This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

School Dress Codes V. The First Amendment

1678 words - 7 pages

America was founded on popular sovereignty and individual freedoms. What do Americans do when the freedoms given to them from birth are restricted or taken away from them? They fight! Throughout time the government has attempted to take away our civil liberties because they viewed them to be for the greater good. One huge government failure was the attempted prohibition of alcohol. It is well known that alcohol can be very dangerous and it should be restricted. However, the government went too far when it tried to take it away completely and just like their rebellious founders the American population just found ways around the law. Similarily, Carroll High School and other schools throughout the nation are severely restricting the students’ rights to express themselves through their visual appearance. The administration, relying on the crutch of limiting distractions and violence, is taking the dress code over the line and is infringing on our right of expression regardless of the lack of results that they are witnessing.
Life is full of distractions and, for high school students, inappropriate clothing has the potential to grab much attention. However, does the matter of clothing warrant strict rules? I agree that, like alcohol, the students’ attire should have rules regarding whether or not the choices in clothing are suitable for a public school setting. I also agree that violators of school rules should receive punishment for their lack of compliance to the school policies. However, there is a fine line. Some schools, like Carroll High School, are taking dress codes too far. One rule in particular hinders the students’ ability to wear pants with holes in them. It makes sense that holes located in certain places might cause a distraction and therefore should be outlawed. On the other hand, it is unnecessary to reprimand kids for holes in their pants that are below the knee. If one young lady can wear shorts with a “four inch inseam” or a skirt “no more than three inches from the center of the kneecap” (Carroll High School Student Handbook 2010-2011 17) then why can’t the same girl wear a pair of jeans with a small hole in them below the kneecap? All eyes are turned towards the girl sporting the classy dress and no one even notices the small hole located in the shinbone area. The strict dress codes do teach the students to dress in a respectable manner that will be necessary in future job efforts, however high school students are not at work. A majority of students have jobs and comply to the job related dress code because they are being paid to do so however, they are not being paid at school and simply want to be able to express themselves while in the public eyes of their peers. The administration is exercising all of their power to prevent the wearing of what they believe to be as inappropriate clothes, when in reality it is not.
The prominent reason behind the various overdone school rules regarding dress is the loose power that...

Find Another Essay On School Dress Codes v. The First Amendment

Dress Codes and School Uniforms Essay

1692 words - 7 pages question to think about. The first amendment gives each person in this nation the right to free expression. You should be able to dress as you wish and not feel pressured to dress in a uniform manner, with the rest of you student body. Right? I agree with this latter statement. "Currently 20% of the nation's school districts use uniforms, most of them voluntarily" (Portner, 2001). The states included in this percentage are: California, Florida

Dress codes, and how the effect school life - English - Essay

416 words - 2 pages Schools all over the country enforce dress code. Dress codes are a set of rules that restrict what students can and cannot wear. Richmond Public Schools says that their dress code is lenient compared to other schools in Virginia. That being said, I still think that there are changes that could be made to improve the current one we have to follow. In my opinion, allowing students to show their shoulders, wear hats and headbands, and wear shorts

Against School Dress Codes and Uniforms

2387 words - 10 pages and cons associated with the implementing uniforms or not. Both sides to the argument bring valid points to the table and must be heard by educators, parents, students and government officials in order to come to the correct decision on whether school uniforms and dress codes should be implemented in Americas school systems. School uniforms and dress codes should not be placed the school system because it violates the first amendment and uses

School Dress Codes and Uniforms Are Beneficial

989 words - 4 pages (Schools 1). Even though the students may not like the uniforms they mostly agree that they will be safer. One of these students said, "Uniforms make the school safer but I don't like them"(Schools 1). The number of people against school uniforms is still high and they stand behind their beliefs. Most cases against school dress codes are headed by the first amendment. The first amendment states the right to free speech(Revisiting 1). Most

Dress Codes in School can Decrease Bullying

772 words - 3 pages , “Dress codes and school uniforms increase school safety by eliminating gang-related clothing and helping aid in the recognition of nonstudents on campus. Other potential benefits cited include better student behavior, more resistance to peer pressure and improved emphasis on academics. About one in four public elementary schools and one in eight public middle and high schools in the USA have policies dictating what a student wears to school

