This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Sherlock Holmes: Logician Or Theseologist? Essay

4562 words - 18 pages

Sherlock Holmes: Logician or Theseologist?

I propose to devote my declining years to the composition of a textbook which shal focus the whole art of detection into one volume.

—Sherlock Holmes in The Adventure of the Abbey Grange

He is a Logician

A logician studies the way we ought to reason; she is interested in the distinction between corect reasoning and incorect reasoning. Although we al reason and are often interested in whether our reasoning is valid we are not a l logicians because we do not make a study of it; that is, we do not reflect deeply enough on this subject.

Now Sherlock Holmes reasons a great deal—Watson cals him the greatest reasoning machine in the world. But he not only reasons he also reflects on how we should reason. Indeed, he was planning on writing a textbook on the art of detection when he retired. When a
person is planning on writing on a subject that he knows so wel in practice he must have thought deeply about the subject.

Sherlock Holmes' profession is crime detection. His expertise is in finding out what criminals are hiding from the rest of the world. But as he has demonstrated over and over again his kind of reasoning can be applied to al kinds of situations in which we want to uncover knowledge of things to which we do not have direct access. Sherlock Holmes was not present when a crime was commited, , but after he had done his work he was able to describe what happened, if not to the last detail, then at least (as he says) in essentials. Watson went out one morning unaccompanied. Afterwards Sherlock Holmes had no dificulty teling him, Watson, what he, Watson, had been doing. Sherlock Holmes is interested in the kind of reasoning that in a textbook on logic would come under the heading 'Scientfic Method'. Indeed, in textbooks as wel as on other occasions Sherlock Holmes is often brought in to ilustrate scientfic method. In one of the articles he has published Sherlock Holmes has this to say concerning the power of this kind of reasoning From a drop of water … . a logician could infer the possibility of an Atlantic or a Niagara without having seen or heard of one or the other.

A Study in Scarlet

Things scientists know are not confined to things they have seen or heard. Scientists are able to tel us what happened milions of years ago—just as Sherlock Holmes is able to tel us what happened when a crime was commited. Now how is this done if not by reasoning? There are two ways for us to know: either directly or by inference. Since scientists were not there milions of years ago; since Sherlock Holmes was not there when the crime was commited; they could not have known what they know directly. They have to rely on reasoning. It is through reasoning that they find out what they want to know.

Sherlock Holmes is aware that he engages in a special form of reasoning—special when compared to the kind we ordinarily do. He cals it reasoning backwards.

In solving a problem of this sort,...

Find Another Essay On Sherlock Holmes: Logician or Theseologist?

Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes vs. BBC's Sherlock A research paper comparing and contrasting the original Sherlock Holmes novels to the BBC TV series

1576 words - 6 pages experienced it, or if it is simply a retelling of an original story that manages to retain its appeal throughout the years. Although I had never read any of Doyle's books prior to starting my research, I was aware that each episode of Sherlock is loosely based on one of Doyle's stories. I was inspired to learn more about Doyle's original Sherlock Holmes, so I composed two questions to investigate: How faithful is BBC's Sherlock to the original

Sherlock Holmes Essay

1090 words - 5 pages Sherlock Holmes is one of the most famous detective. The books are written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. There are four long stories and 56 short stories. ‘A Study in Scarlet’ is the first Sherlock Holmes story. Sherlock Holmes makes his first his appearance in this book and uses his skills to solve murder case. This book is first published in 1887. A Study in Scarlet is a long story book. The mystery presents in this book is a murder mystery and

sherlock holmes

471 words - 2 pages FILM REVIEW #1 Sherlock Holmes is a fictional criminologist. He has an alternate method for explaining the crimes all round, he has a legitimate and exploratory methodology for each case he comprehends. Sherlock Holmes stories strengthens Victorian time values.Sherlock Holmes was in action when Victorian individuals had fear of climbing crimes in the England in the eighteenth century. All the easier class individuals who were included in any

The Personality of Sherlock Holmes

916 words - 4 pages The Personality of Sherlock Holmes Sherlock Holmes, a creation of Scottish Author and Physician Sir Author Conan Doyle, is a fictional detective famous for his prowess at using logic and astute observation to solve cases. Sherlock is a very unique individual and he is so realistic that many people believe he was a real man existed in the late 19th century. In fact, Sherlock

Sherlock Holmes

785 words - 3 pages from the Victorian era loved Sherlock Holmes is the way he solves the crimes. He is observant, intelligent, has a sense of humour, brave and makes deductions very well from almost nothing. Sherlock is a tall slim man with sharp piercing eyes, square shoulders, and known for his hat and pipe, which he smokes quite a lot. He sometimes acts stupidly to catch criminals or uses role reversal and take the criminals for fools. Sherlock Holmes is

