Second Treatise Of Goverment: Equality In Nature Versus Inequality Of Wealth

1222 words - 5 pages

In the beginning of the Second Treatise of Government, John Locke showed his protest against Filmer's theory about the omnipotent power of government over human beings. He assured that political power must derive from the divine state of human beings. That is the State of Nature which includes the state of perfect freedom and the state of perfect equality. In other words, he argued that all men are by nature created equal; however, John Locke didn't reject the reality that inequalities of wealth are natural and inevitable. How is he able to reconcile these two ideas?

According to John Locke, men were "promiscuously born to all the same advantages of nature and the use of the same faculties; they should also be equal one amongst another without subordination or subjection." (Second Treatise of Government, p8). The basic principle teaching is that God has given the earth to humankind in common, to the posterity of men so that they will have enough to subsist and flourish. Everything in its natural state is provided to commonwealth for "the support and comfort of their being." (John Locke, Second Treatise of Government, p 18). So no one originally can have the right to posses that public property. However, history has proven that every man still has the right to own, to enrich and protect his property; how can that "private dominion" come into being?

Locke clarified the problem by pointing out his notions that mostly derived from the natural state of human beings. Each man was originally born and predestined to have his own body, hands, head and so forth which can help him to create his own labor. When he knew how to use his personal mind and labor to appropriate bountiful subjects around him, taking them "out of the hands of nature", they naturally and logically became his own possession. It is obviously right when John stated that "labor put a distinction between them and common." (Second Treatise of Government, p 20) and that was the beginning of the individual property. Taking advantage of one's force and labor to obtain and create one's appropriation is the first rule for men to state their private dominion.

However, this rule was bounded by another one called the law of subsistence as soon as it was recognized that each man could not have the right to overextend and abuse his labor to appropriate all the common property. This rule was set up to limit one's accumulation especially when natural law was dominating and having influence on human life at that time. A person could only possess as much property as he could make use of it. One must be sure that his personal property was not excess and abundant. "Nothing was made by God for man to spoil and destroy." It was so unfair and illogical for his neighbors to use and obtain his left-over especially when all his property went bad and was out of use. In the book, Locke stated: "there was never the less left for others because of his enclosure for himself. ... Nobody could think...

Find Another Essay On Second Treatise of Goverment: Equality in Nature Versus Inequality of Wealth

A Treatise of Human Nature: David Hume´s Philosophy

932 words - 4 pages believe that knowledge is sensory, or experience, based; in essence, that human beings are tabula rasa. It is upon the latter end of this dichotomic spectrum that we find Hume’s epistemology; that of empiricism. Hume divides experiences, or perceptions, into two categories. The first is impressions, and the second is ideas. These are distinguished between one another, he says, by their respective degrees of force and vivacity; that is, how strongly

The Question of Goverment Essay

1474 words - 6 pages ” cannot be changed, regardless of any plan of action, you abandon our responsibility as the dominating species, the “world” is, in part, our responsibility. Human nature created hierarchy, the survival of the fittest, and the government. Humans are to blame for any conceived problem with society, as they created the society. Furthermore, the conceived problems our “world” faces are changeable. It is our responsibility to stop complaining about how

Discuss: Hume, A Treatise of Human Nature, BK III, Part 1, section 1.

2558 words - 10 pages "..when you pronounce any action or character to be vicious, you mean nothing but that from the constitution of your nature you have a feeling or sentiment of blame from the contemplation of it,"The purpose of this essay is to examine Hume's statement contained within the title and explore the possible interpretations and arguments of it. In order to do this I will first discuss the idea of this form of moral subjectivism, before observing other

Analysis of four types of conflict in John Steinbeck's "The Grapes of Wrath", man versus man, man versus nature, man versus society, and man versus himself.

1487 words - 6 pages Tom into trouble and be sent back to jail, and man vs. nature poses a large conflict in the beginning of the novel, as well as a large conflict to end the novel. All four of these types of conflicts contribute to the story's purpose.This was for an A.P. language arts class i took my junior year of high school, and the teacher's suggestions included avoiding abbreviations (versus instead of vs.) and to strengthen the introduction and conclusion.

