This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Senior English And The Benefits Of Using An Interdisciplinary Approach

1841 words - 8 pages

Article Summary
David Fletcher’s article ‘Interdisciplinary perspectives in teaching secondary school English’ discusses the issues around English being taught as an isolated subject. Fletcher recommends that English teachers strive to integrate other subjects into English, and suggests that this will result in student engagement and better results. While he acknowledges that English’s more traditional goals should still be achieved, they should “be pursued in conjunction with the added interest that various disciplines can offer” (1980, p. 81). Fletcher addresses the interdisciplinary debate by drawing from other scholars, giving evidence as to why interdisciplinary approaches are ...view middle of the document...

The following section discusses the mix of English with other humanities subjects, such as history, psychology, communications, theatre, sociology, and science. Fletcher claims that the integration of these subjects will give students a broader knowledge than traditional English, involve them in a range of genres and mediums, and stimulate discussion.
The final section of the article is focussed on English linking with social concerns. Fletcher stresses the importance of English teaching social context, and giving the students ideas to consider outside of the text. Fletcher suggests that English should help students gain knowledge of things like advertising semantics, labels, legalese, contracts as well as social issues like women’s rights.
Overall, the article addresses the issue of “discipline-centred” approaches to teaching, and states that the way to better results with student learning is through a more interdisciplinary approach. The article gives recommendations as to how we can achieve these results.

Colleague Response
The article garnered interesting responses from my colleagues on the online forum, with most agreeing with the article’s content. After briefly summarising the article, I posed the following questions to my peers:
1) What benefits or downfalls can you identify surrounding the use of interdisciplinary perspectives in English?
2) Have you seen/used/experienced any examples of interdisciplinary practice in the classroom, and why did it work/not work?
3) What ideas do you have for integrating other disciplines into your own English classroom in the future?
4) This article was written a number of years ago, from an American perspective. In what ways can we apply it to a current New Zealand context?
1) In order to collate the response, I will discuss each of these questions separately. Question 1 had a lot of similar answers, my peers all seemed to agree that interdisciplinary approaches were beneficial. In particular, it was frequently stated that interdisciplinary approaches makes content more relevant for students; teaches life skills; makes English more engaging and interesting; deepens understanding by giving context; shows students how multifaceted English is; shows students English’s practical applications; and encourages students to read.
There were two downfalls that were identified, the first was the issue of making more work for the teacher, particularly in relation to the career education. Stacey suggested that “teaching students English in ways that relate to their chosen vocation would be a difficult undertaking, simply due to the fact that in a classroom of 28 students, each individual is likely to have different career aspirations, or hasn't a clue what they want to do after school.” The other barrier was to do with the little flexibility of the curriculum at a senior level where these theories are ideal, but there would simply be no time to integrate them into rigidity of NCEA assessments and student...

Find Another Essay On Senior English and the benefits of using an interdisciplinary approach

The Benefits of Using Customer Databases

1156 words - 5 pages customers’ data because it required a lot of time and great effort. Nowadays, customer databases are used by most organizations to help collecting and analyzing consumers’ information in an easier and flexible way. Identifying target clients, reinforcing competitive advantage, and improving product development are three benefits of using a customer database. The first benefit of using customer databases is recognizing target customers. When an

The Benefits of Using Kitchen Floor Mats

941 words - 4 pages your leg muscles pain and strain on the hard floors in the kitchen. However, foam mats acts as a cushion to your feet and makes you stand for a longer period in the kitchen. They are usually heavy and can be placed at the front of the sinks, countertops, islands, etc. One of the benefits of having a foam floor mat is that it prevent breakage like bottles, plates, jars, glass, etc and protects the floor from cracks and damages. They are moist and

BENEFITS OF USING AN OPEN SOURCE CONTENT MANAGEMENT SYSTEM

1625 words - 7 pages kind of system are developed and improved often in a collaboratively manner relying on the input of many. A few of the biggest players in this industry are; Word press, Drupal and Joomla. Each of these big players have their benefits for instance when one decide to chose word press this is what he or she will get; it allows one to some basic features like; themes installation, plug-in installation, widgets, full user registration and many more

Comparison of Socialism and Capitalism - Senior English - Comparison Essay

1058 words - 5 pages Socialism Vs Capitalism Socialism and Capitalism are two very different governmental economic systems. Socialists believe that the government should regulate businesses, trade, and distribution of wealth. On the other hand we have capitalism: In a capitalist society, industry is controlled by private owners for profit. There are what appear to be great things about both sides, yet also aspects that could go very wrong. We will be examining and

