Science Vs. Nature: A Personal Response To Walt Whitman's "The Learn'd Astronomer"

639 words - 3 pages

I do not believe that science and nature are two separate entities, but that they intertwine to create the world as a whole. In the poem, "The Learn'd Astronomer" by Walt Whitman, the speaker sharply divides the two, leading the reader to think that one is possibly more beautiful than the other. He even backs away from a scientific lecture about the universe only to gaze up at the stars. To me, the facts and figures that comprise the world are just as important as the world itself.Whitman seems to imply that over-analyzing nature somehow takes away from seeing it in its true splendor, and that the lecturer himself is blind to the simplicity of the universe around him. If this is the poet's intention, then I would have to disagree. The mathematical figures that comprise the galaxies are equally as beautiful as the galaxies themselves. When he tells his readers, "When I, sitting, heard the astronomer, where he lectured with much applause in the lecture-room, How soon, unaccountable, I became tired and sick," Whitman seems to say that too much knowledge about these things can be an annoyance. In contrast, I see mankind's curiosity as part of the universe, and I cannot appreciate the whole without appreciating the sum of its parts.The second item that this poem makes me wonder about is Whitman's possible objections toward scientific discovery. The poem, written in the nineteenth century, illustrates some of the scientific development and breakthroughs going on in that era. Whitman states that, "I was shown the charts and the diagrams, to add, divide, and measure them," and later acknowledges the lecturer's ideas as genuine and new when it is met with, "much applause in the lecture-room." Of course, it is a scientist's job to pick apart things that are not entirely understood. Yet it almost seems as though Whitman...

Find Another Essay On Science vs. Nature: A Personal Response to Walt Whitman's "The Learn'd Astronomer"

The Spider and Soul in Walt Whitman's A Noiseless Patient Spider

1340 words - 5 pages The Spider and Soul in Walt Whitman's A Noiseless Patient Spider Works Cited Not Included In “A Noiseless Patient Spider”, Walt Whitman compares the images of a spider creating a web to catch its prey to his own soul. In the first stanza, he describes the spider creating its web. In the second stanza, he begins to describe his own soul searching for something it needs. Throughout the poem, Whitman is relating the spider to the human

A review of Walt Whitman's "Live Oak, with Moss"

534 words - 2 pages Walt Whitman's Live Oak, With Moss , is an intricate portrayal of love, both physical and mental. Throughout the poem, Whitman incorporates an array of metaphors symbolic of love and the many characteristics associated with love. Dissimilar to mainstream poetry, Whitman introduces a friend-lover relationship between two men, describing the pain and happiness associated with their love.Throughout Live Oak, With Moss, Whitman illustrates the great

Defining the Soul in Walt Whitman's Song of Myself

780 words - 3 pages Every sentence in Walt Whitman's "Song of Myself" tends to either repeat or contradict. He even says of himself, "I contradict myself" (Lauter, p. 2793). This can make Whitman's poetry a little confusing to some. In his many stanzas, definition of the soul is ambiguous and somewhat contradictory. Whitman says, "Clear and sweet is my soul....and clear and sweet is all that is not my soul" (Lauter, p. 2745). What I believe Whitman

The Meaning of Life in Walt Whitman's Song of Myself

1009 words - 4 pages The Meaning of Life in Walt Whitman's Song of Myself Our culture seems to be fascinated by the unknown and specifically that which pertains to things of an eternal nature such as Heaven, angels, God and the meaning of forever. These things cause us to think about what we can't see and even allow us to engage ourselves in questioning the meaning behind our existence and what our purpose is here on earth. Some of these may be humorous and

Metaphors Of Freedom In Walt Whitman’s “When I Heard The Learn’d Astronomer”

953 words - 4 pages Metaphors of Freedom in Walt Whitman's "When I Heard the Learn'd Astronomer" Walt Whitman, more than most poets, stressed his pure thought in his poems. That is, he stressed feelings towards issues that he attended to every day. This way of expression tends to draw the reader closer to the poem, and allows them to feel the conflict of thought which the author tries to convey. Generally, Whitman expresses an idea that separates conventional

Personal Response to The Bluest Eye

1569 words - 6 pages Personal Response to The Bluest Eye Dear God:       Do you know what she came for? Blue eyes. New, blue eyes, She said. Like she was buying shoes. "I'd like a pair of new blue eyes." Toni Morrison, The Bluest Eye Pecola thought that if she had blue eyes she would become beautiful and her parents would stop fighting. She was just one of the many who believed that having blue eyes would make her and everything around her

