This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Wise Decision: Sherron Watkins Letter To Kenneth Lay

946 words - 4 pages

1. What risks did Sherron Watkins take by writing the six-page letter to Kenneth Lay? Do you believe she should have written the letter? Why or why not?

Sherron Watkins takes a lot of risk when she decides to write a six-page letter to Kenneth Lay. She puts her jobs as well as personal and family safety at risk. This is because she may be fired, sued, blacklisted, arrested, threatened, or even assaulted or killed by Kenneth Lay and other top executives who responsible for Enron’s collapse. For instance, if she get fired, it is hard for her to find another employment because the other employers may be in doubt on her capabilities as she get fired from Enron, the “America’s Most Innovative Company” as named by Fortune for six consecutive year. Thus, during the decision-making process, it can be a financial and emotional hardship for Sherron Watkins.

However, we do believe that she should have written the letter. As what Sherron Watkins said in one of the interviews, “If your values are being challenged, get out, because you cannot change an unethical corporation unless you are at the very top. Pay attention to rationalizations.” The famous rationalization at Enron was, “What do we have accounting rules in this country for, if you do not use them.” Enron has the obligation to comply with the underlying principles in the accounting rules and when Enron break the rules, there must be someone who comes out to report or correct the mistakes in order to save countless lives and billions of dollars in public funds and prevent the disasters from worsening.

Furthermore, Sherron Watkins as vice president for corporate development of Enron shall adhere to Enron’s ethics code which based on respect, integrity, communication, and excellence. When Enron has no longer practice the respectful treatment, did something that they say they will not do, does not communicate and move the information well to the public as well as does not committed to excellent in everything they do, Sherron Watkins as an employee of Enron should conform to the code of ethics by exposing corruption, fraud, conspiracy, mismanagement and other wrong doing that threaten public interests, financial integrity and human rights.

2. Suppose that Sherron Watkins decided to do nothing with the knowledge she had regarding Enron’s “funny accounting”. What would have been the possible risks (or consequences) to her for failing the act?

The possible risks to her for failing the act is Sherron Watkins will be sued for the harm caused to the collapse of Enron since she is the vice president for corporate development of Enron. This is because she does not voice out the misconduct of the company to people who can do something to solve the issue. Every director is expected to act in good faith and in the best...

Find Another Essay On Wise Decision: Sherron Watkins Letter to Kenneth Lay


716 words - 3 pages Enron as a client. In August, Enron Vice President Sherron Watkins wrote an anonymous memo to former Chairman Kenneth Lay, detailing reasons she thought Enron “might implode in a wave of accounting scandals.” On October 16, Enron announced a $638 million loss for the third quarter, and Wall Street reduced the value of stockholders’ equity by $1.2 billion. Enron announced November 8, that it had overstated earnings over the past four years by

Enron Corporation: The Real Scandal Essay

1315 words - 5 pages resignation as CEO after a few short months. Kenneth Lay assured the market that there would be no change in the company moving forward. Lay then announced he would resume his position as acting CEO. The following day Skilling admitted that his main reason for departure was Enron’s faltering price in the stock market. On August 15th, Sherron Watkins, vice president of corporate development, sent an anonymous letter to Lay warning him about the

Cultural Values and Personal Ethics Paper

1400 words - 6 pages conversely, what does not present an issue for me may pose a significant issue to a coworker.An example of this type of ethical dilemma was evident when Sherron Watkins, Enron Corporation's vice president wrote a letter to the company's chief executive office, Kenneth Lay, to advise him that the company's accounting practices were improper (Castagnera, 2003). Watkins' decision-making process in this case undoubtedly called upon her personal values

Ethical Issues in film Erin Brockovich

1129 words - 5 pages accounting that was going on within Enron as she was a Certified Public Accountant. She wrote a memo to Enron CEO, Kenneth Lay, warning him of the errors in the financial statements. Watkins testified before the U.S. Congress and Senate at the beginning of 2002. I feel that the utilitarian view point was represented in this movie. The decision not to testify in court and draw it out would show that. By settling the way that they did, everyone

Fundamentals of Business for Managers

1237 words - 5 pages months, just as the share price was tumbling, Enron management switched pension plans and froze employee accounts. Employees watched in horror, their hands tied, as the stock lost most of its value. Illegal? Employees are suing, and intend to find out.Didn't anyone notice this mess while it was being created? Yes! A few, brave souls even tried to do something. Sherron Watkins, an Enron executive, sent an anonymous letter to Kenneth Lay last

