This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Science Or Pseudoscience Essay

1522 words - 6 pages

Often, therapies that are pseudoscience will appear to be scientifically based when in fact they are not. In their article, “Science and Pseudoscience in Communication Disorder: Criteria and Applications,” Fin, Bothe and Bramlett (2005) assert there are 10 criteria that can assist in determining if a therapy is scientifically based or if it is pseudoscience (p. 172).
Their first criterion deals with the testability of the therapy or treatment. Valid scientific treatments have the ability to be thoroughly examined. If a therapy or treatment cannot be tested, it is not credible. Many pseudoscience therapies claim to have proven and verifiable results. However, the claims are not founded on experiment based evidence (Fin, Bothe and Bramlett, 2005, p. 173). In their second criterion, Fin, Bothe and Bramlett (2005) address the adaptability of a treatment method when conflicting evidence is presented (p. 173) . This criteria, much like the first criteria, deals with the evaluation of the therapy. In true scientific treatment, the goal is to provide valid therapies. Thus, any scientific evidence that differs from the original research is thoughtfully analyzed and, changes or corrections are made when necessary (Fin, Bothe and Bramlett, 2005, p. 173). The third criterion deals with verifiable evidence. It is important for treatments to be assessed in a way that allows for the possibility of failure and, when contradictory evidence is discovered, it cannot be ignored. Pseudoscientific treatments ignore contradictory evidence and base their claims solely on confirming evidence. (Fin, Bothe and Bramlett, 2005, p. 173). Criterion four offers insight on narrative based evidence. The positive claims associated with pseudoscience are regularly based on personal stories or testimonies. While case studies can be valuable for scientific research, they should not be the only proof provided for treatment (Fin, Bothe and Bramlett, 2005, p. 173-174). Fin, Bothe and Bramlett (2005) state in their fifth claim that the evidence provided should support the claims of the treatment. For example, if a treatment claims to cure or eliminate a disorder, there should be immense amounts of evidence to support that research. Often, pseudoscience treatments claim incredible results and have little evidence supporting them (p.175). A treatment’s validity is further recognized when it has been published in a peer-reviewed journal. Before an article can be published in a peer-reviewed journal, it must be rigorously analyzed by a series of professionals (Fin, Bothe and Bramlett, 2005, p. 175). In their sixth criterion, Fin, Bothe and Bramlett (2005) stress the importance of inspection and examination of a treatments by scientists other than the researcher. Pseudoscientific treatments are rarely found in peer-review journals, thus their treatment claims are rarely studied in depth (Fin, Bothe and Bramlett, 2005, p. 175- 176).
Criterion seven addresses the...

Find Another Essay On Science or Pseudoscience

My Journal Entry: Scientific Thinking Essay

758 words - 4 pages the truth. After all science develops, hypotheses and theories that can be tested and falsifiable. Gary R Kirby and Jeffery R Goodpaster who wrote Thinking, briefly discuss astrology in Chapter 10 called “Scientific Thinking”. Kirby and Goodpaster suggest that astrology is a pseudoscience type of science. Pseudoscience a belief or claim such as astrology that is not valid and cannot adhere to a scientific method. Presented as being scientific

Detective or Fictional? Essay

812 words - 4 pages The Scientific American™ defines pseudoscience as “a practice or belief that is known as scientific, but otherwise does not follow an acceptable scientific method, lacks subsidiary evidence or credibility, cannot be consistently tested, or lacks scientific standing.” When studying science, a key to finding “good” science is to make sure it is logical, based on facts and data, not opinions. Pseudoscience tends to appear more in the movie

Grayscale

867 words - 3 pages Jade NataliProfessor CiceroWriting 1012 October 2013Critique of Science IndicatorsScience Indicators 2000: Belief in the Paranormal or Pseudoscience is an article that appears in Joseph Calabrese's book, but originally was published by the Science Board. Also, this article was primarily written by Mellisa Pollak, but the Science Board takes credit for this piece because many members of the Science board have likewise contributed to this article

What is the Classification of Psychology?

