This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Shakespearean Adaptations For Children Essay

1093 words - 4 pages

Undeniably, the works of William Shakespeare have inspired contemporary adaptations that can appeal to audiences who have never read the Bard’s plays. But how appropriate is it to present to children, who lack the life experience and maturity to understand the depth of the works, the dark side of Shakespeare—the death of Juliet, the seductive nature of Caliban in The Tempest, and the violent struggles in Hamlet? There is no simple answer. In appropriating Shakespeare's works for young audiences, producers often alter elements that are deemed inappropriate for children—namely death, sex, and violence—but nonetheless play significant roles in the plays. Obviously, some value is lost in translation. However, the resulting recreations become gateways for young audiences to experience classic works of theatre, possibly outweighing the loss of thematic meaning. Ultimately, Shakespeare for young audiences is divisive, with valid arguments existing both for and against appropriation.
The significance of death in Shakespeare’s works is undeniable and conveys many themes in his plays. In Romeo and Juliet, Shakespeare uses death to comment on the nature and consequences of conflict (Romeo and Juliet). These thematic elements are important in the text, but are practically absent in Disney’s The Lion King II: Simba’s Pride, which directly appropriates the play. In the film, Kiara and Kovu, the children of two warring families, fall in love and inevitably quell their families’ feuds; they are Romeo and Juliet (The Lion King II). Death is not completely removed from the story, but in comparison with its source material, The Lion King II omits the most important deaths in Romeo and Juliet—those of the titular characters.
In the film, Kiara and Kovu, the stand-ins for Shakespeare’s young lovers, do not commit suicide, and their story concludes with Disney’s quintessential happily-ever-after (The Lion King II). This representation of death undermines the critical theme of conflict present in the original text, as well as the notion of “star-crossed lovers,” whose fates are predetermined. The film does not acknowledge the reality that conflict involves casualties and is often not easily resolved. That said, The Lion King II does introduce young audiences to a classic work of theatre and too much death would seem out-of-place in this adaptation. The question remains of whether the value of death lies in the action itself or its significance in the story that frames it.
Many of Shakespeare’s works include topics of sexuality and overly sexualized characters (Wells 1). Shakespeare’s motivation for sexualizing the behavior of his characters depends on the play in question. In The Tempest, Caliban is characterized as seductive and manipulative to highlight the theme of sensuality as persuasion, which is the nature of sex when stripped of physicality (The Tempest). Like all of the Bard’s works, this play is not immune to appropriation, and Caliban serves as a template in...

Find Another Essay On Shakespearean Adaptations for Children

How does Macbeth follow what is expected in a Shakespearean Tragedy?

767 words - 3 pages here after." (Witch 3)Act 1 Scene 3 Line 46-49The Prophesy and Lady Macbeth's very strong influence on Macbeth's decisions (as she seems to over power him greatly, in a type of revengeful way for her not begin able to have children.) are the causes of Macbeth's 'fatal flaw'. This occurs when he is torn between the choices to follow what is right or his wants (and Lady Macbeth's wants). In the end, his wants over power what is right and this is the

Shakespeare as a Real Man in Shakespeare in Love

3728 words - 15 pages feel that modern adaptations don´t challenge viewers and offer weaker plots and less complex characters. Shakespeare in Love combines in a way both. The film applauds the brilliance of Shakespearean writing through the lines directly taken from Shakespeare, while at the same time exploring a fictional depiction of his true love and life. When you deconstruct the script, Shakespeare in Love is built in perfect Shakespearian

Interview comparing Oliver Parker's "Othello' and Tim Blake Nelson's 'O' to the original play Othello. Othello- William Shakespeare

1234 words - 5 pages Hello and welcome to the movie show. This week we have James Pearson, a recognised Shakespearean authority and critic to discuss two film adaptations of the Shakespearean play Othello. Oliver Parker's 1995 production and Tim Blake Nelson's 'O' will be the two films analysed against the original play. James, which do you think better represents Shakespeare's original intent?Well Paul, it would be very hard to decide because the target audience is

Criticism of William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet

1658 words - 7 pages Our Children”. Parents Magazine. August 1945. Dibdin, Charles. "Shakespeare’s Plays," in A Complete History of the English Stage, Vol. III 1800. Reprint by Garland Publishing, Inc., 1970, pp.30-65. Reprinted in Shakespearean Criticism, Vol.5. Dryden, John. The Shakespeare Allusion –Book: A Collection of Allusions to Shakespeare from 1591-1700, Vol. II edited by John Munro, revised editions, 1932. Reprint by Books for Libraries Press, 1970

