This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Separation Of Powers Under The Hk Basic Law

6439 words - 26 pages

Electronic copy available at:
Separation of Powers under the HK Basic Law By Danny Gittings Assistant Professor, College of Humanities and Law, HKU SPACE PhD Student, Faculty of Law, University of Hong Kong
The origins of separation of powers are often traced back to the writings of the ancient Greek philosopher Aristotle. But although Aristotle was arguably the first to divide all governmental powers into three separate categories, he considered it unnecessary for these three powers to be exercised by different groups of people.1 That fundamental principle, often known as "separation of persons", lies at the heart of much of separation of power theory. But it did not begin to emerge until more than 1,000 years after Aristotle's death, when it formed part of the rationale for the overthrow of the absolute monarchy and replacement with a system of parliamentary sovereignty during the Civil War in 17th century England.
It was to be another century after that before the doctrine of separation of powers would be finally encapsulated in a way similar to that in which it is understood today, in the works of the 18th century French philosopher Charles-Louis de Secondat, better known as Baron Montesquieu.2 Montesquieu's writings proved influential with at least some of the Founding Fathers who drafted the US Constitution shortly afterwards,3 resulting in a document embodying what remains the world's best-known example of a relatively strict system of separation of powers. The system practised in the US is also one which, as we will see, bears at least some resemblance to the system of separation of powers under the Hong Kong Basic Law.
In the most extensive modern study of the subject, Vile (1998) defines a "pure" system of separation of powers as consisting of four elements: 1) The division of government into three separate branches: Executive, legislature and
judiciary; 2) The classification of all governmental functions as falling within one of these three
branches, with each branch only exercising those powers that belong to it and not interfering in those functions that belong to the other branches;
3) Separation of persons: The three branches are composed of separate and distinct groups of people with no overlapping membership between them;
4) The exercise of checks and balances between the three branches to avoid any one branch exercising arbitrary power.4
1 Aristotle, Politics, Book 4, Chapter IV [translated by William Ellis (London: J.M. Dent & Sons, 1912)], where
he argued that it "makes no difference" whether these three powers (which he called war, justice and deliberation) "belong to separate groups, or to a single group". 2 Montesquieu, De l'Espirit des Loix [translated by Thomas Nugent, The Spirit of Laws (London: G. Bell &
Sons, 1914)]. 3 There are, however, divided opinions on precisely how influential Montesquieu's writings were on the
Founding Fathers. See further M.J.C. Vile,...

Find Another Essay On Separation of Powers under the HK Basic Law

Separation of Powers Essay

844 words - 3 pages      Successful governments in history gained their acclaim by trial and error. The government in the United States is no different. In fact, the structure of the government in the United States has been through many changes: the American government was once feeble and operated with weak alliances between states; however, the present government functions in perfect equilibrium with the separation of powers, the federal

Separation of Powers Essay

1349 words - 5 pages government. Furthermore, no body of government is supposed to abdicate power to another body. The separation of powers ensures the checking and balancing of each arm of government, although this is not always a harmonious relationship and can provide tensions between the arms of government. Nevertheless, the separation of powers ensures that the actions of government are in accordance with the law and the rights of the people are protected.The

Separation of Powers

760 words - 4 pages If one person handled everything in the United States, there would be so much chaos in this world. Charles-Louis de Secondat, published Spirit of Laws which encouraged the Declaration of the Rights of Man and the Constitution of the United States. He stressed that, to promote liberty effectively, the three powers had to be separated and acting independently (Separation of powers, n.d.). To ensure that the governmental power would not be used in

separation of powers

629 words - 3 pages a branch, declaring a law unconstitutional and many other different powers.      The legislative branch just like every other branch in the government has the power to check other ones and is checked by the opposing branches. This legislative branch checks the powers of the executive branch in many different ways ensuring that they do not become overpowering. One way in which the legislative branch checks the power of