2428 words - 10 pages should be taught to anyone studying psychology. The next source discusses and reviews more on pseudoscience thinking compared to psychology beliefs. Scott O. Lilienfeld, Rachel Ammirati, and Michal David discuss and evaluate problems that occur because of pseudoscience practices that appear to be science in nature but are not. The authors provide steps on how to identify if something is pseudoscience or psychology, such as producing

Demarcation

2077 words - 9 pages event in confirm or falsify the theory. This is due in part to the protective circular logic Popper argued for. The last perspective on pseudoscience comes from Helen Longino. She believes much like the previously mentioned thinkers that a good theory should be accurate, precise, simple, and broad in scope and problem solving ability. She adds an important factor to these as well, that is that science should be free from contextual values. These

Creationism is not Science

683 words - 3 pages Science by definition is the gathering of knowledge about the natural world through the use of observation, critical thinking, and experimentation. Pseudoscience is basically a belief or theory that acts as science but is not supported by the scientific method. It is used as a way to support non-evidence based beliefs which do not stand alone as truth. There are many examples of pseudoscience in our world today, but I intend to focus on the

The Debate Over Historical Information and Scientific Information

1373 words - 5 pages the male adult I may not have noticed if he was wearing a wedding ring or not or I may not have noticed what kind of clothes the male and female were wearing. This human error in not being able to observe every aspect of a situation makes scientific information less reliable. There is a claim that can be made about the scientific information as well as historical information. This claim is related to mathematics. In both natural science and

Dogmatism vs Criticality

1694 words - 7 pages . Popper talks about falsifiability being the criterion of demarcation between science and pseudoscience, but Lakatos argues that even if an idea is falsified, the theory may persist for a while. He brings up seventeenth century literature on witchcraft that contains reports of careful observations and sworn evidence, even from experiments. Scientists dogmatically assert that experimentation and observation is the best way to attain true knowledge, but

Sci Reasoning

1023 words - 5 pages relate. Conflict can result between science and faith when people try to combine them. Someone may be looking to science for spiritual guidance, or to religion to help him or her understand scientific questions. Different types of religious faith also play a role in the conflict. Christians who feel insecure with their faith try to understand their uncertainty through scientific evidence. Whereas atheists are comfortable with saying that the world

Skepticism, Facts and Evidence. Your Keys to Not Getting Scammed

860 words - 4 pages 1. Video “Here Be Dragons” by Brian Dunning (4/15/14) is a fresh and critical overlook on the huge variety of so called “dragons” which exist in abundance even in our civilized society. This video promotes critical thinking and demonstrates the “red flags” that one has to look out for in order to detect pseudosciences. A pseudoscience is an idea that claims to be real but is not backed by any real science or evidence. For instance, hair analysis

The Search for Enlightenment

1869 words - 7 pages philosophers and scientists but rather that they speak to a deaf audience or in a language that the audience can't understand. It has become a trend in our society to dismiss science as too complicated to understand and hence to forfeit it to pseudoscience. It is here that a great irony lies for today science is by far more advanced than the archaic science of the "Enlightenment." Science, during the 20th century has put men on the moon, uncovered the

Similar Essays

Science Or Pseudoscience Essay

713 words - 3 pages Often, therapies that are pseudoscience will appear to be scientifically based when in fact they are not. In their article, “Science and Pseudoscience in Communication Disorder: Criteria and Applications,” Fin, Bothe and Bramlett (2005) assert there are 10 criteria that can assist in determining if a therapy is scientifically based or if it is pseudoscience (p. 172). Their first criterion deals with the testability of the therapy or treatment

Distinguishing Science And Pseudoscience Essay

2214 words - 9 pages part of demarcating science from non-science is to once demarcated, to illustrate it for what it is, just because it is not science it does not mean it has no value, or is nonsense as Ayer claims. A.J. Ayer applied logical positivism to empirical philosophy in the twentieth century, he was analytic and rejected a priori knowledge. Ayer argues for the demarcation of pseudoscience, he primarily argues to refute transcendental knowledge as a

The New Science Of Pseudoscience Essay

2245 words - 9 pages economic standpoint. Southern society began to idealize science as an indisputable vehicle of objective truth. The rapid advancement of scientific knowledge lent scientists a “halo,” as they could claim neutrality and objectiveness. A scientist’s word was law and deemed worthy of imitation. Because of the belief that scientists were unbiased and impartial when conducting research, scientists in the South attempted to legitimize pro-slavery

Big Five Personality Reflection Essay

550 words - 3 pages : · Systematic observation & data collection · Publically verifiable knowledge · Empirically testable problems However, according to Lawson (2007), there are six common characteristics of pseudoscience: · Use of imprecise, scientific-sounding language · No evidence of continued research or new knowledge gained over time · Reliance on anecdotes as evidence · Reliance on authority endorsements, especially “false authorities” (i.e., people