Shakespeare's Hamlet Indecision Within Hamlet

2491 words - 10 pages

The Hesitation/ Indecision within Hamlet

    Hamlet, the hero in Shakespeare’s dramatic tragedy of the same name, goes to great lengths to establish the absolute guilt of King Claudius – and then appears to blow it all. He hesitates at the prayer scene when the king could easily be dispatched. Let’s discuss this problem of hesitation or indecision on the part of the protagonist.


In “Acts III and IV: Problems of Text and Staging” Ruth Nevo explains how the protagonist is “confounded” in both the prayer scene and the closet scene:


In the prayer scene and the closet scene his [Hamlet’s] devices are overthrown. His mastery is confounded by the inherent liability of human reason to jump to conclusions, to fail to distinguish seeming from being. He, of all people, is trapped in the fatal deceptive maze of appearances that is the phenomenal world. Never perhaps has the mind’s finitude been better dramatized than in the prayer scene and in the closet scene. Another motto of the Player King is marvelously fulfilled in the nexus of ironies which constitutes the plays peripateia: “Our thoughts are ours, their ends none of our own.” In the sequence of events following Hamlet’s elation at the success of the Mousetrap, and culminating in the death of Polonius, all things are the opposite of what they seem, and action achieves the reverse of what was intended. Here in the play’s peripeteia is enacted Hamlet’s fatal error, his fatal misjudgment, which constitutes the crisis of the action, and is the directly precipitating cause of his own death, seven other deaths, and Ophelia’s madness. (52)


David Bevington, in the Introduction to Twentieth Century Interpretations of Hamlet, eliminates some possible reasons for Hamlet’s hesitation in killing Claudius during the prayer scene:


Several limits can be placed upon the search for an explanation of Hamlet’s apparent hesitation to avenge. He is not ineffectual under ordinary circumstances. Elizabethan theories of melancholy did not suppose the sufferer to be made necessarily inactive. Hamlet has a deserved reputation in Denmark for manliness and princely demeanor. He keeps up his fencing practice and will “win at the odds” against Laertes. He threatens with death those who would restrain him from speaking with the ghost – even his friend Horatio – and stabs the concealed Polonius unflinchingly. On the sea voyage to England he boards a pirate ship single-handed in the grapple, after having arranged without remorse for the deaths of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. In light of these deeds, Hamlet’s self-accusations are signs of burning impatience in one who would surely act if he could. (5-6)


The play begins on a guard platform of a castle in Denmark:


The story opens in the cold and dark of a winter night in Denmark, while the guard is being changed on the battlements of the royal castle of Elsinore. For two nights in succession, just as the bell strikes the...

Find Another Essay On Shakespeare's Hamlet - Indecision within Hamlet

Indecision, Hesitation and Delay in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1937 words - 8 pages . Fineman, Joel. 1980. 'Fratricide and Cuckoldry: Shakespeare's Doubles.' In Representing Shakespeare: New Psychoanalytic Essays, edited by Coppelia Kahn and Murray M. Schwarz. Baltimore and London: The Johns Hopkins Press, 70-109. Fleissner, Robert. 1982. ' "Sullied" Or "Solid": Hamlet's Flesh Once More.' Hamlet Studies 4:92-3. Fowler, Alastair. 1987. 'The Plays Within the Play of Hamlet.' In 'Fanned and Winnowed Opinions

Hamlet - Is there Indecision? Essay

3108 words - 12 pages my father      Than I to Hercules: within a month:      Ere yet the salt of most unrighteous tears      Had left the flushing in her galled eyes,      She married. O, most wicked speed, to post      With such dexterity to incestuous sheets!   Soon Horatio, the hero’s closest friend (“Horatio, thou art e'en as just a man / As e'er my conversation coped withal.”), and Marcellus make contact with Hamlet and escort him to

Hamlet and Indecision

1475 words - 6 pages Dennis LiuENG 4UAugust 28th, 2014"The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark," written by William Shakespeare, takes place in Denmark in the medieval era. Like other tragedies of William Shakespeare such as "Romeo & Juliet," "Macbeth," and "Othello," "Hamlet" ends in death. Whoever holds the name in Shakespeare's title is not looking forward to a happily-ever-after type of conclusion in Shakespeare's plays. The protagonist of "The Tragedy of

Madness and Insanity in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Insanity within Hamlet

1956 words - 8 pages Insanity within Hamlet         Let us explore in this essay the real or feigned madness of the hero in William Shakespeare’s dramatic tragedy Hamlet.   Critical opinion is divided on this question. A.C. Bradley in Shakespearean Tragedy staunchly adheres to the belief that Hamlet would cease to be a tragic character if he were really mad at any time in the play (30). On the other hand, W. Thomas MacCary in Hamlet: A Guide to the

Indecision, Hesitation and Delay in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Excessive Hesitation and Delay?

