Section 78 Of The Police And Criminal Evidence Act 1984

2192 words - 9 pages

To a man with a hammer everything looks like a nail. I would submit this is the case in regards to Section 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984. The courts have been granted a tool and since its introduction have been wantonly applying it case after case. I will endeavour to argue that s.78 has been developed into the tool the courts sought as oppose to the tool they have been granted and the wording of the statute ignored. The point of s.78 has been glossed over and it has instead been utilized as if it were a subsection of s.76. Whilst ‘unnecessary’ is perhaps the wrong term to use the purpose of s.78 has been defeated.
I would first draw attention to how section 78 of PACE should be used. A judge has the discretion to use s.78 if “the evidence would have such an adverse effect on the fairness of the proceedings that the court ought not to admit it.” The key issue here is that the exclusion has to relate to the fairness of the proceedings. Whilst is states that circumstance surrounding the manner in which the evidence was obtained are relevant, the actual reason for its exclusion remains a question of the fairness of proceedings. An example of this can be found in the case of O’Loughlin where the defendant would not be able to cross-examine the witness. This would be a strict application of s.78 where the fairness of the proceedings is adversely effected. Unfortunately cases like this are a rarity. Bernard Robertson directs us to a long list of authorities in his article where the application of s.78 is inappropriate and/or wrong . Further to this he advocates his argument that cause must proceed effect. The cause is the admission of the evidence and the effect is the unfair proceedings. Only after the cause (the admitting of evidence) has occurred can the effect take place. This means the only viable area for the effect would be during court the court in session. Ergo the affected proceedings mentioned in the statute must refer to the court in session. I concur with this deduction and it is the underlying bases of my argument.
In the Mason case an inappropriate confession was excluded under s.78 by stretching the term “proceedings” to include activates carried out at the police station before the trial instead of applying the common law rule against evidenced obtained by deception . Section 82(3) was ignored in favour of s.78. Mr Robertson also directions us to the cases of Samuel and Foster . In these cases for all intents as purposes the evidence would be considered unreliable and excluded under s.76 of PACE had s.78 not existed. I would submit that in both cases the evidence would not have affected the fairness of proceedings, it would simply have been an unreliable confession. I would submit that these are very different things. A confession can be unfairly obtained but not affect the nature of the proceedings themselves, as such the proceedings remain fair.
In the case of Williams Mr Justice Wright refers to the case of...

Find Another Essay On Section 78 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984

Scientists, Psychologists and the Media do not have enough evidence to support the claim of the relationship between criminal activity or criminal behaviour and video games

1989 words - 8 pages Thesis Statement: Scientists, Psychologists and the Media do not have enough evidence to support the claim of the relationship between criminal activity or criminal behaviour and video games.The public debate regarding the relationship between video games and violence has brewed for decades. The emergence of video games, dramatically changed children's media environment, and this new form of entertainment raised concern because the negative

the notes of criminal law - rape and sexual offences act,. describe and discuss - university - notes

1155 words - 5 pages intercourse”. It was thought that any sex outside marriage was unlawful. Difficulties in defining what rape is. Pre-2003: Criminal Justice and Public Order Act 1994 – recognised male rape as an offence and extended rape to include anal rape for men and women. Forcible penetration of anus. Victims of rape Reforming Sex Offences · Setting the Boundaries: Reforming the Law on Sex Offences (2000) was a report to look at current law and societal attitudes to

How Miller Develops the Dramatic Tension Between the Characters in the Closing Section of Act 1

2734 words - 11 pages How Miller Develops the Dramatic Tension Between the Characters in the Closing Section of Act 1 The play "A View from the Bridge" written by Arthur Miller and set in the 1950s, is a play of betrayal, jealousy and violence. Located in Brooklyn, Miller writes of tragedy for ordinary working class people, juggling with both the beliefs of the Americanised Italians and the new immigrants and resulting in an emotive and powerful

The Overlooked Richness of the Recitatives of Bach's Cantata 78

3000 words - 12 pages the intriguing movements 3 and 5 of Cantata No. 78. In the first of these two examples, the arioso section lasts for the last four and a half bars of the piece and helps show the shift from the sinner's inner monologue to an outward presentation of his grief to Christ. In the second, the arioso spans the last dozen "andante" bars of the piece and illustrates a similar shift from the text's discussion of Christ's strengthening of mankind through

Negative 'old' police attitudes and practices towards rape victims is still very much part of modern day policing. Critically assess the evidence available to support this statement

1425 words - 6 pages . In spite of these much needed changes there has undoubtedly been resistance. Even where the drive and commitment for change exist 'structural reform' is not a speedy process and requires us to 'temper short term scepticism with long term patience (Mastrofski 1998 cited in Newburn) Police and rape The term rape is used as defined in the 1976 Sexual Offences Act as when a man has unlawful sexual intercourse with a woman without her consent and at

