This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Selection Criteria For Employee Layoffs Essay

1034 words - 4 pages

Industry or global shut downs, cost cutting, and spin offs are just a few reasons why employees are laid off. Fallon and McConnell (2007) argue that companies conduct layoffs primarily due to economic issues. Today, many organizations are being forced to reduce their workforce due to these factors. However, before layoffs occur in organizations, there are numerous steps that have to be taken to ensure effectiveness in the process. The selection criteria are the most important aspects of organizations’ initial decision to conduct workforce reduction. Decisions regarding to which employees leave or stay would need to be established before conducting layoffs. Personnel Policy Service Inc (n.d) states that employers should use discretion in determining which employees to layoff. In choosing employees for termination, they suggest that companies use criteria, such as length of service (seniority), performance rating and merit, job status, and job skills.
Seniority is a common selection criterion used by many companies in determining which employees remain.”Of all the criteria, seniority is the most objective” (Segal, 2001, p.199). Under seniority-based layoffs, the most recently hired employees are the first to be laid off. Both Fallon and McConnell (2007) and Personnel Policy Service Inc (n.d) state that using seniority is advantageous because it is a fair and safe means of determining who to layoff. Personnel Policy Service Inc (n.d) argues that it is also very easy to implement seniority as a selection criterion. However, using seniority as the sole selection criterion has it disadvantages. Companies that use seniority as their sole selection criterion run the risk of losing employees that have expertise, initiative, and leadership qualities but lack seniority, which many reduce the diverse of their workforce (Personnel Policy Service Inc, n.d).
To avoid the risk of losing employees with expertise, initiative, and leadership abilities, some companies rely on performance ratings and merit as a selection criterion. The use of performance rating is beneficial; companies use performance ratings to identify their productive employees and layoff their unproductive and problematic employees. However, if companies’ performance evaluation systems are biased, subjective and not taken seriously, layoff decisions can greatly affect a protected class of employees-women and minorities (Personnel Policy Service Inc, n.d). Therefore, if performance ratings are to be utilized to determine layoff decisions, it is important the evaluation system is fair, based on employees’ performance, and conducted in a consistent manner (Personnel Policy Services Inc, n.d). To avoid employees’ legal challenges, Segal (2001) suggests that when performance is measured, objective behavior factors should be considered instead of subjective ones and layoff decisions based on employees recent performance evaluations.
There are companies that require specific job skills and...

Find Another Essay On Selection Criteria for Employee Layoffs

Legal Issues in Reduction of Workforce Simulation

1555 words - 6 pages inevitable. Regardless of the term, this method is potentially painful, economically and emotionally, for both employer and employee. In addition, the performance ratings and absenteeism rates were taken into consideration when the decision was made on whom to terminate. The selection criteria would ensure the laid off employees would not have grounds for discrimination lawsuits.Cutbacks in the workforce, commonly called downsizing, have been a

Employer – Employee Relationship Essay

1044 words - 4 pages supervisor chooses to hire his equally-qualified cousin and not offer Mary the opportunity to return. The use of word "hire" implied that Mary had been an employee and not an independent contractor.Is Mary an independent contractor or an employee? Describe the factors that led to your determination.There are several criteria to determine if Mary is a contractor or an employee. For example, one critical aspect to distinguish an independent contractor

Morale Impacts To Survivors Of Layoffs

2623 words - 10 pages . INTRODUCTION (What This Project Is About.) To anyone who has ever been laid off, you need to read this paper. To anyone who has worked for a company that has done layoffs, you need to read this paper. To anyone who has been a supervisor to people (or thinks they will be someday), you need to read this paper. To anyone who has heard whispering around "the water cooler" the words layoff, downsizing, right sizing, or any word that remotely sounds as if people

Human Resources: Establishing a Business Need for Recruitment

694 words - 3 pages . Interview: All short-listed candidates who meet the substantial criteria for the post as shown in the job specification will be offered an interview. Interview should be performed by a minimum of two people (the panel), one should be from the Human resource department in concurrence with the line Manager to whom the person would be reported to. A range of selection methods, that are suitable for assessing both the substantial and required criteria

Organizational Culture: American Department Stores

2174 words - 9 pages , control, identity, reward system, conflict tolerance and communication patterns.” Schien show that culture involves assumptions, adaptation, perception and learning. He then elaborated that an organizational culture has three coats. The first layer account for artifacts and inventions that seem real but are often unable to be interpreted. For example, a divider wall between the employee and décor. In the second layer, there were value or a bunch of

