Seal Hunting In Atlantic Canada Essay

1791 words - 7 pages

The annual hunt of harp seals (Pagophilus groenlandicus) in Atlantic Canada is contested at the start of nearly every season, with celebrities, politicians, and the public actively weighing in on the matter. Within all of the dialogue and debate, there can be a lot of bias and misrepresentation of facts advocating for or against the seal hunt. Thus, the true sustainable aspects of the industry are drowned out and lost due to the sheer amount of controversy surrounding the issue. Sustainability entails meeting the needs of today without sacrificing the needs of the future (“Sustainable Development” 1). The concept of sustainable resource development involves support pillars that represent economics, society, and the environment. Seal hunting, as it is practiced today in Canada, is indeed sustainable and should continue. The harvest is rooted in a cultural tradition that brings economic benefits to Atlantic Canada while maintaining due respect to the environment. An examination of these tenets, as well as criticism in opposition of the hunt constitute the body of this essay.
Sealing in the province of Newfoundland and Labrador has been occurring for hundreds of years and has become a mainstay in the traditional way of life for coastal communities and aboriginal peoples (“Facts” 1). Many jobs and commodities such as seal meat, oil, and hides arise as direct benefits to society through the seal harvest. According to the government of Newfoundland and Labrador, seal hunting “provides direct annual employment for over 6000 people on a part time basis” and provides employment at a time of the year when opportunities may be limited (“Facts” 1). The historical integration of seals in aboriginal heritage can not be discounted when considering seal hunting in its entirety. Complex socio-cultural relationships and behaviour with respect to the sharing of seal meat have been well documented in aboriginal populations of Eastern Canada (Wenzel 4). Contemporary dishes like seal flipper pie have also contributed to the cultural identity of Newfoundland society. As a result of these strong cultural ties, commercial and subsistence sealing continues to exist through legal policy by demand from both government and society. The policies that govern seal hunting are based on a sustained yield principle that does not compromise the harvest for future generations, and are thus in accordance with sustainable aspects of resource development.
Economic benefits gained from the seal hunt include an increase in trading relationships for Canada and the stimulation of the provincial economy of Newfoundland and Labrador. As reported by the Department of Fisheries and Oceans, the total landed value of the seal harvest for 2006 was $34.3 million dollars (“Market” 1). This figure represents a historic high, when market prices per pelt were favourable. Regardless, the money brought in from seal hunting is said to have a “trickle-down” effect on other sectors of the economy...

Find Another Essay On Seal Hunting in Atlantic Canada

Trade in Seal Products - The European Commission

2459 words - 10 pages I. Introduction Concerns on the animal welfare aspects of the seal hunt and doubts expressed concerning the hunting methods used on seals causing avoidable distress, fear and other forms of suffering to the animal has led European Union (EU) to adopt a Regulation to impose a total ban on the trade in seal products in the EU market. This regulation applies to seal products that are produced in the EU as well as to imported products from other

Canadas Shame Essay

714 words - 3 pages The infamous Harp (whitecoat) and Hooded (blueback) seal hunt photos have virtually disappeared from newspapers or television news. That does not mean that seal hunting in Canada has stopped. The mass killing of seals off Canada’s East Coast is commercial, cruel, and wasteful, yet despite furious outcry from Animal Rights activists the government is refusing to take notice. The cruelty of this extensive killing operation, which

The Deception Behind Canada's Commercial Sealing

1233 words - 5 pages For as long as humans lived in Atlantic and Northern Canada, seals were hunted for food, clothing, tools, and cultural customs. Seal hunts still take place off the Newfoundland coast, near the Magdalene Islands, the Northern Gulf of St. Lawrence, and Inuit regions every spring for rural communities and commercially to provide part-time employment for fishermen. Commercial hunts occurring only for money differ from traditional hunts and lack the

The Hooded Seal

1205 words - 5 pages . Lawrence and in the Davis Strait. Hooded seals are legally hunted in countries such as Norway and Russia, however hunting has been reduced in this seal population in recent years due to decreased access to the seals. The pup is hunted for its hide, while the adult is hunted commercially for its flesh and fat, which are used for animal feed and delicacies in some countries. Hooded seals suffer from entanglement in nets in

Harbor Seals

1640 words - 7 pages most other seal species, migrate southward every winter, returning to New England and Canada in the summer. On Long Island a large group of these seals come in November and remain through mid May, although some are known to stay throughout the whole year. Migrating southward every year became a natural instinct after thousands and thousands of years. Harbor seals have been hunted for food, fur, and lantern oil by people for hundreds, probably

