This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Service Learning Should Not Be Mandatory For College Students

1339 words - 5 pages

Service learning is the name for forcing college students to do volunteer work as part of their college careers. The hope is that this volunteer work will give students a better sense of civic duty, and thus, be a worthy addition to college curriculums. However, this idea relies on the faulty premise that if one is forced to volunteer that one will derive the same benefits as someone who does it out of their own desire to help. Mandatory service learning will not have the desired effect, and should not be forced upon students.

It is perhaps intuitive to think that by making students help others there will be a net positive; there could be no downside to volunteering time and effort to help the community. However, a more detailed inspection reveals there are many negatives, and any positive effects are just wishful thinking.

To begin with, service learning wouldn’t benefit the students’ education. Indeed, many students would be unable to volunteer in their field. This negates any argument that service learning would help the students’ education. While there may be specific cases where a student with a practical major could benefit from volunteering their efforts, this would simply be a positive indirect effect. Not only that, but in many cases such students are already effectively volunteering their time in the form of unpaid internships. If schools wish students to volunteer in such a manner they should be working with charities to establish more voluntary internships. However, as soon as students are forced to volunteer for the sake of volunteering, it no is longer about helping the student.

One has to ask: why it is exclusively schools that would take up this forced volunteer work? If it was really a needed benefit to society, then companies could also be forced to volunteer for the community. Indeed, in many cases a company would be better equipped to help in whatever way was needed. However, to a company their time is money. If a company is forced to give its time and resources to volunteer, it might as well give money instead. That money, in the form of taxes, is already paid by both companies and individuals to the government. That money, in turn, should be used to help communities when needed. If communities need extra help, the answer is increasing taxes to provide that extra help. Forcing college students to provide that help directly ignores the efficiencies gained from specialization. A college student, who isn’t even studying whatever field is needed, would be able to help more by working in their actual field for money, and then giving that money to a specialist, via the government, to provide the direct help. The only problem with that arrangement is that it doesn’t provide the positive feelings that directly helping would. However, gaining a positive sense of accomplishment at the expense of providing less efficient help is a purely selfish motivation.

In the case of labor being needed that almost anyone could do, there...

Find Another Essay On Service Learning Should NOT be Mandatory For College Students

Should students be rewarded for learning

2777 words - 11 pages ’ have successfully used external reward programmes for learning frequently (Akin-Little and others, 2004). The act of rewarding students’ should be a very carefully personal judgment based not only on the tasks performed and the type of reward, but also on the personality of the reward recipient, the deliverer, as well as the environment the reward is given in. For a reward to be intrinsically motivating it must be genuine, unexpected and

NO Mandatory Community Service for Students!

690 words - 3 pages prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, nationalism, religion, or other matters of opinion, or force citizens to confess by word or act their faith therein." (Bowden 1998) School boards who hold diplomas for ransom, pending compliance with the prevailing belief of self-sacrifice, are engaging in nothing less than unconstitutional moral teaching. Supporters of mandatory community service insist that it is really for the students

The Flu Shot Should Not Be Mandatory

1324 words - 5 pages be taken into consideration by the public. In conclusion, vaccination remains the most reliable and cost-effective way to prevent influenza. Influenza vaccination should not be mandatory and should remain the choice of each individual. However, people at a high risk of influenza as well as health-care providers should consider receiving the vaccine. In addition, programs educating people about the benefits of

Impacts of Service-Learning on College Students

1699 words - 7 pages reciprocation between academic content and community service. Research shows the community service and service-learning impact a student in college. The biggest impact is with the students’ civic engagement. However, outcomes of service- learning do not end there. Outcomes of service-learning range from academic to moral to life skills and all outcomes that fall within (Eyler & Giles, 1999). Academic Outcomes Some of the academic based outcomes of

TOEFL Should Be Mandatory: The Case of Higher Learning

1610 words - 7 pages and importance of making TOEFL a mandatory requirement when one chooses to acquire higher learning education today. First, TOEFL should be mandatory since English proficiency is essential for a student to have a holistic in a US university or non-US based university since most learning materials and educational modules are written or done in English. In fact, an Asian academician and author Anwei Feng (272) argued that “English dominates the

