This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Shay's Rebellion And The Modern Militia

858 words - 3 pages

'Who are the militia? Are they not ourselves? Is it feared, then, that we shall turn our arms each man against his own bosom? Congress shall have no power to disarm the militia. Their swords and every other terrible implement of the soldier, are the birth-right of an American...the unlimited power of the sword is not in the hand of either the federal or the state governments, but where I trust in God it will ever remain, in the hands of the People.'-Tench Coxe, Pennsylvania Gazette, Feb. 20, 1788Throughout history the citizen making up militias and anti-government rebellions have all possessed similar characteristics. Though separated by many decades and wars Shay's Rebellion and the Whisky Rebellion of the late 18th century hold similar ties with the unarmed militias of the 1990's. The background, fears, and influence of the rebellious anti-government citizens of the Whiskey and Shay's Rebellion parallel with the recent politically far-right extremist militias. All three assembled the poor yet supporting back-bone of the United States; fearful of the government's potential; and dramatically influenced the general public.The individuals making up these militias have mostly been poor males who believe they are regarded by the majority of persons as being economically unimportant. In both the Shay's Rebellion and Whisky Rebellion the men compromising the opposing force were unwealthy adult male farmers from small villages. In the Shay's Rebellion, fifty-four percent of the combatants made their living as Yeomen and less then five percent considered themselves 'gentlemen farmers' (Saztmary 127). Comparably, the modern militia movement, though providing for a pool of potential recruits for the militias draws most of its members from a large and growing number of US citizens alienated by a government that seems hostile to their interests. This group of affected individuals are predominately politically far-right Caucasian males of the lower-middle and working class sector (Stern 14). These are men that have been affected by global economic restructuring, with its job losses and a declining standard of living.A series of tax revolts during the 18th century in America and the uprisings against the government today all resulted from a deep ceded fear that the government would take away the peoples freedom. The basis of Shay's Rebellion and the Whiskey Rebellion was a dissatisfaction with the power of the government to freely tax the people. Fearful of the authority of the federal government, they thought that it would take over their rights and freedom. During the period of Shay's Rebellion, John Bardwell characterized government rule as 'the...

Find Another Essay On Shay's Rebellion and the Modern Militia

A Well Regulated Militia: The Founding Fathers and the Origins of Gun Control in America

1323 words - 6 pages The second issue in this paper is about rebellions throughout American history. There were several rebellions, but Shays’ Rebellion, the Whiskey Rebellion, and Fries’s Rebellion were an important part of the militia debate. “Shays’s Rebellion was the largest violent uprising in the new nation’s history, would become the first test of the radical potential of the militia and the right to bear arms in post-Revolutionary America”(Cornell, 31

Roles of Colonial Militia and Continental Army in Winning the Revolutionary War

2040 words - 8 pages Roles of Colonial Militia and Continental Army in Winning the Revolutionary War When the fighting at Lexington and Concord broke out in 1775, the conflict unleashed a flood of resentment that had been building over the right of the colonies to govern themselves. This conflict became a symbol of the American fight for "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." As James Kirby Martin and Mark Edward Lender argue in A Respectable Army

Religion and the Northern Rebellion of 1568

1049 words - 4 pages Religion and the Northern Rebellion of 1568 At the time of the Northern Rebellion in 1568, the North of England was greatly aggrieved. When Elizabeth had ascended to the throne she appointed loyal men to her throne, usually Protestants like William Cecil at the expense of the Northern Earls. This subtraction of power of course angered the Northern Earls, but was the Northern Rebellion just down to this? Religion

Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Rebellion

854 words - 4 pages own identity, and his physical and psychological rebellion bolsters the confidence that drives his success. Douglass’ introduction to reading and writing motivates his ambition to reshape his character, which inspires his escape to freedom. Discouraged by his slavery, Douglass suddenly experiences an epiphanic moment realizing that “to wit [is] the white man’s power to enslave the black man... From that moment [Douglass] understood the pathway

Spring Reawakened: The Mind and Matter of Rock and Rebellion

1741 words - 7 pages What constitutes a rebellion against conformity? Is the desire for revolution a matter of action or simply a state of mind? In the 1990s, America’s counterculture was founded on the alternative, grunge, and punk rock movements that embodied the spirit of intrapersonal tension and social upheaval. The ideas emphasized through this counterculture have utilized and influenced many art forms, including theatre. Steven Sater’s Spring Awakening

