Self Defense Post 9 11 Essay

3417 words - 14 pages

When we are attacked with force, we have natural response to want to defend our selves. Whether attacked as individuals, as a group or collectively as a nation, we have the inherit right to use measures of self-defense in response to acts of violence and aggression. Article 51 of the United Nations Charter makes this point extremely clear: “nothing…shall impair the inherit right of individual or collective self defense if an armed attack occurs against a member of the United Nations..” Before 9-11, it was understood within the international community that ‘armed’ attacks were planned and executed by nation States against other sovereign States. According to Theresa Reinold however, the terrorist attacks on the pentagon and the world trade center on September 11th, 2001, has changed the definition of an ‘armed’ attack; effectively changing who is to be held accountable. It is thus necessary to explore the reasons for this change as well as its future implications for the international community in general. In this essay I will examine the criteria for the State’s right to self-defense as it applies to state weakness, irregular warfare and international law in our post 9-11 world. Furthermore, while such change may appear to be linear and expected, Naomi Klein offers a different narrative aimed at exposing the hidden agenda of changing such definition to exploit war for financial gain.
At 11:00 pm on September 11th, 2001, the George W. Bush administration of the United States declared war against Osama Bin Laden and the Al-Qaeda terrorist network. This declaration of war was a direct response to the attacks on the Pentagon and the World Trade Center. This was an unprecedented declaration of war because it was not directed at a particular State per se, rather against a non-state actor and its ideology: terrorism. George W. Bush declared Afghanistan to be a ‘safe-haven’ for Al-Qaeda operatives and other terrorists alike.
‘Safe-havens’ are described as under-governed, ill-governed or un-governed states in which terrorists can freely organize, plan, raise funds, communicate, train and operate in relative security because of inadequate governance capacity, or will, or both. Safe Havens come into existence when States are unable or unwilling to exercise territorial control. Territorial control should be viewed as the state’s ability to govern, police and protect citizens within their territorial borders. When states cannot do this, it allows for terrorist networks to operate without the presence of an overarching authority.

In State Weakness, Irregular Warfare, and the Right to Self-Defense post 9-11, Reinold claims that safe-havens are not a novel phenomenon, and that they have been an ongoing, yet negligible humanitarian problem for the world. After Al-Qaeda launched their attacks from Afghan soil, she argues that the existence of ‘safe havens’ have now become a serious threat to global peace and security. While they may have always...

Find Another Essay On Self-Defense Post 9-11

Preserving Civil Liberties In A Post-9/11 America

3457 words - 14 pages the ACLU, is appalled. "I think our forefathers would roll over in their graves. I don't care if it's never used, granting government that kind of power is a problem" (qtd. in Penn 1).The Patriot Act plays upon the fears of a post-9/11 America in order to justify thetrampling of the Bill of Rights and the rights it guarantees. Congress needs to go back to the drawing boards and find a better solution to preventing terrorism. As Americans

Sikh Issues in a Post 9/11 World

1414 words - 6 pages Sikh Issues in a Post 9/11 World The Muslim Sikh community in the United States have been facing violence and discrimination against their people increasingly since 9/11. FBI: Dramatic Spike in Hate Crimes Targeting Muslims. (2012) . Retrieved from http://www.splcenter.org/get-informed/intelligence-report/browse-all-issues/2012/spring/fbi-dramatic-spike-in-hate-crimes-targetin. According to the FBI, Anti-Muslim has soared by 50% in 2010 since

The Significance of Technical Escort Units in a Post 9-11 WMD Domain

1563 words - 7 pages In a Post 9-11 WMD Environment The world is changing, becoming smaller and more dangerous it seems, and the events of September 11th, 2001, brought a distinct reality crashing down around us. The reality was that we could be hit on the home front, after all. The enemy determined to do so harbors zero concern for the “rules of war” and will stop at nothing to inflict the greatest amount of carnage and casualties possible. As the government and

Causes of Psychological Trauma and Its Effects on Young Arab Americans Post 9/11

1075 words - 4 pages (Hussein Ibish 2008). The unreasonable deportations and secret detentions were also the major traumatizing acts of the government. Most of the people taken into custody (post 9/11) were not even suspected with involvement in any form of terrorist activities (Ibrish 2003). In some cases, people were detained because of stupid and inappropriate reasons. The government has not only detained the majority of young Arab Americans, it has also

Comparison/Contrast Essay Pre and Post 9-11         How drastically has our

979 words - 4 pages Comparison/Contrast Essay Pre and Post 9-11 How drastically has our world changed following the tragic events that our country faced on September 11th.? If you believe the pundits that espouse their timely, invaluable opinions twenty-four hours a day on cable news then you would have be able to come to no other conclusion than that the world will never be the same. The news anchors will tell you nightly that not one of us will ever be safe again

