This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

School Vouchers: Allowing Parents To Choose What School Their Child Attends

1881 words - 8 pages

Americans pride themselves on their freedom. We can choose whatever we want. No government agency dictates what foods we eat, or what clothes we wear; these choices are left to be made by the individual. Despite this relative freedom in other areas, many Americans feel constricted in their choices of where their children go to school. Government agencies draw arbitrary lines on maps that determine school districts. Many parents are forced to send their children to schools which they might not have chosen, if they had the opportunity to. In his bid for presidency, John McCain has promised to give parents the chance to freely decide what schools educate their children. He has suggested that the way to raise the standard of education in America is to turn the school system into a market economy; the parents of students decide the schools their children attend, and which schools receive funding from the government. Though the Arizona senator’s campaign website is surprisingly lacking in details, throughout his political career, McCain has shown strong support for school vouchers as an appropriate system of choice for parents. He argues that opening the education market will increase the quality of American education.
There is little argument over whether or not the dismal American school system needs improvement; most scholars agree that the current system is lacking. Especially in America, there is a divide in education. Currently, there is a wide discrepancy between schools located in poor neighborhoods, and those schools located in wealthier areas (Lyne 2001). Many scholars Though, McCain touts vouchers as the answer to America’s education woes, vouchers are not without critics. Some opponents argue that the voucher programs are not constitutional, because they allow students to put money into schools with religious affiliations attached to them, and that voucher programs do not greatly raise the test scores of the students who utilize the vouchers. Other detractors feel that vouchers do not provide any sustainable increase in the quality of education provided. Though the voucher system is not without its flaws it is largely positive because the introduction of an open market for schools would increase school funding, encourage higher quality of teachers, and more efficient teaching methods, and the introduction of vouchers would allow parents to have greater say in their children’s education.
History of School Vouchers
In order to truly understand the debate about vouchers, one must consider the history of school vouchers in America. Though the efficacy of school vouchers has come to light in recent years, with the implementation of limited voucher programs in several states, the debate over school vouchers is not a new one. The history of vouchers in America reaches all the way back post-Civil War America. The southern United States implemented voucher programs that were redeemable only at segregated schools. White...

Find Another Essay On School Vouchers: Allowing Parents to Choose What School Their Child Attends

Why Parents Should Choose Home School

698 words - 3 pages ones who want us to be successful the most. Children will consider their parents not only their love but also the best teachers. Children that are taught at home have a stronger relationship with his or her father or mother. A student at a public school spends many hours in activities such as lunch, recess, and changing classes. Time is being wasted each day that a child could be learning something else. At home, you can change around the schedule

Public School Vouchers Essay

2634 words - 11 pages expected by June 2002. School vouchers are different from other educational choice programs. A voucher is a government check presented to the parents and school for the purposes of choosing a new school for the student. This is different from other programs such as tax credits in Arizona. Arizona allows families to receive a tax credit for tuition costs of another school. Charter schools are also different from school vouchers. Charter schools

Private School Vouchers

2552 words - 10 pages of public funds, the role of competition in improving public education, and the right of parents to choose a school for their children. Although these issues are of interest, they are not the fundamental questions which must be raised about the future of public schools in a democracy.Two Core Issues In their rush to the marketplace, the proponents of private school choice supported by public funds have chosen to ignore two core issues. First, the

My Son Attends a Special Needs School

723 words - 3 pages . Austin is restricted in many ways because of his mobility and growing height. His school goes year round with only a couple of weeks for winter, spring and summer breaks. No homework is ever given due to the nature of their ways of learning. Each year they have the normal meetings as well as an individualized educational planning committee meeting (IEPC) to help set goals for each child. I could not imagine Austin attending any other school, because he would not be able to learn the way his brain and body requires.