School Dress Codes and Their Oppressive Effects on Young Women

644 words - 3 pages length (Fisher, 2014). Regardless of the statement, residents of Evanston were still outraged with the school’s dress code rule change as they felt the policy held female students responsible for the behavior of their male counterparts. Juliet Bond, a mother of a seventh grade student attending Haven had this response for the school, I see dress codes as a messy attempt at controlling kids’ (mostly girls) bodies rather than educating them

First Amendment Rights of Public School Students

1310 words - 6 pages Administrators of schools can edit the content of school newspapers. This court case is just one of the many examples of how the schools are able to sway and control what their students say and what they see which makes a big impact on the first amendment rights of all the students who read and who have to write the newspaper. Another case that supports the research question is Bethel School District #43 v. Fraser 1987. This case specifically points

First Amendment Status of Cable TV v. Broadcast

764 words - 4 pages ), the court ruled that cable TV regulations should be inspected under the same First Amendment standards that were set forth in O’Brien case. If the system regulations are not content based, there is a chance of being upheld in court. Content-based is a difficult issue to sort. The case that represents this topic the best is City of Los Angeles v. Preferred Communications, Inc. This case showed that cable operators are entitled to first amendment rights; there can't be a single franchise over an entire city. Works Cited Zelezny, John D., Communications Law 6th edition School of Journalism and Communication, Broadcasting: The First Amendment,

The Wretched Violators of Dress Codes

887 words - 4 pages is! And he who walks and weeps before me is! And he / who walks and weeps before me is Ali, / whose face is open wide from chin to forelock. / And all the others here whom you see / were, when alive, the sowers of dissension / and scandals, and for this they are now split” (28.31-6). This type of punishment is called contrapasso, in which the punishment resembles or fits the sin. Students who disagree with the school dress code may create social

The first amendment

746 words - 3 pages The First Amendment, which guarantees Americans the freedom of speech, has been debated for years. An example of the First Amendment in debate is in the case of Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeier. In this case the people (Respondents) First Amendment rights were violated by the principal of their school. Their rights were violated because the principal deleted two articles from the school newspaper which dealt with student pregnancy and the

The First Amendment

750 words - 3 pages best interest of the public.The Supreme Court Case, Debs v. United States (1919), was a first amendment case. Eugene Debs, who was a well-known socialist, gave a speech to a crowd of people on Canton, Ohio. His speech was intended to discourage people from joining in the war effort. Debs was arrested and charged with the violation of the Espionage Act of 1917. Lower courts said he was guilty of violating the Espionage Act. The Supreme Court was

Similar Essays

School Dress Codes Essay

737 words - 3 pages Wouldn't it be great to be able to put limits on your child's school attire, and at the same time help prepare them for their life after school? Well, by enforcing school dress codes around the nation, this is exactly what we would be doing. Therefore, I am completely for the idea of school dress codes. Some people may argue that having a school dress code does not help improve their lives. On the contrary, having school dress codes would ensure

School Dress Codes Essay

1598 words - 6 pages when seeing what some students wear, but that does not affect the way they teach or the way the act towards them. Most of the school's reactions are not that big to force students to wear school uniforms or for them to have dress codes. Principals have thrown at their opinions also about what they think of this big controversy over having School uniforms or not. One principal demanded for the School to have a dress code for their school

Arguments For School Dress Codes Essay

1043 words - 4 pages Ensuing President Bill Clinton's State of the Union address in January of 1996, more and more public schools are implementing dress codes and uniform policies in their schools. As a result, there has been an increase in legal controversies dealing with the issue. The reason that dress codes are not conclusively enforced is due to the application of the First Amendment to juveniles in the public school setting. The First Amendment states that

School Uniforms And Dress Codes Essay

1514 words - 7 pages school uniform, then you have to buy cloths they can wear when they aren’t at school. If you have more than one student that goes to school then it ends up costing way more than it would cost, if the school just had a dress code. So the dress code is a financial burden on poor families. (Arguments about Uniforms 2005) School uniform technically violates the first amendment; the freedom to expression. And if students can’t express themselves then they