Women in Hamlet and the Stranger - Senior English - Essay

1046 words - 5 pages that his selfish father burdened him with. Hamlet decides that his mission is more important to him than love. "If thou dost marry, I'll give thee this plague for thy dowry: be thou as chaste as ice, as pure as snow, thou shalt not escape calumny." (III.i.89-91) Now that Hamlet has finished Using Ophelia it is ok for him to just toss her to the side and complete his task. He has an internal conflict but in the end he is willing to cast her out

The Disadvantage of Using English to Teach Mathematics and Science

1504 words - 6 pages but what can be seen, the lack of PPSMI has overcome all the benefits of PPSMI. Many people do not agree to the implementation of PPSMI. There are disadvantages of using English language to teach Mathematics and Science the effect to Malaysia language, lower student achievement and increase a lot of cost to education. PPSMI been enshrined as a policy decision of the Malaysian government as a result of the Special Cabinet meeting on July 19, 2002

An Approach of Energy Efficient and Secure Data Transfer Using Multicast Routing Protocol in Ad Hoc Networks

585 words - 3 pages itself. Hence, in core based multicast tree, shortest path from the source node to the destination node cannot be guaranteed, but only one tree would be needed to connect the set of the source nodes to a set of the receiver nodes. And many MANET has limited energy resources (battery), and each node operates in unattended manner. So energy efficient is an import design consideration for these networks. So we proposed energy efficient paper using

An approach of Energy Efficient and secure data transfer using multicast routing protocol in Ad Hoc Networks

946 words - 4 pages An Ad-hoc network is a wireless network. It uses high frequency radio waves for nodes or device communications which increase mobility but decrease the ranges rather than using communication cables between the nodes. Ad-hoc network consists of no infrastructure and no fixed base station and centralized administrator. So, each node in this network act as router or host for direct communication with each other. Then nodes are freely move from one

Benefits of Using Computer

932 words - 4 pages everything that I was looking for in a few minutes by using the computer. This is one of the many benefits of using computers. The benefits of using the computer are online banking, using the computer for research, and online shopping. First, the use of computer in online banking is very helpful nowadays. For example, one of its benefits is the unlimited service during the day and the night. This is a good benefit because if a person needs

Analysis of William Wallace using the “Psychoanalytic Approach”

714 words - 3 pages William Wallace Hero or Herod?An Analysis of William Wallace using the "Psychoanalytic Approach""William Wallace, a murderer, a runaway, a patriot, or a thief?" William Wallace led one of the first Scottish revolts against the English in the early 14th Century. His army defeated a much larger and much more powerful English army at Stirling Bridge, they captured Stirling Castle, and then ravaged northern England, for which Wallace was knighted

Language Matters: An editorial critique using Orwell's "Politics and the English Language"

676 words - 3 pages Language Matters In his essay, "Politics and the English Language," George Orwell contends that the English language is decaying but that this decay should not be considered inevitable. He lists several "tricks by means of which the work of prose construction is habitually dodged" [682] and argues that much more than a matter of linguistic aesthetics alone, these tricks are symptomatic of--and help lead to additional--problems of

Similar Essays

How An Interdisciplinary Approach Has Assisted In The Understanding Of Human Language

1922 words - 8 pages How an Interdisciplinary Approach Has Assisted in the Understanding of Human Language All perspectives provide a guide and include more than one distinct theory but within an approach they share certain basic principles and assumptions which give them a distinct ‘flavour’ or identity, The Behaviourist approach studied observable behaviour, and rejected introspection for being to subjective John Watson changed psychology

Inquiry Into The Application Of The Process And The Length Approaches In China's Senior English Writing

4834 words - 19 pages express themselves freely and fluently, and how teachers can help students become more successful readers and writers, etc. There is an urgent need for writing class to help students develop skills in using language by experiencing a whole writing process in the comparatively authentic contexts with the purpose of writing.This paper attempts to provide some guidance to students' English writing in senior middle school of China. First, I specifically

An Essay About How The Book "The Survival Of The Bark Canoe" Is Interdisciplinary

952 words - 4 pages them. He is in tune with his canoes. When the canoes get damaged on the trip, it is Henri that can find the way to fix them even though he has never before done the type of repair needed before.Finally we get to core area D--consciousness and reality. I have to say that here I am getting stuck as to how this relates to The Survival of the Bark Canoe. This is an area that I find more personal. I find the book and this core area combine to make me

The Benefits Of Learning English Essay

583 words - 2 pages Many people think that it is not important to learn any foreign language,but who speaks another language can be able to broaden his knowledge. In Saudi Arabia students in government schools start learning English in the sixth grade and it is not concentrated learning because of the limitation of the classes and the books is not well developed.English is an international language that most people are using it. The well developed countries such as