Sexual Use And What To Do About It

983 words - 4 pages ✓ Expert Reviewed

Alan Soble counters the large dilemmas presented by Immanuel Kant in his article “Sexual Use and What to Do about It”. Soble makes very strong points when he is both agreeing and disagreeing with Kant in his article. The “sex problem” that is discussed by philosophers is a battle of what makes sex immoral and harmful to humanity. The root of the objectification of the body, and luring someone under false pretenses, into sexual activity is viewed as harmful to both the person doing the objectifying and the person being objectified. Soble outlines “Kant’s sex problem” and Kant’s solution, Soble also gives his own solutions, and in learning both I feel the solution is in externalism.
Immanuel Kant defines his second formulation of the Categorical Imperative as knowing the value of a person. It is demeaning to use a person without his or her consent for self-gratification, especially sexually. Kant describes this as using a person simply to serve a means rather than an end, simply put rather than being a concrete loving act with the end of creating new life sex treated as only “scratching an itch”. The idea that Kant, “must take on the other’s ends for their own sake, not because that is an effective way to advance my goals in using the other,” is a way of saying that a man must care enough about the other person treat them as fairly and justly as he wants to be treated (Soble 228). To Soble the “Kantian sex problem” is at the root rather or not all of Kant’s requirements can be met at all in sexual activity¬¬. As Kant lays out all that goes into the second formulation of the Categorical Imperative he describes taking on one another’s ends, but also what it means to make a person simply an end to one’s own needs.
Two people entering willingly into matrimony, and entering into sexual activity mutual with a shared end could meet the solution supplied by Kant. For two people to commit themselves physically and emotionally in the way Kant describes a true marriage is the strongest sanction. However, the idea of taking on one another’s means becomes void if both people give consent of using the other. Entering knowingly into a sexual relationship that will doing nothing but fulfill a means is acceptable as long as it is not harmful to either person. This seems to be rather odd contradictions to Kant’s strong stand point on marriage, but it could be thought that he is referring to a married couple using one another. The human race tends to use sex as a coping mechanism, something to turn when one needs to feel numb or separate from the world. Matthew Stacey says, “What Kant wants if for the mind to always be in control of the body and for us to be temperate in our indulgences,” in his article “Kant on Sex and Marriage: What Kant Should Have Said” (Stacey 20). For this to be possible a person’s control would seem to be on a level that is nearly inhuman.
...

Find Another Essay On Sexual Use and What to Do about It

What to Do about Foreclosures Essay

1102 words - 4 pages on is how to get suppliers to be equitable while still making a profit, and consumers to manage their money better. Being that I am both a teacher and prospective home owner, I'd say it's about education and incentives. For something that is so important to our nation's economic well-being, personal finance is barely explained, as it is taught for only one semester if that. When I went to high school for example, we were required to take ELP...

Ecstasy and what it can do to its user.

913 words - 4 pages The buzz about X (Ecstasy) is reaching an all-time high. Since 1997, teen use of this drug has grown more than any other drug, according to Monitoring the Future, a research group tracking youth behavior; approximately 10.5 percent of 12th graders say they've tried X in the last year.Ecstasy is supposed to bring about a feeling of euphoria. It shuts off parts of your brain and supplants an extended dose of adrenaline and seratonin...

Dairy Allergies and What to do About Them

761 words - 3 pages Dairy Allergies and What to do About Them Food allergy or hypersensitivity refers to the abnormal allergic reaction of the body’s immune system to a usually harmless food such as milk, eggs, peanuts, and fish. Food allergens that cause allergic reactions are usually proteins and this can cause adverse effects even if cooked or have been digested. Dairy allergens include milk and milk proteins that are found in cows, sheep, goat, and other...

How do deaf people use telephones? What about doorbells and alarm clocks?

964 words - 4 pages How do deaf people use telephones? What about doorbells and alarm clocks?      There are many everyday devises that we hearing people take for granted, among these are telephones, smoke alarms, doorbells, and alarm clocks. When we look at how members of the deaf community use these everyday items we must consider that members within the community have very different communication needs, abilities, and preferences. Hard...

Nursing Shortages..talkes about the concerns about nursing shortages, and why it is occuring and alson what we can do to help this problem out.

523 words - 2 pages between 50,000 and 60,000 dollars. The expensive nature of turnover isn't the only problem related to it. Turnover can result in lower productivity because the hospital is trying to find a replacement and when they do find the replacement that person still needs time to learn the system.Secondly, fewer women are becoming nurses since the economy has also now left the door open for women to explore other trades or...

