Samoan Rainbow. "Anthropologists In Search Of A Culture: Margaret Mead, Derek Freeman, And All The Rest Of Us". The Controversy Between Anthropologists Mead And Freeman.

1550 words - 6 pages

Samoan Rainbow"Truth is merely common sense, say the naïve realist. Really? Then where, precisely, is the location of - a rainbow? In the air? In the eye? In between? Or somewhere else?" (Abbey, 11). To define the nature of culture it seems at first, to be a simple task. However, finding and holding the true essence of a culture is like pinpointing Abbey's rainbow. It becomes clear to me the misunderstandings between Margaret Mead and Derek Freeman, they were both trying to pinpoint a rainbow, but not necessarily the same rainbow. "Anthropologists in Search of a Culture: Margaret Mead, Derek Freeman, and All the Rest of us", is an article searching for answers, answers to a mystery that appears to need a detective of Sherlock Holmes caliber to unlock.Margaret Mead went to Samoa at the age of twenty-three in the 1920's. She stayed for nine months observing young girls of a village on the eastern part of the islands. She was trying to gain knowledge for the culture vs. biology debate, which is, in itself, another great mystery. Mead showed, from evidence gathered, culture influences the life cycle of a person not biology. She proves this by showing how adolescent girls of Samoa deal with maturing differently then girls of a western culture. Derek Freeman, after visiting Samoa some thirty years later felt that Margaret Mead's conclusions do not fit at all with what he observed. Thus, the controversy began. A deluge of papers on the topic appears, trying to sort out the mystery. Eleanor Leacock decided to take the opportunity and "put on her applied-anthropology hat..." (Leacock, 3). However, although Leacock is dealing with the Mead-Freeman controversy, she is actually dealing with how one should go about studying cultures.Leacock agrees with Mead much more then Freeman, shooting down many of Freeman's points. She says, he ignored the culture changes that took place between his and Mead's observation, he misinterpreted the Mead-Boas relationship, he was on a different island observing different people, he cites criticisms made by Holmes ignoring the fact that Holmes believes the Mead's study was generally sound and his criticisms were harsh, one sided and an insulting description of Samoan culture. He did exactly what he was accusing Margaret Mead of doing, only from the opposite position. That is not acknowledging all of the observations and making conclusions based on a limited view. What is worse is the fact that he chose not to acknowledge the differences in Samoan culture in the 20's and in the 60's (Leacock, 10).Culture, especially during a time of introduction to Western ideas, is going to change. Freeman ignores this and believes all of the differences he observes from that which was described in Mead's book were inconsistencies on Mead's part. Essentially what he is doing was talking to people of my generation about the people and culture of my grandparents' generation. There is no way I know how it really was, I know what I have been...

Find Another Essay On Samoan Rainbow. "Anthropologists in Search of a Culture: Margaret Mead, Derek Freeman, and All the Rest of us". The controversy between anthropologists Mead and Freeman.

Are We all Simply Serial Killers or Are Serial Killers Different from the Rest of Us?

2513 words - 11 pages Peter Vronsky wrote two different books about serial killers. The first is his book Serial Killers, which covers all of the definitions of what a serial killer is, both men and women. Though the main focus in this book was on the men. The second is his book Female Serial Killers, which goes into a more detailed description of just female serial killers. Everything in the second book could have been included in the Serial Killers book instead of

Role of the mead-hall in The Wanderer (poem)

1246 words - 5 pages killed in an attack, and because the hall is imprinted into his identity, the memories of the carnage will consequently remain with him all his life. This compelling relationship between the protagonist and his role as a hall-warrior leads to his present state of exile.The poem essentially is set in the present where the warrior is on a voyage to seek a new mead-hall - a new life. But within The Wanderer, not only is there physical journeying

Change and Modernization: The Industrial Revolution (an anthropologists point of view)

2354 words - 9 pages this. It may be argued that the reason the Industrial Revolution spanned a period of 120 years was due to it transforming a large-scale culture as opposed to a quicker change in a small-scale 'Arembepe' like culture. Subsequent to the revolution, agricultural growth took a backseat to technological innovations and mass production. Society changed in a very short time from an agrarian and relatively self-sufficient society to an industrial and

mead and symbolic interactionism

2569 words - 10 pages ourselves, if we have a job or not, and if we do, what profession we are in, with all of this deriving from our dress sense. Props are a great way of highlighting things about us, for example, a doctor's stethoscope helps to determine the person's profession, whereas a wedding band would indicate that the person is married.Thirdly, another feature that our audience will pick up on quite quickly is our physical stature. For example, women are especially

George Herbert Mead and Erik H. Erikson: Theories of Socialization

789 words - 3 pages is needed for survival of society and culture. Comparatively, Mead shared some intellectual sociological similarities with Erik H. Erikson. Particularly with Erikson's broader view of socialization: his eight stages of development.Mead understood the self to thrive as long as four major components that revolved around social cooperation fell into place. The first belief he transmitted was that the self was not present in a person at birth. It

