Severe And Physical Punishment Necessary In Ships In The Royal Navy

999 words - 4 pages

The manner, in which crime was punished in the Royal Navy, during the Georgian period, has often been the subject to great controversy and debate. When answering this question, it is important to consider contemporary sources so as to develop an accurate analysis. After examining various sources, it seems clear that the use of physical punishment was indeed necessary so as to constitute power over the seamen, particularly with limited alternatives available. It also becomes apparent that the Royal Navy’s reputation for flogging has been exaggerated, as N. Rodger observes, the violence used, ‘by the standards of Eighteenth Century.... were generally acceptable and even enlightened’.
When assessing whether physical punishment was necessary or not, the potential crimes themselves should be assessed. As D. Pope argues, ‘one of the worst crimes in a ship is theft’, this is supported by J.M Powell’s letter to his father, where thievery is frequently mentioned. Other prevalent problems consist of, drunken behaviour, physical attacks and idleness to name a few. In regards to the necessity of physical punishment, as D. Pope continues to say, ‘the spectacle aspect was regarded as most important’ so as to illustrate the repercussions of crime. N. Rodger presents an alternative to why physical punishment was required, stating that the ‘Captain had no instructions as to how else he might deal with them’. Sources such as Captain Corbet’s appeal suggest that the contemporaneous opinion was that fear prevented crime, and thus in regards to punishment, ‘the more severe in appearance the better’.
When questioning the severity of the punishment administered, it becomes apparent that this was unquestionably a subjective process. As N. Rodger states, ‘In practise officers did vary greatly in the degree of violence which they employed’, this is supported by Captain Corbet’s appeal when he states that ‘severity must depend upon circumstance’. This was primarily due to the fact that the Navy ‘lacked a developed legal code’ and thus those that dispensed punishments were unsure of the correct protocol. Captains were however, not allowed to give more than twelve lashes at a time. The problem was that due to the public nature, time to assemble and inconvenience of punishments, twelve lashes would normally always be given out, so as to not be seen as a misuse of time.
It seems clear that the notoriety of the Royal Navy has been somewhat embellished. As D. Pope remarks, an offence committed at sea may result in a flogging, however ‘his brother on land’ may ‘spend a year in jail or be transported for life’ he claims that this ‘provides some much-needed perspective on discipline in the Navy’. Whilst this may be true, contemporary sources clearly demonstrate that unnecessary violence did occur, perhaps best shown by John Smiths appeal to the court. This seems to illustrate that due to the subjective nature of punishment within the Navy the degree of violence ‘did vary...

Find Another Essay On Severe and Physical Punishment Necessary in Ships in the Royal Navy

Severe consequences of miscommunication in The Jungle and “In the Waiting Room”

1834 words - 8 pages America and everyday life is a struggle. The problems that rise from a lack of communication lead to a path of destruction for the family. Additionally, these problems eventually lead to devastation, manipulation and cause mental and physical health issues. So, Sinclair presents the consequences they face from inadequate communication in a negative light. The language barriers in the story seem to cause horrific and severe incidents to the characters

Cruelty and Racism in the "Battle Royal" by Ralph Elison

553 words - 2 pages "Cruelty and Racism in "Battle Royal"Battle Royal is the first chapter in a novel called "The Invisible Man." "Ralph Ellison," who lived 1914 - 1994, based this novel on the life of a young black man, the narrator, living in the world of cruel racism. The narrator's life was a fine example of racism. The white people, in this story, are merciless and malicious. Ellison's definition of racism incorporates a high degree of cruelty; he tells how

Spanking and Physical Punishment

1237 words - 5 pages Children are like flowers, if well taken care of they will glow. If ignored or tortured, they will damage or die. Child discipline is one of the most significant basics of successful parenting. Today, many people have this belief that physical abuse is in no way a solution to helping children recognize between right and wrong. Since generations children have been learnt the art of discipline through physical punishment. Often this approach to

The Effects Of Physical Punishment To Modify Undesireable Behavior In Children. This Essay Explains The Negative Effects Of Using Physical Punishment On Children

515 words - 3 pages Effects of Physical Punishment to Modify Undesirable Behavior in Children.There must be a concern for the negative effects of physical punishment of children's undesirable behavior. One main concern is that abusive parenting is a model that children adopt an acceptable method of parenting their own children. There is certainly a correlation between children who have been subject to harsh physical punishment and children who grow up to be abusive

The harms of physical punishment in our society today and describes the effects that it can leave on young children later in life

1324 words - 5 pages parent or other caretaker, which is intended to cause physical pain, but not injury, for purposes of correction or control" (Straus). Many may argue that spanking is a practice that is accepted in our society. What worked in the past should work now. In fact, corporal punishment leads to many psychological and behavioral problems later on in life, which include, but are not limited to, aggression, anxiety, and alcohol and drug use.Today many

My Future in The Intelligence Community of the U.S. Navy

1703 words - 7 pages find better ways to protect the nation’s and everyone’s safety. For instance, during the War of 1812, the U.S. Navy used certain technological advances that made it difficult for the Royal Navy to attack. ("War of 1812:," ). “In the 200 years since the war of 1812, technological innovation has been an essential component in the ships, aircraft, sensors, and weapons that have contributed to victories by America’s Navy.” ("War of 1812:," ). The

Was the 2003 war in Iraq justified and necessary?