A Comparison and Contrast of Sherlock Holmes as a Criminal in “Charles Augustus Milverton” and “A Scandal in Bohemia”

2012 words - 9 pages master of crime detection, popular media portrays him as cunning and genius in his methods of crime detection. The method Doyle used in creating Holmes is exquisite, with O. Berg stating “A review of the Sherlock Holmes stories and novels will quickly reveal the wide spectrum of scientific methods and interests utilized by Holmes in his many cases. Almost every one of the forensic sciences as we known them today is touched upon in some manner or

Influence of Sherlock Holmes

1381 words - 6 pages Sherlock Holmes, a name most people would know if they were to hear it, has come to greatly influence the modern world of mysteries. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle had no idea a character he started to write about for the first time in 1887 would still be carried alive by other TV and movie producers in 2014. Doyle also never new that Holmes would become such a popular character or result in a name mostly everybody would know. Even if there was a


1876 words - 8 pages Sherlock Holmes Over the years since Sir Arthur Conan Doyle created the character Sherlock Holmes and wrote a collection of stories of the detective, there have been many television adaptations of his Sherlock Holmes stories. Currently in the 21st century there are two most commonly watched, a Sherlock, BBC version of Sherlock Holmes, and Elementary, US version of Sherlock Holmes. Most of whom have read the stories have read them when they

Sherlock Holmes: A Timeless Victorian Creation

2134 words - 9 pages Arthur Conan Doyle’s legacy rests heavily on one Victorian creation: the character of Sherlock Holmes. Holmes's attitude of intelligence and originality continues to keep fans inclined and fascinated ever since the Victorian era. Holmes persists as remakes and reincarnations of the Sherlock character keep the mastermind relevant. While the modernization of Sherlock creates a personal connection between the reader and Sherlock in “A Scandal in

An essay discussing wether Rudolph Fleisch's "Sherlock Holmes" can be rightly described as a 'Genius'

803 words - 3 pages "What makes men of genius, or rather what they make is not new ideas, it is that idea- possessing them,..."This is Rudolph Fleisch's idea and definition of a 'genius'. In this essay, I will pursue this idea with the purpose of convincing the reader that Sherlock Holmes is indeed a believable study of a 'genius'.Sherlock Holmes is a fictional character created by the well-known author Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. This late Victorian writer invented a

Moriarty as a Trickster

1394 words - 6 pages inversion, bricoleur, and imitation of the gods. Hyde maintains that all tricksters are motivated by a hunger, be it food or otherwise. When thinking of these traits the many incarnations of James Moriarty come to mind but none quite resonate with each of them like that played by Andrew Scott in BBC’s series Sherlock. In this recent adaption, Moriarty is driven by an insatiable need to best Sherlock Holmes through a series of clever competitions

Similar Essays

Why Is Dr.Watson Important To Sherlock Holmes

675 words - 3 pages the humane personality of Dr.Watson, Sherlock might just be consumed by his demons, or his bad side, a drug addict side.You may see this in almost every Sherlock Holmes book or TV show. The second reason would be because Dr. Watson provides Sherlock with a different perspective towards the case and the clues. Dr.Watson is more “human”, therefore, he provides Sherlock with a normal human's point of view. In the Sherlock BBC TV Show epidsode of

Compare And Constrast Between Warner Bros’ [Wb] Sherlock Holmes And Bbc’s Sherlock

947 words - 4 pages Sherlock Holmes earned the title in Guinness World Record as the “Most Portrayed Literary Human Character in Film & TV”, the world’s favorite “consulting detective” has been adapted by over 75 actors on screen over 250 times. Originally from a famous detective story by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle in 1887 , Sherlock Holmes is well known for his exceptional intellect. Ever since Doyle published his first novel, ‘Sherlockians’ demanded more; and this is

The Influence Of Sherlock Holmes Essay

1503 words - 7 pages , and brought back the famous detective in the novel “The Hound of the Baskervilles”. The critic Christopher Morley, while speaking of Holmes, said “Perhaps no fiction character ever created has become so charmingly real to his readers” (World Book). Believe it or not, Sherlock Holmes is just as popular today as he was 100 years ago, and fans of Sherlock Holmes are just as crazy today as they were when the stories were first published. As of today

Sherlock And Watson Essay

1107 words - 5 pages lastly the how the modern day versions of the stories have twisted or defied this very important characteristic of the stories. From the very first publish of the stories of Sherlock Holmes, ”A Scandal in Bohemia,” the story is started out from the perspective of Dr. Watson telling of his separation from his friend Sherlock. The story states that the pair had drifted apart due to Watson’s Marriage and the Dr. Watson had only heard from Sherlock in