This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Self Plagiarism Is Allowed By Jewish Law

1459 words - 6 pages

Ever since the invention of the printing press and other forms of mass reproduction, duplicating the work of another has gone from being a painstaking and time-consuming task to a simple click of a mouse. As society moves towards an electronic-based culture, plagiarism, the act of using another person's words or ideas without giving credit to that person, has become much more prevalent due to the ease with which it can be done. With plagiarism becoming commonplace in colleges and universities, teachers have begun to restrict what can and cannot be submitted to fulfill assignment requirements. As a general rule, a paper that was written by a student for one course may not be handed in again, even by the same student, to satisfy a different course requirement. This is called self-plagiarism, the reuse of one's own work, and is usually not considered an accepted practice in the writing world. However, is self-plagiarism considered a form of stealing according to Jewish law or is it just frowned upon by society.
According to Green, a professor of law, plagiarism is a relatively recent concept which started sometime in the eighteenth century:
It was not, until the Romantic Era of the eighteenth century—when the notion of “authorship” and “originality” emerged as significant cultural values—that the norm of attribution and the taboo of plagiarism came to the fore. As art and literature became viewed as the expression of the unique and autonomous personality of the artist or writer, the crediting of literary sources became an increasingly important concern…it was not until words and ideas could be viewed as “property”—typically, through publication—that “originality” became a significant cultural value, and plagiarism a powerful cultural taboo (176,177).
What Green appears to be saying is that plagiarism is not necessarily illegal; however, society considers the act of passing off another’s ideas as your own to be “a powerful cultural taboo” and should not be allowed for ethical reasons. Similarly, we find that although there are ethical problems that can arise from unauthorized duplication, plagiarism is not inherently illegal according to U.S. law:
The most common vehicle used by owners of material to challenge plagiarism is the Copyright Act. However, the law and plagiarism intersect only imperfectly. Plagiarism is not a legal term, and though an instance of plagiarism might seem to be the quintessential act of wrongful copying, it does not necessarily constitute a violation of copyright law. Copyright protection applies only to original works of authorship fixed in any tangible medium of expression. (Mawdsley 261)
However, in Jewish law, there appears to be a general agreement that ordinary plagiarism would indeed be considered stealing. The Pirkei Avot (usually translated as Ethics of the Fathers), a Mishnaic tract, states that, “he who reports something in the name of the one who said it brings redemption into the world.” Although the theory...

Find Another Essay On Self-Plagiarism is Allowed by Jewish Law

Racial Profiling by Law Enforcement is Not Justified

1105 words - 4 pages risk of having an obtrusive body scan or being patted down by a complete stranger if they are wary of your nationality. All while Little Johnny and Suzy Smith are welcome to continue on with their trip without so much as a second glance after passing through the metal detector. An interesting fact, it is reported on that, “26 states have no law explicitly prohibiting racial profiling. 46 states do not ban racial profiling based

God is Potrayed as Law in Before the Law by Franz Kafka

1448 words - 6 pages do we distinguish the characters. The man from the country has been contracted to the embodiment of a relentless craving, the doorkeeper is restricted to the capacity of an impediment, the personality of the Law remains covered up. However, once we acknowledge the sort of actuality characterized by these confinements, the story represents no issue. Yet it is clearly meant to be a parable. This is proposed by its context in The Trail. Some

"Mortal Law Verses Divine Law"-- In the play Antigone, there is a clear conflict between the written law made by the king, and the higher law, dictated by the religious beliefs of the time

1057 words - 4 pages created conflicts in society, as described by the play Antigone by Sophocles. In this play, there is a clear conflict between the written law made by the king, and the higher law, dictated by the religious beliefs of the time.When Creon, the king of Thebes, decrees that the body of Polyneices should be left unburied, he believes he is doing the right thing. He sees this law as good for the people because they will see him as a good, strong king

Aristotle- Man is the worst animal when separated by law and justice - College - Essay

554 words - 3 pages POSC 202 ARISTOTLE- LAWS AND JUSTICE In the aspect of philosophy and the studies illustrated by the wise, one in particular catches my attention as stated by Aristotle, on the significance of law and justice together with its contribution to man or societies. Aristotle’s philosophical theory that states that … “man is the worst of all animals when he is separated from law and justice.” If man is the worst animal separated from law and justice

The increasing number of accidents in transportation is caused by lack awareness of self-discipline and half-hearted punishment

652 words - 3 pages errors is a big factor in accidents of transportation.So the pople’s awareness of self discipline in transportation has to be increased optimally. In conclusion, The accidents of transportation especially in the road is happened by human errors largely. We hope that the people’s awareness of self discipline can be increased more better.They have to be be aware to law of traffict while driving a vehicle on the road especially.So, The accidents of transportation especially in the road can be decreased.