Canadian Culture

2163 words - 9 pages nine provinces, as well, it is the "third largest producer of hogs and has a quarter of Canada's sheep" (p.17). First Nations have the oldest influence on Prairie culture as they have lived in this region for centuries. Fur traders and explorers from Eastern Canada were the first Europeans to come to the Prairies. "They gave rise to the Métis, famous for their skill in bison hunting" (Wikipedia, 2007, par.9). Located in Southern Alberta, there

Regionalism and it's Effect on a Unified Canadian Identity

1691 words - 7 pages asthe prairies, are much different from say the coastal proximity, for example, of Atlantic Canada.The climate in relation to the different geographical characteristics of Canada attributes to thedifferent life styles in these regions, ultimately changing their identities. This causes differencein economies of the regions, in turn affecting the political agenda of each region. The concept ofregionalism has caused many to attack other regions based

Canadian Regional Development: The Atlantic Region

929 words - 4 pages Economic Development is a term generally applied to the sustained expansion of a region's wealth, which translates into increased quality of life and well-being of its inhabitants. Looking at the change from 2002 to 2006, we notice that the real GDP per capita of the Atlantic region rose by 7%, while Canada's Real GDP per capita rose by an astonishing 10% (GEOG 1410, Table 2). In other words, relative to the rest of Canada, the Atlantic region's

Newfoundland and Labrador's Cod Collapse

1458 words - 6 pages Introduction Newfoundland and Labrador’s fisheries might start to be dated in a period not too distant from that Age of Discovery years, about five centuries ago, and since this period it had been performed an important role in both economic and socio-cultural structure of Atlantic Canada. Among several species, northern cods performed one of the main sources of food for both populations from Atlantic Canada and Eastern European countries such

Distinctly Canadian

2470 words - 10 pages Distinctly CanadianCanada, federated country of North America, bounded on the north by the Arctic Ocean; on the northeast by Baffin Bay and Davis Strait, which separate it from Greenland; on the east by the Atlantic Ocean; on the south by the United States; and on the west by the Pacific Ocean and Alaska. Canada is the world's second largest country, surpassed in size only by Russia. Canada has a total area of 9,970,610 sq. km (3,849,652 sq. mi


1591 words - 7 pages . The land in Canada covers seven time zones. The territory known as Nunavut has the most square miles, followed by Quebec, Northwest Territories and, Ontario. Canada is bordered by the Pacific Ocean on the west, the Arctic Ocean and Labrador Sea on the north, and the Atlantic Ocean on the east. Canada mostly borders the United States to the north. However, Alaska, one of the fifty states in the United States is North of some parts of Canada

Similar Essays

Seal Hunting In The Maritimes Essay

1268 words - 6 pages specific limit as well. With near extinction of the northern cod population, more than 40,000 Atlantic Canadian commercial fishermen had lost their only source of income because of the collapse of the industry. In turn of the fishing industry collapsing with the cod, the DFO had turned to seal hunting to make up for the loss of income in the cod industry. Their blame was on the seals eating the cod and therefore pushed the blame towards the new way of

Poaching Seals Essay

1873 words - 8 pages Seal hunting for sport is illegal, and it needs to be controlled or stopped. Seal pups especially need protection, because these brutal killings at one time almost led to the extinction of harp seals, and that still is a possibility today. Most hunters do not understand the damage they are causing. Poaching is a serious crime in most parts of the world, but mainly in Canada. What most hunters do not understand is that it is illegal regardless

East Coast Canadian Fisheries Essay

2448 words - 10 pages . Because of this Canada stopped commercial whale hunting in 1972. However, fisherman are still using whales to make a living by as in recent times, whale watching has become part of a tourism industry. In many locations across Atlantic Canada there are daily tours.Seal hunting still exists though it is tightly regulated by the Canadian government. Many changes in seal and whale hunting were made between the 18th century and today. In the 18th

The Inuit People Essay

2057 words - 8 pages (from an Eskimo word meaning "home") was constructed of packed snow and used only during the winter, villages of igloos were built on the firm ocean ice of the central Arctic to help seal hunting through holes in the ice. They were also used as temporary structures in Greenland and in parts of Canada and Alaska. Food The traditional method of hunting seals during winter through the frozen ocean ice was most