Secret Diplomacy Essay

3385 words - 14 pages

Introduction

International negotiations may comprise a number of different channels during a peace process. Negotiations between states may take place in public front channels or they may be veiled to maintain secrecy of the bargaining process. This essay will look at the later and examine whether the beneficial effects of secret diplomacy can also yield negative consequences. This essay will be divided into three sections. The first section will define secret diplomacy, referred to as back channel diplomacy (BCD), and outline some of its characteristics. The discussion will outline why parties use BCD and convey the benefits and disadvantages. The second section will outline the function of BCD in two negotiation case studies. The first will look at Israel and Palestinian negotiations leading up to the Oslo Accords in 1993. The second case study will examine British negotiations with the IRA and Sinn Fein in Northern Ireland leading up to the Good Friday Agreement in 1998. The third and final section will evaluate the use of BCD in both cases and convey some lessons for policymakers. This essay argues that whilst BCD can be helpful in facilitating a peace process, it can be damaging if it is not managed with front channel diplomacy (FCD).

What is Back Channel Diplomacy?

Secret diplomacy, also known as ‘back channel diplomacy’ (BCD) refers to ‘official negotiations conducted in secret among the parties to a dispute or even between a party and a third party intervenor, which may complement front channels, and are potentially at variance with declared policies’ . Wanis-St. John has also described them as the ‘black markets’ of negotiation. This is because they provide a separate negotiation space away from public diplomatic channels, and enable parties to seek alternative arrangements . In this manner BCD contrast with front channel diplomacy (FCD) which involve overt activities such as direct bilateral negotiation, multilateral conferences and open mediation by a third party . BCD can also be used in pre-negotiation to diminish overall tension and provide substantive inputs for official negotiations . Moreover BCD can be used in parallel with FCD to advance decision making and problem solving. Depending on negotiations BCD can also take on one of two forms. This may either be in the form of direct discussions between decision makers and official representatives, or indirect discussions using third-party intermediaries . The case studies of this essay will present examples of both forms being employed.

BCD contains a number of distinguishing characteristics. First, BCD negotiators typically involve individuals who are closer to the pointy end of decision making. By virtue this enables negotiators to explore a wider range of divergent positions, and creates flexibility to reach tentative agreements . This then enables BCD to proceed to front channel negotiations. Second, BCD negotiators can sometimes have their origin in ‘freelance’...

Find Another Essay On Secret Diplomacy

Instruments of Foreign Policy Essay

1183 words - 5 pages In American foreign policy, security, prosperity, and the creation of a better world are the three most important goals that policy makers try to achieve. To achieve these goals, policy makers use the assistance of foreign policy instruments. The instruments include intelligence gathering, diplomacy, the use of military force, covert action, economic statecraft and cultural and moral influences (18). The instruments fall into two different

The Ping-Pong Diplomacy Essay

1627 words - 7 pages Before the Ping Pong Diplomacy the United Sates and China never had a good relationship. In 1971 The American Ping-Pong and Chinese team were at 31st World Table Tennis (ping-pong) Championships which was held in Nagoya, Japan from March 28 through April 7, 1971. During the Championships the two teams had meet, because Glenn Cowan, a member of the U.S. national ping pong team, happened to get on the Chinese team bus at the Ping-pong competition

Cryptography

602 words - 2 pages Essential Question: How do people communicate through codes?Emerging from the need for secret communications, "cryptology" is the science of interacting through codes and consists of two aspects; "cryptography", which is putting messages into covert form and accrediting them and "cryptanalysis" which is solving secret messages. (Encyclopedia Americana 275) In all ages, "cryptography" has been used in "diplomacy", "espionage' and "commerce

South African International Relations

2858 words - 11 pages Introduction.Diplomacy and foreign relations is more than a carrot and stick methodology. Diplomats have various strategies to use. Diplomacy will be addressed in this short analysis of South African foreign policy.Firstly, states need to have formal recognitions of each other in order to engage in formal meaningful dialogue. Dialogue is founded on common trust and interest.Secondly, dialogue should have a direction or purpose. This is the end

Freedom of the press, globalization, public diplomacy and current events

2047 words - 8 pages . For example, in France during World War II, media from a secret press risked their lives to disseminate their material. In Britain, citizens against the government created their own newspapers that showed their oppositions against the government. Africa contains the Revolutionary concept in relation to radio broadcasts since it is the most used type of medium. Also, audiocassettes in Iran have been used to record speeches of Ayatollah to spread his

