Sensible Censorship Essay

1107 words - 4 pages

Sensible Censorship?
In Plato’s Republic, Socrates claimed that stories affect the souls of those who hear them. Given this, he went on to argue that censorship was not only necessary but also beneficial to society. Socrates wanted to censor portions of poetry, the arts, and sciences that were not productive or beneficial to society. He believed that poetry was neither philosophical nor pragmatic and did not lead to true knowledge. Rather, he found it to be unethical, leading to desires and passions. He thus declared it inferior to the practical arts and lacking in educational value.
I agree with Socrates’ goal to protect the world from such falsehoods. Our minds are like sponges, and in order to protect against the absorption/effects of unnecessary and harmful practices, there must be a filter. Such a filter would protect/preserve that which is moral and good in society, including the innocence of the youth. This can be encouraged by banning the inappropriate elements of popular culture, including suggestive movie content, explicit song lyrics, and false information shared and displayed in the media and replacing them with beneficial practices.
So how much does the world affect us? Can these “harmless stories” really harm our souls? Yes! We are a product of our environment. We mimic those around us to be accepted. We conform to what society deems normal or desirable in an effort to “fit in”. For example, a student can go to Baylor University, major in engineering, meet some supportive and encouraging “nerd” friends, and join a life group at church. That same student might just as easily have attended the University of Texas, joined a sorority, embraced the “party life” and gotten pregnant.
Young, preteen girls growing up with (the perfect) “Barbie” receive the message that “beauty” is defined by being fit, tan, and blonde. They are exposed to cultural messages that “they are not good enough”, often resulting in problems with self worth/esteem, depression, and eating disorders. A multimillion dollar cosmetic surgery industry suggests that we are receptive to messages about physical beauty and compelled to adapt to/become what society identifies as “ideal” and that this somehow completes us. Consider also television commercials and the entire advertizing industry. Obviously if such messages were ineffective in steering our thoughts and spending choices toward a desired service or product, they would cease to exist!
No one would spend millions on Superbowl ads if they did not impact perceptions/spending favorably toward company products. There are million and billion dollar industries that prey upon the soul.

All such non-philosophical, non-beneficial messages threaten to corrupt society. Undeniably, we live in a vastly different world than Socrates. We live in world that is much different from what it was like forty years ago. Today’s society holds completely different values and morals. The “Brady Bunch”,...

Find Another Essay On Sensible Censorship

In response to the prompt: "We're not morons": governments should butt out of young people's lives

1098 words - 4 pages “We’re limiting your rights for your own good.” It is true that Australian teenagers have rights. These rights should not be trampled. And there are some extremely important rights of which Australian teens have been robbed.Contrary to popular opinion, the rights which we, the teenagers of Australia, are most lacking are not associated with our freedom to drink alcohol. They are not related to internet censorship. They circumvent

Technology and The Workplace Essay

1776 words - 7 pages for the standards that are included in a cipher of ethics. Professional standards for HIM encompass the importance of education and technical competency, persevering safety, facts and figures validity and correctness, truthfulness, compassion, and dedication to providing quality services in expert roles. Decision-making criteria for work decisions can include technological feasibility, sensible cost, legality, available staff expertise, measures

Legislative Limits: Government’s Influence on Technology

6506 words - 26 pages to promote a free space for citizens and put few limits on the fluidity of information. While most governments fall between these two extremes, the extent of their control is determined by both the government’s influence and the individuality of the citizens. China China’s censorship policies of Internet content are infamous for its prohibitive qualities. Since the mid-90’s, China has been restricting the content their citizens can view. The

Pornography Should be Regulated

2343 words - 9 pages When deliberating over whether access to pornography should be prohibited, four areas of contention must be elaborated upon and evaluated critically to provide a sensible basis on which a judgement can be made. Firstly, it must be concluded whether pornography can be classed as a form of speech, and whether it enjoys the same protections as art and literature under the principle. Secondly, works such as those of Catherine MacKinnon can be

Rhetorical and Fallacies in the Article “The Media Violence Myth” by Richard Rhodes

