School Vouchers Are Not The Solution

1178 words - 5 pages

One of the primary reasons for parents choosing to send their child to a private school is due to the many pre-conceived notions that private schools carry regarding their overall reputations. There are three main misconceptions that will be addressed here. These misconceptions are: the misconception of parental choice in selecting a school; more qualified teachers with the most current teaching knowledge; and the myth that private schools are more successful than public schools.
Many proponents of a nationwide standardized voucher program argue that such a system will provide parents and students with the opportunity to choose the school in which the child will attend. In fact, the opposite is true. Unlike public schools that are required by law to accept every child, private schools can choose who their students will be. Private schools do not need to accept the fifth grader who is autistic or the eighth grader reading at a third grade level. These factors simplify education and therefore further resources can be placed on the “norm” as opposed to students with disabilities. Indeed, in the voucher system, there is very little parental choice instead the choice is dependent on the private institution (Myth vs. Fact, 2002).
The misconception of parental choice can also correlate to the next misconception, which is that private schools are more successful than public schools. This idea is misleading as well. To date, there is no statistical data that shows private schools are achieving at a greater level than students in public schools. The reason for this can be several fold. First, we have the issue of accountability; second, we have the issue of the liberty of private schools to pick and choose their students; and third, private schools are not always required to take the same assessments as public school children to accurately compare the data of who is achieving at a higher level.
The final misconception of private schools is the qualification of the staff. In private schools, institutions not funded by the government, teachers are not required to have the same qualifications as their counterparts in the public system (The Voucher Threat, Fall 1998). Public school teachers, especially in Illinois, are expected to fulfill a certain amount of professional growth requirements for recertification. These requirements, such as CPDU’s, continued education, and fulfillment of a mentor program demand extra hours from public school teachers; however, holds the public school teacher to be accountable for his or her growth as an educator. These standards are not shared by private schools. How can teachers who are not required to continue their education be expected and trained to introduce their students to the most cutting edge teaching strategies that will help ensure optimal success for their students.
As mentioned above, by giving public dollars to private and religious schools the issue of accountability arises. Should...

Find Another Essay On School Vouchers are NOT the Solution

America’s Failing Public Schools: Charter Schools Are Not the Solution

1955 words - 8 pages America’s Failing Public Schools: Charter Schools Are Not the Solution   It was with wild fanfare that the state’s Republican legislature and Republican Governor enacted their reforms for the state’s public school system. Among the panaceas was charter schools, a ‘90s education fad that gives individual parents the right to send their children to state-approved public charter schools at public expense. Politicians reasoned that less

Not a Magic Solution to School Problems

1674 words - 7 pages Not a Magic Solution to School Problems School uniform policies are often referred to as a Band-Aid solution. They help hide more serious problems at the school by giving the school a nice look. Surveys of students and teachers show that in general people believe a well-dressed person is more intelligent and better behaved. Politicians like the look of school uniforms; many of them support this cause until the schools ask for more money

The Effectiveness of Private School Vouchers

1358 words - 5 pages parents feel that their education goals are not being met through the public school system. But how beneficial are these vouchers to everyone, including taxpayers? It seems that more research needs to be done to see what the real cost is, if it truly allows children from low income families to attend without a financial burden, and to see if the students transferring from public schools to private schools are becoming more successful in achieving

The Problem of Vouchers and School Choice

1138 words - 5 pages government. But we could not allow a discrepancy in funding or community commitment to make one school a palace and another a snakepit. If we reform educational funding so that schools receive the resources they need to attract students based on their special features, rather than a desire to escape something, controlled school choice could work. I believe in the concept of magnet schools and perhaps even of charter schools. Convince me that

South African Artists: Paul Stopforth. An essay I wrote for my final year at school - unfortunately pictures are not included

1428 words - 6 pages reality of photographic prints, and enlarged beyond natural human proportions, the disembodied heads acquire a disturbing, threatening presence. Even the transparency of the drawings, which is not unlike that of a projected film, serves here to deny the perceived normality of cinematic imagery. This is not light flickering on a beaded screen: these images are permanent, inescapable and charged with dark associations. The triptych is usually mounted

