow angle of vision, which affects her own pathos, and may lead to generalizations about Western parents. Not using pathos effectively leads me to think this article is not persuasive because it only captures the attention of Chinese mothers.
Amy Chua’s article uses ethos effectively because it makes readers trust what she is doing. She shows trustworthy by talking to us about her own personal experience. She is a Chinese mother, she does have all these rules and understandings on how her daughters should be no matter if they like it or not. Amy states things like, “Well, I can tell them, because I’ve done it”(para 1); now the reader can see that she has knowledge on this subject. She also demonstrates her knowledge and the way a Chinese mother would react to a situation by giving us a “story in favor of coercion, Chinese-style”(para 19). Amy’s daughter was trying to learn how to play a song on the piano and she just could not do it and wanted to give up. Amy reacted by screaming at her and telling her that she would give away her toys and she would not get any gifts for the...

Find Another Essay On Same Opportunities, Different Parenting Views

Pros and Cons of Parenting Styles

1350 words - 5 pages certain things in the world. Children can not learn anything more unless they go and experience things for themselves. Parents teach them the things they already know and the things they have learned previously, not teaching them anything new. Different parenting styles have an effect on every single child. Whether it is disciplinary strategies, warmth and nurturance, certain communication,or even expectations of a child's maturity and control

Intellectually disabled parents have the legal right and human desire to become parents.

1590 words - 6 pages intellectually disabled people and parenting will prevail to be a highly argumentative discussion. I believe that there is a need to ensure that parents with disabilities have the same opportunities as parents without disabilities to raise their children within their homes, families, and communities. As social workers within our communities, we will need to be dedicated to the empowerment of families and strive to promotesensitivity, awareness

Responsibility of Parents

749 words - 3 pages Parenting carries love, moral values, life skills, knowledge, traditional and so on to their children all the time. Most of the children practice the moral values, knowledge, and tradition which taught by their parents. In this way, most of them follow and believe in their parents’ word. Basically, children world views and mind were deeply shaped by their parents. Most of the children exercise what their parents practice. Children learn to make

Two methods of parental handling of teenage problems

1000 words - 4 pages and extracurricular activities to enhance children’s level and social skills too. They always encourages their offspring by requesting them to complete some chore, housework so as to help children create their confident and competence on dealing with simple troubles that play an important part in their life. It is not denied that all parenting styles has nurtured their children with the same target that assist them in gaining achievement in

Parenting Styles: The Effect on Your Child

582 words - 2 pages In my recent psychology class we studied parenting styles. They are grouped into three different categories; authoritarian, authoritative, and overly permissive. This gave me insight into a couple of different programs I’ve watched on television.Authoritarian parents are parents that set strict rules to keep order and they usually do this without much expression of warmth and affection. “They demand obedience to authority.” (Coon & Mitterer

parenting styles

1689 words - 7 pages on how to morally act through modeling behaviors in which they imitate actions that are appropriate from adult behaviors. Pertaining from different perspective of moral developmental theories, these are supplemental guide for us to understand and appreciate process of development even if these theories have different kinds of views from each other according to Alegre (2012). The child’s development focuses on the hidden child’s mind mobilizing

The Effects of Gay/Lesbian Parenting Styles Correlating to Children's Social Acceptance

1497 words - 6 pages behaviors and social acceptance based on their parenting styles. Each parent will be surveyed on the same day. On that day, they couples will be explained the importance of not telling their significant other about the details of the observation. They will also be given the results and the purpose of the study when all the research has been collected. All parents will be tested in different locations around the community, sporadically, to prevent

Gay Parenting

833 words - 4 pages to have the exact same effect as regular marriages. Everybody is entitled to his or her own opinion when it comes to judging someone else. Hot country artist Carrie Underwood even agrees with supporting marriage and parenting equality. From someone who was raised as a Baptist her views are out in the open and almost everyone knows how she feels, especially since she is a celebrity. After being interview by The Independent Underwood stated “As a

Pros and Cons for Each of The Four Parenting Styles

2231 words - 9 pages different approach towards their children. In an authoritative parenting style, the parent acts as a role model for their child. This means a parent exhibits the same behavior that they expect their child to follow. These parents tend to set high standards for their children but are also nurturing and responsive. They also show plenty of respect towards their child who as a result of this style develop into an independent, rational human

Parenting Styles: What They Are and Why They Matter

2821 words - 11 pages can consist of things like how well one could do at a certain task to non-academic things like how well they think they can achieve on solving a problem or their self-image. Each parenting style has a different level of responsiveness and demandingness, and only an equal level of both responsiveness and demandingness can be healthy for the child’s physical and psychological development (Ishak, Low, Lau 2011). In support Weiss and Schwartz as

Parenting and culture

1516 words - 6 pages The universality versus cultural specificity debate both have aspects that make sense and can be applied to childhood development. On one side, supporters of the argument for the universality of parenting suggest that certain types of parenting styles will produce the same child development outcomes in different cultures. On the other hand, the argument for cultural specificity states that different parenting practices vary from culture to

Similar Essays

Different Methods That Parents Use To Raise Their Children

1865 words - 7 pages -being. Therefore, parents need to make wise choices in the way they raise their children. Since authoritative parenting proves to be the most beneficial to children and their development, parents need to adopt the strategies of this style in order to successfully raise their children. The different methods that parents use to raise their children are categorized by experts into four distinct styles – each style determined by a parent’s level

Parenting Styles Essay

1014 words - 5 pages rare. Permissive parenting style is described as laze fair. Parents make few demands of the child, there is little behavioral discipline or expectations of the child. Parents are thought of as very nurturing, affectionate, communicative but at the same time they offer the child very little discipline or control. The third parenting style is authoritative parenting style which is described as somewhere in the middle of the other two. Parents that

Humanities Essay

976 words - 4 pages families for themselves. The research that I gathered expresses surprisingly similar views to the idea of gay parenting, the theme of the research is overwhelmingly supportive of gay parenting as a whole. The first piece of research I gathered, titled, "Psychologists' Attitudes Toward Gay and Lesbian Parenting" makes note of the immense amount of children who reside in foster care and orphanages in the United States alone. All children there are on

The Factors In Parenting Styles And Their Influences On Children

2292 words - 10 pages notion in recent. And this mixed cultural notion affects the formation of different parenting style. From traditional Eastern cultural, Chinese parenting style is stated as “restrictive”, “controlling” (Chiu, 1987; Kriger& Kroes, 1972; Lin& Fu, 1990; Sollenberger, 1968; Yee, 1983) or “authoritarian” (Dornbusch, Ritter, Leiderman, Roberts, & Brown, 1992). To clarify this kind of parenting, Confucian concept can be used to apply as the factor of