1410 words - 6 pages two are in agreement regarding the subject of violence in the media. To the left-leaning, primary audience, this strategy is most likely to be effective. Because the affiliated readers already scorn those who support censorship, the idea of Grossman being less aesthetically (and thus logically) sensible than Sohn acts as an affirmation of their beliefs; Rhodes is jumping on the bandwagon and giving his audience what it wants to hear. However, a

Teenagers

1397 words - 6 pages correctness surrounding sensitive issues that almost merits censorship. How are we ever going to get to the bottom of things when we are too afraid of offending anyone? You offend everyone that you disagree with. I could be offending someone with this article, but I can't bring myself to care because it's my view and it's their problem if they don't like it. To be fair, the media are not misrepresenting teenagers, they are merely reporting the bad side

The Irish Troubles: Yeat's Poetry

2018 words - 8 pages literature in Ireland was subjected to censorship. By this he knew that nothing was read in Ireland but prayer books, newspapers and popular novels. He also knew that the Irish had been trained by politics and the church to listen. Yeats incorporated the feelings and suppressed emotions of both himself and his fellow countrymen in his writings. His focus was based on the injustice that saturated his country. Although he was aware of the political

Paradise Lost

2292 words - 9 pages freedom of the press from government censorship], Poems of Mr. John Milton (1645, during the English Civil War) [containing "On the Morning of Christ's Nativity," "L'Allegro" and "Il Penseroso"], Of the Tenure of Kings and Magistrates (1649, during the trial of Charles I) [a republican argument that monarchs can rule only with their subjects' consent], Eikonoklastes (The Image Breakers) (1649) [a defense in Latin of the execution of the king

Rousseau & Mill on the Limitations of Freedom

2035 words - 8 pages nature. For example, he says that dictatorship may be necessary in order to restore public order when there is a civil emergency. He also says that censorship may be useful in order to preserve public morality and in order to prevent corruption of social values. Even more unacceptable is his statement that if the prince of a state declares that a particular individual must be put to death, then that individual should be put to death, because the

Psychology of Dreams

3471 words - 14 pages make the dream easier to remember and recite. Several mostly subconscious forces can work against the analyst interpreting a dream, including repression, condensation, and displacement. Repression is the act of self-censorship on the part of the dreamer (Felluga). Many influences cause the dreamer to explain the dream with a slight but significant difference from the original. Also, the dreamer may not discuss a part of the dream, believing it

Hitler as a Totalitarian Dictator

4271 words - 17 pages is admired even today as a great director. Goebbels realised that film was quickly becoming an important media, and if he was too heavy handed with censorship, then people would be bored and stop going to see the films. Coincidentally, the owner of Germany's biggest film company 'UFA', Alfred Hugenburg was a big Nazi supporter. Anti-Semitism still reigned supreme, as Jews could not be actors or directors. Even though films

Similar Essays

Cyberspace Hate Propaganda And Internet Censorship

1238 words - 5 pages contradictory, her style depreciating, and her solution vague but sensible. Despite these shortcomings, the idea to utilize free speech and public education to combat cyberhate is a powerful suggestion in comparison to the social impediments of censorship. Kim begins the article by stressing the growing number of hate groups and web sites on the Internet in the USA. This provides the reader with a reason for concern, but the trend is questioned

Internet Censorship Essay

972 words - 4 pages the net. Many "chat rooms" will not allow profanity on their forums, and although this may seem sensible, most kids who will cuss in a "chat room" will do the same and probably worse at their school. It is their right to choose what language to use; it is their parents who have any reason to care. What is the answer to our censorship problem? Simple, we should never censor the Internet. Parents who worry about their child going

Cencorship Of The Internet Essay

1026 words - 4 pages , and religion. Now those are the main things that people fight to abolish from the net. Many chat rooms will not allow profanity on their forums, and although this may seem sensible, most kids who will cuss in a chat room will do the same and probably worse at their school. It is their right to choose what language to use; it is their parents who have any reason to care.What is the answer to our censorship problem? Simple, we should never censor

Cat’s Cradle: Bans Without Reason Essay

925 words - 4 pages contribution to society. Unfortunately, the few negative views on religion were overshadowing and possibly played a role in the reasoning behind the bans. Minor occurrences of adult content and profanity were also sometimes used. However, the instances were generally sensible and perhaps even essential in showing the reality of certain situations. Evidentially, it is safe to assume the novel’s adult content, profanity, and religious satire were