LAws are the solution

982 words - 4 pages should not be as harsh or punished as violent crime as they are not the same. However, under the mandatory minimum sentencing law, they are considered equal and should be punished equally. A study on 2010 showed that 344 people in California are serving a life sentence for shoplifting small amounts of merchandise and more than 650 people are also serving life sentences for possessing small quantities of drugs, (Chemerinsky, 2010). Such punishments

The Death Penalty is Not the Solution

2943 words - 12 pages support methods that will bring about the highest balance of good over evil. Capital punishment is believed to be such a practice. It is seen as beneficial to society because it could deter violent crime. While it is challenging to produce direct evidence to back up this assertion, by definition, those deterred by the death penalty do not commit murders or other violent crimes, common sense indicates that if people are aware they will face death if

Punishment is not always the Solution

694 words - 3 pages are lessons in it that can help create a better place to live. We should not apply a one size fit all type of solution to any situation. Nowadays, everything seems to disappear; there is no respect for value. People have the tendency to do what they want; they don’t have any morale value and self-esteem. Nobody is perfect; everyone has the tendency to explore or do something that is probably going in the opposite direction of what is expected

Water Scarcity: Privatization is Not the Solution

1053 words - 4 pages every corner of the planet as the decrease in the water supplies and the rapid increment in the population will not improve in the future, since these both elements are seemingly going to continue this trend. Nonetheless, not only these factors are reinforcing this catastrophe, it is also the latent worldwide social inequality that is inducing a disproportion of the provision of water around the globe. Fresh water sources subsist in most

Arresting Batterers is Not The Solution

1210 words - 5 pages Arresting Batterers is Not The Solution Does arresting batterers do more harm than good? For this debate my side is the con and I will give ideas and support to their views. Before I get started I just want to say that I don’t condone husbands beating their wives at all, and many others feel the same way. Battering is a learn behavior you are accountable for your own actions and must face the serve consequences ahead

Why Euthanasia is not the Solution

1338 words - 6 pages disease or illness so it doesn’t make sense to kill a patient As a conclusion, there are hundreds or even thousands of cases where patients that are terminally ill have recovered from their illness and have lived for a decades after that and we cannot ignore the fact that science is evolving day after day so there is always a hope to discover a solution to the killing diseases. In addition to that we should not forget that the main mission of any

Similar Essays

School Vouchers Are The Solution Essay

1673 words - 7 pages present system is unable to grant the education that it has always promised and much of the money utilized in bringing about improvement is wasted. This is where, I feel, the market-system, with its abundant, competitive suppliers of education can bring about a change, where modern tuition vouchers will take care of any financial assistance crucial to keeping the system going. School vouchers are a form of scholarship, which transmits the flow

Vouchers Are Not The Solution For Improving Public Schools

1762 words - 7 pages Vouchers Are Not the Solution for Improving Public Schools Missing Works Cited “Vouchers lead us away from the basic American tradition of a free, quality public education for every student and undermine the kind of comprehensive, systemic school reform that is working […]” (Tirozzi, 1997). This quote taken from Gerald Tirozzi, the assistant U.S. secretary of education for elementary and secondary education, sums up the issue of vouchers

Web Filters Are Not The Solution

625 words - 3 pages Web Filters are Not the Solution The scene is perfectly clear in my mind. Twelve years old and just home from an overnight stay with a friend, I walked in the door with a Sex Pistols patch on my backpack, a clip-on earring in my ear, and a cherry Kool-Aid dye job. The initial looks of shock and horror on the faces of my parents were priceless - that is until they opened their mouths. I was grounded for a month

Pesticides Are Not A Solution Essay

1821 words - 7 pages Life is easy for the modern persons. The threat of starvation is not imminent. The days of hunting and gathering are over for the vast majority of citizens thriving in developed nations. If one is hungry they need only go to one of the many supermarkets to purchase food. The day to day has been simplified in so many ways that it is not hard to understand why the base step to that simplicity would be overlooked. Why question a good thing