Paratextuality in Shakespeare's King Lear

3319 words - 13 pages Pitching Mad Boy: How Paratextuality Mediates the Distance Between Spectators, Adaptations, and Source Texts. A popular anecdote used to introduce students and spectators to King Lear tells how, for 150 years, the stage was dominated by Nahum Tate’s adaptation, in which Lear and Cordelia are happily reconciled, and Cordelia is married off to Edgar. Here is what N.H. Hudson had to say about Tate: This shameless, this execrable piece of

Marcus Brutus as the Tragic Hero in Shakespeare's Julius Caesar

1280 words - 5 pages conspirators, have been put into the "tragedies" category. According to the specifications and qualifications for a Shakespearean tragedy, Brutus, one of the men who conspired against Julius Caesar, can be considered a tragic hero. Despite the fact that Brutus can be considered a tragic hero, I don't feel that he has the qualities and traits of a true hero. The first element of a Shakespearean tragedy is the requirement of a tragic hero. This tragic

On the Triumph of Stanley by Means of Natural Selection: Survival of the Fittest in A Streetcar Named Desire by Tenessee Williams

1523 words - 7 pages implies that the organisms which can most readily change and adapt to their present situation will be the most able to survive in any environment. In addition, environment-specific adaptations can prove superior to overall advancements in the evolutionary chain. For example, humans are widely considered to be further along in the evolutionary chain than most other organisms; they are poorly suited to life on the ocean floor, but primitive

Charlotte Chorpenning: Changing Children's Theatre Forever

760 words - 3 pages century by writing and adapting countless plays for children. Charlotte Chorpenning’s writings and adaptations of children’s plays have changed the world of children’s theatre by nearly doubling the repertoire for children’s theatre while continually portraying a traditional moral message in her plays. Chorpenning’s experience with teaching and dealing with children helped form and influence her writings. Before she started to write and

Exercise And Resistance Training Guidelines For Children

1922 words - 8 pages this type of training it is observed that strength capability is increased through training within the nervous, as well as muscular, system. According to Westcott (2003:1) strength adaptations and exercise offers numerous advantages and benefits for youngsters, over and above any other form of training adaptation. It is also seen to be more enticing for many children as a primary preference of physical activity with periods of rest and recovery

Mens Superiority over Women During Shakespearean Times

935 words - 4 pages house. They may do most of the chores, but they have a job to support the family. Most women pay the bills and shop for the food. Women may question what their husband demands, and this is now called common sense. Some things, like taking good care of the children, are left for the mother. Men will not question the abilities of a good wife, or look down on her.Society created a disappointing existence for women. "In the eyes of the law, women

Macbeth as a Shakespearean Tragic Hero

2784 words - 11 pages natural order itself. When Macbeth first murders Duncan, the "chimneys were blown down and "the earth was feverous and did shake"; a Shakespearean tragic hero's actions normally affect other people or the country itself and this is what is happening here. Normally the audience feel great sympathy for the Shakespearean tragic hero. The audience feel pity and sympathy for Macbeth because he has finally got what he wanted, to

Similar Essays

William Shakespeare's The Taming Of The Shrew

3110 words - 12 pages thoughtful, showing no evidence of the women who are acted out in the play or any of its other adaptations. Booth also suggests that “the models of womanhood in her studies of Shakespeare and art are striking figures for the potential of feminist biographical representation.” This argues that the artists who interpreted Shakespearean characters may be seen as early feminist scholars, in that they seem to depict the women as mostly independent

To Know Our Foundations: The Greek And Elizabethan Eras

828 words - 4 pages , studying Greek and Shakespearean works was not without its challenges. The most daunting task I faced, as I had encountered many times before, was comprehending the texts' complex use of language. Extensive passages, unfamiliar syntax, and archaic vocabulary had, for many years, frustrated me and kept me from exploring the classics. Reading Shakespeare often felt like deciphering a foreign language, despite the words being written in English

William Shakespeare Essay

659 words - 3 pages hearts with the stories that he tells. From tragedy to history his tales of love, drama, adventure and comedy live on, his words forever immortalized. His words cut across history and culture. His characters continue to tell their stories centuries later due to their complexity. We see modern adaptations of Shakespearean plays everywhere “West Side Story” (Romeo and Juliet), Lion King (Hamlet), “My Own Private Idaho” ( Henry IV, Henry V) and “Forbidden Planet” (Tempest). These adaptations may not be the work of Shakespeare himself but even from centuries past he still finds ways to influence our lives.

Shakespeare's Timeless Love Story Retold In Film

1264 words - 6 pages “He was not of an age, but for all time!”, described Ben Jonson in regards to Shakespeare (qtd. in Chrisp 62). As research proves, there is no doubt to the truth of this statement. Adding to Jonson’s words in regards to Shakespeare’s timelessness Peter Chrisp explains that “there have been more than 500 film and TV adaptations of Shakespeare’s dramas” (Chrisp 65; Mabillard). Furthermore, in the introduction to Gnomeo and Juliet, a Red Good