2913 words - 12 pages Hamlet – the Hesitation and Indecision       William Shakespeare’s Hamlet presents a hero who hesitates to avenge his dead father when given the opportunity – what should be his judgment? This paper examines the decision from various points of view.   Mark Rose, in “Reforming the Role,” comments on how the hero’s hesitation to kill at the propitious moment, coupled with his later hasty decision to kill, have left the protagonist a

Shakespeare's Hamlet

1849 words - 8 pages Hamlet. Laertes serves as a direct foil to Hamlet. Laertes’ general behavior draw direct parallels to Hamlet’s, and the contrast between the two of them highlights some of the flaws in Hamlet’s behavior, such as his indecision and his thoughtlessness. The world of Hamlet is undeniably chaotic and full of contradictions. This strangeness pervades the play, evident both externally in the atmosphere of Denmark (for example, with the presence of

Shakespeare's Hamlet.

1849 words - 7 pages In William Shakespeare's play Hamlet, the concept of cultural identity is explored through Hamlet's isolation which is created by the conflict between his duty to his father, and his duties to the monarchy and society. Hamlet is isolated from his society due to his turbulent emotions which result from his indecision on how to respond to his father's murder. Hamlet's duty as a son is to avenge his father's death and he would be supported in his

Shakespeare's "Hamlet".

1479 words - 6 pages he has obtained sufficient proof from Claudius' reaction to the play-within-the-play, Hamlet realises he should kill him, as he had promised the ghost. However, Rosencrantz and Guildenstern inform him that he must go and see his mother. A key point here is that he could easily have killed Claudius first, and then gone to "speak daggers" to Gertrude afterwards. The fact that he did what his 'friends' asked him to do first shows that he is beginning

Themes within Hamlet

2056 words - 8 pages Themes within Hamlet         Regarding the themes in Shakespeare’s tragic drama Hamlet, there is a divergence of opinion among literary critics about which should be called the dominant theme and which should be classed as secondary. This essay will discuss the various themes and their ranking.   Perhaps the most popular theme in the play is that of revenge. R.A. Foakes in “The Play’s Courtly Setting” explains the burden of

Corruption within hamlet

959 words - 4 pages personified within the play, Hamlet's major antagonist is a shrewd, lustful, conniving king who contrasts sharply with the other male characters in the play. Whereas most of the other important men in Hamlet are preoccupied with ideas of justice, revenge, and moral balance, Claudius is bent upon maintaining his own power. The old King Hamlet was apparently a stern warrior, but Claudius is a corrupt politician whose main weapon is his ability to

The Characterization within Hamlet

3176 words - 13 pages The Characterization within Hamlet      This essay will inform the reader regarding the characterization found in Shakespeare’s tragedy Hamlet – whether the dramatis personae are three-dimensional or two-dimensional, dynamic or static, and other aspects of the character portrayal.   John Dover Wilson in What happens in Hamlet tells how the Bard is capable of even bringing realism to a ghost:   Shakespeare’s Ghost is both a

Similar Essays

Indecision, Hesitation And Delay In Shakespeare's Hamlet Procrastination And Indecision

1840 words - 7 pages Hamlet – the Hesitation and Indecision         Is there a plausible explanation for the hesitation by Hamlet in carrying out the ghost’s request in Shakespeare’s Hamlet?   Lawrence Danson in the essay “Tragic Alphabet” discusses the hesitation in action by the hero; this is related to his hesitation in speech:   To speak or act in a world where all speech and action are equivocal seeming is, for Hamlet, both perilous and

Indecision, Hesitation And Delay In Shakespeare's Hamlet

2497 words - 10 pages The Indecisiveness and Hesitation of Hamlet         In the Shakespearean drama Hamlet considerable literary critical comment swirls about the subject of the hero’s hesitation or indecision in the prayer scene. Is it weakness? Is it representative of a mental condition? Are there other incidences of hesitation? Let us explore the subject in this essay and interpret the key scene in light of other scenes, with input from literary critics

Indecision, Hesitation And Delay In Shakespeare's Hamlet

2484 words - 10 pages Ghost, ironically a sinner suffering in the afterlife (West 110), reveals to the protagonist the extent of the evil within Elsinore, “the human truth” (Abrams 467). The Ghost says that King Hamlet I was murdered by Claudius, who had a relationship with Gertrude prior to the murder; the ghost requests revenge by Hamlet: “Revenge his foul and most unnatural murder.”   Ay, that incestuous, that adulterate beast,      With witchcraft of

Indecision, Hesitation And Delay In Shakespeare's Hamlet

2233 words - 9 pages explicable. He seems to have utter proof of Claudius’ guilt, but it is from sources that will not stand up in any court. For example, you cannot hail a Ghost before the judge. Hamlet quite justifiably becomes suspicious of the Ghost’s story. Very well, he will test it-and does so in the play-within-a –play. But even after that “proof” he is still, at least subconsciously, in doubt (Kemp 13). Kemp reflects on the scene where Hamlet is first commanded