Plan of Investigation 150

1705 words - 7 pages superpowers of the period time between the years of 1969 to 1977, the United States and the Soviet Union. The investigation focuses on the diplomatic talks of Henry Kissinger with officials of both the People’s Republic of China and the Soviet Union, and the triangular diplomacy among the three nations that arose from these events. The policy of Realpolitik will be discussed within the investigation as a way to justify Henry Kissinger’s, and in

This is a film review of "The Interpreter" that was written form my college newspaper

546 words - 2 pages "The Interpreter" is a watchable, if not always absorbing thriller, thanks to sheer star power and top directing talent.Nicole Kidman is Silvia, an American raised in Africa, who works as an interpreter at the United Nations. One night she overhears an assassination plot that appears to be about a controversial head of state who is about to make a speech to the General Assembly. Secret Service agents Keller (Sean Penn) and Woods (the superb

National Security Decision Making

2598 words - 10 pages play during the event is the media and public opinion. The President and his staff carefully plan the announcement of the surge at a West Point speech and show concern for leaks about the options. They are also concerned about General Petraeus and McCrsytal’s interview with the press because they understand the importance of overall public opinion and support for their security decisions. Diplomacy plays a critical role in this event as

i search paper: how to thrive as a foreign service officer

1286 words - 6 pages Foreign Service career is a diverse corps of working professionals who represents America’s interest and responding to the needs of American citizen in other counties around the world. As I researched the process of becoming a Foreign Service officer I learned there are five major career tracks: Consular, Economics, and Management, political and public diplomacy. They work in embassies, consulates and other diplomatic missions .They can be sent

Crisis in kosovo

1189 words - 5 pages life throughout the Balkans. The wars of this period precipitated changes in diplomacy, and in their aftermath entirely new social and political processes began to change the way these people lived their lives. They remained overwhelmingly peasant societies, but the older aristocratic dynasties were increasingly challenged by the rising middle classes, which saw "national interest" in different terms. This led to the weakening of the aristocratic

Saddam Hussein Theories of Force

593 words - 2 pages forces from a secret hideout, Saddam Hussein was eventually captured and killed against his own will. Even though the theories of force, as presented by Art and Schelling, would've suggested a premature surrender by Saddam Hussein and his armies, the Iraqi dictator is fueled by an egotistic personality, a nationalistic pride and a glory seeking imagination that would never enable him to agree and surrender to the overpowering authority of the

Similar Essays

The Tools Of Foreign Policy Essay

976 words - 4 pages . In ancient worlds, traditional diplomacy was very strict which is involves two parties (bilateral) and both parties need to keep the negotiation secretly. Most diplomacy occurs behind the scene as officials hold secret negotiations or meet privately to discuss key issues (Sparknote, 2012). Moreover, the agenda of traditional diplomacy focused on variety of issues especially military and war. After the end of the World War II, the process and

'rather Than Being In Decline, Diplomacy Is Still An Essential Mechanism In Managing International Crises And Conflicts.' Discuss In The Context Of The Post Cold War Developments In Global Politics

2205 words - 9 pages , 2002, 7), especially in the area of coercion, which, in its ultimate form, means war. Today's diplomats must also rely on their ability to transmit, receive and process information speedily and effectively in an era of instant news, global reach and high expectations. Although secret diplomacy and closed-door meetings are still a prerequisite for some negotiations to proceed, the diplomatic process is becoming increasingly transparent. This has

President Truman And World War Ii

829 words - 4 pages choose diplomacy to end the war, this option is beneficial by saving many lives and keeping the atomic bomb a secret. The first beneficial aspect of diplomacy is saving many lives both American and Japanese that would otherwise been lost in a invasion or bomb. By being involved in World War II the United states had lost 400,000 people and the Japanese had lost over 2 million, by choosing to end things more peacefully would not only save civilian

The Nazi Soviet Pact Essay

2549 words - 10 pages ,(1994), Diplomacy, Simon & Schuster Paperbacks, New York]Ribbentrop focused on the secret protocol dividing up Eastern Europe. In the north, Finland, Estonia and Latvia were assigned to the Soviet sphere. Poland was to be partitioned in the event of its "political rearrangement"-the areas east of the Narev, Vistula and San Rivers going to the Soviet Union while Germany would occupy the west. Lithuania, adjacent to East Prussia, would be in the