Science and Religion: A Christian's Response to Biology

2726 words - 11 pages Science and Religion: A Christian's Response to Biology Introduction In the beginning, God created...the earth and the heavens, or an evolving mass of matter, later to become the heavens and the earth? The conflict between science and religion is a hot topic in many intellectual circles today. One of the more controversial topics is creation versus evolution. How did the world get to where it is right now? How was creation initiated? Is

Death and Regeneration in Walt Whitman's Poem, When Lilacs Last In The Dooryard Bloom'd

562 words - 2 pages Death and Regeneration in Walt Whitman's Poem, When Lilacs Last In The Dooryard Bloom'd Whitman in 1865 wrote an elegy for President Lincoln entitled "When Lilacs Last in the Dooryard Bloom'd." The "Lilacs" elegy is an outpouring of the deep sense of loss that Whitman felt after the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln. The President's death was a great shock to the poet; it overwhelmed him in a very personal way. Whitman

"Acts of Violence" A Personal Response to Literature

514 words - 2 pages The short story, "Acts of Violence" by Ursula Hegi is essentially about an old woman who takes self-defense classes due to a rekindled epiphany of erstwhile experiences. The son of the mother and also the author narrates in first person, which aids the reader in comprehending his personal thoughts and emotions towards his mother's decision. Not only does the author worry about his mother but so does his wife as well. Throughout the story they

T.S Eliot- An personal response to the poetry of Eliot

1378 words - 6 pages despair. In 'Preludes', Eliot uses the image of woman to portray the 'cheapness' and sordidness of urban life,' You clasped the papers from your hairOr clasped the yellow soles of feet...'In 'Aunt Helen' Eliot uses the image of woman to create a sense of elitism ,which he so greatly despises, and a certain sense of foolishness,Eliot has left upon English poetry a mark more unmistakable than that of any other poet. His poems have challenged me to further explore the frontiers of my own emotions and have allowed me to examine my darker nature. I am thankful to have had the opportunity to study such a profound poet.

A Personal Anaylisis of the Original Book, Voodoo Science: The Road from Foolishness to Fraud by Robert L. Park

1463 words - 6 pages " discoveries that tend to be unreal. Dr. Fludd and his water mill are an example of Voodoo Science. He believes that the water mill would have enough energy to drive a pump and grind flour when it is lifted and turned. Then the water would be pumped back to turn the wheel again. The first law of thermodynamics was found, you couldn't get more energy than you start out with. You would need the same amount of energy to pump and push the water mill and to

Similar Essays

Nature And Death In Walt Whitman's Song Of Myself

677 words - 3 pages There are many "popular" topics used frequently by authors. Love, religion, and war are some favorites. Two other such topics we typically read about are nature and death. The two can be discussed separately or they can be related to each other. Walt Whitman, a lover of nature, tackled these subjects in "Song of Myself" from Leaves of Grass. Another author who does the same is William Cullen Bryant. Though two very different writers

Walt Whitman's View Of The Civil War

858 words - 3 pages Like most of the unprepared, naïve Americans who believed the Civil War would consist of a few short battles and little casualties, who then after the war reached it's second year truly saw the Civil War for what it really was- the bloodiest in America's history; Walt Whitman's 'Drum Taps' represents this ideal from start to finish. From the war's first battle in 1861 when Whitman saw the endeavor as a chance for the North to put to rest

On Walt Whitman's Crossing The Brooklyn Ferry

788 words - 3 pages person can never live a fulfilling life. Distinguishingoneself from the mobs of society can be next to impossible whenevery other human is competing for the same recognition withtheir own similar accomplishments. The suggestion that Whitmanoffers as a means of becoming distinguished, or obtaining anidentity, is to live a life of self-satisfaction. Thepersuasive devices in 'Crossing Brooklyn Ferry' successfullycommunicate Whitman's own theory of

His Song To Us (A Critique Of Walt Whitman's Song Of Myself, Quotes Included)

741 words - 3 pages displays these elements is Song of Myself. Just a single section of this poem will contain all the elements listed. The dominant theme of this poem is Whitman's dedication to nature and animals. Every stanza in this poem is talking about either his love for animals or his involvement with nature.One aspect of Whitman's character that any reader can admire is the way he uses free verse and doesn't adapt rhyme scheme and meter, which was the most popular