Importance of the Separation of Powers in Government

1224 words - 5 pages The principle of the separation of powers is the ‘division of state and federal government into three independent branches’ . This divides the governmental power between the three divisions of the constitution, ensuring the state power is equal and is not violated by an individual branch. In concurrence with the principle of constitutionalism, separation of powers also ‘limits the power of the state’ . The separation of powers also specifies

The Separation of Powers in the United States Political System

892 words - 4 pages Powers. The system of checks and balances have also been under heat for not providing satisfactory Separation of Powers because some have observed how since the 19th Century right up to the modern day, the presidential authority seems to dominate in government. They observe how President Thomas Jefferson in 1803 authorised the 'Louisiana Purchase' without the consult of Congress. This more than doubled the size of the US

The Separation and Balance of Powers in the UK Constitution

1742 words - 7 pages The Separation and Balance of Powers in the UK Constitution “By the latter part of the 20th century the independence of the judges had come under increasing threat from interference by the executive. Recent reforms have, however, served to redress this position and ensure that a proper division of personnel and functions between these two arms of the state is restored. Discuss this statement in the context of the

The Power of Presidency: The Separation of Powers that the President has to follow

823 words - 3 pages Dating back to 1690, the Framers created the system we know of today as the System of Checks and balances. This system provided the Separation of Powers for our Federal Government, in which it was created in our Constitution. This meant that there would be three branches of government, the Legislative, made up of the House and Senate, the Executive, which is the President and Vice President, and the Judicial, made up of our federal courts and

The 5 Basic Sources of Law

1033 words - 5 pages is then limited by the system of checks and balances among the executive, legislative and judicial branches. The judiciary has the power to conclude whether or not these laws are lawful under the constitutions. Generally, these statutory laws are designated as Private Laws or Public Laws. They can either relate to the general public as whole or specific institutions. The last basic source of law being discussed is treaties. “An official

Seperation of Powers and the Rule of Law

1139 words - 5 pages to define but put simply it is not ‘the rule of men’ and is evident in societies with functioning judiciaries and a clear separation of powers such as New Zealand. It is one of several intrinsic attributes of our constitutional makeup and overall the Judiciary aid in ‘ensure[ing] that the rule of law is maintained’ . The judiciary is both part of and upholds the rule of law, it is however the lesser of the three branches of government yet

The Division Of Law-making Powers In Australia

1266 words - 5 pages . Concurrent powers are powers which can be decided upon by both the Commonwealth and State Parliaments and residual powers were lawmaking powers which were not mentioned in the Constitution, and were left to the State Parliaments these areas included crime, education, health, environment.At the time of Federation there were a few major ways in which the States ensured that they would keep sovereign law making power. One way was to make most law making

Similar Essays

The Separation Of Powers Doctrine Essay

1605 words - 6 pages The judicial control of administrative agencies is held in check by four principal mechanisms: (1) Structural Constraints imposed under the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers; (2) statutory constraints set forth generally in the Administrative Procedure Act and specifically in each agency’s organic legislation; (3) the requirement that individuals be treated fairly in conformity with the standards of procedural due process; and (4

No Separation Of Powers In The Uk

1698 words - 7 pages brings about the most essential principles of the rule of law, that every individual is equal under the force of law, as minister or officer acting on behalf of the Crown is subject to judicial review. Although it can be said that due to the doctrine of the separation of powers the Supreme Court cannot declare acts of Parliament invalid or play any crucial role within the legislature, with the power of judicial review they courts can effectively

Separation Of Powers In The Us Government

1014 words - 4 pages order” (Beltz 28). The separation of powers is a basic constitutional principal of modern democracy. “Since the writings of Locke and Montesquieu, the separation of the legislative, executive, and judicial is deemed essential to avoid tyranny from the people who hold these powers” (separation of powers A society where the law is not overseen and the separation of powers of is not ensured has no constitution at all (separation

Separation Of Powers Essay

709 words - 3 pages Constitution established three separate branches of government. By structuring the government in this fashion, the power to rule and govern would be distributed equally through a “separation of powers” arrangement. This structure prevents any single entity from ruling on its own without any checks or balances in place to protect the citizens. In creating a government with separated powers, three branches were established: the Executive Branch, which