This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Saving Morality: The Implications Of Hard Determinism

1333 words - 6 pages

Hard determinism, the acceptance of determinism and the rejection of libertarian free will,
results in some serious consequences for moral responsibility. At its most extreme interpretation a
form of moral nihilism arises. ”Without God ... everything is permitted now.”[1] That is, if
determinism holds true, then there is no free choice, and without free choice there can be no
moral responsibility. By taking hard determinism to its logical conclusion, and evaluating the
results of a steadfast adherence to the theory this paper serves to show that moral nihilism is not
the inevitable end to morality in a hard determinist framework. Instead morality, if not wholly, at
least partially, is capable of being maintained by the hard determinist.
Determinism is the philosophical theory that for every action there exists antecedent
conditions from which that action necessarily follows and these conditions are governed entirely
by the natural laws of the universe. Hard determinism claims that not only is determinism true,
but that it is also wholly incompatible with free will. Hard determinism employs the following
physicalist argument as a means of extinguishing the notion of free will:
1. The world, including man, at its most essential level is composed of quanta in motion
(quanta constituting the minimum amount of any physical entity involved in an interaction).
2. The motion of these quanta are governed by a set of materialistic principles constituting the
physical laws of the universe.
3. All actions are determined by antecedent causes that constitute the laws of the universe
acting upon physical entities (quanta).Lawson 2
4. Given the nature of physical entities (quanta) and the laws that govern their behaviour, there
is no principle of autonomy (free-choice).
5. All actions are determined by antecedent causes. Given the antecedent causes, the actions
cannot be other than what they are.
∴ It follows that there are no free choices, and thus no free-will.
The implications of accepting hard determinism are born from this abolition of free will.
Hard determinists notion of free will is that of libertarian free will. This notion of free will
requires that our choices are completely free from determination or restricted by human nature,
nor are they constrained by predetermination by God. As the hard determinist presupposes a
deterministic universe libertarian free will is impossible. A commonly accepted necessary
precondition for moral responsibility is free choice and in the case of the hard determinist this
free choice is constituted by libertarian free will. Without the possibility of free will moral
responsibility is no longer possible. A succinct version of the hard determinists argument for the
freedom from moral responsibility is as follows:
1. Suppose that determinism is true.
2. If determinism is true then our characters are ultimately due to forces beyond our control.
3. If our characters are ultimately due to forces beyond our control, then no...

Find Another Essay On Saving Morality: The Implications of Hard Determinism

The Surge of Morality Essay

1829 words - 8 pages The Surge of Morality Morality in its actuality boils down to different meaning from perspectives that are not necessarily good or bad. The application of morality determines how it can be explained. This shows how an outward appearance defines morality. The concept of morality identifies what is to be done and why it is done in certain ways. However, the existence of conscience gives rise to the definition of a moral act. It is only expected

The Morality of Torture Essay

1348 words - 5 pages The Morality of Torture The moral issue of torture is one that has come under scrutiny by many national and international organizations as of late. To talk about torture one must really understand what torture is. As taken from Dictionary.com “1.a. Infliction or severe physical pain as a means of punishment or coercion. b. An instrument or a method for inflicting such pain. 2. Excruciating physical or mental pain; agony. 3. Something

The Acquisition of Morality

1320 words - 6 pages Would you describe a dog as capable of being evil? Or a cat? Or a chimpanzee? Most likely you could not. We humans belong to the taxonomic kingdom of Animalia and are therefore animals. Our species has evolved from animals that looked and acted more like the modern chimpanzee than we do. So at what point did we go from being creatures of instinct do developing the concept of morality? A great deal of literature has been written about morality

the morality of euthanasia

1031 words - 5 pages financial restraints, some family member may persuade an ill person into requesting euthanasia. That alone compromises autonomy. For those reasons, and since every person is priceless, the values of mercy, justice, and autonomy are not fully justified. As the issue of euthanasia generates many discussions as to what is considered moral or immoral, one thing stands strong: the value of life over death. Life is hard, and even though euthanasia can

The Morality of Money

1187 words - 5 pages morality." His reason is that one makes money through production and trade. And that is the noblest way to live: as a producer who creates value and then gains values from others through voluntary exchange.That is just what people normally do in a free market. Money does not itself create anything, but because it is the medium of exchange it makes possible the specialized production and long-distance commerce that are the basis of our advanced and