"Much Ado about nothing" - "Changing self" can be an internal process but is often influenced by external factors

547 words - 2 pages In the play "Much Ado About Nothing" written by William Shakespeare, the process of changing self is mostly shown by two of the main characters, Beatrice and Benedick. Their hatred for each other is clear in the first act. This is shown through a process in which they are tricked into loving each other, in the end their feelings of hatred are overcome by feelings of love and passion.In act one, scene one, Beatrice and Benedick have their first

A Misrepresentation Is Defined At Common Law As A "Statement Of Fact Made By One Party To The Other Party, Which Is False

1913 words - 8 pages From looking at the facts laid out by Bruce in his letter to me regarding his purchase of a second hand Mercedes from Asbury Motors it seems that the most likely action is that of misrepresentation. A Misrepresentation is defined at common law as a "statement of fact made by one party to the other party, which is false. And while not necessarily forming a term of the contract, is yet one of the main reasons which induces the later to enter into

Rebecca by Daphne Du maurier. Essay is a description of the Narrator's perception of self at three points in the novel. Quotes are included

731 words - 3 pages In Rebecca, by Daphne Du Maurier, the narrator's perception of self changes over the course of the romance novel. This can be observed by scrutinizing her perception of self at the beginning of the novel, soon after she arrives at Manderly, the famous mansion where her new husband, Maxim DeWinter, lives, and after she hears Maxim's revelation: he killed his first wife, Rebecca, because he thought she would have a son who would not be his, yet

Looking for Alibrandi by Melina Marchetta Josie is a different person at the beginning of the novel than she is at the end. How do these changes in her self come about?

702 words - 3 pages In this novel (Looking for Alibrandi) Josephine Alibrandi is seen as an illegitimate 17-year-old girl who is self-centred, ignorant and sensitive about her illegitimacy and her reputation and what people say about her behind her back. She is also described as confused because she isn't sure where she stands in life, whether she is an Australian or and Italian, and is paranoid in thinking because she is of Italian background she is constantly

this essay is about blasphemy in pakistan it is a law by which anyone can be punished who tries to insult islam , god and the prophet in any manner

1546 words - 6 pages favour into the bargain, when they are pressing charges under this law. This is zeal sanctioned by law and clothed in self-righteousness.I draw no analogies but consider also the case of the sectarian terrorist, he who murders in the name of Islam. Far from feeling any remorse for his actions, he glories in them because he is convinced that when he kills an 'infidel' he has struck a blow for the faith and has thereby earned for himself a place

Take the book 'A Civil Action' by Jonathan Harr and outline this case. Discuss the problem of people whose health is affected by toxic industrial pollution in obtaining compensation under civil law

2643 words - 11 pages employed the tort theories of negligence, nuisance and strict liability.Toxic tort victims, like those at Woburn, have often used a claim of negligence when seeking compensation. This means that the defendant's release of the toxic chemical or hazardous materials amounted to negligent conduct. Negligence is conduct or way of practice that, 'falls below the standards established by law for the protection of others against unreasonable risk.' However

Similar Essays

Title:Jewish Ethics On Abortion Author: Brett Novick It Answers The Question: "Is Abortion Allowed In Jewish Law?" And Under What Conditions It Is Allowed. 837 Words 3 Pages

875 words - 4 pages standing idly upon the blood of your neighbor and you are breaking Jewish law. In addition, if the mother is forced to have sexual relations with somebody against their own will they may also abort because of the psychological harm that may cause both the child and the mother. Even though it is a mitzvah to " fruitful and multiply..."8 this commandment is only talking about having children after you are married.In conclusion, one may not abort

Thou Shalt Not Steal: Should Self Plagiarism Be Allowed In Colleges

1406 words - 6 pages world. However, is self-plagiarism really considered a form of stealing or is it actually allowed and just frowned upon by professors? According to Green, a professor of law, plagiarism is a relatively recent concept which started sometime in the eighteenth century: It was not, until the Romantic Era of the eighteenth century—when the notion of “authorship” and “originality” emerged as significant cultural values—that the norm of attribution and the

Why The Religious Law About Pure Sex Is Beneficial For Jewish Orthodox Women?

2402 words - 10 pages ).Therefore ,by abstaining from sex for almost two weeks,due to impurity of menstruation ,Jewish Orthodox woman gain several psychological benefits such as renewal of sexual interest between husband and wife, feelings of personal and collective efficacy and increased self esteem . By keeping the “separation” law, women increase the sexual desire, which gives them power to control their sexuality and be sexually expressive. Finally, it gives their

Racial Profiling By Law Enforcement Is Unjustifiable

1449 words - 6 pages standard by which a police officer has the right to make an arrest, conduct a personal or property search, or to obtain a warrant for arrest” (Silverman). Many people throughout today’s generation believe that police officers are most likely stop or arrest individials because of their race. Assuming that in individual is breaking the law because of the color of their skin is not an appropriate reason to state probable cause, however many cops engage