This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Shakespeare Authorship Controversy Essay

1903 words - 8 pages

Shakespeare Authorship Controversy Zach Radel
The Shakespeare authorship controversy is the disagreement involving the dispute of whether William Shakespeare of Stratford-upon-Avon wrote the thirty-seven plays attributed to him. The authorship of the great works was first seriously questioned in the mid 19th century when reverence of Shakespeare as the paramount playwright in history had become the mutually broadcast opinion. Shakespeare's biography, which gleaned the details of his somewhat unexceptional origins and his reasonably secretive existence, seemed incompatible with his reputation for poetic genius. The controversy has spawned over seventy "authorship candidates", whose supporters argue that there are more plausible authors than Shakespeare. They state similar quotes such as, "Shakespeare's writings testify to the training of a scholar and a traveller, and to an intimate acquaintance with the great and learned." (Schoenbaum 545) Most contemporary scholars however agree with the opinion that, although other persons such as Christopher Marlowe, Francis Bacon, and Edward de Vere could be seen as possible authors, evidence, tradition, and history state that Shakespeare stands the legitimate author of all thirty-seven plays.A popular theory of anti-stratfordians is: The Marlovian theory. The theory holds that the Elizabethan poet and playwright Christopher Marlowe was the true author of the Shakespearean works. A question arises though, when you realize that if he was already a well-known playwright, why didn't he take credit for the plays that he supposedly wrote under the pseudonym of Shakespeare. One of the main arguments for the Marlovian theory is the similarity in style. Many parallelisms can be drawn between the plays by the authors including one set, which includes very similar versage from the balcony scene in Romeo and Juliet and Marlowe's The Jew of Malta. However, when comparing the written work between the two authors, the main problem with using similar writing style as an argument is it is not completely possible to determine whether they were by the same author, or if Shakespeare copied them knowingly or unknowingly. It is also worth mentioning that Shakespeare seemed to only "copy" from Marlowe, no one else and that Marlowe's influence is actually acknowledged by almost all Shakespeare scholars. His influence is duly noted in many of Shakespeare's early historical plays like The Life and Death of King John or Henry IV"As new information has become available over the years, however, the Marlovian argument about Marlowe's death has itself changed from thinking that because, in their view, he wrote Shakespeare his death must have been faked; to challenging the details of the inquest in an attempt to show that it must have been; to claiming that the circumstances surrounding it suggest that the faking is the most likely scenario, whether he went on to write Shakespeare or not." (Pinksen 19)This seems unlikely though because an...

Find Another Essay On Shakespeare Authorship Controversy

Korbin Drake Essay

1104 words - 5 pages Controversy at its Best Throughout many years of wonder and confusion, the main controversial and debatable question still remains, did William Shakespeare, in fact, write the famous plays accredited to him? For a lengthy amount of time, the question has never really truly been answered. Through the controversy, names have been thrown out left and right but no one person brought up has had substantial evidence supporting them in saying that

William Shakespeare's Life in London Essay

1087 words - 5 pages . Even though the plays were different at this time, they were still impressive and are a huge part of what literature has evolved to today. There is some controversy about the authorship of Shakespeare’s works. People are not one hundred percent certain whether William Shakespeare wrote all of his plays. Researchers believe that he could have been aided in the writing process or that other authors deserve the credit of his plays. Some scholars

William Shakespeare as a Writer

1696 words - 7 pages seemed to be very much in love with" (McMahon 4-5). The sonnets were well known by 1598, but were not published until 1609. They were probably the only works Shakespeare published that had personal meaning to him. Like any famous figure, Shakespeare also had his share of controversy. Although, none of it ever surfaced while he was alive. The biggest debate was over authorship. Did Shakespeare really exist and write his own work or was

Shakespeare as a Real Man in Shakespeare in Love

3728 words - 15 pages to examine the untold story -- how they categorically decided to ignore all of the surrounding debate about the true Shakespeare, to ignore the whole controversy surrounding the authorship question as if there could be no other choice. Instead, they presented the audience with a traditional version of the life of William Shakespeare, weaving aspects of the purist´s side into the film. Apart from that, the film

Francis Bacon, The True Poet of those Attributed to William Shakespeare

1108 words - 5 pages For the past few decades, people have questioned whether or not Shakespeare should be accredited for writing his own plays. “More than twenty thousand books and articles have been written about the identity problem regarding William Shakespeare”(Palmgren). Because of his earlier years in life, people have always thought there would be no way he had the capability of writing the impressive works that he is known for. There has been controversy

The Argument for Shakespeare Being the Real Author

1836 words - 7 pages Criticism. Ed. Michelle Lee and Dana Ramel Barnes. Vol. 41. Detroit: Gale Research, 1998. Literature Resource Center. Web. 16 Jan. 2014. Edmondson, Paul, and Stanley Wells, eds. Shakespeare Beyond Doubt: Evidence, Argument, Controversy. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, n.d. Print. Green, Nina. "Oxford's Biography." The Oxford Authorship Site. N.p., 2010. Web. 18 Jan. 2014. Looney, J. Thomas. "Shakespeare" Identified in Edward De Vere, the Seventeenth Earl of Oxford. New York: Frederick A. Stokes Company, 1920. Print. MrCrea, Scott. The Case for Shakespeare: The End of the Authorship Question. Westport: Praegar, 2005. Print.

