This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Security Dillemma & Ethnic Conflict Essay

644 words - 3 pages

The security dilemma can be used explain and predict ethnic conflict within a given state. Posen’s argument is supported by the belief that the basic tenets of realism provide a clear view of the security dilemma and its relationship with ethnic conflict. I believe the security dilemma in general is largely based in realist theory, and therefore fails to view international relations fairly. I believe that liberalism offers important insight into dealing with conflict that Posen fails to address.
     Realist theory believes that one states military improvements are undistinguishable as offensive or defensive, and are seen as threats to another state. This, in turn, requires the opposing state to improve its military to ensure its own self interest. Posen argues that when an empire falls, there will be a power struggle between competing groups, within a state, as a result of the anarchy left by the failing empire. It is argued by Posen that the competing groups variations in the history of their group and whatever military power they may have will threaten other groups, creating a security dilemma, which results in ethnic conflict.
     I believe the security dilemma is shaped by realist theory because it presupposes military improvements will be seen as threats. It has been shown that military improvements are not always seen as threats, for example the United States is not threatened by Pakistan having nuclear weaponry. Mutual agreements can be reached to provide trust that military armament isn’t threatening. I believe that ethnic conflict is avoidable within a failing state. Cooperation can occur between groups, if they can see the security it will provide. Mutual agreements can be reached by ethnic groups to cooperate prior to conflict, which can secure their self interest.
     Posen feels agreements are often reached after conflicts have already began with cease-fires. He also contends a cease-fire only occurs when one side feels successful and the opposing side fears the result of continued conflict. Posen argues that a cease-fire...

Find Another Essay On Security Dillemma & Ethnic Conflict

John Herz and The Concept of Security

1564 words - 6 pages , democratization, ethnic conflict and various other social issues. My understanding, with the expansion definition of national security, it would increase the danger. The threat might be faced by the state is not only the nuclear threat, but also threats to the economic, social, and cultural. Thus, an expansion of threats in national security related with multiple dimensions, as follow: First, the dimension of 'the origin of threats'. If during the Cold War

The Succesfull of Community Policing Essay

1010 words - 5 pages agencies in maintaining safety and comfort for society. Precautions already taken in the beginning of the ethnic conflict in Lampung happened. Initially, it alleged accident between two people of Lampungnese in Balinese’s village. At first, Balinese intent to help them, but next sexual harassment isuue bloomed. Actually, the police had started to reconcile both of sides and processed their incidence report. When the conflict heated up, and group

Post-conflict Peace building in Eastern Indonesia: case study in Poso, Central Sulawesi

901 words - 4 pages Background Since the fall of the authoritarian New Order regime and the reform of 1998, Indonesia experienced political changes and are in the process of transitioninginto a more democratic country. These changes characterized by the rise of large scale communal conflicts either between ethnic or religious. Conflict violence based on ethnic takes place in Sambas, West Kalimantan (Klinken, 2007, Tanasaldy, 2012) and Sampit, Central Kalimantan

Is Partition an Effective Way to End Conflict?

1739 words - 7 pages borders in order for ethnic conflict to be ceased. There has been numerous cases made for and against the idea of partition with many controversial results being seen from countries who have undertaken a partition, under the impression that it would end the ethnic conflict within. A nation is something that is born not something that can be made by the political powers involved, nationalism describes the loyalty one has to its nation, thus

rationalization of mass killing

3253 words - 14 pages science professor at MIT presents his explanation for mass killing and ethnic conflict in his article “The Security Dilemma and Ethnic Conflict”. The article presents a vindication for mass killing through the lenses of a realist explanation for international relations. Thus, his argument heavily focuses on the concept of security dilemma, a model that realists utilize to describe why states go to war. Realists assume that because there is

Explaining Wartime Rape In Armed Conflict: The Great Lakes (Sub-) Region

3689 words - 15 pages . In. Weingast, Barry and Wittman, Donald, eds. The Oxford Handbook of Political Economy, pp. 852–868. HANSEN, Lene (2001). Gender, Nation, Rape: Bosnia and the Construction of Security. International Feminist Journal of Politics 3 (1), pp. 55–75. HOROWITZ, Donald (1985). Ethnic Groups in Conflict. Berkeley: University of California Press. KOO, Katrina Lee (2002). Confronting a Disciplinary Blindness: Women, War and Rape in International