Comparison/Contrast Essay Pre and Post 9-11         How drastically has our

938 words - 4 pages Comparison/Contrast Essay Pre and Post 9-11         How drastically has our world changed following the tragic events that our country faced on September 11th.? If you believe the pundits that espouse their timely, invaluable opinions twenty-four hours a day on cable news then you would have be able to come to no other conclusion than that the world will never be the same. The news anchors will tell you nightly that not one of us

Chaos in the skies – the airline industry pre- and post-9/11

1252 words - 5 pages Chaos in the skies - the airline industry pre and post 9/11 Case Study Chaos in the skies- the airline industry pre and post 9/11 1. Introduction The terrorist attack on the New York World Trade Center and the Pentagon on September 11, 2001, when civilian planes were turned into guided missiles flown by suicide bombers driven by religious fundamentalism and hatred for the United States not only seared themselves into the consciousness of the

Changes to the US Government in the Post-9/11 Period

1459 words - 6 pages The period of American history that we live in today is commonly referred to as the “post 9/11” period due to the September 11 attacks in 2001. Often characterized by a heightened sense of suspicion among the American people, a hawkish American foreign policy and last but not least, a rise in surveillance for the increased the security of the state. It’s been known for some time that the National Security Agency (NSA) has been involved in

Rhetorical Analysis of President’s Address To The Nation Post 9/11

1650 words - 7 pages Rhetorical analysis assignment: President’s Address to the Nation Since the 9/11 attacks, the Bush administration has been calling every citizens and every nations to support his Middle East policy. Nonetheless, the U.S. has been involved in the middle-east struggle for more than half of the century, wars were waged and citizens were killed. Yet, political struggles and ideological conflicts are now worse than they were under Clinton’s

Shades of Gray: The Importance of Seeing the Other Side in a Post 9-11 World of Black and White

10175 words - 41 pages Shades of Grey: The importance of Seeing the Other Side in a Post 9-11 World of Black and WhiteOn September 11, 2001 at 8:45am American Airlines, flight number 11 out of Boston MA, carrying 81 passengers and 11 crew members crashed into the north tower of the World Trade Center and exploded into flames. At 9:03am, United Airlines, flight 175, also out of Boston, carrying 56 passengers and 9 crew members crashed into the south tower. Soon after

Connections between Lewis Lapham's essay, "Who and What is America?" and Christopher Edley, Jr.'s essay "The New American Dilemma: Racial Profiling Post-9/11"

1295 words - 5 pages and the politicians try to categorize Americans and split us into groups turning one against another. Politics turn Democratic Americans against Republican Americans and the media turns white Americans against Americans of color. As a result, the sense of feeling as one nation is lost, causing prejudice, dishonesty, and hate. Christopher Edley, Jr. states in his essay "The New American Dilemma: Racial Profiling Post-9/11" that our diversity is what

Similar Essays

Post 9/11 Afghanistan Essay

938 words - 4 pages Introduction On September 11, 2001 the United States' economy, government, and national defense were left crippled. Members of Al Qaeda, a militant Islamic group, hijacked and crashed planes into two World Trade Center towers, the Pentagon, and an attempted to attack the White House as well (9/11 Commission Report). Al Qaeda controlled many training camps in Afghanistan along with the Taliban, who called themselves the "religious leaders" of

Life Post 9/11: Children Without Parents Essay

1117 words - 4 pages 9/11 we remembered those who were lost and remember the past, as it was the day our nation came together in unison with a sense of patriotism to defend the land of the free and the home of the brave. This is a story we all know how to tell; there is no happy ending, there are some without hope, there are tears of grief, but this story is filled with faith. A vast number of individuals were affected by September 11th, the youngest victim

Post 9/11 Counter Terrorism In New York City

2012 words - 9 pages ://www.npr.org>. Kramer, Marcia. "Exclusive: Elaborate New York City Post-9/11 Security." Central Broadcasting System. CBS, 8 Sept. 2011. Web. 10 Feb. 2014. . Long, Colleen. "Incoming New York City Mayor Inherits Massive Counterterrorism Operation." Buffalo News [Buffalo] Jan. 2014: n. pag. Print. Lucas, Fred. "Obama Invokes MLK, 9/11 While Calling For Changes On NSA Data Collection." The Blaze. The Blaze, 17 Jan. 2014. Web. 31

The Impact Of Stigma For Muslim Americans Post 9/11

2774 words - 12 pages situation is even worse in traditional states. In more Republican-leaning states, only 2 percent of applications by the Muslim candidate received interview invitations compared to 17 percent for the Christian candidate, the study finds. This report confirms the post 9/11 Muslim discrimination in the US. In the years following September 11th, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) reported a staggering 250 percent rise in the number of