This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Serious Problems With Dna Fingerprinting Essay

1675 words - 7 pages

Serious Problems with DNA Fingerprinting

    Is there any piece of physical evidence so foolproof it could be used to prove or disprove anyone's case in a trial? Many people believe the answer to this question is DNA. In theory, this argument is true, but many believe certain factors can lead to inconsistent data gathered from DNA. There are many differing opinions on how DNA should be used, or if it should be used at all.


Many people are uninformed about what DNA actually is or how it is used in criminal trials. DNA is the generic term for deoxyribonucleic acid. It is a molecule found throughout the entire body that determines all inherited characteristics (Forensic Testing Division, 1998). Someone receives half of his or her genetic makeup from each biological parent, making each person's genetic makeup unique, except for identical twins.


Since the genetic makeup of each individual is entirely different from another, it is believed that DNA can be used to prove exactly who was at a crime scene and who was not. The process to determine whose DNA has been gathered at a crime scene is known as DNA fingerprinting. In actuality, only 2% of DNA are genes; the rest is called "junk DNA" which biological purpose is unknown (Verrengia, 1997). Junk DNA is what is mainly used in DNA fingerprinting.


DNA can be found in many different substances including hair, saliva, blood, and other fluids or tissues. That junk DNA found in these substances are tested in different ways including Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism and Polymerase Chain Reaction. These tests are usually referred as the RFLP and PCR tests, respectively.


In these tests, DNA is exposed to enzymes which cause the strands to divide at different points. "Variable number tandem repeats" is the name given to this phenomena, and it enables technicians to test DNA in an interesting way. The fragments are subjected to electrophoresis-a process in which an electric charge propels the fragments through a gel (Williams, 1989). Logically, the shorter strands will move at a faster rate than longer ones, thus leaving different patterns for different people. The process is not finished, though. The sample is given radioactive probes which bonds to the DNA. Lastly, the sample is blotted against film which shows a unique pattern for every individual, similar to a bar code. This bar code is then compared to a sample from the suspect in question. It should be known that the theoretical chances of someone having the some DNA fingerprint of someone else is said by some to be as little as one in one quadrillion. This is why many scientists and prosecutors believe DNA is a great way to create an open-and-shut case.


Although the process used in DNA fingerprinting is very complicated, it is a little easier to understand the arguments posed for or against this process. In many cases ranging from the famed O.J. Simpson murder trial to the JonBenet...

Find Another Essay On Serious Problems with DNA Fingerprinting

Legal Aspects of DNA Fingerprinting Essay

1883 words - 8 pages identification. This is shown in Figure 3 on page 4. One can extract DNA from hair, nails, blood, skin or even saliva. It was first used to discover genetic diseases but now is also used to help catch criminals or research the dead in order to unlock the evolution of mankind. Facts about DNA fingerprinting: • Sir Alec Jeffrey discovered DNA fingerprinting on accident on September 10th 1984 • DNA fingerprinting doesn't have much to do with actual

Bio Literary Task Essay

1664 words - 7 pages analysis has aided evolutionary biologists by providing them with conclusions about the true origin of organisms o DNA fingerprinting has been used in court cases as evidence as well as for genetic research o Genetics has helped Archaeologists to better understand our past by enabling them to accurately map and date last known survivors of different species o Genetics has led to major evolutionary discoveries and has provided evidence to support

Forensics Does Not Lie

2357 words - 9 pages , whilst in prison he was stabbed to death, taking the truth of his actions to the grave. Fifty years later forensic scientists were able to use seminal fluid found at the crime scene to prove that DeSalvo was in fact the perpetrator that raped and murdered Marcy Sullivan as well as the other ten women. As technology advances, so do the techniques available to prosecute criminals, such techniques include DNA fingerprinting and carpet analysis. For

Pos. and Neg. of DNA Profiling

966 words - 4 pages having the individual employed. Hopefully, rulings such as these will serve their purpose in protecting the right of all citizens, (Privacy and DNA Fingerprinting News, 1994). In Blood Testing, AIDS, and DNA Profiling: Law and Policy, Andrew Grubb makes the following statement. “With individuals concerned about confidentiality and discrimination, and insurers and employers concerned about liability, it will fall upon legislators and the courts to