Factors Leading to the Rebellion in Burma and the Phillippines

1739 words - 7 pages Post-independence rebellions refers to insurgencies, by groups who either challenge the ruling power or other groups, out of political and social reasons, that occurs after a state has achieved recognized independence from a colonial power. In this essay, I will discuss the similarities and differences in the varying factors that led to the outbreak of rebellion in Burma and the Philippines. Independence of Burma from Britain was achieved on

Female Rebellion and It's Impliactions in The Bacchae

980 words - 4 pages Euripdies' The Bacchae is known for its celebration of women's rebellion and patriarchial overthrow, claims which hold truth if not supremely. The Thebans, along with other women, pursue the rituals and culture of Dionysus’s cult which enacts their rebellion against men and the laws of their community. However, this motion to go aginst feminine norms is short lived as they lose power. When Agave comes to her epiphany, Dionysus is the one who is

Governments Established by a Rebellion: The US and France

656 words - 3 pages France and the U.S. are both governments that were established from a rebellion. They created their forms of government because they wanted a voice in the government, wanted a fair tax structure, and wanted to get rid of their respective monarchs. France’s and the U.S.'s government are both fairly old, 1799 and 1783 respectively. They both are similar in many ways. The countries wanted a Republican form of governments to address thier concerns

Conformity and Rebellion in Conversion of the Jews

1314 words - 5 pages Conformity and Rebellion in Conversion of the Jews Though it seems like a stereotype, all teenagers, at some point, choose to rebel against authority figures or conform with their friends. Part of growing up means becoming the person God intends you to be and finding out how to survive, or be independent, on your own. Conformity and rebellion, two issues that each human being has experienced, have great effects not only on

The Modern Family and Traditionalism

2005 words - 9 pages Traditional and Modern Family All cultures reflect different levels of the importance of family. The Jewish have this famous saying, “God could not be everywhere and therefore he made mothers.” The Chinese believe if you know one’s family, you do not need to know the individual because his identity is directly linked to his family. For the Africans, family is one’s legacy, “A person who has children does not die.” On the other hand, the

Eros and The Modern World

2412 words - 10 pages is one member of a race of mythical creatures. Second is the misconception that Eros is the god of love when he is really the god of sexual desire. Although Eros is commonly depicted in the modern world he is more often recognized by his Roman name Cupid. By using the name Cupid it becomes much easier to find depictions of the god Eros. For this assignment I have chosen to use three depictions from the modern world and one from the

Similar Essays

The Whiskey And Shay's Rebellion Essay

1558 words - 7 pages toward the armory a day early. Shays' fourteen hundred men approached the armory unsupported by their allies. Bowdoin's militia pursued the defeated rebels, and managed to scatter the rebels force completely, but Shays was able to escape, fleeing to Vermont. This battle was the effective end of the rebellion (Stock). The ineffectiveness of the central government to contain this uprising led to the unnecessary death of many innocent people. The lasting

The Ripple Effects Of Shay's Rebellion

1012 words - 5 pages and hold them back. The militia of Massachusetts was there but would not protect the judges, after court the judges snuck out. The farmers then took over the empty courthouse. After this event, many courthouses around the state were being held up by different farmer groups that were inspired by the acts of Shays’ men. Talk of the rebellion spread quickly through the country and state. Massachusetts went to the Congress of the Confederation to ask

The Hutu Militia And The Disaster Of Rwanda

735 words - 3 pages It was early in April when the disaster of Rwanda happened. When the president of Rwanda , Juvènal Habyarimana, was assassinated. After the president was assassinated thats when the fighting and killings started. A guy who has won the Pulitzer Prize twice said the most vivid thing from his assignment was hearing all the scream. The Hutu militia was killing everyone and everything that had crossed their path. The stench of dead bodies was

The Whiskey And Shay Rebellion Essay

1348 words - 6 pages Regulators side caused a group to march toward the armory a day early. Shays' fourteen hundred men approached the armory unsupported by their allies. Bowdoin's militia pursued the defeated rebels, and managed to scatter the rebels force completely, but Shays was able to escape, fleeing to Vermont. This battle was the effective end of the rebellion (Stock). The ineffectiveness of the central government to contain this uprising led to the