The morality of abortion

1398 words - 6 pages in the question of the morality of abortion. When parents decide to keep or not keep a baby the issue of adoption does not play into this. The reason for this is that once the baby is born that the parents may change their mind if they want to keep it. Parents must decide at the onset of the pregnancy to decide if they can in good conscience bring a child into the world, if the answer is yes, then people should proceed with the pregnancy and

The Morality of Torture

1710 words - 7 pages unsubstantial conflicting as a moral and immoral belief. Many individuals would argue that torture is immorally wrong and views it as a malevolent form of punishment, but on the other hand, a solider fighting in war may see it as a justifiable action towards protecting themselves, other citizens, and the country. Nevertheless, if torture is so immoral, why is the topic so hard to explain? Within the society of social order, many people would

The Implications of Rapid Urbanization

1977 words - 8 pages especially the Rapid ones come with implications; both positive and negative. Other countries especially developing and less developed are not well prepared for the growth in population at the cities thus causing a strain on the available resources. Global negative implications are increase in traffic, environmental pollution, overcrowding among public institutions and facilities and increase in the cost of life at the cities (University of Michigan

The Implications of Digital Convergence

566 words - 2 pages Anthony McKeeComputer ApplicationsUnit 6 EssayThe Implications of Digital Convergence Digital convergence is defined as the concept by which all forms of media become digital, in order to supply users with said media via a single method. While the idea sounds complex, it is, in fact, fairly simple and comprises the core of the concept known as "new media". In this essay I will attempt to break down what exactly is meant by the term

The Implications Of Self-expression

1215 words - 5 pages The Implications of Self-expression "The Awakening" by Kate Chopin begins with 28 year old Edna Pontellier summering with her husband and their twin sons on Grand Isle. It is there on the island where she begins to change from an abnegated wife and mother to an independent and self-involved woman. This begins her journey into awareness, which sadly leads to her death. In this Strum und Drang novella, Chopin tells of the solitude

Implications of the Peel Commission

2519 words - 11 pages of it in 1947? No matter how many questions are answered, there will always be many more to take its place. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict may seem to be just another what-if, and understandably, it’s hard to look at what happened without the knowledge of what happened, and maybe for that reason, the Peel Commission, is still silently being persistent, even after falling between the cracks of history. 16

Similar Essays

Implications Of Determinism And Free Will

2264 words - 9 pages implications of determinism in the ability to understand free will? Hard Determinists believe that individuals do not have free will, which then questions moral responsibility. As opposed to this are the compatibilists and soft determinists who believe in both the compatibility of determination and free will. As the ‘yin-yan’theory that free will and determination is interdependent but interconnected as they interrelate to one another. As William

"Hard Determinism" Two Ojections And One Responce!! How Does Hard Determinism Over Come The Free Will And Determinism Argument!!

1151 words - 5 pages Hard DeterminismIn this paper, I will argue that hard determinism is the only viable position with respect to the free will and determinism debate. I will consider W.T. Stace's objection concerning the semantic problem, which is explaining what the real sense of the word" free will" means, and the objection raised by the libertarians, which is how can a person want things and the wanting just comes up out of nowhere, but ultimately I will reject

Defending Hard Determinism Against The Strongest Objections Raised Against It

1679 words - 7 pages Defending Hard Determinism Against the Strongest Objections Raised Against It In this academic essay there will be a clear and defined description of both hard determinism and its eventual nemesis indeterminism. Based on these definitions there will be a personal attempt at denying hard determinism. This will be accomplished through the introduction of David Hume and his radical philosophy on causality and the relation

The Saving Of Energy Essay

1736 words - 7 pages ENERGY SAVING INDEX 1. Introduction 2. Improvements to the insulation of the structure of the houses 2.1 Draught-proofing 2.2 Wall insulation 2.3 Floor insulation 2.4 Windows 2.5 Roof insulation 3. Energy Audit 4. Examine methods of supplying 4.1 Air source heat pumps 4.2 Ground Source Heat Pumps 4.3 Solar panels (PV) 4.4 Solar water heating 4.5 Thermal stores 4.6 Wood-fuelled heating 5. Critical analysis of the performance 5.1