DNA: The Doble Helix

1291 words - 6 pages adenine pairs up with thymine and cytosine with guanine. DNA FINGERPRINTING How is it used in crime scene investigation? Discuss dna fingerprinting. How accurate is this tecnhgiue? For the past decade, DNA has been a great advantage in crime scene investigation. Not only can DNA identify criminals’ in a crime scene investigation, but it can also exonerate suspects who were wrongly convicted or accused of a crime. DNA fingerprinting is a technique for

Using DNA in Criminal Trials

1612 words - 6 pages . Until then, however, statistics are used in order to estimate the number of people who could possibly carry the combination of DNA strands that match a sample given for testing "Like everything else in the scientific world, nothing about DNA (profiling) is %100 assured"(Problems with DNA Fingerprinting). Errors are very rare, and preventable because the statistics used to calculate the probability are said to be the most accurate way at this

genetic engieering

1063 words - 5 pages an important scientific breakthrough because with genetic engineering, we can alter DNA molecules and find cures and solve problems Genes are the blueprints of the body. All of the living things from the plants the little things have genes. They are stored in chromosomes found in the human cell. The gene is a unit of a lot of genetic information that can code for a single biological function. They tell a cell which molecule to synthesize based on

The Use of DNA in Forensics

1257 words - 5 pages ] (adjective) First appeared 1659 1 : belonging to, used in, or suitable to courts of judicature or to public discussion and debate. 2 : ARGUMENTATIVE, RHETORICAL. 3 : relating to or dealing with the application of scientific knowledge to legal problems *~ medicine* *~ science* *~ pathologist* *~ experts*.1 How are the two related? DNA can be used to identify an individual. In relation to forensics, when there is a crime investigation

DNA In Forensics

1188 words - 5 pages retention of an innocent person's DNA can be charge or otherwise, seen as a invasion of that person’s privacy and civil liberties. Dr. Alec Jeffrey, a former professor at the University of Leicester laboratory, consulted with his lawyers to develop the new type of technique called DNA profiling. His technique would prove that DNA fingerprinting (profiling) can individualize evidence compared to the blood typing. DNA profiling compares 13 standard STRs

Research Paper: DNA

2120 words - 9 pages genetic engineering so that they can create an organism with a specific gene that was not there before. DNA is very complex and has many tasks that it has to complete. DNA is one of a class of molecules called nucleic acids. Nucleic acids were originally discovered in 1868 by Friedrich Meischer, a Swiss biologist, who isolated DNA from pus cells on bandages. This is kind of disgusting if you ask me. I would never in my life even think or have

Arrests of Violent Criminals Made with DNA Evidence

591 words - 3 pages the suspect’s identity has been confirmed the state crime laboratory sends information to a local crime laboratory in which then they send the information to a police agency. Although fingerprinting is utilized and processed more often than DNA in a property crime, the case study states that police officers place the highest value on DNA identification- ahead of fingerprints- when categorizing the most important forensic evidence to identify a

Similar Essays

Dna Fingerprinting Essay

930 words - 4 pages contaminated. The ability to use DNA fingerprinting is not effective with crimes, but it has also come to be successful in other areas as well. DNA fingerprinting is now become successful in determining kinship. Since DNA is heritable and highly specific to an individual (except for monozygotic twins), DNA profiles represent an excellent means of resolving genealogical problems. With the same example as paternity testing law, enforcement agencies are

Dna Profiling At Birth Essay

930 words - 4 pages match crime scene evidence with suspects in criminal investigations for a very long time. However recently the lack of suitable experimental approach prevented them from achieving this until DNA fingerprint profiling was discovered. During the 1980’s geneticist Alec Jeffreys discovered how to DNA fingerprint using a drop of his own blood. Since then DNA fingerprinting has been used on hundreds of thousands of people throughout many countries and

Dna Fingerprinting Essay

825 words - 3 pages 1988. In 1992 the National Research Counsel found that DNA testing was a reliable source for identifying criminal suspects. In the early 1990's DNA fingerprinting technology was changed for the better by the development of the Short Tandem Repeats (STRs) technique, which is basically microsatellites of small repeating units two to five bases in length with a maximum length of 300 bases which shows a high degree of

Bilogy: Dna Fingerprinting Essay

1244 words - 5 pages through the process of DNA Fingerprinting. Police collect evidence from the crime scene to take in for testing. When the testing is complete the police know who the criminal is by their fingerprint. DNA Fingerprinting has also proven effective with miss person cases. “The concept of DNA profiling was developed by British scientist Alec Jeffreys and first presented to the public by him in 1984.” DNA Fingerprinting has helped solve thousands of