George Herbert Mead: The Self, ''Me'' and ''I''

3135 words - 13 pages and the apex itself. It is with the apex in relation to the whole arrow as with our eyes in relation to the rest of our body. As Mead himself notices (§18), we can see many parts of our bodies, but we can never see the whole body. With Mead's "I" as a background, let us take a look at performatives again. A performative is an action performed by the "I" aspect of a self. Consequently, it cannot be directed at itself when it is performed. Since

The Revolt of Mother, by Mary E. Wlkins Freeman

1194 words - 5 pages though she deeply resents that her husband is not paying heeds to her demand of a new house, but she never fails to pay attention to his wants. Sarah’s relationship with Adoniram, her husband, is a typical example of the relationship between a man and a woman living in a patriarchal society of the 19th century. Adoniram embodies all the characteristics of male dominance and authoritarianism. He is an authoritative husband who does not like his

Regional Writers, a comparison of Mary Wilkes Freeman and Kate Chopin

1251 words - 5 pages Regional WritersDuring the post-Civil War era writers from all regions of the country emerged. The writers all generated stories in respect to their region of the country, that incorporated local values and characteristics. Many of the authors use some of the same themes, such as irony. Mary Wilkes Freeman writes with irony in "A New England Nun" and Kate Chopin uses irony in "Desiree's Baby." Freeman is from a small town in Massachusetts and

Feminism in "The Revolt of 'Mother'" by Mary Eleanor Wilkins Freeman

655 words - 3 pages The Wife of Man: An Existential Approach to Modern Feminism"In literature, Expressionism is often considered a revolt against realism and naturalism, seeking to achieve a psychological or spiritual reality rather than record external events in logical sequence"The Revolt of "Mother" by Mary Eleanor Wilkins Freeman is a piece of literature that subjectively reconciles the author's inner experiences through the main character. Coincidentally, the

What does ‘oral history’ entail, and what use can it be to the agendas of anthropologists, or historians or archaeologists?

2143 words - 9 pages What does ‘oral history’ entail, and what use can it be to the agendas of anthropologists, or historians or archaeologists? Rowse states that ‘human society, its story and how it has come to be what it is, is due to the factors that operate in them’ (Rowse, 1963). This is especially true when looking at history from an oral historian’s perspective. Oral history has always been a topic open to much debate – whether or not it is a method worthy

Freud and Mead´s Theories

707 words - 3 pages the one component that a human has at birth. It is the part of the personality structure that is unorganized, which contains human's basic, instinctual drives. The id is where our needs wants, impulses, sexual, and aggressive desires come from. If people were only guided by the id, people would not be able to cope in reality. The ego was developed in order acts as a mediator between the id and reality. Initially the ego is “that part of the id

Similar Essays

Biography Of Margaret Mead Essay

793 words - 4 pages Samantha DzirkoPeace Studies - Period 3October 25, 2007Margaret Mead was a strong-willed woman who desired to help people from a young age. Born to highly educated parents, Edward Sherwood Mead and Emily Briggs, Margaret was raised in a household of great intellect and in an environment where her activist mother influenced her immensely. From a young age, Mead wanted to help people. This is evident in the fact that she later went on to become an

Why Have Anthropologists Insisted On The Differences Between "Gift" Exchange And "Commodity" (Or "Market") Exchange? How Useful Is The Distinction?

1899 words - 8 pages difference. Finally I will explain the utility of the distinction, and emphasise why I believe the separate terms are required.The term 'gift exchange' has many other alternative phrasings. 'Gift economy', 'gift culture' and 'ceremonial exchange' are all interchangeable, and each distinguishes a slightly different nuance in the complex occurrence that is gift exchange. Anthropological research primarily recorded it first in the Trobriand Islands

Margaret Mead This Was Written For An Anthropology Class

861 words - 3 pages ." (Snider).Many of the methods of study that Mead created are still used in research as well as study. Along with being a founder of the "Culture and Personality School of Anthropology" she also was the first to conduct field work from a psychologically perspective and was influential in generating between anthropology and other fields. (http://www.wic.org/bio/mmead.htm). With 44 books and over 1,000 articles in numerous languages Margaret Mead's

Evaluations Of The Oraibi Split. The 'oraibi' Was A Pueblo Of A Native American Culture Called The Hopi. This Essay Examines Why The Oraibi Split From Four Different Anthropologists Views

1923 words - 8 pages strategy based on ancestral Hopi social organization, culture, and history (Clemmer 1995: 24). He contrasts Traditionalists with the Hopi Tribal Council, who also seeks self-determination, but follows a strategy allied with the European-American political-economic system. The Hopi Traditionalist movement occurred in response to the contact between Hopis and the U.S. government (Clemmer 1995: 27). Such contact has been dominated by the attempts of