The Youth Criminal Justice Act

1157 words - 5 pages more minor offences committed by the youth in society. With that being said, the YOA went back to legislation to fix some of its problems and in return a new act called the Youth Criminal Justice Act [YCJA] or also known as Bill C-7 was enacted and became effective in April 2003 (YCJA: Summary and Background, para.4). Due to society's concern with youth involvement in crime, the Canadian government has developed an improved version of past acts

Interrogations, Confession and Admissions in the Criminal Justice System (Interrogation Policies used by Police today)

1843 words - 7 pages sympathetic approach, but also offers an approach favorable to their intention, to obtain a confession. We agree this may seem like psychological coercion, but it strengthens the police's vantage point.In today's judicial society, judge and jury, the courts consider a confession to be a very important piece of evidence. The law enforcement agencies comprised of detectives, police investigators, and prosecutors, rely heavily on this evidence when

Comparison of 1984 and The Dispossessed

1188 words - 5 pages In all of human history, the notion of a perfect society has been considered and attempted, but never truly attained. A positive perfect world, were every member is blissful, is a utopia. Alternatively, a negative perfect, world full of disdain and melancholy, is a dystopia. 1984 is a dystopia because its society is decadent and miserable. The Dispossessed is a world full of tranquility and freedom; therefore its society is a utopia. Both novels

This Essay Describes The Patriot Act I In Terms Of Control And Compares Today's Reality To That Of Geroge Orwell's 1984

1084 words - 5 pages "informants" will include postal workers, utility technicians and even your "cable guy" (ACLU 2). Similar to the "thought police" and the zealous citizens of Oceania in 1984, everyone around the common citizen seems to be watching, waiting for a neighbor to expose himself as a criminal by the magazines he gets or, like Parsons, to become a "thought criminal" for what he says in his sleep (Orwell 193). It seems as though even the media, praised

Police Discretion and the Use of Force

2202 words - 9 pages Discretion is defined as the authority to make a decision between two or more choices (Pollock, 2010). More specifically, it is defined as “the capacity to identify and to document criminal and noncriminal events” (Boivin & Cordeau, 2011). Every police officer has a great deal of discretion concerning when to use their authority, power, persuasion, or force. Depending on how an officer sees their duty to society will determine an

Evidence of Criminal investigation - Administration justice - es\say

1313 words - 6 pages 5 Evidence of Criminal Investigation Evidence of Criminal Investigation Professor Provencher Citrus College AJ 103 John Chuo Njuh May 22, 2017 Evidence is the key element in determining the guilt or innocence of those accused of crimes against society in a criminal court of law. Evidence can come in many different forms such as weapons, documents, pictures, tape recordings and DNA. According to the American Heritage College dictionary, evidence

Similar Essays

Scope And Ambit Of Section 113 B Of Indian Evidence Act

3036 words - 12 pages latest decision of the Supreme Court19 it was held that even husbands who contract invalid marriages will be liable if dowry death occurs, considering the very purpose of Section 304-B IPC and Section 113-B of the Evidence Act and they cannot escape from criminal liability pleading invalid marriage.---------------------------------------------16. AIR 2003 SC 2865.17. 2004 AIR SCW 133718. 2004 AIR SCW 1230.19. 2004 AIR SCW 343.IV

Police Brutality Is A Criminal Act

1383 words - 6 pages illegal immigrants. Dogs were set on illegal refugees in South Africa by the police (Top Criminal Justice Schools). Gangs of criminals roam the streets of Rio de Janeiro and in this city three people are killed by on average each day by law enforcement officers due to the large population of criminals (Top Criminal Justice Schools). Being beaten and tortured is just a few of the torments the citizens of Russia go through, being used as a human

Significance Of Section 3 And 4 Of The Human Rights Act 1998

1738 words - 7 pages incentive to act once a DOI has been issued. Section 3 Case Law In R v A, section 41 of the Youth Justice & Criminal Evidence Act 1999 was found to violate Article 6 of the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) because it denied the Defendant’s right to a fair trial. Section 41 prohibited cross-examination of the complainant’s sexual history with Defendant, which was an important factor in the Defendant’s case. The court decided, in

Section 504 And The Americans With Disabilities Act

899 words - 4 pages the right of disabled Americans to dignity of self-respect as equal and contributing members of society and to end the virtual isolation of millions of children and adults.” (Smith, 2001) In all, Section 504 has significantly altered the common and legal perception of civilization. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) is probably the most comprehensible formulation of disabled individuals’ rights. The ADA officially became a law July 26