A Corporate Code of Ethics is Not Enough

2435 words - 10 pages Sherron S. Watkins stepped forward. It was latter learned that as Kenneth Lay was supposedly researching her claims, he was actually conducting an investigation to find grounds to fire Ms. Watkins (Flynt 1). It is simply not enough to have a code of ethics if there is not a solid, fear free path to follow to report violations. Johnson & Johnson An Effective Code of Ethics A good example of a working code of ethics is Johnson

The Beginning of the End of Enron

2097 words - 8 pages impressive. In order to keep investor confidence, Enron engaged in mark-to-market accounting and the most complex off-balance sheet accounting. Many executive members of Enron and auditors of Arther Anderson contributed to demise of Enron; however, Jeffrey Skilling, Kenneth Lay, Andrew Fastow, and Sherron Watkins played a significant role in the collapse of Enron.      Typically assets and liabilities are valued on a historical cost basis, but

Impact of Unethical Behavior

688 words - 3 pages was actually worth $1.2 billion less than previously reported (, 2006). When this information was revealed, investors, creditors and stockholders knew something was amiss. This behavior would have continued had it not been for one whistleblower that recognized the unethical behavior that was taking place. Sherron Watkins (Thomas, 2006), Vice President for Corporate Development, wrote a memo to her boss, Kenneth Lay, stating

Enron Stakeholders

1708 words - 7 pages Lay should have dismissed the traders and made an example of them showing other employees that behavior is unacceptable. That would have created more ethical decision makers when it came to later incidents, such as the energy crisis in California. Management should have been aware of and done something about the electricity trading in California. Enron ripped California off of billions of dollars, all with a slap on the wrist when they were

Enron Case Study

650 words - 3 pages their own jobs in the company. Management forced them to produce NO MATTER WHAT or their job would be done at the company. According to Sherron Watkins, “Enron’s unspoken message was, ‘Make the numbers, make the numbers, make the numbers—if you steal, if you cheat, just don’t get caught. If you do, beg for a second chance, and you’ll get one.’” Enron’s culture did not promote anything close to values or even responsibility and respect and

why being ethical and who bothers?

3354 words - 13 pages acts originate in the choices and actions of human individuals, it is these individuals who must be seen as the primary bearers of moral duties and moral responsibility. The then chairman of the board, Kenneth Lay, and CEO, Jeffrey Skilling, allowed the then CFO, AndrewFastow, to build private cooperate institution secretly and then transferred the property illegally. The CFO, Andrew Fastow, violated his professional ethics and took the crime of

Similar Essays

Book: Scarlet Letter Author: Nathaniel Hawthorne Title Of Paper: Allegiance This Essay Parallels Arthur Dimmesdale From The Scarlet Letter To Kenneth Lay, The Former Ceo Of Enron

509 words - 2 pages In the novel The Scarlet Letter, Arthur Dimmesdale is a young Puritan pastor who has committed adultery. While Hester was looked at with scorn for the sin that she had committed, Dimmesdale was greatly respected by the whole community, who were unaware that he had committed the same sin as Hester. The way in which Dimmesdale broke his allegiance to himself, Hester, and his Puritan community can be compared to the way that Kenneth Lay, the CEO of

Enron Research Paper

942 words - 4 pages purpose entity designed to take high-risk poor-performing assets off Enron's balance sheet,” (Pasha, 2006, para. 2). Later in August 2001 Sherron sent, “an anonymous letter to Enron founder Kenneth Lay… warning him that the company “had a hole in the ship and we’re going to sink,”” (Pasha, 2006, para. 1). Eventually she came forward and announced she wrote the letter and met with Lay. After this announcement Sherron became known as a whistleblower

The Enron Scandal Essay

945 words - 4 pages that there were "no issues".Sherron Watkins, an Enron vice-president, wrote an anonymous letter to Kenneth Lay setting out her fears of an impending scandal. As Enron's investments and stock turned bad, the partnerships couldn't pay up because their capital was disappearing at the same time. A huge hole had opened in the accounts.As stock slid to $33 a share, nearly two-thirds lower than a year earlier, executives decided to cope up to their

Cultural Values And Personal Ethics Paper

1114 words - 4 pages values. An excellent example of this type of ethical dilemma was evident when Sherron Watkins, as the Enron Corporation's vice president wrote a letter to the company's chief executive office, Kenneth Lay, to advise him that the company's accounting practices were improper (Castagnera, 2003). Watkins' decision-making process in this case undoubtedly called upon her personal values because she was driven to expose what was ultimately uncovered as