Psychological debate of Nature versus Nurture

620 words - 2 pages product of the environment.The nature and nurture dichotomy refers to the disposition of people based on their innate factors versus environmental influences on them. Innate factors include genetics or inborn temperaments, such as, whether if a person is an introvert or extrovert, their personality and characteristics. Nurture is the shaping of an individual through influences of their environment and what they are exposed to. Nature verses nurture

Democracy Outweighs The Other Forms of Goverment

1552 words - 6 pages Even though democracy has been in existence since the ancient Greek, it rose to prominence in the twentieth century with a large number of countries shifting to democracy. This transition to democracy has sprung up a debate over its appropriateness as a system of government, with some supporting it as an ideal system while others coining it as the vilest form of government. Although it is argued that democracy and economic growth do not go hand

Comparative View of Wealth Accumulation in America

1283 words - 5 pages believed in a society that is free of laziness and eating from other people sweat. No wonder the common phrase, “If thou have not sown, thou shall not reap.” He was strongly opposed to the communist ideologies that advocated for social equality. As matter of fact, Carnegie strongly opposed programs that were aimed at helping the poor. He argued that such plans went against the law of nature and the natural process of evolution. Carnegie actually

The Value of Wealth in Ancient Rome

1766 words - 7 pages The imperial expansion of Rome or in simpler terms the development of the Roman Empire can be associated with the second century BC. Over a relatively short period of time, Rome immensely expanded its territory at a rapid rate. Although the victories in the Second Punic War satisfied Rome, they also motivated them to expend further into their neighbour’s territories and eventually conquer Greece and the North African coast. The Roman Empire

An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of NationsAdam Smith

693 words - 3 pages In 1776, Adam Smith completed and published “An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations”, more commonly referred to as simply “The Wealth of Nations”. In this document, Smith analyzed wages, labor, trade, population, rents, and money supply (Andrea, 151). Because of his work, Smith is known as the founder of the academic study of economics and the father of capitalism. The kind of economy Smith envisioned and described in

The Wealth of Nations

993 words - 4 pages The Wealth of Nations Adam Smith’s famous attempt to explain the nature and causes of the wealth of nations rests on several crucial assumptions about human nature which in turn rely on false universalism and questionable dichotomies. To begin with, Smith makes roughly three claims about human nature. Primarily, Smith assumes that self-interest is inherent in all human beings. As opposed to animals which rely on benevolence, in opposition

The Wealth of Nations

1072 words - 4 pages : Locke, Steuart, Mandeville, Petty, Cantillion, Turgot, not to mention Quesnay and Hume again. Smith took from all of them: there are over a hundred authors mentioned by name in his treatise...The Wealth of Nations is not a wholly original book” (1999). Rima disagrees to some extent saying that it “contains remarkably few references to the writings of other authers and that Smith was perhaps less scholarly in this regard than he might have been

Similar Essays

Property In Second Treatise Of Civil Government And Robinson Crusoe

2557 words - 10 pages without his own consent" (Larkin 58). According to Paschal Larkin, the principle of Locke's Second Treatise of Government was to "discuss the origin, foundation, and limits of civil authority; his treatment of property was merely incidental" (Larkin 59). But even though the topic came up incidentally, Locke had much to say about it. He dedicated an entire chapter in his Treatise to discussing property and its importance in the laws of nature and

John Locke: Second Treatise Of Civil Government

903 words - 4 pages Civil Government and Locke The Second Treatise of Government provides Locke's theorizes the individual rights and involvement with the government; he categorizes them in two areas -- natural rights theory and social contract. 1.Natural state; rights which human beings are to have before government comes into being. 2.Social contact; when conditions in natural state are unsatisfactory, and there's need to develop society into functioning of

Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan And John Locke's Second Treatise Of Government

2995 words - 12 pages Hobbes' Leviathan and Locke's Second Treatise of Government Hobbes’ Leviathan and Locke’s Second Treatise of Government comprise critical works in the lexicon of political science theory. Both works expound on the origins and purpose of civil society and government. Hobbes’ and Locke’s writings center on the definition of the “state of nature” and the best means by which a society develops a systemic format from this beginning. The authors

The Significance Of Reason, Discussed In John Locke's "The Second Treatise Of Civil Government", And In Jean Jacques Rousseau's, "Emile"

1353 words - 5 pages The significance of reason is discussed both in John Locke's, The Second Treatise of Civil Government, and in Jean-Jacques Rousseau's, Emile. However, the definitions that both authors give to the word "reason" vary significantly. I will now attempt to compare the different meanings that each man considered to be the accurate definition of reason.John Locke believed that the state "all men are naturally in ... is a state of perfect freedom" (122