This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Senate Election Reform Essay

1214 words - 5 pages

The turn of the 20th century brought a tremendous amount of change to the United States, its government and its citizens. A greater amount of prosperity and technology increased citizens exposure to information. With this information came empowerment, with empowerment came the ability to make more informed decisions about government at all levels. As people learned more they were no longer accepting of the status quo of the States appointing their Senators. With this, pressure came and ultimately the 17th Amendment, allowing people to directly elect their Senators. The 17th Amendment came relatively easy but it was not without its own controversy then or now.
The 17th Amendment is a relatively simple and straight forward document. It states simply that Senators will be elected by popular vote and that Senators will serve for six years and have one vote in the senate. This supersedes Article 1, Section 3, Clauses 1 and 2 of the Constitution:
The Senate of the United States shall be composed of two Senators from each State, chosen by the Legislature thereof, for six years; and each Senator shall have one Vote.
With the founding of the United States the founding fathers understood that the primarily agrarian society would not necessarily have the information on hand to elect their senators. “The argument was that legislatures were more able than the electorate to give sober and reflective thought to the selection, and by doing so would take a greater supportive interest in the fledgling national government” (Guide to Congress, 6th ed., vol. 2, 968). Thus the Constitution was written to give the states that power in order to have qualified educated men and after all, the members of the Constitutional Convention had been picked by the state legislatures. Although in a draft of the Constitution “The Senate to consist of persons elected to serve during good behaviour; their elections made by electors chosen for that purpose by the people” (Senate Report No. 691). As the United States developed after the civil war and people gained greater access to news and education they began to see the corruption within the senate appointment process. This started a push for electoral reform and the progressive movement.
It should not be over looked either that the election of Senators by popular vote would not only leave the nomination and election of the members of the legislature upon the simple issue of their fitness, but it would place every candidate before the people, where his views and relationship to the public interests of the State could be known and understood by all.
In the first eighty years of Congress, only nine resolutions proposing a constitutional amendment for direct election of senators were introduced in Congress. In the 1870s and 1880s the number increased, and by 1912 no fewer than 287 such joint resolutions had been introduced. Not until 1892 was a resolution reported favorably from committee in the House. From 1893 to...

Find Another Essay On Senate Election Reform

The case for repeal Essay

1830 words - 8 pages 17th Amendment is that it was needed to prevent and reduce the spread of corruption in the election process. Some people believed that Senate seats could, and were regularly purchased by candidates running for office. Progressives believed that the 17th Amendment would solve this issue by taking the immoral state legislators out of the equation, and replacing them with the citizen population of the states. They’re assertion was if Senators were

"Explain the impact that the dismissal of Gough Whitlam and the labour party has had on the civic life of Australia in the twentieth century."

895 words - 4 pages Senate. Whitlam tried to tough it out but Kerr stepped in on November 11 and withdrew Whitlam's commission to form a government. He installed Fraser as caretaker Prime Minister and called for a full election of both Houses of Parliament on December 13.The events of 1975 caused enormous controversy at the time and there is still bitter dispute about the political and moral correctness of the decisions that were made.In the domestic sphere, Labor

Edmund Muskie's 1958 Senate Campaign

1731 words - 7 pages popularity allowed him to reestablish the Democratic Party in Maine politics. He used his art of talking and persuasion to let the voters see what his points of views on certain issues were. This talent allowed him to be one of the most charming but yet tenacious candidates for the 1958 Senate campaign. The 1958 Senate campaign election is an election that will always be a remembered in the state of Maine. This election is referred to as the “mid-term

The Rise and Fall of Gaius Gracchus

1912 words - 8 pages Tiberius spoke of worry that his younger brother was soon to follow in part and, therefore stopped. The Senate had returned to the previous nature of how politics worked and did not want such an exceptional orator altering the balance. Gaius, to the favor of the opposition, received election to the position of quaestor in Sardinia under Orestes instead of the tribunate. Although, his time as tribune did not come, his plan for reform built

The Canadian Governing System is not Fair or Democratic

1391 words - 6 pages will inevitably be more incidents like these unless the Senate is reformed. Thankfully, there are several possible ways to reform the Senate as to make it a more democratic institute. The Senate, undemocratic as it is, obviously needs some tweaks and changes in the system to make it more so. The Canadian Senate should reform entirely into a triple-E Senate (Elected, Efficient, Equal). In the Triple E Senate, Senators should be elected by the

