This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Savages? Cannibals? Barbarians? Oh My!: Montaigne And His Ideas About Society

1200 words - 5 pages

In The Complete Essays Michel de Montaigne questions societies ideas about what is right and good in society with the knowledge of the existence of a cannibalistic culture from the “New World”. This completely different civilization shapes his ideas about his own society. Montaigne wants people to take this practically alien civilization and use it as a mirror for their own ideas of what is right and how they conduct themselves.
The introduction of a culture so drastically different from what the Europeans were used to called into question the rightness of their ways. If a whole separate group of people could have developed so differently, their own customs were, perhaps, not the best as they had considered them thus far. Montaigne brings this to light when he says,

“every man calls barbarous anything he is not accustomed to; it is indeed the case that we have no other criterion of truth or right-reason than the example and form of the opinions and customs of our own country. There we always find the perfect religion, the perfect polity, the most developed and perfect way of doing anything!” (231).

They have only their own culture as a basis for what is “truth or right-reason”. Without being able to see the cannibals culture from the perspective of a cannibal, they cannot think of it as normal. To Europeans, anything that is different will be the wrong because it is not theirs. Through exclusion, people are able to define what they are. By discovering this society, Europeans could claim superiority because they do not act in such “barbaric” ways and have what they would consider a better system. Montaigne commends the cannibals for their consistency in their values of “resolution in war, and affection to their wives” (214). He continues to reflect on this notion because their simplicity is so contrasting from the complicity of his own society and yet the cannibals function well enough.
Montaigne uses the cannibals’ civilization as a contrast to the French in order to criticize the French. He does so without always saying what he wants to explicitly so as not to offend people directly, but it is connoted. He says, “They are still in that blessed state of desiring nothing beyond what is ordained by their natural necessities” (236). He is arguing that the cannibals are more in touch with nature and, therefore, in a blessed state. What he leaves out is that since the French do not have a society that is structured the same way, they must be in a state that is less blessed. He does not say this directly because that would be much too blasphemous. He chooses not to offend, but rather to plant the seeds of a certain way of thinking. He does not want people to assume that the things they consider normal as the definitively correct way. Instead he is subtly inserting the idea that difference is not necessarily incorrect. Difference can teach new ways of thinking that may enlighten society.
Contrary to his contemporaries, Montaigne does not think...

Find Another Essay On Savages? Cannibals? Barbarians? Oh My!: Montaigne and His Ideas about Society

Plato's life and contributions to society.. What is known about his past, and how he enhanced the world around him

1629 words - 7 pages Plato is a man that has, in a way, been immortalized. Even though, he lived and died thousands of years ago, his thoughts and his ideas still live on today. In order to most accurately get a feel for who Plato was, there are many factors to be looked at. First, one should look at the times in which Plato lived. This includes, but is not limited to, the culture, the common thought, and any major historical happenings. Second, one should examine

An Inspector Calls By J.B. Priestly - How Does Priestly Convey His Concerns About Society In His Book "An Inspector Calls"

3127 words - 13 pages An Inspector CallsJ.B. Priestley wrote the play 'An Inspector Calls' in 1945. He was a politician and socialist who believed that everyone should be treated fairly. He wrote the play to express his concerns about society. He believed in equality for all sexes, races and classes. He thought the class system was wrong and believed that everyone was equally important. He did not approve of the way the Upper Class thought of themselves as superior

In defense of the Indians by Las Casas and On the Cannibals by Montaigne

1707 words - 7 pages the Cannibals by Michel Eyquem , Seigneur De Montaigne are two recounts of how the Conquistas treated the native inhabitants. This purpose of this paper is to compare and contrast the realistic truths of both documents, and compare what each author had to say about how the Europeans saw the natives’ religion and who the true barbarians were. De Las Casas is a very important religious figure in the sixteenth century. He was born in Seville

The ideas of Machiavelli, Locke, Shakespeare, Montaigne, and Achebe

1427 words - 6 pages ). Montaigne believes society can stay together without any strong and organized government controlling them. Such a notion is a total contrary to the idea of Achebe.While keeping in mind his own ideas about independence from colonial influences, Chinua Achebe's thoughts parallel the thoughts and writings of Machiavelli, Shakespeare, and Locke, as well as their premises about human nature. Okonkwo becomes an exemplar of the ideas of all three figures with

Purity and Civility in The Praise of Folly by Desiderius Erasmus and Of Cannibals by Michel de Montaigne

1521 words - 6 pages within fresh memory,not among ancient enemies,but among neighbours and fellow citizens,and what is worse,on the pretext of piety and religion.” It is to be discerned that Montaigne also satirizes the conflicts which were brutal between Catholics and Protestans as something to be despised and dishonouring.Yet,he advocates that modern men – ignorant of his own barabarity which exceeds that of the cannibals’ – justify

Gandhi, and Martin, and Malcolm, oh my!

