This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Sarah Polley’s Stories We Tell Essay

1607 words - 6 pages

Sarah Polley’s film Stories We Tell is as much about how we interpret images – what we take as “true” – as it is about how we remember. Through a close analysis of the film discuss what you think the film sets out to do and how it achieves these aims. In answering this question you might also want to look at reviews of the film.
The truth is subjective and how we see the truth impacts the way we understand meaning. Each individual’s memory is a result of what they deem to be true. Sarah Polley questions this concept through her film ‘Stories We Tell’ and brings to light the topic of reliability and subjectivity in terms of memory and the truth.
Polley highlights the notion of truth and how each individual sees it differently. In her film, she denotes that in order to understand the truth and its subjectivity, stories must be seen, heard, and told (Vulture 2013). The interviews depicted in Stories We Tell allow the audience to absorb the subject as well as witness each character revisit the past and see it in a different light. This is shown near the end of the film where each character is seen reflecting on the subject of their mother, reflecting on their “private memory, his or her ‘truth’” (Vulture 2013). Through presenting this near the end of the film, it allows the audience to register how subjective the truth is, in that although they all spoke about the same topic, the way in which they reflect on this is entirely associated with what they remember.
What we see is not always what is true. While watching the film, the audience is captivated by the “archival footage” shown while Polley’s family members and friends recall what kind of person her mother, Diane, was. Initially, we as the audience do not question the footage, as it is acts as a supplement to the subject. Once it becomes apparent that most of the old family footage was actually actors portraying a described reality, the audience is forced to question whether this has had an effect on their meaning and subject of the film. It brings to light the idea that in film, everything we see is orchestrated. In that, everything we see is what the director wants us to see. Joye Weisel-Barth (p. 164, 2014) extends this further noting, “what I know and will take away will not be “the truth”; it will be the truths that Sarah has provided and shaped for me and that I have accepted”. Polley herself affirms this, saying that “the truth about the past is often ephemeral and difficult to pin down… and many of our stories…end up with shifts and fictions in them, mostly unintended” (Stories We Tell 2012).
Polley’s direction of the film directly impacts the way the meaning it conveys. David Edelstein (Vulture 2013) draws attention to the film in that is has “no ambiguity whatsoever about what happened and why”, and that Stories We Tell “is actually a rare instance in which ¬multiple perspectives dovetail neatly”. This particular stance on the film is interesting as it is true. Everything we see...

Find Another Essay On Sarah Polley’s Stories We Tell

Comparing the French Lieutenant's Woman and Jewel in the Crown

1021 words - 4 pages importance of social stature, both portray society's view of what's acceptable in the intimate relationships of women, and both are stories in which two lovers are together regardless of whether or not society approves.   The portrayal of social statures in French Lieutenant's Woman is rather simple.  Other than Sarah Woodruff, the characters are of the wealthy upper class.  Sarah is described as a "poor but educated woman who has lost

Where Friendship Takes You Essay

787 words - 4 pages In the novel, Staying Fat for Sarah Byrnes, we learn the story of a abused girl trying to survive the world that she was placed in. She never had any friends until she was in the sixth grade, when she met Eric. Eric was also an outcast because of his weight. The other kids call him Moby because he's on the swim team and that's their clever way of saying that he is like a whale. Sarah and Eric have been friends for six years and when she stops

Feminism Idea in Revolt of Mother

3734 words - 15 pages . This is a story that shows how the main character, Sarah Penn, solve problem in her family. Sarah, who is a house wife, fights against her husband, her son, and her surroundings. Although people never listen to her, but Sarah keep strong and at the end, she can make a big difference in her family. She takes a job that it should be her husband's job.Problem FormulationTo conduct this research, the writer will start by answering two problem

Electric Cooperatives: Serving Our Members Past, Present, and Future

929 words - 4 pages working at the electric cooperative, back in 1935 when Roosevelt was the President.” “I remember when he first created the Rural Electrification Administration.” Grandpa said. “What is that?” Hanna inquired. “Oh we just learned about that in history! It made money available, so people in rural areas, like us, could have electricity.” enunciated Sarah. “That is right Sarah, see this picture here is when one of the first power lines went up here in

The Things You Can’t Take Back

1784 words - 8 pages “…So I take him to the club thinking, alright, this is cool, we’re friends now, let’s chill with a few drinks and get to know each other, if you know what I mean. Then we get to the front of the line and it turns out he doesn’t even have a license, so he pulls out his passport! Can you believe that? It’s like, where are you flying, bro? And he says…” Sarah smiled and nodded and laughed at the appropriate times. She learned how to give off

Salem Witch Trials of 1692 What really happened?

