Scottish Independence Essay

3028 words - 12 pages

Scottish Independence and theReferendumA general overview of the upcoming referendum on Scottish Independence.IntroductionDescribed as Scotland's "biggest choice since 1707" (McLean et al, 2013, p. ix), the upcoming referendum on Scottish independence will provide a pivotal event for the current and future populations of Scotland as voters get the opportunity to decide whether or not they are to remain a part of Great Britain or become an independent nation. As McLean et al (2013) have referenced, 1707 was a year of major importance in Scottish history because it saw the passage of the Union with England Act by the Parliament of Scotland, thus legitimising the reciprocal Union with Scotland Act which was passed by its English counterpart the previous year (Davis, 1998). The Acts of Union have now stood for more than three centuries and, although there have been proposals to challenge it in recent years, this is the first time that the Scottish public have been given the opportunity to vote on the issue in a formal referendum. This essay will examine the issue of Scottish independence by providing an insight into the historical and political events that have led to the 2013 proposal to hold a referendum on the issue. It will also look in depth at the campaigns for and against Scottish independence in order to assess the approaches that each one has taken in order to sway voters towards their individual cause. This will ultimately facilitate the drawing of the conclusion that Scottish independence has the propensity to fundamentally alter the political landscape of the entire international community rather than being limited to a British and European context. However, although both campaigns relating to the referendum are fundamentally flawed, the choice made by the Scottish people will decide the nation's fate for the foreseeable future.Historical BackgroundAlthough this referendum is the first in/out vote to be held in relation to Scottish independence in the 21st century, votes have previously been held over the issue of devolution. In both 1979 and 1997, Scottish devolution referendums were held with varying outcomes (Deacon, 2012). In the 1979 case, the yes vote did gain a majority but failed to attract 40% of the total electorate and therefore failed to achieve change (Dardanelli, 2006). However, in the 1997 referendum, there was clear majority support for both devolution of the Scottish Parliament, which was achieved in the Scotland Act 1998, and Parliament establishing the base rate of income tax (Dardanelli, 2006). In both instances then, there was significant support for the devolution of Scotland and important powers. As such, sovereignty has been an issue for some time, which is further reinforced by a study of cultural identity by Bechhofer and McCrone (2007). The study suggests that the Scottish people have come to feel more comfortable with the Scottish identity, with the British collective identity being weakened as a result,...

Find Another Essay On scottish independence

How the U.K. was formed Essay

1413 words - 6 pages While many people in England believe that the Scottish are beneficial to their union. The Scottish people believe that their way of life and culture is at risk of becoming an English one, and for the reason, many Scots want independence. This is a good thing because it will be the first time in a very long time that the Scottish people will have a voice of their own, and choose their own fate as a nation. First off, we will start with how and

To What Extent is the Proposed Scottish Split from British Rule Beneficial for Either Country?

3522 words - 15 pages Ireland’s example and propose independence. Whether or not this was a wise move by the Scottish National Party leader, Alex Salmond, is up for debate. The true extent of pros and cons, although they will vary depending on public viewpoints, will be uncovered on the 18th September 2014 at the final vote count. The benefits of the proposed split, on Scotland’s side, are outweighed by the troubles that will be brought by attempting to enter the EU, the

A Historic Referendum

868 words - 4 pages studies and statistics to prove their points, but the year chosen for the referendum has historical importance as well. It has been decided that the vote will take place on September 18th 2014; 2014 is the 700th anniversary of the Battle of Bannockburn. This is one of the battles in the Wars of Scottish Independence in the 1300’s. In the battle the Scots were outnumbered nearly three to one and were lead by Robert the Bruce, King of Scots. This was

Scottish Separatist Movement - Yes Scotland vs. Better Together

2291 words - 10 pages collapse (which they’re known for all too well), their banks would need a large-scale bailout from the UK, which may not happen should they choose independence. Now that we understand the reasons for and against Scottish secession, we can look closely at the factors which may have had an effect on the independence movement. Scotland now is predominantly left-wing, which is a contrast to the generally right-wing nature of England. Scotland

William Wallace

1319 words - 5 pages William Wallace, popularized in the 1995 movie "Braveheart", was a Scottish patriot and national hero. He was a fierce advocate for Scottish independence from the English, who had taken control shortly after the death of the 8-year old "Queen" Margaret, called the "Maid of Norway". Their rule was widely resented among the common people and, after many of the Scottish nobles defected to England, Wallace emerged as the leader of the various rebel