818 words - 4 pages Indian people of the time had to carry to move about the city and country. After several years fighting in South Africa, he moved back to his home in India, where he spent the rest of his life battling the british government in India. Over the years he was jailed many times and sent to prison two or three times. In 1947, he was shot and killed by a hindu fanatic in New Delhi, the same year India gained independence. Another famous civil rights

Discussions, and Genres, and Friends, Oh My!

685 words - 3 pages shouting to his friend across the bus. As she hangs off her seat, she ponders about how convenient it would be to have an after school club. An after school activity that everyone would appreciate would be a book club because members can discuss the books, find unfamiliar genres to read, and establish new friendships. A countless amount of students would stay after school to participate in a book club. In this club, everyone sits in a circle to talk

Karl Marx and His Ideas

1796 words - 7 pages Marxism of the Social Democratic Party was like Engel's reaction to Marxism: that it is an oversimplification of history and our contemporary society to say that the lines of causation run in one direction only, from the academic structures to the other elements. Since the Socialist Democratic Party's leader in Germany was an extreme Marxists, Weber got to dislike Marxism even though Weber got most of his ideas from Marx

Idolatry and Social Injustice and Religious Ritualism, Oh My

1057 words - 5 pages The Lord called prophets to speak for Him to the people regarding their sinful behavior. The prophets were God’s “spokesmen,” who were called by God, held accountable by God, and empowered by God to deliver His messages. Idolatry, social injustice, and religious ritualism had become prevalent in Israel and Judah and is rampant in today’s society as well. The prophets delivered their messages through various methods. They preached the word of

Oh My God: History of Mythology and its Influences Today

1715 words - 7 pages Oh My God Mythology is defined as the collection or study of myths. As stated by David Abraham, since the beginning of time mankind has always wanted to know the answer of how we got here or what’s the meaning of life. Early mankind began to create different stories or myths to how it all began and how to explain things in nature like thunder or fire. Many cultures and religions were created due to these questions that have been past down

The Good, the Bad, and the Oh My

1106 words - 5 pages by Bruce J. Schulman, is a clear representation of not only how LBJ developed as a politician, but as well as how a nation grew under his presidency. But more specifically, the documents in the book provide an inside into the different perspectives people had on the actions Johnson was taking. A key component of the Johnson era was a vision of prosperity and liberty, also known as the Great Society. The Great Society has always been a topic of

Similar Essays

Shakespeare's Ideas About Love In His Sonnets

1394 words - 6 pages Shakespeare's Ideas About Love in His Sonnets The two sonnets Shall I Compare Thee and Let Me Not are by William Shakespeare. Love is the main theme of both sonnets. Shall I Compare Thee is written for Shakespeare's love, and it is more personal and cheerful. He takes apart the greatness of a summer's day and compares it to the subject of the poem, but the subject (whom we assume is a 'she') is always more divine and

Thomas Paine Common Sense And Related Writings. How Do His Ideas About The British Constitution Compare With His Ideas About Nature?

587 words - 3 pages Nature's Reasoning" The simple voice of nature and of reason will say, it is right."(76) Thomas Paine passionately argued for what is right and logical in maintaining a working and equal society. Realizing the evil and non-constructive affects of a monarchial government, Paine derived his beliefs and opinions from the simplicity of nature.In mid-June of 1775 the Revolution had reached its bloodiest and pivotal part. The moral of the American

Gandhi. About His Contributations To Society

942 words - 4 pages program of tolerance for all peoples and religions.Gandhi showed miraculous efforts in peace and nonviolence which led to India's independence from Great Britain. His life left an important mark on India's society and history. His accomplishments changed both India and its people forever. He will always be remembered as a great hero and an inspiration to all peoples.

Explain How Shakespeare Communicates His Ideas About The Conflict Between Reality And Appearance In ‘King Lear,' And The Effect On The Audience’s

1030 words - 5 pages oneself, allowing the person to no longer mistake the two. Shakespeare conveys his ideas about appearances and reality, and the consequences confusing the two can impose, through the symbolism of blindness and true sight, as exhibited by Gloucester. The Earl of Gloucester is shocked with Lear’s decision to cast off Cordelia, and thinks him foolish to disregard the only daughter who truly loves him. Gloucester does not see that he is essentially