793 words - 3 pages their pain. All would await trial for a crime punishable by death in 17th century New England, the practice of witchcraft.Elizabeth Parris 9, and her cousin, Abigal Williams 11, and a slave woman, Tituba, cared for the two girls. She would tell them stories of voodoo to entertain them. Elizabeth and Abigal were so facinated with the stories that they began to play with the idea of telling each other's fortune. They soon had several of their

This story is about an issue of conscience

882 words - 4 pages to go through all of this agony, but I am glad that I made the decision to tell someone. Sarah is continually making progress because of it.We don't know exactly what happened to Matthew. Sarah decided that she'd rather not know. We do know however that he did serve a sentence in jail, but for how long, or if he's still there, we don't know. There is a restraining order against him, so Sarah never has to see him again. My relationship with Sarah has grown so much since this terrible crime occurred, and we will only grow closer and closer throughout the rest of our lives.

Genesis 18

1965 words - 8 pages ? Where was Sarah? How did Abraham know they were messengers from God? The Passage begins with Abraham out by his tent on a hot day when the lord appears to him. One problem with the interpretation of this is the use of the word " lord" does this mean God himself or a divine being. I believe that the words LORD and God were inter-changeable in the Bible text. It is important to remember that these stories were written many years

Mary Freeman's The Revolt of Mother and the Domestic Feminist

1842 words - 8 pages ; she is aware that he provides for her and is respectful of him even when he does not show her the same respect. We can see how much power the father holds when Sarah tries to convince Adonitram to explain why they need a new barn. “I want to know what you're buildin' that new barn for, father?” “I ain't got nothin' to say about it.” “It can't be you think you need another barn?” “I tell ye I ain't got nothin' to say about it, mother; an' I

Forever Mine (Fighter Club 2)

3500 words - 14 pages Sarah walks into her daughter Ellie's bedroom, sits on her bed and watches her for a few minutes before waking her. "Ellie Belly time to get up, we are going to see Alexia, Ben and Amber" Ellie stirs "No London!" she say’s as she pulls the cover over her head. Sarah giggles at her "We're not off to London you numpty, they've moved in just down the road remember" Ellie sit’s straight up and looks in Sarah's direction, blinking her eyes to try and

Winchester Mystery House

765 words - 4 pages behind them or a reason for them being there. At the end of the build the house consisted of 160 rooms, 2,000 doors, 47 stairways, and 10,000 windows. The house is now seven stories tall. Sarah lived a long life and this may be because she followed the directions from the medium. Sarah passed away on September 5th, 1922. The Winchester Mystery House is proven to be haunted. Many tourists had visited the house and have explained how spirits

Similar Essays

We Tell Stories To Come To Terms With The World To Harmonize Our Lives Within Reality

1767 words - 7 pages Campbell's theory, like wise the story Father Christmas has mythic qualities. Campbell also looks into the hidden meaning of myth, why we tell stories, and what their meaning is. In "The Power of Myth" he is shown to believe that myths prepare us for rites of passage. Our ancestors have been through events and experiences that have caused them problems, puberty, marriage, death of a relative, hunting etc. Each of these experiences is echoed in a myth

Title Essay

1585 words - 7 pages dad was thinking of a plan to get Sarah. But then mom had a plan and told her husband to come over so she can whisper the plan in his ear and he leaned over and she told him. “so get a glass of cold water and put ice in it then go up to her room and I will pull her covers down then you will dump the glass of water slowly so she will get up and she will want to get the cup but you will run down stairs and sit on the coach then we will tell her the

Selfish Or Selfless Essay

1265 words - 5 pages choose to help, guilt is an emotion that drives a person to change their mistakes. Guilt, a negative emotion, can sometimes be turned into something positive where it allows a person to right their wrongs through helping others. Sarah and Little Bee felt guilty because both felt that they had some part as to why Andrew decided to commit suicide: We need to collect the stories of people who’ve been through the same things as you. We need to make

Friendship A Bond Of Love And Hate

1392 words - 6 pages Friendship - A Bond of Love and Hate Sarah and I had a fight about two weeks ago. We hadn’t fought in a while so we were due for a battle. Sarah complained that a girl at my party was “talking about her,” and, obviously, if I was a real friend, I should have kicked her out. Funny thing is I wouldn’t have kicked the girl out even if I had known that she was talking about Sarah. This, in turn, caused Sarah to tell that she hated me and never