Using Selection Processes for Selecting Potential Employees to Maintain Efficiency and Staffing Quotas

995 words - 4 pages selection, increasing the chance that they will be more self-selecting. Self-selecting increases the organizations effectiveness for hiring a satisfied employee. A structured interview is the most effective selection system when conducted correctly. It is more effective than cognitive-abilities tests, because the abilities tests only address how the person may perform. It fails to address the concerns of the applicant that may lead to

This economic crisis affected the credit and equity markets, and will challenge our endowment. downsize at least 30% of the class

1402 words - 6 pages our class, our first step was to determine how to rank our classmates against each other in a justifiable manner. Ranking our classmates was a difficult task because of the emotions aroused while determining the selection criteria and the importance of those criteria. While the categories were easily determined, the weight of each category varied drastically. These differences resulted from opinions driven by the different backgrounds of the

Measuring people's performance for selection purposes and suggest how these might be overcome

2494 words - 10 pages concerned with whether or not a test is representative of the type of work an employee will have to do in the performance of the job. For example it is impossible to assess an individuals ability to work as a member of a team in an interview, but this is more easily done in a "leaderless group" activity as part of an assessment centre. The content validity enables a ratio to be calculated that gives the validity of each selection tool in terms of

Discuss current practice in recruitment and selection in the hospitality and tourism industry in the context of achieving employee 'fit'

2537 words - 10 pages hospitality and tourism is widely practicing good HR policies, including systematic recruitment and selection processes to encourage culture of commitment and have employee 'fit'. However, it would be completely wrong to say that no efforts are being made in this direction: Hoque's (1999) finding of trainability as a major selection criteria for Hotels in comparison to manufacturing industry is significant in this relation since it shows that

Strategies of Employee Appraisal

1631 words - 7 pages . Employees can follow increase or decrease in their performances, and realize their strengths and weakness with the historical feedback. Appraisal shows results which is useful for the administrative area. Those results are useful in complete range of personnel decisions. Decisions on some categories like salary, promotion, retention/termination, recognition of performance, layoffs, and identification of poor performers can be made by the results

Dismissal Meeting

1575 words - 7 pages , 2012). Downsizing and mass layoffs can be traumatic for those who are laid off and for those who survive the downsizing and remain employed. The manager’s ability to communicate effectively and regularly with the employees after layoffs will prove invaluable in the long term. People may show signs of anxiety, lack of commitment, and even a decrease in productivity and creativity. In the weeks and months that follow a layoff or reorganization

Similar Essays

Dental Implants: Criteria For Implant Case Selection

1152 words - 5 pages . International Journal of Prosthodontics 2002; 15:413-4. 3. Proper case selection is the most important aspect of implant risk management. Dental expressions 2008;1:1-4. 4. Hatim NA, Al–Rawee RY, Tawfeeq BA. Criteria for selection of Implant cases. Al–Rafidain Dent J 2006;6:161-70. 5. Mckinney RV. Contemporary Implant Dentistry. Part II. 1st ed. Mosby Co. London. 1993; pp: 355-390. 6. Misch CE. Implant Treatment. Contemporary Implant Dentistry. 1st ed

Reviewing The Entry Selection Criteria For Mph In The United Kingdom

1422 words - 6 pages To the author’s knowledge, this is the first study to review the entry selection criteria for MPH in the United Kingdom. Student selection is an important part of SOPH activities and all course directors interviewed felt that their selection process was adequate, since they had achieved good results over the years. There are a few differences in the student selection process used by SOPH in the United Kingdom, with directors playing different

Mitigating The Impact Of Layoffs Essay

1396 words - 6 pages (2001) and Marshall and Broas (2009) also point out that the selection criteria must be well defined and the reasons for their selection documented. Marshall and Broas (2009) and Segal (2001) state that seniority is the most objective selection criterion. However, according to Marshall and Broas (2009), by using seniority as the sole selection criterion, health care companies run the risk of losing employees with expertise, initiative, and

Analysis Of Downsizing

9536 words - 38 pages downsize enter it with no formal plan, with disastrous results (Hargie and Tourish, 2004). The planning process should include a plan for forming a vision for downsizing, communicating that vision through an announcement, defining the restructuring/layoffs necessary with employee involvement, implementing the downsizing, measuring the results and adjusting.Form a vision for downsizing: Downsizing is not a short term task. It is carefully planned