School Vouchers: A Harmful Choice

3089 words - 12 pages force Christian, Jewish, Muslim, atheist, and other citizens to pay for the religious instruction of school children at schools with acutely religious goals (School Vouchers 1). While the Supreme Court has not yet heard a voucher case, the High Court has denied past education programs allowing parents of religious school students to recover part of their tuition expenses from the state. The Court has also declared programs unconstitutional where

School Vouchers - A Great Relief!

875 words - 4 pages accountable for achieving those high academic standards." (p.2). The school voucher plan actually helps a parent in satisfying himself in a way that he/she has put their child in a school of their choice. The choice gives them a big satisfaction. By giving the choice of schools to the parents while giving school vouchers, parents are given the choice of putting their children in a school that has a socially a very good background as well as an academically

School Vouchers are the Solution

1673 words - 7 pages of funding that is devoted to education and directs it to consumers rather than to school districts. This gives families the freedom to choose any school and thus send their children to institutions they feel are best suited to their children’s needs. There are government funded vouchers, as well as that made available by private institutions. I feel that one good way would be to do it through gigantic corporations, who have the capital and may

Second Year High School Students Should Be Allowed to Choose Their Teachers

1961 words - 8 pages Have you ever been tired of getting the same kind of teacher? The one who doesn’t understand you? The one who you don’t understand? Teachers are some of the most important people in our lives, so why not have the right to choose them? Students who are in their second year of high school should be able to choose their teachers. They are capable of doing so, but why aren’t they allowed? Students should have this choice because of many reasons

Trend Of Public School Vouchers Over Time

2824 words - 12 pages Trend of Public School Vouchers: Please visit to view full version with graphs and special formatting.Since the inception of universal public education, public debate has remained constant. Battles between local, state, and even national control of schools have never ended. Politicians, parents, and teachers continuously tinker with public education, seeking an ultimate utopian system. Today, educational debate is harsher than

The Effectiveness of Private School Vouchers

1358 words - 5 pages Today, a solid education is what any parent should desire for their child. Without that education there is really no successful future ahead of them. Many parents and teachers have been very supportive of the Common Core Standards, but many are against it and feel that it puts an unnecessary strain on students, parents, and teachers. Several states now offer vouchers that give students the opportunity to attend private schools if the student or

Parents that go back to school create a positive learning environment for their children

1396 words - 6 pages that encourages learning I am a perfect example of how a parent going back to school creates a healthy and nourishing learning environment for their children. My first day back in college, I have my books and my laptop; get the light right and sit at the table and I start doing my homework and discussions. My ten year old comes up to me and asks me “Daddy, what are you doing”, I look at her with a smile and tell her “honey, I am doing my homework

Similar Essays

School Vouchers Essay

720 words - 3 pages don’t qualify may ask themselves am I put into a disadvantage because my friends are attending a school, which is known to better than mine? Did my friends choose to attend this school or were there parents up to it? These questions can cause a dilemma to the students and their families. There are many advantages to school vouchers, however there are also disadvantages. Knowing both sides can lead you to your view of the school voucher.      One

School Vouchers: Parents Need A Choice

4626 words - 19 pages vouchers will improve education overall by allowing children to attend schools that focus on their needs socially, mentally and physically. Yet, those parents without school voucher plans will continue to be forced to send their children to schools that treat students the same. In public schools, parents and students have to deal with ineffective teachers and administrators as well as a curriculum which may not be truly suitable for every publically

School Vouchers Essay

1461 words - 6 pages increased by an urge to become more private once the market opens to all students, not just those who can afford to attend private schools. In the long run this could defeat the voucher system. On the flip side, the state of affairs would be completely different if the government would choose not to adopt a system of school vouchers. First of all, if vouchers were not instituted the money spent on them would stay in the schools (Messerli). Unlike the

School Vouchers Essay

734 words - 3 pages also isolates a small percentage of 'desirable' students from the rest of society. Voucher programs will only benefit a minute amount of students while hurting the entire school system and the general public.Tax-funded vouchers are highly disputed among politicians and anyone with school-aged children. The main idea of the voucher system is that parents or guardians choose the school that they want their children to attend, with hopes that good