Contributition Of The Building Of Rome

577 words - 2 pages Asia Minor & Syria. Pompey's absence from Rome allowed his opponents in the Senate to take control of the capitol and veto his plans for land reform. Pompey formed an alliance with two other generals (Crassus & Juilus Caesar) to form the first triumvirate. His election with Crassus as consuls in 55 BC was the last popular election in Rome before the Republic collapsed in civil war. But Caesar's ambitions led to a gap between the triumvirs

Political Campaign Reform

549 words - 2 pages Threat of Demagogic Oligarchy" shows that over $250 million was spent on the political campaigns in 1988 and in the election of 1990, half a billion dollars was spent in Senate and House campaigns. More and more money is being spent every election with no sign of slowing down.This kind of power given to these broadcasting lobbyists is ridiculous. This is the reason why campaigns have so many problems with funding. With so much emphasis of an

Campaign finance reform

1379 words - 6 pages Are our senators and congressmen voices of the people, or voices of the special interests? Campaign finance reform has been an issue in almost every election in the past 10 years. Those candidates that have lots of money to spend are quiet about it, but those candidates who do not complain about it and make an issue of it. Most Americans would agree that the campaign fundraising process must be changed, but little action has been taken.Among the

Account for the survival of the Electoral College?

1825 words - 7 pages election saw the emergence of a popular third party known as the Reform Party led by Ross Perot. The threat of such an event occurring was likely to occur as Perot had quite popular support only for Perot to pull out earlier voluntarily to prevent that from happening. Reform could prevent this but then you can get caught up in the debate that the party system of America could change. Conservatives would not like this.Further exploring the faults

Electoral College

1147 words - 5 pages (currently 270 of 538) is required to win. If no candidate receives a majority, then the House of Representatives elect the President, and the Senate, a process known as contingent election, elects the Vice President. (North Harris College Library, 2003)The Electoral Collage as used todayIn practice, this formulation also prohibits any person working for the federal government in either a civilian or a military capacity from serving as an elector

Changing Role and Responsibilities of the Roman Senate under Augustus

1042 words - 4 pages The Senate began to see Augustus as one of their own after he had won their trust, and later only after hesitations because he far outranked them in power and prestige. From this, we can see that the Senate considered Augustus a powerful ally of sorts, and Augustus needed the Senate to uphold, on the surface, the fundamental premise of Roman political thinking, since anyone of importance in the political world was a part of the Roman

Similar Essays

The Fall Of The Roman Empire

598 words - 2 pages use his army as force to get what he wanted. There are many reasons why they are both responsible.The Senate did many things to help the collapse of the Roman Republic. They would not carry out any reform measures that the people wanted because they didn't want to have to give up anything that was theirs. They would not give up any more land to the people in the army and who were poor and did not have a nice place to live. They also lost all of

The Dismissal Of Gough Whitlam Essay

553 words - 2 pages government was not responsible for these issues they were blamed for having no answer to the problems.Malcolm Fraser, leader of the Liberal opposition believed these reasons showed Labors inability to govern. Knowing from opinion polls his party would win Fraser wished to call a general election for the House of Representatives, so he aid his party would not vote on money bills until a general election was called. Whitlam wanted a half-senate

Removal Of The Canadian Senate In 21st Century Democracy

2697 words - 11 pages In 2012, the Canadian Senate became embroiled in a scandal that is still ongoing, and still having an effect on Canadian political life today. At times in the 20th century, there have been calls for the reform, or even the abolition of the Senate completely. The current scandal has resulted a renewal of the frequent calls for reform that have frequently accompanied the many questionable actions of Senators. The structure of the Senate, and its

Senator Roger Wicker Essay

1078 words - 4 pages . Roger F. Wicker was elected to the United States Senate on November 4, 2008, and currently serves with Senator Thad Cochran representing the state of Mississippi ( Each state always has two senators in the Senate regardless of its population size. Since there are fifty states that means there are one hundred senators currently serving in the Senate. Out of the one hundred senators, one-third of them come up for election