Notes Of Much Ado About Nothing

1574 words - 6 pages official, would have been granted a waiver of tuition for his son. As the records do not exist, we do not know how long William attended the school, but certainly the literary quality of his works suggest a solid education. What is certain is that William Shakespeare never proceeded to university schooling, which has stirred some of the debate concerning the authorship of his works.The next documented event in Shakespeare's life is his marriage to

Perfectly Imperfect - The Shakespeare story

2367 words - 9 pages IIIRomeo and JulietThe Comedy of ErrorsThe Merchant of VeniceThe Merry Wives of WindsorThe Taming of the ShrewThe TempestThe Winter's TaleTimon of AthensTitus AndronicusTroilus and CressidaTwelfth NightTwo Gentlemen of VeronaVenus and AdonisThe list of Shakespeare's plays is very long, and this has led some to believe that other authors wrote some or all of Shakespeare's plays. This is called the 'authorship controversy.' The people who believe

William Shakespeare and His Works

3594 words - 14 pages sparked such controversy; the sonnet as a whole is very sexually driven. But the orientation toward which it drives, well, that is the question. Keep in mind that sonnet 20 is one out of 126 supposedly dedicated to the same man. There are several other examples of the poet praising his subject throughout, for example in number 68. Shakespeare “celebrates a friend’s decision to age naturally and truthfully, without recourse to cosmetics

Francis Bacon the Orchestrator of the Shakespearean Plays

1875 words - 8 pages Much controversy exists around the authorship of the Shakespearean plays. In this paper I shall put forth evidence as to why I believe Mr. Francis Bacon to be the Orchestrator of these great works, along with the help of a group of writers known as the Knights of the Helmet. While no concrete conclusive evidence that I have found can be put forth to end the debate. I shall try to show why this is the most likely logical conclusion. The time


9473 words - 38 pages some to raise questions about the authorship of his work and even about whether or not William Shakespeare ever existed.Theatrical BeginningsBy 1592, there is evidence William Shakespeare earned a living as an actor and a playwright in London and possibly had several plays produced. The September 20, 1592 edition of the Stationers' Register (a guild publication) includes an article by London playwright Robert Greene that takes a few jabs at

Similar Essays

Will The Real Slim Shakey Please Stand Up? Accellerated British Literature Argumentative Essay

1405 words - 6 pages , \ Best, David, and Sharon Marcus. “Surface Reading: An Introduction.” Representations, vol. 108, no. 1, Fall 2009, pp. 1-21. JSTOR, doi:10.1525/rep.2009.108.1.1 Edmondson, Paul and Stanley Wells, ed. Shakespeare Beyond Doubt: Evidence, Argument, Controversy. Cambridge University Press. Cambridge. 2013 “De Vere Authorship Argument.” De Vere Authorship Argument at Absolute Shakespeare

Life Of Shakespeare Essay

1126 words - 5 pages layer in society, his education, and the similarities between his poetry and that of Shakespeare’s. They claim that William Shakespeare had neither the education nor the literary training to write such rich characters, and intense and deep storylines (The Shakespeare Authorship Controversy, Wright). However, the vast majority of scholars are convinced that William Shakespeare existed and that he wrote all of his plays. They point out that other

Jagger Delgado Essay

869 words - 4 pages William Shakespeare: Was William Shakespeare the One Who Wrote the Poetry? Throughout many years of wonder and confusion, the main controversial question about Shakespeare has left many people dumbfounded. With knowledge and research, it is time to find out if Shakespeare was really the one who wrote these plays and poetry. For years there has been controversy surrounding this one question, did Shakespeare, in fact, write these famous plays

Who Was The Bard Essay

2399 words - 10 pages pattern and order on the Dedication page of Sonnets is almost a trillion to one. The controversy about the authorship of the Works has been laid out above. All of the evidence is against Shakespeare as being the author. Charles Dickens said: "The life of Shakespeare is a fine mystery." So much is unknown about his life, and the "proofs" that Shakespearites use to prove that he is the author are merely deductions made from a minute amount of