Shakespeare And Gender Essay

2684 words - 11 pages

Valerie Traub claims that ‘the meanings of homoerotic desire during the early modern period seem to have been remarkably unfixed, with contradictory meanings existing across a complex and fractured field of signification’ (‘Desire and the Differences it Makes’ in The Matter of Difference: Materialist Feminist Criticism of Shakespeare). Choose ONE play on the module and discuss the ‘meanings’ of homoerotic desire.

“Not only did legal, moral, religious and literary discourses understand and evaluate homoeroticism differently, but within each discourse there existed contradictory positions.” Here, in her essay Desire and the Difference it Makes, Valerie Traub observes that homoerotic desire had a variety of “meanings” in the Early Modern Period. She, however, refers to the “act” of sexual intercourse between two men as being the form of homoerotic desire categorised as ‘sodomy’. By focusing on playwrights such as William Shakespeare, who recognised this ambiguity and chose to explore it in particular works such as his Othello, we can see how the idea was represented at the time. However, it appears that not only the ‘meanings’ of ‘homoeroticism’ were unfixed, but that the words ‘love’ and ‘friendship’ were also ambiguous and period-bound. The word ‘love’, for instance, had four distinct meanings in classical Greek and so it is not surprising that we have difficulty in engaging with the past.

By examining the context of these terms, what can be seen is that homoerotic activity has been visible throughout literature and the visual arts since antiquity. However, from our perspective we need to be cautious in making assumptions about what the ‘meanings’ were actually inferring at the time. For example, an understanding of the word ‘sodomy’ implicated a variety of acts and behaviour. Critic, Mario DiGangi points out that this word did not correspond to our understanding of the term ‘homosexual’ and that “the label [of ‘sodomy’] also meant that this particular man was treasonous, monstrous [and] heretical.” What is known of ‘homosexuality’ is related to the legal understanding of the term at the time. In the Early Modern Period, the view on ‘homosexuality’ was that it could have either romantic or physical manifestations. The distinction was of importance since the latter was condemned both legally and by the Church, with its biblical undertones of sinfulness. Whilst from our own standpoint this condemnation seems somewhat extreme, it is important to remember that, despite our seeming accommodation of such behaviour legally in today’s society, there are many ways in which we show our aversion to it too. Nevertheless, Alan Bray affirms that the distinctions were still incongruous as “one was universally admired, the other execrated and feared: and yet in their uncompromising symmetry they paralleled each other in an uncanny way” . This is now explored through the context of Othello.

It is fitting that Othello is set in Venice, as it was known...

Find Another Essay On Shakespeare and Gender

Gender Equality in Twelfth Night Essay

1277 words - 5 pages Allison HirschyDr. Eleni SiatraENG-L30828 February 2014Gender Equality in Twelfth NightIn William Shakespeare's play Twelfth Night gender plays a large role in the overall plot. The play involves the confusion fueled by the disguise of the character of Viola, as well as the unlimited freedom given to her. In the purest form of comedy and entertainment, Shakespeare uses Twelfth Night to actually challenge the idea of gender and social norms by

Taming of the Shrew Response Essay

1043 words - 5 pages One of Shakespeare’s biggest accomplishments was appealing to all audiences. In a time rigidly divided by classes and gender roles, Shakespeare was able to appeal to the wealthy, the poor, men, and women. By showing both sides of the story and leaving some room for the imagination, Shakespeare was able to poke fun at the flaws in many groups of people for the amusement of the audience without offending those he joked about. In his play The

Gender Stereotypes in Othello

1952 words - 8 pages includes the effects of gender roles and identities and the consequences of violating those roles. Through the depiction of both women and men in Othello, Shakespeare criticizes society and the gender stereotypes it creates that erode one’s humanity and individuality. Men and women are victims of society’s influence as they succumb to stereotypes that shape their perceptions of their individual roles in society and those of others. The flawed

Shakespearean Texts: Titus Andronisexist

1704 words - 7 pages Shakespearean texts often examine attitudes and beliefs towards gender and contrast the gender roles to negotiate issues of gender in Elizabethan society. ‘Titus Andronicus’ by William Shakespeare explores several ideas of gender. The play is set in the later days of the Roman Empire, it tells the story of Titus Andronicus, a general in the Roman Army and his cycle of revenge with Tamora, the queen of Goths, Titus’ war prisoner and the new

Gender Roles in Shakespearan Society and Modern Society As Viewed in Movies

1371 words - 5 pages us repeatedly, a complex world where gender roles are uncertain, and things are seldom what they may seem. Anton Chekhov’s “The Lady with the Little Dog” and William Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night, along with the film Shakespeare in Love, depict the similarities of the Elizabethan Era and 19th century of women through induced character roles and powerful emotions. Shakepeare in Love comes closest to breaking the gender seal because the Viola uses