Scotland’s Superman; William Wallace

2360 words - 9 pages (Ironically the same charge given to his deceased bride). Later decapitated and limbs removed; each of the parts were placed in symbolic areas of England as a warning. This did not discourage the Scottish from fighting harder later, the Scottish won their independence. Many of Wallace’s attempts to save Scotland has been lost in the folklore that surrounds him; leaving gaps in details that can make a big difference in the story. The most known

Devolution: Compare differences between Scottish Parliament and Westminster

1209 words - 5 pages fire services, environment, , law, home affairs, social work, and transport, the list goes on. It seems then , that Scotland has received to an extent 99 percent independence. In fact the devolution settlement consisted of the power to pass legislation, the power to alter the rate of tax and to have 129 elected representatives (MSPs), (Devolved Parliament, Online, 2006). The Scottish executive consists of The First Minister, The Lord Advocate, the

Wallace's Revolutionary Fight

1185 words - 5 pages to hide. Edward sent men ahead to seek out Sir William. While he was waiting for word of Wallace’s whereabouts he went and found the high ranking Scottish officials. Most of them surrendered to his rule and gave up on their fight for independence. “Wallace’s activities are unknown for the four years following his defeat at Falkirk” (Phillips, 3). Eventually after several months of searching Wallace was found and he was tried for his treason

Scotland's Referendum 2014

2918 words - 12 pages will take place on September 18th 2014; 2014 is the 700th anniversary of the Battle of Bannockburn. This is one of the battles in the Wars of Scottish Independence in the 1300’s. In the battle the Scots were outnumbered nearly three to one and were lead by Robert the Bruce, King of Scots. This was the first battle that the King of Scots and the King of England, Edward II, were face to face. This battle was won by the Scots and this lead to the

Origins of the First World War

1971 words - 8 pages . In fact, the SNP want complete independence from the UK government. Other reserved matters that are controlled at Westminster are defence, asylum, and foreign policy. So bearing in mind the differences between policy styles in Scotland and England, Scotland does appear to be very constructive and efficient. Additionally, Scotland is also very efficient at selecting their MP’s, and in fact, the overall priority of the Scottish Parliament is to

"Braveheart" Movie Review

525 words - 2 pages The movie "Braveheart" is an epic based on Scottish independence for the fierce grips of English control. Mel Gibson directs and stars in this movie. The film also won five academy awards; including best picture, director, cinematography, makeup as well as sound effects. The major theme through out this movie is freedom and destiny. That one should always fight for what they believe in and nothing can stand in the way of love. Though sometimes

Similar Essays

Scottish Independence Essay

3028 words - 12 pages Scottish Independence and theReferendumA general overview of the upcoming referendum on Scottish Independence.IntroductionDescribed as Scotland's "biggest choice since 1707" (McLean et al, 2013, p. ix), the upcoming referendum on Scottish independence will provide a pivotal event for the current and future populations of Scotland as voters get the opportunity to decide whether or not they are to remain a part of Great Britain or become an

Scottish Independence Essay Argumentative

2283 words - 9 pages Essay on Scottish Independence."The beauty of independence, departure, actions that rely on themselves"-Walt WhitmanCurrently Scotland is part of the United Kingdom. Scottish Independence is "a political aim for some political parties, advocacy groups, and individuals in Scotland for the country to once again become an independent sovereign state." A Referendum ("A general vote by the electorate on a single political question which has been

Uk Political Devolution And Scottish Independence

2267 words - 9 pages thinking, the survey showed the vast majority opted for separate parliament. Scotland at this point did not want to be independent only separate parliaments, therefore they were not in favour of any parties which were devoted to home rule or independence. Although in 1947 a Scottish convention was formed in hope of gaining the support needed in parliament for the separation it was not something Westminster seen as a priority therefore it was

Examine From An Economic Perspective ‘Poverty In Scotland’ In Relation To The Forthcoming Scottish Independence Referendum. Based Upon Your Analy

948 words - 4 pages First Paragraph! The Scottish referendum due to take place September 18th 2014 will determine whether Scot’s gain independence or stay in the current UK set up. One of the main policy areas which could affect the outcome of the vote is poverty. This study will analyse poverty from an economic perspective by comparing the current UK levels of unemployment, wage rates and tax levels against the predicted changes from the Scottish government. A