11254 words - 45 pages sanctions committee (the "661 committee").662 (9 August 1990): Iraq-KuwaitDecides that Iraq's annexation of Kuwait is "null and void".664 (18 August 1990): Iraq-KuwaitDemands that Iraq release "third state nationals".665 (25 August 1990): Iraq-KuwaitImposes a shipping blockade by calling for the use of "such measures ... as may be necessary" to enforce the maritime embargo. In effect, this resolution reassigns some of the practical responsibility for

The Necessary Separation of Church and State in America

1664 words - 7 pages The Necessary Separation of Church and State in America On January 1, 1802, Thomas Jefferson wrote a letter to the Committee of the Danbury Baptist Association in Connecticut in which he stated: “Believing with you that religion is a matter which lies solely between Man & his God, that he owes account to none other for his faith or his worship, that the legitimate powers of government reach actions only, & not opinions, I contemplate with

Crime and Punishment in the Elizabethan Era

1957 words - 8 pages />. "Crime and Punishment in Elizabethan England." . N.p.. Web. 26 March 2014 . . "Life in Elizabethan Courts." . N.p.. Web. 26 March 2014 . . Taylor, Christopher. "Elizabethan Government." . N.p.. Web. 26 March 2014 . . "The Elizabethan Court ." . Royal Museums Greenwich. Web. 26 March 2014 . .

Motivation and the Role it Plays with Royal Marine Physical Training

2700 words - 11 pages PSYCHOLOGY MODULE - MOTIVATION AND THE ROLE IT PLAYS WITH ROYAL MARINE PHYSICAL TRAINING.In my opinion, to be a successful and competent teacher you must be able to motivate people. The whole concept of learning requires effort, commitment and diligence and this must come from both the student and the teacher. I have decided to base this Psychology Module on Motivation and the dynamics of motivation. I will chart my progress as a motivator and

Crime and Punishment in the 1650's

1179 words - 5 pages Crime and Punishment During the 1650'sDuring the 1650's if a person broke a law, it was considered a sin and the punishment was very severe in most cases, but now criminal law has developed largely due to increase of education. For example, in the Scarlet Letter Hester Prynne was charged for adultery, and her punishment was to wear an A on her shirt for the rest of her life. She also had to stand on the scaffold for three hours, and she also

Similar Essays

The History Of Naming U.S Navy Ships, Captain James Lawrence, The Uss Lawrence And The Uss Charles F. Adams

1957 words - 8 pages How are US Navy ships named? How was the USS Lawrence DDG-4 and the USS Charles F. Adams DDG-2 named? The history of naming Navy ships has always been a mystery. You have the history of the men who become namesakes of these ships. Then there is years of history of the ships themselves during the time that they were in commission. These topics tie in together to understand the USS Lawrence and the USS Charles F. Adams. U.S. Navy ships have

Hiring And Appraisal Systems In The Us Navy

2315 words - 9 pages There are many different types of hiring and appraisal systems in multi-national corporations. Many adapt to local environments and differentiate their systems based on their goals. Unlike most civilian jobs, the U.S. Navy has limited protection from discrimination based on gender and physical appearance for certain jobs. Nevertheless, entering the service in general has similar fundamentals in its civilian counterparts. Although there are many

Necessary Physical Contant In D.H. Lawrence's Women In Love And Plato's Symposium

2665 words - 11 pages Necessary Physical Contant in D.H. Lawrence's Women in Love and Plato's Symposium D.H. Lawrence’s novel, Women in Love, presents a complex model of female-male and male-male relationships. Lawrence’s model relies heavily on a similar model presented in Plato’s Symposium. The difference between the two works lies in the mode of realization; that is, how one goes about achieving a ‘perfect’ love relationship with either sex. Lawrence

Old Navy In The International Business Market

1849 words - 7 pages – because what we do in our jobs, as well as away from work, is consistent with our lives' goals and dreams. Fun: Come see for yourself! According to Gap Inc., they operate 3,143 stores, which includes the Old Navy brand. Old Navy first opened its doors in 1994, in Colma, California. Less than four years after opening, in 1997, Old Navy's annual sales reached a record $1 billion. In 2000, Oldnavy.com was launched. Old Navy made its