Implausible Love in Midsummer Night’s Dream

1513 words - 6 pages Love is chaotic and free, and because love is so powerful, we often do extreme and erratic things to capture it. The tradition of marriage, or mawage, is so firmly established in history that the gender roles common to marriage are often inescapable, no matter how strong love is, or how powerful a person is. In A Midsummer Night’s Dream, William Shakespeare uses imagery to portray the theme of gender roles and show how love has the spell

The Impact of Gender on Shakespeare's Othello

1350 words - 5 pages gender has greatly impacted the outcome of the play in William Shakespeare’s Othello. From a careful analysis of the story, tragedy in Othello is result of violating expected gender roles, gender performance by Desdemona and Othello, and the result of Iago’s inability to tolerate these violations. The tragedy “Othello” is written by William Shakespeare in 1604. The story is based on revenge of two characters, Othello and Iago. Othello, the play’s

Research Paper

1344 words - 5 pages herself as a male named “Cesario”, which eventually causes Olivia to fall in love with Cesario without knowing that “he” is truly Viola, a female. Throughout Twelfth Night: or What You Will, Shakespeare uses the element of disguises to merge the male and female genders within individual characters. In addition to these “sex shifts”, Shakespeare incorporates peculiar romances between the characters despite their gender. Viola creates a fictional male

What challenges does As You Like It present to out conceptions of gender identity?

1365 words - 5 pages Present day conceptions of gender would appear to be different to what they were in Shakespeare's day. Clear cut divisions of male, female and neuter are apparent. One would need to look back to the time of Shakespeare to try and see the different view of gender identity. Using the play As You Like It and the characters portrayed within it one might be able to see how our concept of gender may well be challenged. Gender role in this play does

Essay on Social Order in The Tempest

1134 words - 5 pages The Social Order in The Tempest         In Shakespeare's time, the social order was as powerful and rigid as law. Shakespeare provides an example of this social structure in his play, The Tempest. In the course of his play, the reader sees superior men dominating lesser beings on the basis of race, financial status, and gender. Not all upper class are completely corrupt, however. We see a semi-virtuous hero in the character of Prospero

Disguises and Mistaken Identity in Twelfth Night

1555 words - 6 pages fundamental message about the true nature of love and whether genuine love should be deemed as wrong purely based on gender. Similarly, this idea relates to the suggestion that Shakespeare may use mistaken identity and disguise to challenge society’s social norms and values in an Elizabethan period. At the time, it was a patriarchal society, male dominated, by which women remained passive and had to conform to social expectations. However, by

Similar Essays

Gender Roles In Romeo And Juliet, By William Shakespeare

876 words - 4 pages dead, she stabs herself through the heart with a dagger. The roles that man and women were supposed to play had a major impact on their deaths. If women were allowed to choose whom they were to marry, than there would not of been a problem with her marring Romeo. And if Romeo did not have to protect his honor and act like a man Tybault may still be alive and he would not of been banished from the city. Due to these gender roles that men and women are supposed to play both Romeo and Juliet’s life ended tragically. Works Cited Shakespeare, William. Romeo and Juliet. ed. John E. Hankins. New York: Penguin Books, 1960. "Verona." Baedeker. 3rd ed. 1996.

Gender Roles In Shakespeare Essay

1777 words - 7 pages . Beatrice says "O, that I were a man" (Much Ado About Nothing, IV.i.303), implying in context that her gender has made it impossible for her to act. Other female characters in Shakespeare do take on male roles, and whether it is because their true identity is hidden or simply by virtue of their acceptance as non-female, they are able to function in the text in ways that an undisguised female character could not. Rosalind

Transgressing Prescribed Gender Roles In Shakespeare

1938 words - 8 pages she is able to transcend traditional gender boundaries to become a powerful masculine figure, allowing Shakespeare to call into question the serious nature of gender and identity, while also adding to the comic relief of the play through the use of dramatic irony. The serious potential of transgressing gender roles is explored through Rosalind's ability to subvert the limitations that society imposes on her as a woman (Howard 221) and gain

Gender Roles In Macbeth By William Shakespeare

2032 words - 8 pages Gender Roles in Macbeth by William Shakespeare Although at the time of Shakespeare, women were thought of as lesser beings, he still manages to portray them as strong, and influential people in his play Macbeth. The orthodox view of females when Shakespeare wrote the play is that they were homemakers, looked after their children, they were quiet, weak and unintelligent, and the only reason they existed is to have male