Food Choices and the Obesity Epidemic - psychological approach to why people eat what they do, and what can be done about it. Includes Bibliography.

1128 words - 5 pages ) Good. But Good for you? Human Ecology Forum, v24, n4, p20(4)Glanz, K., Basil, M., Maibach E., Goldberg, J., & Snyder D. (1998, October) Why Americans eat what they do: taste, nutrition, cost, convenience, and weight control concerns as influences on food consumption. Journal of the American Dietetic Association, v98, n10, p1118(9)Brownell, K. & Liebman B. (1998, July-August) The pressure to eat: why we're...

A psychology abstract on the article "Thinning Down School Food." Talks about increasing childhood obesity, and what schools need to do to change it.

576 words - 2 pages habits. Instead of saving children from scarcity of food, they need to save them from excess of it.Even as juniors, when we're in the last years of our education, school food still plays a big part of our daily nutrition. Now that we're ages 16 and 17, we know how to make healthy eating choices from years of experience from our parent's teaching. But personally, I don't think the healthy choice is always available at school.Huge...

Global warming effects outcome and what we can do about it

1799 words - 7 pages the extinction of many animal species at the moment including the Lion, Polar Bears and a few Bird species. This though is only the beginning of possibly thousands of extinct species.What can we do about it - but do we want to?Stop Co2 emissions on cars and aeroplanes this can be achieved by either using high grade filters which purify the air on the way out of the exhaust or by using alternative energy sources. This would be advisable...

What to do about ethnic cleans

1098 words - 4 pages an end to the issues of ethnic cleansing. As long as distinction can be made between groups, that distinction will be made, and as long as that distinction is made, there will be a few warmongers who will take advantage and cause bloodshed. Although the madness of a few people will not always spread, once in a while it will go out of control, leading to a massive genocide such as in Germany and Rwanda. And when there is another massive wholesale destruction, what will the world powers do about it?...

TOK Essay: What criteria do you use to distinguish between knowledge, opinion and propaganda?"

1246 words - 5 pages Title: "There are many different authorities, including academics, politicians, global organizations and companies, who make knowledge claims. As an experienced TOK student, what criteria do you use to distinguish between knowledge, opinion and propaganda?"IntroductionThese days, in the information age of the 21st century people in our society are engulfed in the mass media and receive many kinds of information. All this...

What do we own the animals and how and why do we owe it to them? Kant, Singer

542 words - 2 pages What do we own the animals and how and why do we owe it to them?According to Kant we do not owe animals anything as he puts it "Animals... are theremerely as a means to an end. That end is man."(emp130) I think the way he sees it isthat animals do not have the capacity to understand, to make reason. When a dog istaught something like not to urinate in the house, they understand that doing this will getthem...

Similar Essays

Alan Soble’s article “Sexual Use and What to do about It

1011 words - 4 pages notion, that marriage is a sacramental union rather than a legal union brings the two classes of solutions together. Setting moral constraints on desires allow an individual to control sexual desires, and choose only to pursue the desires, which eventually bring virtuous habits. Work cited Soble, Alan. "Sexual Use and What to Do about It: Internalist and Externalist Sexual Ethics." The Philosophy of Sex: Contemporary Readings. Ed. Alan Soble. Fourth ed. Totowa, NJ: Rowman and Littlefield, 2002. 225-258. Print. ...

Am I Obese and What to Do About It

3287 words - 13 pages the heart is going to work harder. When comparing the two results between Saressa and Samuel, Saressa’s numbers were lower than Samuels due to her higher body fat percentage and less water percentage. Samuel’s water percentage and more body mass allows him to have more energy and burn fat at a faster pace. One last subject I wanted to touch was that people are all worried about being overweight and obese. What most people do not realize is that...

Why Software sucks and what you can do about it.

939 words - 4 pages The magazine ad I choose to write about called, "Why software sucks (the exact word used) and what you can do about it," was published in a magazine called SD West Conference Catalog 2007 and written by David S. Platt, on page 4. The company called Thunder Computing has done computer consulting and developed education software for over 20 years. Platt teaches software development at Harvard University and companies all over the world. The...

"The E Myth Revisited: Why Most Small Businesses Don't Work and What to Do About It" by Michael E. Gerber

1982 words - 8 pages it got to where it is, and what it must do to get where it wants to go."(p.68) This is not the end stage to and of the previous stages talked about but it is just another platform to come upon. The people that get to this stage did not take any different steps to achieve their goals, they just went about things in a different manner than most do and that is what makes an Entrepreneur.The last thing I want to discuss is...