Concept of Security in the Context of International Relations

2287 words - 9 pages political unit (state) in preventing conflict and overcome obstacles (Deutsch in Rosenau, 1976: 157). Implicitly, it is concluded about the presence of security as the element that stimulates the effort for the attainment of the power itself. Inference Buzan says that the security aspect has been the approach in contemporary International Relations Studies with the main motive of behavior refers to a country, which has its own differences with

Relationship Between Poverty and Conflict

1439 words - 6 pages “The world is over-armed and peace in under-funded” This phrase said by Ban-Ki Moon, security general of the United Nations emphasizes the interconnection between poverty and conflict. Though both terms can be used separately the two often interplay with one another when dealing with the issue of human security. In the current year, 2013 citizens in undeveloped and developing countries suffer from lack of human security which is essential in

Ethnic Cleansing in Sudan

1188 words - 5 pages , currently, the IDPs are being pressured to return home - even though there is little security (UN estimates?, 2004, para. 7). The conflict in Sudan is affecting the human rights of over two million people. The Sudanese government, both directly and indirectly, has breached at least two Articles of the UDHR. The only way the human rights of the affected population are completely ensured is with; an end to the ?ethnic cleansing? and Arab aggression

An Analysis of the Effectiveness Security Sector Reform Based On the Programs Implemented in Palestine and Colombia

1450 words - 6 pages state institutions, a fragile inter-ethnic or political situation, with influential armed and other security forces, both statutory and non-statutory, and precarious economic conditions.” (Hänggi) This seems to suggest that there is in fact a difference between these two transitioning societies due to the fact that the post-conflict society has inflicted so much damage on every aspect of the country that it is in fact more fragile than the post

Ethnic Migrant Workers

1741 words - 7 pages riots in Xinjiang and why Uyghurs are considered as terrorists in contemporary China? In this part, we will analyze the Han migrant workers in detail and examine how migrant worker trend causes conflict between Han Chinese and minority groups. Among all the fifty-five ethnic minority groups, many of them are scattered in different provinces and live in one county or town with in a province, it is not typical to use them as research target. In China

Similar Essays

What Are The Causes Of Ethnic Conflict?

2523 words - 10 pages . [JSTOR] Lake, David A; Rothchild, Donald. “Containing Fear: The Origin and Management of Ethnic Conflict”. International Security, Vol. 21, No. 2 (Fall, 1996), pp. 41-75. [JSTOR] Miller, Holmes; Engemann, Kurt J. “A Simulation Model of Intergroup Conflict”. Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 50, No. 4 (Apr., 2004), pp. 355-36. [JSTOR] Oberst, Robert C. “Federalism and Ethnic Conflict in Sri Lanka”. Publius, Vol. 18, No. 3, The State of American

Kazakhstan: The Ethnic Controversy Essay

2136 words - 9 pages threatens the resurrection of a Kazakhs national identity. This has caused Kazakhstan complex ethnic structure to be viewed as a security threat. Since such practices create a power distribution between ethnicities, ethnic conflict has the ability to ensue. Kazakhstan vs. the United States In a comparative view of Kazakhstan and the United States, the United States is also an extremely ethnic diverse country. The ethnic populace consists of

Foreign Decision Making Essay

1797 words - 7 pages and Partitions in the Twentieth Century." International Security 23, no. 2 (1998): 120-156.Kaufmann, Chaim. "Possible and Impossible Solutions to Ethnic Civil Wars."Nationalism and Ethnic Conflict (1996): 444-83. Print.Taras, Raymond C., and Rajat Ganguly. "Resolving Ethnic Conflicts Through International Intervention." Understanding Ethnic Conflict (2008): 43-67. Print.Walter, Barbara F. "Designing Transitions for Violent Civil War." Civil Wars

Primordial Conflict Essay

1453 words - 6 pages . This circumstances is able to bring a new conflict or social conflict, one example is the ethnic conflict. According to Brown (1997), the word 'ethnic conflict' is often used flexible. In fact, in some usage, the word is actually used to describe the type of conflict that is not at all possessed ethnic base. There are at least six things that must be met before a group can call themselves as ' ethnic community'. First, a group must have its own