College Students should not have a job

726 words - 3 pages Why shouldn’t college students work? There are a lot of reasons why. In college there are a lot of things college students should be more worried about than working. Like their classes and grades. We know some students are not fortunate enough to be in college and not work. Being from another state and not having a full scholarship or not having enough money to support yourself while in college. Means you do have to work to help pay for school

Service Learning in College

1831 words - 7 pages programs. The mission statement at Drury College sums up how the college believes that education should be spread to the community and participation should be in full effect with all the students. According to Flikkema, a major goal is to develop the skills of the students through service learning (DeVitis, L. Joseph, Robert W. Johns, and Douglas J. Simpson 23). The students of Drury College have to turn in a reflection of their personal

Should College Athletes Be Payed or Not?

1526 words - 6 pages athletes shouldn't get paid. They need to focus on getting an education which is what college is for. Also, the pay they are getting, aka scholarships, should be plenty. Though they get paid more, and its not equal at all. Between the players and the teams, its not fair pay. They could get paid though for their playing time since they do dedicate their college lives to the sport, but they don’t go to class. Should we really be paying 18-22 year old to

"Students Should Not Be Forced to Do Community Service" This essay explains the negative effects of forcing students to fulfill a community service requirement in high school

623 words - 2 pages , and add more pressure to the already hectic life of a high school teenager. Students should not be commanded to do 75 hours of community service!To begin, requiring 75 hours of community service could be a disservice to students because it could hold many back from graduating. A lot of students have a very busy schedule and might not be able to do the required amount of time of community service. It may be mandatory to go somewhere or to do

Why College Athletes Should NOT be Paid

1997 words - 8 pages not make this possible. Nicholls State among hundreds more universities could make this possible. “They are not what some people are arguing they should become, unionized employees of the university” (Morganteen). Consequently, the idea of creating contracts and signing-deals with salaries for college athletes is not a smart move and should not be made. The payment of college athletes will kill the principles of recruiting.High school students

"College and university education should be free for all students, fully financed by the government."

713 words - 3 pages There is no such thing as 'free education fully financed by the government'. A zero-tuition college education simply means that instead of the students bearing the cost of attaining their degrees the taxpayers bear it. Students and parents misperceive the price of education, considering it to be free, even though it comes out of their pockets in taxes.And why should low-income taxpayers finance the education of wealthier students? Proponents of

Similar Essays

Should Community Service Be Mandatory For Students To Graduate

866 words - 3 pages upon graduation for students who volunteer. With students already being obligated to other outside school activities such as athletics and personal home life is it acceptable to add more on to the load? Community service is beneficial in a number of ways. The first reason community service should be mandatory is because for years service learning has been closely correlated with scholastic achievement. The majority of students who engage in

Military Service Should Be Mandatory Essay

821 words - 3 pages Military Service Should be Mandatory Americans, especially baby boomers, should be ashamed of themselves. How can the world's richest population let its military go begging for recruits? Each year, the military services -- Air Force, Army, Marines, Navy -- establish recruiting goals to maintain adequate numbers of personnel. The numbers change annually depending on, among other factors, service needs, recruitment figures the year before

Should Community Service Be Mandatory? Essay

700 words - 3 pages problem is promptness, if needing to be on time to a certain event it could teach dependability for oneself at a young age. If doing volunteer work then you will always try to do the best you can, to fulfill a duty properly is also useful tool for teaching responsibility. If community service is started at a young age it will become habit to help others and not so much burdensome to us. Grades are obviously not enough of a requirement. Teenagers need

French Classes Should Be Mandatory For Canadian Students

1811 words - 7 pages its nature. Bilinguals are more efficient at attention control; they focus on important tasks and information with ease. French courses should be mandatory for all Canadian students since bilingualism benefits meta-linguistic awareness, mental flexibility, and control of attention. Mental flexibility is superior in bilingual children since learning two language forces their minds to process two language systems at one time. Bilingualism promotes